Food is a solid 4 stars but owner and his service makes this a bona fide 5-star enterprise. I had the privilege of growing up in NJ/NY as a child and joke that I have marinara running in my veins. This place is a genuine throwback in everything you want in a locally-owned Italian restaurant. Their pizza and calamari are out of this world. Also ordered their chicken parm empanada and lasagna. However, the empanada came out cold and lasagna was mistaken for linguini. However, the owner personally apologized and remedied both situations without question right away. On our way out he handed me a $10 gift card for our troubles. Not all restaurant owners do this. This is why people on Yelp love and rave about Rosario and Danny - they are owners who truly understand that patrons are why they do what they do. It's not always about the food (which they do well) but about their service, name, reputation, and their customers. Even if I never received the gift card, I would have come back. That said I highly recommend. read more

See all

Been in the area for years, brothers is some of the best pizza around. Best Sicilian I've had in ages, and a damn good grandma pie. Can't go wrong here. read more

Worth the drive. Surprisingly good pizza. Great large tasty slice. Fresh mushrooms and other add on. Plentiful. Some places just put very little additional topping's but brothers is very generous. Friendly customer service read more

This Pizza surely hit the spot. The sauce was Delicious. The crust was crispy but not to crispy. It was cooked perfectly. All around very tasty. Haven't had a slice like this in awhile. The service was also very friendly and accommodating. Thank you! See ya next time read more

Let me tell you man, I was having one of the shittiest days of my life and this place made it all better in a blink of a second. I got out of work late and passed by literally 5 minutes to closing and I asked the gentleman if it was okay for me to get something. He showed me what was available and I ordered. The pizza was delicious, and his kind gesture really made and impact. It's amazing how something so small can do something so great. Will definitely be coming back. read more

Best pizza!!! Fast delivery We love the chicken franchise pizza... highly recommend Brothers pizza

The best pizza I've ever had! We moved a little further away but we continue to make the trip for the pizza. We buy often maybe 3-4 times per month, and they never disappoint. The owners are really nice, the service is phenomenal, and the food is amazing. They also own the pastry shop around the corner, which also has a delicious selection of sweets. I will continue to support this local shop!!! read more

I came here under the recommendations of Yelp. The pizzas are excellent. The staff could be a little more hospitable.But then again this is a pizza shop in NJ read more

Came here on the way home from a long day of working and wedding planning and I'm not exaggerating this might have been the best pizza slices I've had. Perfect plain slice super crispy and the right amount of sauce and cheese. The buffalo slice was PHENOMENAL and they even gave me a side of blue cheese! Absolutely great pizza and super friendly staff and owners turned my day around! Will def come back! read more

My family was hungry last night and it was a bit late. So because of places closing early due to Covid it was hard to find a good place that was open. It was a little before 9pm. I tried my usual places but they were either closed or closing. So I went onto yelp to see if I could find a place with a good rating and still open for delivery. This one popped up so I gave it a try. The person answering the phone was really nice and polite. The delivery came really fast. I ordered a Brooklyn pizza. It was OUTRAGEOUS!!!! The sauce was so good. The crust was so good. Absolutely DELICIOUS!!!! This will now be my go to place for pizza. I will also try other dishes on the menu. Thank you so much for such a great find. Try it. You won't be disappointed. read more

We are originally from the North East, now living in Florida. We couldn't wait to have some pizza during our time here. After carefully reviewing Yelp, we decided to try Brother's Pizza. We ordered the gold standard, a large cheese pie. It became evident that this is more of a take out place then an eat in place when our pizza was put on a tray holder entirely blocking an aisle rather then a table top tray holder. People were reaching over our pie to greet each other. Not very sanitary. The good point. The pizza crust was thin and crisp. The pizza was served bubbling hot. However, the sauce was not very flavorful. I needed to add oregano, garlic and a couple of red pepper flakes. Service was nonexistent. Overall, not a very good experience. I think our pizza place in South Florida is much better. "Stella's " read more

I have NEVER tasted a better Brooklyn Pizza than from this place. We travel to Brooklyn for pizza and suddenly discovered its right here in our backyard! The crust and sauce and cheese is to die for! You will not be disappointed. Hands down better than BROOKLYN!! Janet Calvitti read more

It's a very good slice at an above average price. The location is definitely tucked away deep in Saddle Brook. So deep in fact, that you'll probably need to use gps if you aren't familiar with the area. Definitely a good locals spot, but nearly every town in Bergen County has a pizzeria similar in quality. Think Angelo's in Maywood, or Angelo's in Bogota, or Emiliglia Romana in Wood Ridge for a frame of reference. There's a ton of good pizza in Bergen County. You an add Brothers to the list... read more

Best pizza !!!! The white pie with spinach sooooo good and the regular pizza THE BEST !! Thin crust so good!! Try his dinners portions huge and always delicious ! And after you eat all that good food don't forget to order the homemade cannoli rolls for desert !! They are amazing fast delivery and always consistent great delicious food ! Great place read more

Delicious pizza, the white spinach pie is to die for! The regular pie was out of this world as well. Also great zeppoli with cream

Went to my friends house in saddle brook last night for a little catching up and we decided to order food. After going thru numerous menus of Chinese takeout, the diner and then we found brothers pizza. After looking over the menu my boyfriend and I decided to order the mac and cheese bites, tortellini with alfredo sauce, and chicken franchise. The mac and cheese bites were mac and cheese coated in breadcrumbs and fried (I think they may have been frozen but who cares they were really tasty), the tortellini was cheese filled and the alfredo sauce was delicious and rich with flavor. The chicken franchise is like any other italian place but the sauce is what made it! Each of the entrees were served with a choice of soup or salad I chose the salad and it was delicious! Can't wait to order from here again and try the pizza everyone is raving about! read more

See all

I used this restaurant to cater a dinner and the food was delicious. Everyone could not stop talking about the eggplant rollatini and the seafood salad, it was delicious. The owner was very attentive and accommodating to our requests. Without a doubt I would use Brothers again in the future! read more

There is so many good things i can say about this business. First of all, the pizza and food are so delicious. The pizza has so many varieties and all of them are out of this world. The owner, is so accommodating and personable. If you ever need pizza or food for any event, he is the one to talk to and work with. I had this food for the night before my wedding for over 150 guests and we could not have been happier with the results. The food was amazing, pizza was absolutely delicious. If you want good food and professional service please be sure to stop and visit this restaurant. Trust me, you will not be disappointed read more

Asked for extra cheese and crispy. They delivered on exactly that. I'd give it a 4.5 if I could. Very solid Jersey pizza.

I used to come in to buy pizza every week, the past few times we all noticed the pizza DOES NOT have any flavor ; I'm Italian you should taste the sauce on a pizza : nothing it's a shame they lost another customer They should figure it out !, read more

Even though I repeated my order twice and had the girl read it back to me it still arrived wrong

Izzy- My Wife just picked up Large Cheese pie from your place, the best pizza I had in a long time, best in Town, THANKS!! read more

Brother's Pizza - GREAT PIZZA, BEST IN TOWN!! - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

As a lover of pizza and buffalo chicken, brother's buffalo chicken pizza is on point. Pictured is well done. Friendly staff, quick service. Haven't tried anything but the buffalo chicken pizza. Pretty...pretty... pretty good :) read more

Brother's Pizza - Well done Buff chicken pizza. Plenty of chicken, not overwhelmingly saucy. - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

So good. We order every other week from here and always consistent, from pizza to sandwiches. The ziti pizza is delicious. Haven't tried their sweet shop around the corner yet but will soon! read more

This place has amazing pizza and Italian dishes. The two owners are friendly and the staff is awesome! I can't believe after all these years, I never posted on yelp about how good this place is!! Trust me, if you come here once, you'll be back because EVERYTHING here is delicious! read more

Best pizza in Saddle Brook. Their Brooklyn style Sicilian is amazing and a must have.

I ordered food from brothers for my birthday. We ordered some salads and pizza pies. They even sent over an extra pie and it turned out to be a dessert pie. My whole family loved it and thought it was so nice of them to send us that extra pie. Everything was delicious. I highly recommend. read more

Brother's Pizza - Dessert Pizza with Nutella, banana, strawberries and whip cream. - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Not only is the service great the FOOD IS AMAZING!! Everything on the menu is out of this world. The cafe around the corner is equally as great for all your sweet tooth needs! read more

Brother's Pizza - BEST EVER - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Brothers Pizza is a little hole in the wall place but don't let that fool ya. Brothers has only about four tables but they crank it out. There was about 6 guys working there when I was there. There were cooks , prep people , delivery and the owner overseeing it all. The pizza is great, typical NY NJ thin crust pizza that only taste like it does in New York and New Jersey . They have a huge very creative menu. They deliver. But I'm satisfied with a slice of traditional plain cheese. Wow it's good. read more

Very good and well-cooked pizza. Very friendly and welcoming staff. Would definitely come back again.

I was so disgusted. I order here all the time but when I bit into it and realized it wasn't chicken I just thanked god I wasn't allergic to seafood! How does a shrimp tail end up in my chicken parm wrap?! One star for this one time they will prevent me from ordering from her again read more

Brother's Pizza - I ordered a chicken parm with vodka sauce wrap and when I bit into it and started chewing on a breaded shrimp tail. So disgusted! - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Best pizza in town/surrounding area. Always friendly and accommodating. Chicken francaise and every other entree is MASSIVE and DELICIOUS! Highly recommend Brother's! Although not much seating space read more

One of the best pizzarias in the area, the pizza and food are very tasty, of course the sauce is the best part of any pizza. Brothers pizza as always catered for us and never a disappointment even worked w the menu for our needs read more

Def the best pizza place saddle brook has had in years. The buffalo chicken or the chicken Parm slice is the route to go. Even the regular slice is great. Def recommend this place if you're looking for phenomenal pizza. read more

Great counter help and wonderful food. Been ordering there since it opened and will have no other pizza but theirs.

Great pizza! We are staying nearby and saw this place was close to us. It's a really cool at-home vibe. Kind of like a really nice episode of Sopranos. The owner was really nice and we're probably coming back tomorrow before we head out because my son loved the pizza. read more

They took my thumbs Charlie!! They took my thumbs!! The pizza is very good but taste better on weekdays read more

Brothers is the town pizza place. My family gets pizza from brothers every Friday night. Always the perfect ratio of sauce and cheese. Their specialty pizzas are great too! I've also had sandwiches and salads from brothers and I'm never disappointed. read more

I order Brothers constantly!! They deliver super quick and the food is always fresh and amazing. Tonight specifically I ordered grilled salmon and pesto sauce on penne and it was the best meal I've maybe ever eaten! I would recommend Brothers for lunch, dinner or catering any day! read more

Brother's pizza is by far the best pizza and best Italian food in the area. The owners are amazing and always accommodating and the employees are friendly. I have always had nothing short of an amazing experience from start to finish at Brother's Pizza. Everyone that I have suggested to go and try the food have always loved it! read more