This used to be my local pizza joint when I lived in Garfield but since I've been back in NJ I hadn't had a chance to grab a slice until today. The restaurant itself is spacious and sparkling clean with lots of seating and a nice variety of pies to choose from at the counter. I saw they had a 2 Slice + Small Drink deal for $5.95 so that's what I went with. The slices were just like I remembered them which was GREAT! Perfect cheese / sauce balance and a nice firm yet not crispy under carriage. The staff were also pleasant to myself and everyone else who came in. I'll surely be back anytime I'm in the area :) read more

See all

Got delivery, pizza had a great undercarriage . They made me a pie that was half/half and the restaurant followed my directions. The person who took my order was very nice. Have to visit the restaurant one day. read more

Brother's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Their Grandma pizza caught my eye so when we needed a quick lunch, we decided to call ahead to order for pick-up on Labor Day at around 1. We ordered the Grandma pie (plum tomato, garlic, basil & mozzarella. We did half regular, and half drunken, which is vodka sauce, and added pepperoni to the whole pie. I appreciated that toppings for the whole pie were only $2-$3. Something unheard of in this economy! I liked the regular half better than the drunken half because it was more garlicky. Overall, the crust was a little too thick for me. I probably wouldn't get the Grandma again, just because it was so heavy. But, the ingredients tasted fresh so I wouldn't mind trying some of their other specialty regular pies. read more

Brother's Pizza - Half Grandma Pizza/half Drunken Grandma Pizza added pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

My chicken Francaise was so good and enough for 2 meals. Free bread along with free garlic bread and soup or salad Waitress was Briana. So nice ! Enjoyed speaking with her This used to be Franks Pizza and has a lot of tables. Roomy. Clean bathrooms Great specials each day read more

See all

I really do try to support small business, but some of them just dropped the ball and this is one. OK, first it started with the fact that I was trying to order food with my credit card and the girl kept saying that my card was declined, but I knew she was putting in an incorrect number because the credit card had plenty of money on it and I was getting aggravated, but I was just like you know what let me just calm down and use a different card. I was told that the food would be there in 45 minutes which I will give them. It did arrive then it just was not good. The salad we ordered had strawberry feta cheese and mandarin oranges. The mandarin oranges were definitely from a can, and the feta cheese was chopped up into these weird blocks, almost like they went into the grocery store and said what's the cheapest cheese we can get we also asked for balsamic vinaigrette they sent us balsamic vinegar. we move onto our appetizer roll. We are vegetarians and I was eating a small piece of the eggplant Rollatini I just knew something wasn't right so I started to look through it on my plate and found huge prosciutto or some sort of ham. How does that even happen? Did they just mix all the ricotta cheese altogether in the morning and then slap it onto whatever was there? I was disgusted at this point, but I tried to eat a piece of pizza. It was OK, but definitely not cooked well and very soggy. One of my family members the cauliflower pizza and she had to basically cook it in the oven once it arrived because it was pretty much raw. In New Jersey, we have so many great pizza places in Italian places. It's a shame that people just drop the ball and only care about what they're getting paid. The quality of the food was just not good. I don't see us going back there. read more

We've been to Brothers a few times and we've never been disappointed. My daughter who is gluten free and struggles to find pizza she enjoys loves their cauliflower pie. read more

Brother's is a pizzeria restaurant located in a strip mall in the saddle brook Walmart shopping center. Brother's was formerly Frank's for many years and has kept basically the same menu as Frank's. They offer a full menu of pastas, chicken, veal and seafood dishes and of course, pizza. The dinners are very good and come with soup or salad. The pizza is good as well. They have waitress service and you can bring your own alcohol. Takeout also available. Brother's is a great casual spot if you're in the area. read more

On an evening on my way home from work tired I decided to try out this spot for a simple cheese fries order. They were close to closing time and still took my order and were friendly greeting me and checking me out. When I arrived home my order was still fresh and warm and very tasty. For an order as simple as cheese fries, I've had unpleasant experiences before but Brother's knocked it out of the ballpark! Overall, I would definitely recommend and plan to return! read more

Idk. Just not a good pizza really. Very very thick crust. Something was just off about the flavor of the thing. Really wanted to like it but it just wasn't good. Was hoping for crumbled sausage on the pizza like in the pictures but I ended up with shaved strips, no flavor. The Italian empanada was good but not good enough to go back for it. read more

You're (not so) far from home.  One of your kids is partaking in an all-day lacrosse tournament and you've lost the first three matches. Famished and defeated, you hop on Yelp whispering a silent prayer, "C'mon, Yelp.  You've never let us down before.  We need something close by that's good.  We need nourishment." And within walking distance... you find Brother's. There's just something divine about their crust.  And it's not so much the 'cornicione' (where my pizza nerds at?!) but specifically that cornmeal bottom that has this incredible texture and crunch when you're taking a bite.  (They'd make a mint selling their secret to the countless subpar pizzerias out there that can't make such a good pie/crust.) We went with the white-broccoli, as well as their plain and a slice with mushrooms (not those bland, generic, wimpy 'from a can' button ones, either) and one slice was better than the next. Giddy that we stumbled upon this unassuming joint in the middle of a strip mall that knocked it out of the park and refueled with a pep once again in our step - we ventured back to the field for the fourth and final match of the day. Oh, and we lost.  (To the host town - Saddle Brook - no less!) Cool staff. Mainly a take-out joint (only two tables in front). Fair pricing. Limited/standard soft drink/water options. read more

Hello everyone, well I must say our Chicken Francaise dinner was the best dinner we had in a really long time. The chicken was cooked perfectly and nice and thin, and the francaise sauce was also really good. Battered Mozzarella Sticks (6) And sauce very good, and the salad had carrots,onions,tomatoes and dressing not bad. After this dinner we had, I will be going back read more

Never stepped foot in the store, needed a quick recommendation on Yelp. Thank you for dealing with an anxious voice with such kindness. And boy, did it work out!!! Ordered a few pizzas to be delivered hours later for a surprise party. The delivery was on time, professional, and piping-hot. Not to mention, the pizzas were very tasty. Your pizza does not disappoint! read more

Good quality food / Pizza and is the some of the best in the area. Great ingredients! New location near Walmart is not my favorite nor very convenient (for me) but I plan to go here for great pizza! read more

This place deserves more than five stars. First the pizza is great and they don't skimp with the toppings. The people that work there are awesome. Friendly and great service. Lastly, they're not insanely over priced like everyone else is these days. Their prices are what think you should pay for a slice of great pizza. Thank you Brother's Pizza. read more

We came up North on Wednesday and stopped in for some soup & a slice. Place continues to be kept clean, food is great, and service is excellent. Brother's Pizza is "PRIMO" there is no need to go anywhere else on Rt. 46. We have 9 Pizzeria's in Barnegat, and none of them compare to Brother's. It's BYOB as well..... read more

They have really good crispy pizza. I ordered their special. 2 slices and a small drink for $5. Definitely going back. read more

I asked first if they know how to make a real italian style hot dog and they replied yes of course I ordered 3 singe dogs no mustard no ketchup and the looked puzzled I was charged 34 dollars and recieved the worst interpretation of an italian style hot dog. It was minced into 1/4 inch slices and sauteed with pepper and onions and potatoes it was a greasy mess served on a sub roll There was no fried potatoes and it wss just reddened grease soaked bread that just broke apart whole attempting to eat it I wasn't expecting a Jimmy Buffs hot don't but at least leave the hot dog whole and fry the potatoes my wife and I both called to offer constructive criticism and were met with sarcasm and treated rudely Steer clear of this place read more

Been there quite a bit, good pizza, good food, like the area it is in. Everyone really nice, owner always comes by table. Girls are really nice. Usually quick service read more

I had the most amazing pizza last night! Been in the area for 40+ years, tried Ness, Turvino's and many others, but here's the difference on the plain pie. Just enough crispness in the dough (not soggy), just enough sauce and just enough cheese. The pie was also very visually appealing (on every slice ) I couldn't even add any suggestion to make it any better than it was. This is my future go to pizza place from now on - without a doubt. Only downfall is they are not open on Sundays... but a day of rest is fine by me...I will plan around it! read more

Amazing pizza and service!!! Hotel recommended this place for delivery and Brothers pizza did not disappoint. Excellent customer service during placing order and asking annoying questions during the dinner rush. Staff did not hesitate and answered promptly. Delivery was quick! And the pizza AMAZING! Perfectly thin crust and sauce tasty. Happy to find this place and will order again. Thank you Brothers Pizza for making this a true Jersey coming home with real PIZZA. read more

Love this place. It's my go-to for pizza on the weekends with the family. Service is good. Delivery can take some time though

I absolutely love everything from Brothers! My family and I order from them every week for dinner, and I even stop in for lunch. One of my favorite Appetizers is their Fried Raviolis and their wings are great ! If you want an even better desert and coffee stop into their cafe around the corner for some gelato and amazing deserts. My favorite is the zepps filled with cannoli cream and nutella read more

Brother's Pizza - Fried Ravs - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Tried placing order to be delivered. Had to repeat my first item 6 times. Girl put me on hold 4 times. After she finally heard my first item she tells me they don't have it anymore. We ordered mussels and a cheese pie. Waited over an hour for delivery. Placed order at 626pm and didn't get it. Neighbors down street got it. Since covid and the fact I have terminal cancer I couldn't accept order from neighbors. Had to can for full refund. We will see if that happens. Off to BK I go. read more

I ordered online from Brother's Pizza on a weekday evening for delivery. The delivery was super quick and definitely no issues with the order at all. I absolutely love Grandma's Pizza, and theirs is definitely really good. It is more of the thick crust variety and you can definitely get full from just one slice alone. We ended up freezing a big chunk of this pizza and eating it later throughout the week! But it definitely lasted for a long time. The tomatoes and the marinara sauce are super fresh and the crust is very crispy. We also got some garlic knots and fries, you know, just to keep things healthy. I think I definitely could drink their marinara dipping sauce that came with the garlic knots. I highly recommend checking this place out for delivery and/or take out until we were able to dine in again! read more

Brother's Pizza - Grandma's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

See all

As a Philadelphian I was skeptical that the stuffed cheesesteak slice would be any good. It was exceptional, the thin sliced beef, cheese and crust were all on point. A white slice with spinach featured gooey goodness and tasty veg, but the crust was not up to the task, costing Brothers that 5th star. I will return read more

Best place to eat in all of Saddle Brook. Everything I've ever ordered has been excellent. Will continue to order, delivery is fast.

I ordered 15 pies from Brother's Pizza for my daughter's 1st birthday party. The owner Danny was the one that helped me set up my order. On the day of the event, the delivery was right on time and all the pies were delivered right to the park. By far, the best pizza that we have had. From the owner down to the delivery driver, it is evident that this business goes above and beyond to deliver the best food and customer service. We cannot wait to go back for more! read more

Great neighborhood spot. Owner is SO NICE and the employees are as well. Everything we've gotten we've liked and delivery is always super fast. I've never been disappointed when trying new things either. This is just one of those places you can consistently rely on. Seriously, that is awesome for when you're a busy person, and you get home late and you're exhausted. Time for brothers! Pizza and entrees are delicious and some random things you wouldn't maybe think to get, but are delicious, are the fried shrimp and the panzarotti. Yum yum yum. I'd love for them to expand their dessert selection but otherwise - no complaints!! Keep being awesome! read more

Brother's Pizza - Fried shrimp! So good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Brothers pizza is by far the best pizza place in the bergen county area. The owners, Danny and Rosario, are some of the kindest and friendliest people i have ever met. Their food is out of this world as well. The pizza dough is made fresh daily with fresh local ingredients every time. The crust is some of the best I have ever had. The sauce is deliciously tangy and the cheese is phenomenal. They also serve an assortment of pizza by the slice. They will guaranteed have something you like. Their dinner entrees are always made fresh and are delicious Italian recipes. I love brothers pizza and will recommend this place to everyone i talk too. Great establishment. read more

See all

Best pizza in town. Get the extra large size pizzas. The pizza is thin while still holding its shape. Also, if you're a true pizza lover, you should know that pizza needs to be eaten fresh. Pick up your pizza. Don't get it delivered since it gets soft/chewier from the moisture while sitting in the box. Favorites: XL Pie - Pepperoni Mushrooms Garlic Grandma's Pie on Sicilian - BEST GRANDMA'S PIE IN NJ. PERIOD. I"ll bet my money on this. I'll upload a pic the next time I get it. read more

Brother's Pizza - Best grandma's pie I've had in jersey. - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

My mother has an severe allergy to oregano that's why we keep ordering but every time I order they mess up the order in some way. I get the same thing almost every time 2 xlarge cheese no one oregano cutting to 16 and an xlarge white broccoli cut in 16 no oregano This is definitely not a hard complicated order I get it home it's not cutting 16 and there's oregano all over it. So once again my mother cannot eat it This is about the 6 time they messed up our order I stopped ordering for a while because they kept messing up the order.hoping to find a new place to accommodate this yet it's very hard .. I just keep hoping one day they will get it right such a shame read more

Nutella pizza not available..eggplant parm its like eating layers of bread crumbs with sauce I'm pretty sure they're frozen, not homemade...minestrone soup is homemade and it was good...eh I don't know if I'll order again! read more

Excellent food, large menu, great service and great value. They cater to all your requests and I've never had anything missed on an order. Delivery also available. Go-To Menu Item: Large Baked Penne Pizza. read more

Most amazing cauliflower crust pizza! Best low carb option in the area. Been coming for 10 years and the rest of the menu is also the best. read more

Brother's Pizza - Cauliflower crust pizza with vodka sauce and pesto - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Fantastic food. We've ordered pizza, calamari, and entre, along with cold hero's. All were fantastic. We had it delivered and the time quoted was "right on". great place read more

What a great find in Saddle Brook for a quick bite! I stopped in for lunch today and the food was fantastic. They have a "Chicken Parm Empanada", which is basically a calzone but the dough was lighter, crispy, and no loads of ricotta that you would find in a typical calzone. It tasted crazy good! The Chicken Bacon Ranch slice was very flavorful and not overloaded with ranch. Kelly brought my slice and empanada to the table and asked if I needed anything. She was kind enough to bring me an extra side of sauce, above what I expected from a typical pizzeria. Overall, great experience both food and service! I recommend to anyone wanting to grab lunch, delivery, or a quick bite! read more

See all

Meh....I mean, the slices are huge! But c'mon. We got half eggplant/half olive, onion, and mushroom pie. The eggplant slices are HUGE. Just visually unappealing. The taste was fine though, nothing special. I think the ultimate deal breaker though was the wings. First of all, there was no hole cut in the plastic lid to release the steam and prevent the chicken from getting soggy. So of course, since there was SO much breading they were really soggy, and it was so thick that it was difficult to find the chicken. When I did bite in, my wing was undercooked. That's just a health hazard. read more

See all

I work in the mall nearby and wanted to treat my store to a holiday meal. I normally don't expect much ordering out, and especially when i am not familiar with the place whatsoever. This place has me soooo impressed. I am Italian and will tear apart pizzas and subs. They go since and beyond for their customers and their food really is immaculately made. The counter staff, manager, delivery, everyone i have has the pleasure of encountering were so accommodating and nice. Sorry my review jumps all over the place, just very enthused about this place! I live more south in NJ but whenever i am in the area they will have a repeat customer. read more

I have been a resident of Saddle Brook for over 30 years and everyone here knows Brothers is the place to go!

We ordered both pizza and antipasto salads twice. We are new to this area and were searching for really good pizza. I think we found it. Can't wait to order again. read more