There pizza is so good. Always the right amount of cheese and there sauce has good flavor. Ordered a pepperoni and mushrooms & sausage and onion. Both were very good. And have to give them extra props for the last minute delivery. They closed at 11. And I put the order in at 10:40pm. Most places would have not accepted it so late for delivery. But they did with no problem. Ordered two sodas with it. Only one came. After 11. The driver went back to get another soda. That was really professional of him for the business Great staff, excellent tasting pizza read more

I was jet lagged and wanted a chicken parm sandwich. The sandwich was lacking in many ways (taste, little chicken portion, etc). I won't go back. read more

Trash! Honestly the food could be much better! The pizza sauce tasted old. I will say the service was great but I was not impressed by the meal at all. First and last time going. read more

Love the Pizza, specially the sauce. Like to order the baked ziti which is a favorite of mine. The staff is kind every visit and food is always done on a timely manner. read more

I placed an order today 6 subs for a retirement party. Two of the sandwiches were supposed to be tuna. I looked thru the tray and I didn't see any tuna. I called them asking for the missing tuna the man who made them wasnt there at the moment and the had to call me back. Needless to say 5 sandwiches cost was $60 today I added a sandwich and tge price went up $15. so now the total was $75. He soon returned my call and said he gave me Italian subs instead of the tuna. my question to him I paid for tuna why didn't I get it. then he asked if I still had the Italian and if not o well. Ge hung up on me twice. I will never order here again! Do not support this business they are rude and give you what they want you to have. read more

They didn't send me what I ordered and when I called to tell them they refused to even listen to what I had to say. The employee or owner, whoever answered the phone, then cursed at me and hung up on me because THEY got MY order wrong. Extremely unprofessional. And the food isn't even that good. Digiorno's oven pizza tastes better. read more

Honestly ignore the other reviews. I stepped in here for a quick bite before a business meeting and was completely caught off guard. The pizza is absolutely delicious and that's a lot coming from me since I'm from NY (lol just kidding!). Honestly great pizza and you can tell it's been around for a while. read more

We had a wonderful dinner Thanks to our new friends at Neil's Pizza. The meatball and Spaghetti was amazing and my wife loved her cream raviolis. Food was nice hot and the young woman that delivered our food very sweet and professional! We will definitely buy more wonderful Items off the menu again. Continue Success Our Friends! read more

This review based on Meatball hero and Burger Only. I'm from NYC so local pizza is part of routine culture. Been to many different local pizza joints and this place is by far the worst. I had pizza here before and it was just average joe Pizza. The owner seems to be grumpy sometimes but I really didn't care since it wasn't a serviced based joint. However, few weeks ago I ordered meatball hero w.pepper and burger w.fries. Meatball had no flaver, tasted flat, green pepper was undercooked. Burger was plain, tasteless, fries were soggy and disgusting. It is difficult to make bad burgers or Meatball unless you really give a xxxx about what you cook. I don't usually get unhappy after eating a meal but this place will make you regret that you ever came here. read more

Really good pizza, and the best in town...Love the fact the pies arent greasy and super fresh and cant beat the price!!

Updating my review for Neil's and was pleasantly surprised. Went on April 15th for a free large pizza they were giving away to the first 25 people from 4-6pm it was in conjunction with the Little Ferry Police paying for the pizza during the pandemic for the community. I have to admit the pizza was good with nice cheese and crisp thin crust pizza. They were organized and got my pizza in less than 2 minutes because they knew they would be busy so they prepared the pizza ahead of time and handed out to everyone as they came. Wish Zio did that I waited like half an hour for my free pizza there. Good job they must have stepped their game up since I was last there. I would buy the pizza just not meatballs lol. Thanks all for doing this for the community to Neil's and the police department read more

I love it. My boyfriend and I called late at night because it was the only place open. We were a bit skeptical because of the reviews but please ignore them. everything was amazing, its my new go-to spot for pizza read more

They have good pizza. However they are the cheapest crooks in the business. They always over charge. Never order extra cheese, you pay for it but don't get it. They always yell. No customer service what so ever. read more

After a visit to the post office, my wife and I were a little hungry. We saw this place and decided to try them out... Here's what I think... 1. I don't care that they are San Francisco 49er fans (pictures and posters everywhere), the place needs a good cleaning. They have a hockey stick on the wall that has about a 2in coating of dust on it. Do you know how disgusting that is? 2. I don't know how old the graded cheese you put on your pizza is, but I think that needs to be kept refrigerated especially on a hot day. 3. It's never a good sign when you want to go grab a soda out of the fridge and there's boxes of motor oil on the floor! Are you going to give me an oil change if I buy a pie? Get rid of it, it's a pizzeria not a auto shop. Food: Overall... The pizza is not bad. It is what it is. The garlic knots in my opinion stink! It's like left over dough that they just sprinkled garlic powder on. When you bite into it, it's all plain and doesn't have a good taste to it. I must say, the guy serving up the pizza was friendly... That was the only thing saving this place from a 1 star rating! read more

Neil's Pizzeria - a car parked in front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Little Ferry, New Jersey

A hole in the wall pizzeria adjacent to Royal Billiards. The pizza is certainly pizza by definition, but when it comes to my definition of pizza, it falls flat. ...miserably flat. The crust is chewy, the sauce is from a can and salty, and the cheese is unevenly distributed. Many a time growing up, my friends and I would grab a slice here before venturing into Royal Billiards. Thankfully my tastes have changed and sites like Yelp are able to help differentiate contenders and pretenders in the "pizza by the slice" game. Weak sauce... read more

My wife and I have been ordering from them for about 25 years. This one time my wife ordered a pizza for delivery and the delivery person did not have enough change so my wife said next time we order, we will compromise the difference. The next time we ordered couple dates later, the pizza was 2 bucks more and the same delivery person forgot about the money she owed us from the days before, so we refused the pizza. They called us back and said do not order from us again. BAD BUSINESS PEOPLE, YOU THINK THEY WOULD COMPROMISE BUT GREED PREVAILS read more

Seriously?????? Ok I'm a real pizza lover and this was just horribad. I was in the area and was really starving had no time for dinner. I wanted to get a slice or two quick and wow.... is this really considered pizza? I should've just waited to get a decent meal. This place was in business awhile now but never tried it tillthat day. I ordered two slices and I could not finish a single slice because of the taste. Usually I can eat almost any pizza but u know what I did? I tried putting salt on my pizza trying to fix it, now who puts salt on pizza? Um... I wanted to eat it by fixing it but nope. Slices were soggy from start, can't taste the sauce, cheese seemed old or hmmm fat free or who knows. So sooogggyyy I had to use a fork and knife to try to work on each slice. Food had to goto waste and was thrown out. Really disappointed these slices were that bad. Maybe this spot used to be good before but now is a NONO. The lady, owner I'm assuming was nice but I wanted food not being nice. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Sooo soggy and bland - Pizza Near Me - Little Ferry, New Jersey

See all

This place is out right dirty, how can a restaurant not clean cobwebs from the ceiling? I have no idea, my wife & I had a few slices of pizza from here, we won't be back... read more

We ordered a large pizza, well done and I have to say, it was delicious! It had the right amount of tomato sauce and cheese. The crust was good too. I don't know how he got the pizza to be crispy, but when I order well done at other places, its usually soggy. read more

We stumbled upon this mom and pop joint looking for a quick bite. had two plain slices and it was so delicious. It hit the spot! Crispy, right amount of cheese and sauce. The gentleman was very nice. Def a place we'll come to again! read more

When I ordered, I asked for mushrooms on half and just cheese on the other half. When delivered, it was all mushroom . That said, they do make a good pizza. read more

I ordered a meatball hero from here and I got one - with whole meatballs on it. I mean, wth? How do you even try to eat a hero when the meatballs are trying to roll away? Sorry, but that is a huge fail and I'm not going back. read more

Neil's Pizza is a delicious pizza they make their Pizza very fresh and they deliver it very fast I always get the Neil's special large because that comes with everything and everytime I serve that pizza with friends they always say it's delicious so if you want a good pizza order it from Neely's read more

Ordered a large margherita pizza. Worst pizza I've ever had. Mozzarella wasn't cooked/melted entirely; there were too many slices of uncooked tomato; the sauce was watery and runny, making the crust soggy and gross. Avoid this pizza at all cost read more

This is my favorite pizza spot. Never disappoints. Owner is nice and friendly. Sauce is so gooood. Pizza's always delicious! :)

Wow, this place is in SERIOUS need of a face lift!! I'm not sure how I even ate here but I gave it a try. I ordered 2 plain slices that were mediocre. The staff seems absent minded and did not really care what was going on. The whole time I was eating, I kept staring at the hundreds of dusty (actually, dusty doesn't even begin to describe it) pictures and "flare" on the walls. If this place did an extreme cleaning and dared to put a fresh coat of paint of the walls, I'm sure they would get more customers. C'mon guys, some Clorox will do you wonders. If the dining area was that dirty, I can't imagine how dirty the kitchen is. I will not be back. read more

Ordered food and waited an hour before getting an email saying that there was a problem with the delivery

Coming from a big italian family..i know food...and it doesnt get much better than this. This is a review on just hot subs and calzones. How people give this place 3 stars is unbelievable to me. This is...hands down...the best pizzeria in the area. The sandwich...veal parm...is placed on great bread and cooked to perfection. The calzone is the same price as any local pizzeria and stuffed with tons of meat. On top of this all...i called for delivery at 1030 on a Thursday and they were pleased to take my order. Standing ovation for Neil's. We love you guys and will order again soon. read more

Same great owners for more than twenty years! Whenever I go to New Jersey, I always make a stop here. The pizza is not as great as it was fifteen years ago, but they still make the best chicken cutlet hero. read more

While I was working I ordered a pie of pizza and a meatball sub for my 10 year old and dad online. I called a few hours later to check how the food was and my son said the sub tasted "old" therefore he did not eat it. I called to express my concerns and the man started yelling at me and saying it was not old and don't say that to me and I'm being unreasonable. WOW is all I have to say! He insisted that it was because he didn't like the sub and hung the phone up on me. Poor customer service and I most certainly will never order from there again. read more

Decent sandwich but really.. nearly $4 up charge on 2 meals to use a credit card? Fast delivery but won't be ordering again. $28 for a sandwich, fries and an app is ridiculous. We could've had a much better meal for that. read more

Decent pizza little to thick to be considered jersey New York thin crust but they have a decent crust and sauce so I would eat here again

Pizza was OK. Owners were very nice to me and especially to my son. Prices were very reasonable. Definitely would return for a quick meal if in the area. read more

They deserve no stars. There food is horrible, ordered a couple of sandwiches there on New Year's Day and they are so cheap with the ingredients and they did not even taste good, plus they over charged me on my food. Will never ever go to this location again. read more

Tables need to be clean... kitchen looks ok.. Could be better.... Owners are nice; especially the lady. Guessing it's a family business. Food ok. Not the best. Prices are fair. Wouldn't suggest this place. Maybe if you're hungry at home, order pizza. The place inside is filthy.. At least push the chairs in. Waited 40 mins for a chicken parm.. Too much cheese.. Chicken bland.. Bread soggy.. Looked like a dirty diaper.. Chicken Looked microwaved. As I'm typing this the owner is inside, drinking a coffee.. Doesn't even push the chairs in or clean the tables. If u want check it out for ur self. Btw the chicken parm was like the size of my arm.. Too over portioned.. read more

Really tasty pizza!! Crunchy crust; good cheese; good sauce.... Just solid pizza!! Friendly service with parking!!

Good pizza, amazing garlic knots. A bit expensive which is why Im giving 4 stars.

Neil pizza is a excellent place pizza is excellent and very hot and I like chesse and salami are fresh service

At one time this place was great and so was the pizza. But the last couple of years, it rapidly decayed. At first I thought new owners? No, it's still the same people, but they're obviously using inferior ingredients now and just simply let the place go. read more

all what has been written badly about neils pizzeria can be only categorized under just one wor "BULLSHItTTT" my family, my friends, and I have been ordering from this pizzeria over 7 years now. We are good friends with them. they only high up their menu when the food prices go up. also, they do their best. Give me one pizzeria that opens 7 days a week from 11 till 11 non stop, fast deliveries with only one chef !!!! Come on plzzz be fair!!! These people don't know what vacation means just to keep serving little ferry, Moonachie, Hackensack , south Hackensack, Carlstadt and bogota the best Italian food in no time. read more