I'm a New Yorker at heart. CT overhyped pizza. But Jimmy's is the best pizza I've had since moving here 20 years ago.

I ordered a med mozz with onions 25 mintutes went there not ready 15 mins. later chef comes out I dropped the pizza I will make a ne one. One hr he brings it out. it had burned red onionson it so wrong and it was warm. It was awful. read more

I always order here to go it's ready and good time and it's always delicious. I never actually sat down at 8:00 so I can't say how well the service is but they're always very friendly when I go to pick up my food. There is the inside seating and it's decently lit. There's two bar stools at this counter as well as tables to sit and eat. read more

Jimmy's Pizza - The front counter where you order - Pizza Near Me - Meriden, Connecticut

One of my favorite Greek pizza restaurants closed down years ago, and recently I stumbled onto Jimmy's, which is finally comparable. I've been searching for a while now and this is a keeper - for sure. It was down the street from me all this time. Great service, and nice people. read more

Coming late to the game to this wonderful restaurant! Ordered pizzas and salads and all were delicious! Friends turned us on to the place with great reviews! Theyve tried lots of the fishes with rave teviews. Its a bit busy so order early...def worth any wait. Delivery has always been in the delivery window time given. Check them out. Jimmy and his wife are great people and are very accomodating. read more

Jimmy's Pizza - Ricotta n pepperoni. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Meriden, Connecticut

See all

How did I miss this place? I lived in Meriden for 23 years and never noticed Jimmy's. I had to move a few towns away and read about it on the internet. Well, Jimmy's gets phenomenal reviews from people that love Greek pizza and I happen to love Greek pizza so I tried it out. Wow... if you love Greek pizza look no further... best one I've found in central Connecticut... the dough,sauce and cheese are all perfectly made and flavorful. The staff is friendly and professional... the prices are not bad at all. My brother from Florida came up a couple weeks ago and went with me to Jimmy's... he told me the flavor of the pizza made him miss Connecticut and it was the best pizza he had ever had... it is seriously good... I highly recommend Jimmy's... you won't be disappointed. read more

The food was amazing the pizza crunchy like I like the service was really fast they make you feel like comfortable I when a Saturday and it was pretty busy so that mean that they are good read more

Jimmy's Pizza - Pizza with mozzarella sticks and buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Meriden, Connecticut

Delicious Greek pizza- crust perfect and pizza not greasy. We had a bacon and onion pie. Will definitely return!

Well, this is what happens when I believe reviews from CT people. How ? How do you think factory bought frozen crust is acceptable?? It was Pizza Hut quality. Remember those?! Ugh. Horrible. I burped it iup three times. And. If you tell me 30 minutes on a busy Friday night. Don't make me wait an hour!! People, demand better. read more

Jimmy's is a little hidden gem. My son loves Greek-style pizza and was advised to try Jimmy's. I live in Meriden and didn't, until recently, know he was there. We ordered pizza, Greek salad, and a hot grinder. We were quite impressed with the high quality of ingredients. The pizza was delicious. Light crust, beautiful sauce, and generous cheese. Salad was perfect and loaded. Stuffed grape leaves among the best I've had. The eggplant grinder was huge and wonderful. I am so glad that we found this place. Prices quite reasonable, especially consideration the size and quality. We will definitely return. Well done! Vegetarian options Non-meat eating family found plenty of options. Since our first visit, above, we have ordered thrice more, over three consecutive weekends. The high quality is consistent. How did we not know about Jimmy's sooner? read more

Tried Jimmy's Pizza for the first time last night. I was craving a greek style pizza with a thicker crust. My husband went and picked it up and there was a child's birthday party going on and it was utter chaos inside the restaurant with children running around screaming and trying to get into the kitchen. My husband said the staff was doing their best trying to keep the children out of the back but it was pretty crazy. We ordered the meat pizza and it was supposed to be ready just before 6pm. They were running behind and it was another 15-20 minutes before it was ready. I do have to say that the pizza was fantastic. The crust was buttery and light. The sauce was tangy with the perfect amount of cheese and toppings. We will definitely be ordering again. Hopefully next time we will miss the birthday party. LOL. read more

I waited 25 minutes for buttered noodles with chicken and broccoli versus chicken and broccoli Alfredo. The chef insisted that the noodles "soaked up all the sauce" but I ordered take out two weeks ago.... If you're out of something you can just say that... had to go back to get the Alfredo sauce and the chef was rude. I get that you're closing but it's hey close at 10pm and I placed my order at 8:50pm read more

Jimmy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Meriden, Connecticut

See all

My wife, our friends and stopped in to Jimmy's last night. We had heard great stuff about the pizza, so we went. We were not disappointed! Pizza was great. Staff was very friendly and accommodating. We will not hesitate to stop in again. read more

Everything is great! And B.Y.O.B.! The pizza is amazing. Nice thick Greek crust! Their garlic bread is pretty good. Nice topped with cheese.

Sooo my daughter turned 21 and wanted a party in the backyard.....best thing to feed 21 year olds who are drinking!? Pizza! Lol Jimmy's delivered a stack of pies on time and hot. The pizza is a Greek style and tasty. We had some with pepperoni, some with sausage and some just cheese. Each one was yummy. I definitely want to try some of their dinners! read more

I was new to the area three years ago. Lot of Pizza spots although Jimmy's Pizza quickly became my favorite. The Jimmy's Special (loaded pizza) is amazing! read more

We ordered two large pizzas last night. A extra pepperoni and a clam with white sauce. When we received the pizzas we didn't have clams so we called and the owners wife said she would get one out to us right away. It was a simple misunderstanding. They sent the right pizza and only charged the extra $4 for the clams since we had originally been charged for a cheese. The delivery driver was friendly and the pizza was bomb. We will be ordering again! read more

The best dining experience on my trip from California to Connecticut. I got a large pizza with large mushrooms on it(mushrooms are my favorite ), yummy sausages and extra cheese. It was fantastic! I also got some chicken wings with barbecue sauce on it.The owner and the staff were very kind and friendly. The little 5-year old boy invited me to play his toy cars. He's super energetic! I had a lot of fun. I'd love to come back to visit some time! read more

No doubt about it when it comes to great Pizza and subs. This is a great place. I always kept the Italian combo with mayonnaise on both sides of the bread, light mustard, lettuce, red onions black pepper, jalapeños peppers, oregano, American cheese. I also had a cheese pizza. It was very tasty. I am sure everything else will be amazing. Now that I live nearby I need to take a lunch to work. Their subs are huge great portions. It will fill you up for sure. I wish I could get some more stars, keep up the good work amazing staff... read more

I visited several times with a friend who lives in Woodmont. Bacon & Onion Pizza was very good. Service was efficient. read more

Never tried Greek type of pizza and I have to say it is spot on delicious. I never had mushroom,onion and sausage pizza in my life ,but my coworkers ordered one tonight and asked me to try. The meat is good quality and the thick crust holds topping better then thin. I never thought I'd enjoy mushrooms on a pizza like I did tonight . They don't burn pizza ,so they have my vote and I can't wait to order a whole pizza soon. Great job ! read more

Jimmy's Pizza - Mushrooms, onions and sausage absolutely delicious - Pizza Near Me - Meriden, Connecticut

My son and I had a good time switching our dish back and forth!! Pizza, mozzarella sticks to chicken parmigiana grinder.. next time maybe steak grinder and lasagna. The Chef seems like a good guy. read more

Our favorite pizza spot in the area and they have Greek style pizza. The crust is perfect and they always deliver deliciousness.

I am a Greek Pizza Snob. This pizza does not disappoint. A very subtle sauce. Nice thin Greeek pie And not too greasy. However, I do like a greasy pie. Sausage and bacon quality meats. If they keep up the quality.....the word will be out And this place will be #1 Greek pie in the area for sure. This place has earned my business. Goes great with IPA read more

If you remember Family pizza in Wallingford the pizza and wings are exactly the same. Good food fair prices.

Honestly that review a few down has to be from a miserable human being. These people are so sweet and so hard working! They seem like the kind that would give you the shirt off their back. This is a family run business and they are so passionate about the food they serve. So personable, so thoughtful, so generous. The service level is above and beyond. Now...the food. The sauce is fantastic. Not a jar sauce and so yummy. The homemade dressings are reason enough to go. I dunk everything into it because it makes they already great food amazing. The Greek style pizza is phenomenal. The salads are outstanding! The best of all is the wings! I like them dry. Best wings ever. The wings are hearty, full, and perfectly crisp. I wish they delivered to Wallingford. All this talk has me wanting more. Definitely pop in! You won't be disappointed. The family special feeds a crew! read more

I have ordered takeout out here a few times and the food has always been good and prices are good.

I tried Jimmy's at a work meeting and was pleasantly surprised. I've been craving pepperoni pizza during my pregnancy so after trying another pizzeria and being let down I figured let's try Jimmy's! I'm really glad we did the pizza was really good. I called really close towards closing and felt bad, but THESE CRAVINGS!! The owner was really nice and sent the pizza delivery guy anyways. The delivery guy was super sweet and nice! Great customer service!! I really appreciate your kindness!! It was affordable and oh so satisfying. We will be ordering from them again! read more

Jimmy's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Meriden, Connecticut

See all

The most delicious pizza I have had in Meriden since I moved 9 years ago! Thank you to the people that speak so highly of Jimmy's because had you not I would have never found the most delicious pizza!!! Staff are super awesome and attentive to all my needs!! I will definitely be going back!!!! Thank you so much for the pizza of my childhood...never knew I would find it so close to my home!! read more

Jimmy's Pizza - White Pizza Eggplant and ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Meriden, Connecticut

Delicious pizza! Amazing Greek-style airy and crunchy thick crust, excellent sauce! Their Greek salad with house dressing is phenomenal. We'll be back. read more

Pizza? Very good. Service? Terrible. Called in an order to pick up. Woman that answered has an accent and speaks softly. I had to keep repeating myself and asking her to repeat herself. Was given an amount of time for when it would be ready (30 minutes). I arrived at 20 minutes and it wasn't even prepared yet. Took over 45 minutes from the time I called until it was ready, and it appears the only reason it was ready that quickly was because I was standing there waiting for it and they moved it ahead in the queue. There were at least three different people that kept coming out asking me what I ordered. Delivery drivers kept passing through the entry area leaving no place for waiting customers. Watched an argument between a customer and the woman behind the counter over what was ordered. Both had their own strong accents and both spoke softly despite it being so loud in there. Woman behind the counter had no clue what to do (should have started with an apology, at least, but that didn't happen). Again, pizza was very good. They need to figure out how to run a business. read more

We just ordered three large pizzas for a gathering of 16 people. I think that' reflects a pretty good census for a pizza review board! Here it is! Everyone loved the pizza - piled up veggies were bursting with flavor! The house special was a hit too! Every ingredient cut to the right bite- size proportion! Both pizzas were a hit. If I didn't already serve the appetizers or our home made antipasto salad with the dinner, we would have needed a forth pizza. Great job Jimmy's. You have 16 new fans! read more

Awesome pan style pizza! It is ran and owned by the original owners of Family Pizza in Wallingford by the train station. There is nothing like it around. the wings are amazing as well as their grinders and Gyros. read more

See all

I dont even like Greek pizza but it's actually pretty good for a thicker style pizza, in usually like only prefer thinner pizzas like new haven style only reason why its 3 stars but the flavor and everything was there if you like thick style pizzas then this is the perfect spot for you, the fried calamari wasn't bad either wish the oil was alittle cleaner but it was tasty. read more

This unassuming spot knocked it out of the park. Their cheesy garlic bread was irresistible (made with homemade butter... who still does that?), the buttery crusted pizza was a slice of heaven. And their broccoli chicken was a plate of "oh my god yes more, please". I'm quite sure the chicken parm was exceptional as I didn't hear a peep from my husband for a good 10 minutes the moment it was served. This will be our Meriden-Go-To whenever we're in town. BRAVO!! read more

I've gotten take out a few times and it's been really good one of the better pizzas I've had. So last night I ate in and it was so good. An extra sauce, extra cheese sausage pizza. It was so good. How good was it? Well I'll put it this was besides the crusts because I have to be in a mood for crusts and besides for me the cheese is the best part, there were no leftovers. Nothing. I would definitely go back. Recently I had the cheese ravioli and it was so good. You could tell the pasta was fresh and I was so glad it was cooked through but that's another story for another review. I'm probably going to get the pasta again. I mean if a restaurant like Jimmy's can do pizza and pasta well you know they're doing something right read more

Our neighbors and good friends invited us for dinner here. The team at Jimmy's has known them for many years. We were welcomed in with open arms and enjoyed a wonderful meal. The meal deal with pizza, garlic bread, wings, salad and soda is so much that we had lunch for our family of 3 the next day too. All was delicious & we could not wait to go back. We have since been a few times, and have been treated to the same great food and service. read more

Pizza is top notch - really flavorful, perfect ratio of cheese to sauce to toppings. Also the crust is really nice - crunchy and chewy. Service with a smile. Highly recommend read more

Absolutely one of the best pizza places in town! My staff orders from the Jimmy's weekly. Do yourself a favor try it out. You will not be disappointed! Jimmy will treat you like family. read more

I absolutely love this place. The food never disappoints, and the service is amazing. I try to eat at Jimmy's pizza at least once a week. It keeps me going. read more