I first heard of this spot via YouTube and after looking it up on Yelp, I noticed a couple of my Yelp Elitist friends have also reviewed this spot with good ratings. So added to my list of places to go. Came here on a Thursday afternoon. The place has an old school pizzeria vibe to it. Once you enter, you place your order at the counter. I knew I had to get the Sicilian slice and the person taking my order suggested I get the sausage slice so I got both. The sausage slice was really good and the sausage didn't seem like your typical frozen sausage. The Sicilian was also really solid. If I'm in the area I will stop by to try other topping slices. Solid pizza joint. * Parking on premise * Cash only * Indoor door seating (limited) * Outdoor dining available * Each table has its own Parmesan shaker * Plastic utensils individually packaged read more

See all

I honestly am beginning to question who is writing these pizza reviews in north Jersey because there is no way Lodi Pizza should be 4 stars overall ... like no way possible because there's not a single 4 star aspect of the establishment. The pizza is literally like a thinner triangle sliced version of Ellio's frozen pizza as you can see from the pictures ... that dough / crust had to be mass produced and the slices are the size of what you would get back in school for lunch on pizza Fridays. They then have the nerve to be cash only in 2025 ... unless you're using a business credit card .... like whaaaat???? And the place definitely needs a cleaning from top to bottom and also needs to put away the pile of fluorescent light bulbs that were just thrown on one of the benches at a table. Never again! read more

See all

Review from a poor man. This place reminds me of the pizza I have grown up with. So it is very nostalgic in that sense (except it is cooked a little bit more and I am more than fine with that). Now it isn't as thin as I like my pizzas to be at this stage in my life but it was a tasty enough pizza. I would have it again but it isn't my first choice. The side salad I got was, also, not amazing but it was good for a side salad. Way much tomato's Just sayin. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - The pizza box. - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

My love was in the mood for Sicilian pie. I was in the mood for mussels and a hunk of bread. The mussels were delicious! Tender and tasty. The tomato sauce was sweet and fresh. The bread was a substantial little loaf that held up to the sauce. What more can you ask for? It made me happy. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

See all

Fair prices, ready fast, fresh, and well seasoned. Fair prices on snacks, drinks, and other menu items as well. Friendly service. Plenty of seating. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

This is a great pizza place. Bottom line. I have eaten pizza many places, and I am especially a fan of Sicilian. Lodi makes one of the best. The crust is crispy, it has plenty of mozz on top, the tomato sauce is sweet and prominent, and the bready part is soft but not soggy. That's a A+ pizza for me read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Sicilian pie to go. - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

Really like this place. Stopped in a few times and got slices. I really enjoyed their white slice so this time we got a whole pie. $20 good size pie that was delicious. I walked in ordered and it was ready in about 15 minutes. They have all sorts of options and they have fountain sodas. Which is a huge plus for a pizzeria. A lot of the trendy new spots don't. Now if you are a thin crust pizza eater this probably isn't for you. This is old school NJ pizza at its finest. A little thicker a little more cheese. The people that work there are all pretty nice. In the main room they have bunch of sopranos themed stuff on the walls. They also have a side room with a bunch of Misfits memorabilia. Very cool! read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Side room with Misfits memorabilia - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

See all

Really great NYC style pizza. I didn't think I could find this style pizza unless I was in NYC. I truly love this pizza. It's so fresh and delicious. The crust is perfection. As a bonus, the service is super friendly! I can't wait to try what else they have. Bonus trivia: a scene from the Sopranos, season 3, episode 4, was filmed here read more

See all

I only had pizza from here when neighbors had gotten delivery many years ago. I had wanted to come for a while but saw the reviews got really bad but I checked again and was seeing great reviews so I went. I wanted a plain slice and asked the girl there what her favorite was and she said pepper and onion so I got a slice of that also and I spotted large rice balls so I took one home to have the next day. The slices looked really good and the undercarriage had great color however I found it to be very salty and heavy, too much cheese and sauce for the dough. The pepper and onion was better but again too heavy. The rice ball I had the next day was unimpressive. I'm not sure if the latest reviews were from customers back in the day when this was supposed to be some of the best pizza around but I certainly didn't feel that way. read more

See all

If you want a pizza that tickles the deep part of you that yearned for a Chuck E. Cheese pie as a kid, you've met it. Lodi pizza is virtually no-flop without being too thin or dry. It's well-sauced, so you don't get an imbalance of salty cheese. The cheese pull is magnificent. It's oily enough to feel good, but not so greasy that you can't easily house half a pie (don't look at me). There's not much else to say. It's not fancy, it's simply done right. Also, their soda fountain is fantastic. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

Ordered for pick-up for lunch on a Friday, and was quoted a 20-30 minute wait time. No online ordering, and cash only. We ordered a supreme Sicilian pie, which had pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives, and anchovies. They'll ask if you want anchovies included, which is nice since it's not for everyone. I happen to like anchovies so I appreciated that this was included because not many places do. I liked the crust - it had the perfect amount of crispiness and bite to it. Pies are on the pricier side - this one was $30, but they don't skimp on the toppings. Would definitely order again next time I'm in the mood for a Sicilian slice. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

I've been wanting to try this place for a while now. Tried the plain cheese pie with half sausage and a margherita. Big chunks of sausage, plenty of cheese, and lots of basil on the margherita. All solid pizzas with a crispy crust, mine were on the more "well done" side. Would be interested in trying the Sicilian and zeppoles. Called ahead for pickup - there is some seating inside but it's small. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Half cheese half sausage - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

See all

Pizza has fantastic crunch on the bottom. Sauce is good. Cheese is good. Sicilian is amazing. Nice little local spot that's been there for like 50 years and the staff is very friendly. Especially Kevin! read more

Very popular pizza spot that I been wanting to try but the slices here is a little bit on the thicker end but pizza was very juicy and cheesy so that was great! Love that they also have outdoor seating too read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

Got two pies from this places after seeing it featured on Dave Potnuy's page and it's solid pizza. I give it a 7.8 on the one bite review. No flop on the slice. Had to drive through 7 towns to get here because no matter what they tell you Jersey's pizza scene is overrated and no decent places in or near Lyndhurst, NJ. Has the ambiance of an old school pizza joint that looks like it's been open since the 70s. Friendly service. I'll come back. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

The Sicilian pie was delicious! Highly recommend!! We also ordered a meatball pie and one with spinach. All were great and tasted just as good reheated in the toaster oven the next day! read more

I have been wanting to try this place forever. Well I finally got here and I love everything about the inside old skool pizza joint. The pizza is GOOD!! Went at lunch time and there was a constant flow of patrons coming in. Staff was friendly. Cash only read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Plain and Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

Classic spot, chill staff, very good pizza just bring cash. Right off the highway outdoor seating is nice when the weather is nice nothing beats that read more

Lodi Pizza is fantastic! A great stop for a slice of a fresh pie. It's right off of 46 and has a good sized parking lot. The vibe here is incredibly old school and retro. The menu is vintage and so is the cash register. It's very cool! The staff is friendly and they know what they're doing. My friend and I got a large pepperoni pie, a pepperoni Stromboli and a cheese calzone. All absolutely delicious. The dough is great, the fillings are generous. The pizza is great too, the crust is not too thin and not too thick - just perfect. Great sauce, good amount of toppings. Really, no complaints. I can definitely see myself ordering from here in the future. read more

Good Pizza, Mussels, Sicilian and Regular. Fresh, does a good buisiness. Good friendly service Fair prices Good Food read more

My boyfriend and I had this place on our list for a while since we always see it while driving down 46. This place isn't bad, but it just isn't my favorite in the area. We ordered a Sicilian Pizza, Pie (1/2 Veggie, 1/2 Pepperoni), and Mozzarella Sticks. The Sicilian was pretty straightforward, but the veggie tasted a bit bland (too much onion or not enough mushroom, idk). What was consistent among the 2 pies was the amount of oil that sat on it. We had to dab it with paper towels before biting into a slice because it was just too much. Just be aware that it is CASH ONLY (at least the day we ordered). We weren't told that when we placed the order over the phone, but we were lucky to have had some on hand. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Left: Sicilian Pie, Right: 1/2 Veggie + 1/2 Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

An excellent old-school pizza parlor, not a restaurant, not a fast-food place, not a tentacle of huge corporation. We ordered a large cheese pie which is the time-honored test for pizzas. The three prime components cheese, sauce, and crust each have to stand on there own for a good pizza. The cheese is absolutely the best cheese I've had on a pizza in at least twenty years. The sause is also the best in at least twenty years. The crust while the best in the last twenty years was a little to dense for my personal taste but the left over slices the next day were near perfect and the slices reheated quite nicely. So if you're tired of crappy pizza go to Lodi Pizza for a pie or a slice and you'll wonder why to didn't go sooner. read more

The best pizza that I have had near Hasbrouck Heights, NJ. Don't call in your order. It is better to do it at the counter so you can watch his long-time customers order and Frank the owner say hi to everyone who has been going to this place since they were kids. The pizza? The best no-credit is just cash. read more

The aftertaste of this pizza is terrible. I haven't had pizza this bad in a long time. How do people eat this pizza?

Lodi Pizza is a staple on Route 46 for a number of years and so popular that even celebrities frequent the place (as indicated by their wall of fame). After ordering a few times from here, I can see why. They take their time with the service because there are so many orders for pickup. From the time I parked to the time I walked out with the food there must have been at least 5 people in and out with their orders. Mind you, I was there for about 5 mins max. We most recently had the Sicilian - half veggie half pepperoni and it was excellent - not too bready and the sauce was almost sweet and delicious. I can't help but think that they even slice their pepperoni a sliver thicker than other restaurants because I felt like I got more for each bite. The veggie part was great too because of the mushrooms and the olives. If you're looking for that Sicilian goodness, look no further than Lodi Pizza on Route 46! read more

As usual , another excellent meatball pie. Crisp crust / excellent count on the meatballs read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Meatball pie - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

See all

All areas are excellent food service well this is an authentic pizza place and its ambience is real and comfortable No person should not be satisfied with anything they order. read more

Guys is this is CLASSIC spot. Honestly worth a visit if you're in the north jersey area. Lots of memorabilia inside from the misfits and sopranos. What I love about the spot is that they actually still speak Italian there. the pizza is great. Little on the greasy side but so good either way! read more

Great and efficient service. Food was very good and perfectly seasoned. The workers were very sweet and the hospitality was great.

Tonight I bought a calzone at Lodi Pizza and you tell me why a place I thought was one of last old school treat you right places sold me this piece of s'h't read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Are you serious thx - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

I've been meaning to go to Lodi pizza for a while, so I finally got there. I ordered a plain slice. It was hot and gooey and just hit the spot. The staff is nice and friendly. Shout out to Kevin! I ordered some zeppoli to go, and they were on point. I don't know what took me so long to go there, but I will be back! read more

Amazing "old school" NJ pizza. I can honestly say being from NJ and living in NYC for the past 10 yrs or so...that there are a select few NJ pizza spots that top NYC spots, and this is one! read more

See all

I have been going here for over 3 decades and it continues to be the gold standard when it comes to my favorite pizza spot! The same guy (the owner) has been serving me pizza since the 90s. Sausage Sicilian pie w/ Cherry Pepsi is my go-to. I love this place! It is definitely a taste of the "Old" NJ! Lodi Pizza was featured in Season 3 of the Sopranos and the walls are covered with pictures of celebrities that have eaten there like Joe Pesci, Reggie White, Real1 (fka Enzo Amore in WWE). Definitely would recommend for take out or a to get a quick slice. FYI this place is CASH ONLY but there is an ATM on site. read more

Best Pizza in New Jersey hands down. Sauce on the pizza is just delicious and the crust has the perfect crunch and the pizza is always cooked perfection. Frank the owner is the best. He puts his heart and soul into that place. Been going there since I was a little kid. read more

the best pizza I've ever had in my life. I'm from Egypt, and I've never eaten better pizza than this. read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - "Literally the best pizza I've ever had in my life. I'm from Egypt, and I've never eaten better pizza than this. - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

See all

I know pizza. Been around the u.s and tried allot of places. I usually try top rated spots and this place is definitely up there! Barstool needs to rate it! read more

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!! My uncle knows the owner and has bin going there since he was a kid. The food is sooooo good. YOU HAVE TO GO. But it is cash only. read more

I ordered a pie with half mushrooms and onions and half buffalo chicken, it was undoubtedly delicious and will definitely go there again read more

Lodi Pizza Restaurant - Pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Lodi, New Jersey

Great pizza , the few times I have been there I have been happy with my pizza choice , old fashion pizzeria can't complain

A friend asked us to order the Old Fashioned Bianca (onions and anchovies). I will give it up that they crumble the anchovies and not just slab them on the pizza. We ordered half Bianca and the other half sausage, pepper and onions. The pizza was a bit chewy. We've tried this place twice already and are not wowed by it. Perhaps next time we will ask them for well done. The zeppolisare on point though! read more

See all