Finally got to try this place out after my friend told me about years ago. They don't have any pizza pies on display but they do serve slices. I got the Hot honey heaven slice which consists of tomato base, pepperoni, crispy chicken, ricotta and Mike's hot honey, really good. Parking is limited. I heard there is a parking lot across the street ;) * 4.5 stars read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - Plain and hot honey heaven slices - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

I've seen this spot pop-up on my socials a lot recently, so I decided to place an order on a day I had errands around this business. First off, I did a call-in order (very 2000s, I know). I could tell the business was very busy, but I was so surprised that despite being surrounded by the "crazy" she was doing her best to suggest what she liked and then after speaking a bit, what I might like. She was very helpful and considerate despite me calling during the "lunch rush". I came into the business --- small but efficient space --- and it was a quick transaction. My kind of place. As I was eating for 1, I didn't want to be a true "big-back", new year, new resolutions. I just got a 10' Neo Margherita Pizza + Parmesan Peppercorn Bone-In Wings. So the thing that makes Grumpy's stand-out and different from the competition? Boy oh boy, that crust. It is sourdough, it is crisp, it is light, it is so complimentary to anything that goes on it. I truly understand the hype about their pizzas --- and I truly can't wait to try more from their establishment. On to the wings; I ordered the Parmesan Peppercorn Bone-In Wings, simply because it's a flavor I don't see too regularly on the menus. It was exquisite; I could only imagine how much better it would've tasted fresh from the fryer. I had a 15 minutes drive until I had eaten the food. So the food-fluencers are not lying about this place. Check 'em out --- an awesome business ran by awesome people. read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - 10' Neo Margherita Pizza + Parmesan Peppercorn Bone-In Wings - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Probably the best pizza I've had in a very long time!!! My son & I were on the way home from his private school entrance exam and as a treat I told him we could get some pizza. We came here and there were a ton of people waiting for their orders. A few chairs along the window, but it's definitely a take out place. It was about 7:45 when we arrived and they told us it would be about a 30min wait for our order. They were not grumpy at all, very nice in fact! We waited in our car. The time came, we went back in, waited about another 5min and our order was called. I wish they were closer to where we live!! read more

See all

Definitely get any pizza and absolutely the creamy buffalo wings. Idk what they put it in but hands down top 5 wings I've had. Theyre juicy and seasoned very well. I think I liked the wings over the pizza more The crust on each pie was great. I did like the hot honey meat lovers but I think it was too much honey for me. My family loved it. My go to for sure would be the wings and jalepeno pie. read more

See all

Every pie we ordered was delicious and perfectly cooked, no flop. I love the variety of pies and flavors they offer, and the service was just so friendly and accommodating. Would definitely recommend! read more

See all

If you like thin crispy pizzas, this is the place for you! They don't skimp out on the toppings, and I love the extra basil they give as well. You can go for classic pies like Margherita or heavy, loaded ones like the Garbage Pie. I also like that you can customize the level of crispiness and the crust flavors. I'd love to try the square pies and see how the sourdough tastes different or similar to the regular pies. read more

See all

This was ordered and delivered. It was hands down the best tasting pizza, sandwiches, and salads I have had in a long time. Everything was perfection. Huge portions, fresh, and so so delicious. I almost want to not recommend it so I can have the place to myself!! read more

See all

I was a victim to social media marketing on a Saturday morning as I scrolled through my TikTok and saw that Dave Portnoy reviewed this place a couple of days ago. I was intrigued by the sourdough aspect to this place and decided to stop by. We got the regular cheese and the drunk chicken parm, both personal pies (they don't do individual slices). Now I'm sure they've gotten so popular after Dave's visit (rightfully so), and we waited about 30 min for our pizzas, and even got to meet the owner. Definitely worth the wait!! The drunk chicken parm was so flavorful, deff my favorite flavor. Would love to taste my way through the rest of their options! read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - 10" Classic Cheese Pizza & 10" Drunk Chicken Parm Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

All I can say is this pizza was to die for. I just kept eating slice after slice after slice. I've been trying to order here for weeks, but they're always so busy and now I understand why. Can't wait to try their other menu items, but it will be hard to deviate from this delicious hot honey heaven pizza read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - 10" Hot Honey Heaven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Loved the wings. easily some of the meatiest wings I've had in a while and I loved em. Fried oreos knocked it out of the park too. it's takeout only and by the time I got home my pizza was kinda floppy which I could get but after air frying it was still kinda chewy. I will definitely be back to try more of their stuff cause the sourdough garlic bread subs and a regular sized pie which i will eat in the car for the freshest flavor. the subs look insanely delicious and hopefully after that I can update to even more stars haha. Also I am a pink sauce snob and this one wasn't quite up to my standards. Service was good and the place is takeout only so def place ur order ahead if you don't wanna wait. read more

Pizza on sourdough bread? Count me in. Grumpy's Pizza looks to be the place everyone likes to hang out in SaddleBrook. You walk in and you feel you are part of the family. Small scale, a lot of love built in to this place with a lot of creating happening between the dough behind the glass or the sauces being assembled to the side. It's a good kinda busy to walk into when you are waiting. I ordered The Grumpy Pie. After reading the framed articles by the window, I didn't know the owner liked the order too. I thought it was pretty cool. My husband ordered his pie and a side of wings. My Grumpy Pie was flavorful. A little too much sauce for me, however if you love burrata, you gotta try this out. I love having sourdough and thought it was neat to try it with pizza. I see why customers love it here. All payments accepted, slightly cheaper with cash. Parking can be tricky, choose your spots and read all signs. What a delicious night, be back next time! read more

See all

What an incredibly amazing Pizza place! Old school! No it's not fancy in there but you can grab a slice and eat at a counter. The owners and staff are friendly as can be and most importantly, this is without question the best pizza in New Jersey. Beautiful crispy crust, not like a cracker like a pizza crust is supposed to be! Sourdough. Outstanding delicious sauce that is full flavored without being acidic and without being sweet. Their ingredients are great their Pizza is crazy good. I had three different kinds today and will be getting many more in the days and weeks and months to come! If you haven't come to this wonderful place you need to! read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

See all

No longer live in Jersey, but whenever I get back, no matter how short, look for recommended pizza, this was at top of folks' lists. So glad I got there. The sourdough crust was amazing, pizza delicious. I added some veggies. You can order it to the level of done you want. The owner and his wife were so nice. No dine-in, a couple of seats by counter along window, I ate there. read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - Sourdough personal size pie, few veggies added. - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

The food was delicious and the restaurant went above and beyond to deliver my order when an issue arose with the Grubhub delivery driver. I'm very grateful - amazing service!!! read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - 10" Meat Haters Pizza (Veggies) - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Ordered through ubereats so I can't speak to the location experience-only the food, however for me that's enough. I ordered the personal Hot Honey Heaven Pie and it was indeed heaven! It's very rich in flavor and the portion is well worth the price even as a "personal" - I only got through 2 slices in one sitting. The pepperoni, ricotta and breaded chicken with the hot honey drizzle on a thin crispy crust was exceptional. I will definitely be returning and recommending. read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - 10" Hot Honey Heaven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

The staff was incredible! We drove an hour to try their pizza. On arrival we realized that there was no dine in service. We placed our order and the team expedited our pie which was amazing! Perfect crust, consistently excellent bite to bite. 5 stars! read more

Grumpy's...technically: Grumpy's Pizza Co. (Sourdough Pizza)....may look like a regular Jersey pizzeria. But you would be totally wrong. Grumpy's is 5+ Star for casual Italian food. Not only with traditional items like chicken parm, heros & pizza (10",16" or square; all with a special sourdough crust that is crisp & so good)), but very creative & well executed dishes like these we tried: --Hot Honey Heaven Pizza with San Marzano Tomato Base, Pepperoni, Crispy Chicken, Ricotta & Mike's Hot Honey -- Eggplant Rollatini Pizza with Crispy Eggplant, Ricotta, Homemade Basil Pesto, Grandma Sauce & Parmigiano Reggiano Amazing selection of salads bursting with loads of fresh ingredients like the : --Half Spinach & Fig Salad with Baby Spinach, Mission Figs, Pecans, Baby Mandarins & Goat Cheese with Mandarin Ginger Dressing. The menu is huge. Nothing boring. Can't wait to try more and more items. Highly recommended! ( parking in rear and real friendly staff too) read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - eggplant pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

See all

Yes but be patient ! It's too good and everyone wants their pizza NOW ! Hmm and other items on the menu are a must taste ! Not To mention the wings ! read more

I've had a couple of their pies before and wanted to try the mushroom truffle one. It was very good but I found the crust to be thicker than the pies I've gotten previously which I wasn't much of a fan of however the taste and toppings were done well. They also cooked it perfectly medium as I requested. read more

See all

I ordered grumpy's hot honey pepperoni pizza for pick up and had a long wait. 95 minutes! I thought well if they are that busy they must be good. I was not so pleased, the pizza box was not hot, so of course the pizza was cold. It was also very bland, not very much pepperoni and very little hot honey taste, with more of a cardboard taste. The price was also very high. The did a great job on the advertising, so that's why I tried it. I would not recommend. I gave it 2 stars for the advertising. read more

Sadness. We order from here almost on a weekly basis. Unsure what's been happening as of recent, but it's been a miss. A few weeks ago, they sent the delivery to the wrong address, and we got our meal VERY late. No resolution; just an sorry oh well. Today we got our order, and my pizza was VERY dry; almost like missing a sauce. May have to look for another place if it happens again. read more

See all

This is Pizza Worth Traveling for. The sourdough crust doesn't just make Grumpy's different; it makes it delicious! The crust was perfectly crisped and every topping was prepared and portioned to perfection. We tried the Hot Honey Heaven, Garbage Pie and Big Grump Pizzas and all were incredible! I like that on their online ordering platform you can choose the crust doneness and other options. We also got an order of their Fried Calamari which also thoughtfully incorporated hot peppers, adding some perfect pizzazz! The service and atmosphere was above the bar for a walk-in pizza place however, I recommend you order ahead of time and find an alternative place to eat as it is mostly a takeout establishment. read more

Awesome pizza! I really enjoyed the sourdough crust. I actually liked the classic better than the veggies. I'm not sure how the storefront or sit down is, but as a take out option - I would stick to the classic plain and pair it with a nice wine. It's a good pie and definitely would recommend. Looking forward to trying it with hot honey next time! read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - plain pizza and veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

See all

Hankering for pizza not only satisfied but also energized to comeback for more! Small shop with limited parking in the back. They have the option to sit inside but it's also limited seating too. The owner greeted us warmly and took our order. I was set on the personal white pizza. Got it with regular crust and added extra mushrooms (it's portobello). Received our order between 10-15 minutes. Had to take it to-go as our baby was tired and getting restless. The pizza box had a few sprigs of basil inside that made opening the box a lovely experience. Not only was the pizza cooked to perfection, the taste was on point too! The white sauce was perfect, not too much or too little. The ricotta was on every bite. And the mushrooms were plentiful! My only issue is not ordering it in a large size. I would love to try this place again while I'm visiting. I can see why they are a local favorite! read more

See all

I love New and interesting places. Saw they had a prosciutto & pear pizza. Wasn't bad. Got black & white sesame crust as well.!great flavor in every bite. I tried the Parmesan truffle boneless wings. Weren't the best was a little disappointed was a little dry. Would go back if in area. read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - Boneless Wings - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

See all

The sourdough crust was crispy, crunchy and chewy....absolutely delicious! We had the cheese and spinach & artichoke...they were both a hit with the family. read more

Grandma Pizza and Margherita Pizza flavor wise was decent pizza. We got the garlic crust but it didnt taste too different from regular crust. The bottom of the pizza had a lot of burnt parts that had to be avoided while eating. The arugula pear and goat cheese salad was worth getting and the serving was huge. We also tried the sourdough garlic bread which barely had any butter/garlic flavor which was super disappointing. We were told it would be a 30 min wait but it took almost an hour. Not the best but not the worst read more

Still waiting for my delivery for over an hour PAST the delivery time quote. I paid for expedited delivery and nothing. ZERO communication and ZERO discount to make things right. It's amazing how far a simple apology call or text would go, but nothing. Now I have to leave a bad review because simple courtesy is ignored. This pizza is very good, but we aren't in Alva, Oklahoma, this is Bergen County, New Jersey. There's a ton of great pizzerias they're competing with. Shame. read more

The pizza is spectacular! The crust is so crunchy and holds well. The toppings are amazing. They do get backed up so order early. Also, parking is bad in that area. read more

I went to this place because I saw good reviews on tik tok -went and requested slices and unfortunately and they said they don't sell slices only pies . I said that is not posted online! very rude about it like I'm supposed to know that!! I just left -counter girls were rude ! Treat your potential customers better!! read more

The pizza is very good and they have a lot of variety. But get it delivered because trying to pick up at that place during any kind of a peak time is an absolute nightmare. You're really not supposed to park on the street there and the lot in the back is basically nonexistent plus it's a one vehicle road so very hard to turn around in. Better yet park across the street in the little strip mall. They really should think about moving to a much better location. They should take that eyesore, vacated for years pizza place by the light and move in there. read more

This pizza was so good I got the margarita pizza with customized dark, crunchy crust and garlic crust. I love how you can choose a different type of crispiness of the crust. This was one of the best margarita pizzas I've ever had it was super saucey. I love how juicy it was that you couldn't even see the dough through it. This is definitely my go to spot now because how delicious the crust was and the ratio of sauce they provided. read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - 16" Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

After trying Grumpys 3 times I can confidently say it is my only pizza place I will go to from here. I've had the sliders, sub, and multiple pizzas and they were all fantastic. I don't usually order sauces on the side but tried the pink and the red and I was blown away with how good the red sauce was. Me and my sister absolutely loved the garlic knots. Felt light and crunchy. Other places are very dense and hard so it was wonderful here. I can't wait to try the other menu options here. read more

Amazing pizza! Ordered the Chicken parmigiana pizza with garlic crust and it was so delicious and the crust was so good! Crispy and the cheese/sauce combo was perfect. Ordered the coconut shrimp and that was good too! Can't wait to try other things. Ordered from grubhub so they were ready in time for pickup so service seems good. read more

What a bummer. I have been ordering there for almost a year now, and tonight out of all nights I order buffalo chicken pizza, and instead of it being with grilled chicken as always, it was with fried chicken cutlet pieces. No Thank you. read more

I went to visit family in NJ and they ordered Grumpys. They ordered plain, pepperoni and half a tray of wings. My favorite was the pepperoni pizza. The pizza is sauce and the crust is super crunchy and tasted really good. I could have eaten 3 slices. They aren't big slices so you can def eat more than one slice. The wings were good we got plain wings with a aside of mild. Good pizza in my opinion. read more

Drive all the way from Long Island! Definitely yummy. I liked the"personal" pie idea. We got 2 and shared different flavors. The garlic knots were more like zeppoles with garlic topping It finely took me off guard, but I kinda liked it! I love that they give the marinara and vodka sauceeee. Game charger. If I lived closer, this would be a more regular spot for us! The staff was kind and quick. As for the ambiance, I wish they'd flip the seating and put it newr the bathroom and supplies on the counter side. It'd be more inviting and flow better for customers. read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

See all

I personally thought the pizza looked good online , it had mad sauce (like a lot of sauce) too much sauce if you ask me.. overall the crust was decent but it's a 4/10 for me, the sauce was over powering thick and not in the good way. read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - Really wanted to like. - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Amazing customer service and delicious pizza! Try the prosciutto and pear with a garlic and oil base, instead of tomato, and you'll have a winner. Maybe we can convince them to make it a regular menu item. So delicious! read more

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Holy shi* $24 for wings? No thanks Small pizza and wings $50! Even if the food was amazing which it isn't this it outrageously expensive. read more