What a horrible first time experience. Such a shame because for a family owned business, you'd expect better. Got there at 7.. there were maybe 8 tables with people in the restaurant (all they can fit). Couple of open tables. Our waitress came over & got our drinks. My party (4 of us), 2 which came at 7:15 sat & we ordered calamari and mozzarella carozza. Both appetizers were eh. We ate because we were hungry (emphasize on hungry). The calamari wasn't all special, it's basic like most restaurants. We finished around 7:30 and ordered our dishes. Two which were chicken parm dishes, a pasta dish & a fish dish. My friend had to leave by 8:15 so we were expecting the entrees to be served by 8. Still waited past then and by 8:15 my friend had to leave (so upsetting). I could make these dishes quicker. Our server then told us that the food was coming out.. it wasn't. The food was served at 8:45. Almost an entire hour, for a slow night which was unacceptable. Around before the food came out, I asked the manager where the food was that it was taking long. What we got in response was basically questioning our ordering skill by saying we didn't order properly, asked us how many appetizers we had, we didn't order everything all together, basically treating us like we went out to eat. It took the 3 of us back. I could not believe the response from this manager. I asked the server as he walked away where the owner was and he came out to the table. I was very frustrated from the managers comments towards my friends and the owner apologized and offered a free drink/dessert. I didn't take a bite of my food because by then I wasn't hungry. It's a shame because the restaurant has potential, but for the size of my closet, the kitchen shouldn't have been as slow as it was. Service was alright, she could have came to the table more to apologize for the wait more than once. I will never be back here ever again. Try Osteria in Garfield, don't waste your time. read more

Went there on the spur of the moment got a great table staff friendly food excellent had a salmon dish, chicken dish and finished off with carrot cake. Good drinks as well diffidently would go back read more

Haven't been here in years. Service was extremely slow had to ask for water twice after initial serving asked for dipping sauce for our bread asked for more but it never came. Food was good but slow basically had to ask for everything two or three times ambience was fine, but if there was music on the weekend, it would be too noisy for me. read more

We went to Goodfellas for Christmas Eve dinner and we had a wonderful time. While the restaurant was incredibly busy they took great care of our family. The Christmas menu was excellent and reasonably priced. While we always enjoy Goodfellas, they made Christmas dinner very special. read more

Kicked off the new year at one of our town's longtime favorites (over 30 years!) enjoying a delicious meal, fabulous drinks, and even better company. Amazing service and a place that always feels like home. read more

GoodFellas Restaurant - Cheers!! - Italian Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

The service, the ambiance, the owners, the wine, the food was off the charts amazing. Can't wait to come back to this part of N J to eat here again. Make reservations please!!!!! read more

My annual birthday gift to my Mother is a meal at our favorite restaurant and Goodfellas did not disappoint. Three of us had the veal and I always say the best veal in the state. Two Veal Parmigianas and one Veal Conte. All outstanding. My sister had the Lamb Chop special which was perfect as well. Always a delight to see Sammy, my personal favorite maître d. Added bonus was seeing Dr. Dan III, his lovely wife Leslie and their children. Well done boys. Can't wait to our next meal there! read more

The food is great love the mustard sauce salmon, and casino clams, service is pretty good and the place is very clean, love the atmosphere, pricey but worth it, I recommend this place read more

Even with living a mile away, I haven't experienced this restaurant until a week ago. The ambiance is excellent and reminds you of an old school Italian restaurant. The menu is quite large plus they have great daily specials. The food is excellent. Everyone enjoyed their food. The service was also wonderful and many people checked on us during the night. The small restaurant can get loud if there is a band or singer, so be aware of that. read more

Consistently outstanding after so many years! Food, service, ambiance, free valet parking (please tip). Not many places left where the smiles are refreshing, the freshness of the veal, chicken, pasta, salads, desserts and extensive wine list continue to deliver. Veal scaloppine, chicken piccata (capers with lemon ), chicken parm w/penne and Caesar salad were all good to the last bite .Real candlelit tables, Frank Sinatra both recorded and in -person.. who does that anymore??! Love this spot. read more

Great food and amazing service. Sammy is the absolute best - goes above and beyond every time we visit!

Great authentic Italian food and friendly staff. My favorite was the meatballs. The chicken parm was recommended and was also amazing! I'll definitely go back for dinner. read more

My company likes to have dinner here whenever we have a national business meeting and the team from all over the country flies in. Always a special treat. This was the first time that I ordered a rack of lamb and it did not disappoint. I ordered it cooked medium and it turned out perfect. Along side we ordered appetizers to include shoestring zucchini, stuffed mushroom, calamari. Pricey but delicious. Parking is quite tight and they do valet. It is a small place so I would definitely recommend to make reservations ahead of time. Service team was good and always came to clear and take our plates at the table to make room for the next dishes. There was live music playing some very classic songs and genres like Frank Sinatra. read more

See all

First time here and will be back. Everything was so delicious and the ambiance is great!!! read more

See all

Food was very delicious and our group basically had a great time. The exception is that the owner/manager chose to not turn on the air conditioning tonight. It was not a good experience for any of us. The staff kept saying there was a problem with the A/C unit. Sure there is. I said it would work if someone turned it on.One said it was maintained at that temperature and then the server apologized so many times for the inconvenience. Trust me that with 97 degree temps, you do not want to be in that restaurant. Not even a fan ran to at least offer some comfort. Definitely do not go there in high heat summer. You will be uncomfortable all the way through. read more

The zucchini flowers was excellent. The food is aways delicious. Sammy and Millie are the best! Going there is like being in your own home.

The food was absolutely amazing and for the price the quality was perfect. The service was quick and attentive and the place inside was beautiful and peaceful. The only thing that should've been better is the dessert prices it was tasty but $14 for a small dessert should be a little cheaper. Highly recommend this restaurant though. read more

GoodFellas Restaurant - Dessert - Italian Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

A delicious and authentic Italian restaurant! From the moment we entered, we were greeted by the owner who personally sat us at our table. The menu has a great variety of options to satisfy everyone as well as a bar! We ordered CHICKEN PARMIGIANA, POLLO SCARPARIELLO, and SHRIMP SCAMPI (which were all delicious!). For dessert we ordered a Tiramisu and cheese cake! We had an amazing time here with great authentic Italian food! read more

See all

Outstanding meal. Veal was perfect, as was the pappardelle. Fresh bread was excellent as well. read more

GoodFellas Restaurant - Veal Scallopine Saltimbocca Pappardelle ala Vodka - Italian Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

AMAZING FOOD! Zucchini Fritti great-Pollo Scarppariello SO GOOD -Carrot cake was to die for! read more

GoodFellas Restaurant - Pollo Scarpariello - Italian Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

The food is always amazing there has never been a dish I have not liked! When you go there it's like you're eating with family, it's a great place, with great music too! read more

Great food! Bread and oil dip is amazing! Love the zucchini appetizer. Chicken Marsala is excellent. Valet parking.

The food was excellent here. Had the Veal Scallopini with a side of mashed potato's and vegetables. Generous portion and perfectly cooked. They have valet parking and the service was very good. When we sat down their was no wine list but I'm sure they'd provide one if asked. Full bar. read more

The best Italian dinner I think I've ever had. Simply the best all around. I would highly recommend. Gary

Wow! This was very cool. A hidden gem in an older neighborhood. If you delicious Italian food, then look no further than Goodfellas. My friend had been here before and insisted that we went there for lunch and it was great. I had the pasta alla vodka and my friend had the chicken parmigiana. I cleaned my plate which is very unusual. Come check it out. read more

Ray Liotta had just died and we wanted some Italian food- why not try a new place. Goodfellas has valet parking which was a nice touch. Inside is decorated in goodfellas pics- posters and some personal photos. Modest interior makes you feel at ease and not at a pretentious restaurant. Specials are priced as normal as a North Jersey Italian restaurant- slightly high. Menu has all that you would want. Drinks are yummy and they start your dining experience with some amazingly hot bread with a magical oil / cheese dip. read more

GoodFellas Restaurant - a hand holding a bag - Italian Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Great spot and very popular with the locals and especially the regulars. Always looks full any day of the week. Italian classic food made simple and to the point. read more

Great "Old School" Italian in Bergen County. Been there 3 times in the last few years for lunch with my college buddy. Service is excellent. Food was delicious, especially the veal dishes. They have an extensive menu which includes many daily specials. Prices by today's standards are very reasonable. Goodfellas is a must try. read more

Step inside to a world where time seems to have come to a standstill. A space where staff moving busily from one space to another creating the Illusion of activity and serving tables. The next moment you realize you've crossed into another dimension. Welcome to the Twilight Zone........ We were having a small reunion with another couple we hadn't seen in years. We landed here as the mid point meeting point. The staff is nice, but they are excruciatingly slow. 15 mins for a drink, 25 mins for the entree, and so on. And it wasn't just our table I noticed the same at every table. The food is ok, but dated. We put up with the wait because we were talking so much. I think it's a one and done for us. read more

First time here and had a really great experience. You get free bread and a mixture of Parmesan cheese & olive oil to start, so yummy. Our meals were delicious I had the chicken Milanese with fettuccine Alfredo pasta & I really enjoyed it. My fiancé had the penne vodka with chicken Milanese as well. His came with a smart portion of pasta but it was very good. read more

Came here for my parents bday dinner. I think the ambiance is nice and service was great. The food is why I have to only give three stars. It's just okay. Nothing special. Nothing I would go out of my way for. I tried the shrimp scampi and there is nothing good or bad to say. I liked my boyfriends meat sauce on his pasta more than my food. My mom had a fish dish and barely ate it. She didn't think it was fresh. read more

GoodFellas Restaurant - Shrimp scampi - Italian Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

Incredible service. Well made drinks. Great location for an authentic Italian dinner, without the uncertainty of the ending of the Sopranos.

Best Italian food in New Jersey. Always fresh and delicious. Service excellent ---ambiance comfortable and welcoming. I highly recommend this wonderful restaurant. read more