Let me start by saying overall, Wallington Deli is excellent. The Chicken parm vodka and the bread are delicious. However...... I ordered the eggplant parm sandwich and I will say, unequivocally, do NOT order this. It's a complete and utter failure and I'll explain why. The eggplant itself is cut so thin, about 2mm on a mandolin. Instead of bread crumbs, it's coated with a foamy egg batter. Fried. There is barely any sauce on it and two lumpy pieces of mozzarella on it. Tasteless. And for $14, I tossed it in the garbage. Stick to the chicken parms. I will still patronize this place, but never again, the eggplant. read more

I finally made it!! Small deli in a small shopping section. Limited parking in the lot but there is street parking as well. Very no frills inside; just how I like it. Everyone inside was inviting and polite. Service was top notch. I got the chicken cutlet with pesto and fresh mootz. Only thing I wasn't crazy about was the oil and vinegar on this particular sammich.. I know for next time. Quality was out of this world. Mootz was fresh. Chicken cutlet was fresh. A home run all day long. A must try if in the area read more

Wallington Deli - Chicken cutlet with fresh mootz and pesto. - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

Great tasting sandwich bread made in house crispy n airy n plenty of meats. It's my go to Sandwich guy Paulie

This is an excellent deli. It's reputation, to me, exceeds it by a bit, but that doesn't take away from what it is. If you go here, you're going to get good bang for the buck. Nothing fancy, but if you want a generously loaded serious sandwich at a reasonable price, this is a good bet. The service is friendly and efficient. read more

Their buffalo chicken salad with ranch dressing is amazing. The service is good. I waited less than 10 minutes for my food.

This spot is an "if you know you know" Jersey legend. Wallington Deli is renowned for its house-baked bread and freshly made mozzarella. When I say fresh, I mean so fresh that the gentleman pulling the mozzarella to finish it pulled a sheet right in front of me for my sandwich, still hot and melted. This remains the only place where I've seen the mozz on my sandwich being made. I got the chicken parm cutlet. The bread was perfectly crusty and held up to the sauce well. The chicken cutlet was perfectly fried and crispy. The staff was welcoming and friendly. I did feel like the sauce could have benefited from a touch more salt, but overall, the most magical experience a person can get in Wallington. I'll certainly be back! read more

Wallington Deli - The mozzarella that went on my sandwich being freshly made! - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

A staple in my deli rotation. Home made bread is spot on. Staff is very chill and menu is super customizable.

Fantastic deli with a perfect menu. No stupid sandwich names, just perfectly executed sandwiches. Bread is the best around. read more

Wallington Deli - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

See all

This sandwich was great! The bread was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The chicken cutlet is as good as everyone is saying and the vodka sauce was tasteful. I like that they put the sandwich in a container since the sandwich can get messy. I'll definitely be back to try other sandwiches and definitely recommend it if you're in the area. read more

Wallington Deli - Recent menu - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

See all

Absolutely amazing sandwiches the cheesesteak is legit good stuff can't get better around and that cutlet sandwich omg I can taste it so good can't wait to go again and try more of the menu small tiny place but cozy very nice staff read more

Excellent fresh deli sandwiches. Too bad I'm moving out of the area but I highly recommend this place. Ordered through Uber Eats.

Just wow. I had the #2 chicken cutlet sandwich with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, a drizzle of balsamic, and a touch of fresh basil, and it was absolutely incredible. Every bite was bursting with flavor--the chicken was crispy and tender, the mozzarella creamy and fresh, and the peppers added the perfect sweetness. The balsamic brought everything together beautifully, and that hint of basil? Chef's kiss. It was refreshing, satisfying, and honestly one of the best sandwiches I've ever had in a long time. read more

Wallington Deli - #2 - #Chicken #Cutlet, #Fresh #Mozzarella, #Roasted #Peppers w/ #Balsamic and #Basil - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

Have gotten uber eats from them twice in 3 days. I have yet to visit their store but I can firmly state that their italian sub is the best I have ever tried in my life. Bread is so fresh and has the perfect amount of crunch on the outside and is deliciously soft on the inside. Everything inside is perfectly ratio'd and super high quality. A perfect italian sub. The vodka parm was pretty great too. read more

Wallington Deli - Vodka parm - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

See all

This places is a sleeper. What a phenomenal sandwich. Who knew, I had a 5/5, a 10/10 right on my door step. I've tried all the sandwiches around here, some better than others, but this one is the best. This is the best Italian sandwich around, I can't wait to go back and try their other sandwiches. The bread is fresh baked, the cold cuts are succulent and the lettuce is crisp, right amount of vinegar. This is an old school good Italian combo. I'm elated read more

Wallington Deli - Italian sandwich w provolone - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

See all

Very good! Bread And homemade mozzarella is so tasty. Never had a mediocre sandwich, read more

What a great sandwich, messy in the best of ways, vodka sauce was super creamy, cutlet was nicely seasoned and super juicy, and the bread was fresh, soft, and held up to the mess of the sandwich. The mutz is some of the best I have had in the area, creating that great pull you want when biting into the sandwich, I will be back read more

Wallington Deli - Vodka chicken parm - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

I have been here several times in the past couple of months. I have had several chicken sandwiches, however, my favorite sandwich by far is the cheesesteak on garlic bread. The sandwich is next level. So I walked in and saw a pizza oven and thought they made pizza too. Turns out I was wrong, they use the pizza oven to make their own bread. So ALL sandwiches in this place are made on their own, Homemade bread.this is a huge part of the reason the sandwiches are all so delicious. Any chicken sandwich you get is amazing. Also, when you walk in this place is very simple. A deli counter, a soda case, and one rack with Vickie's chips. Do not let this fool you. These people are banging out these sandwiches all day that are seriously impressive! It's definitely one of the top sandwiches in Bergen County. It's a must try! read more

See all

I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich with fresh mozzarella and hot and sweet peppers. It was very tasty, but I also ordered a tuna fish sandwich and that was to die for. The bread was EVERYTHING and made both sandwiches worth the trip!! I highly recommend checking this out! read more

I was recommended from a friend to try this deli. I will definitely go back again. Excellent classic Italian hero.

Wow wow wow, what took me so long to come here?!?!?!? We ordered the cheesesteak, roast beef with mutz and gravy and the chicken cutlet with fresh mutz. Only problem was, they mixed up the order for the chicken cutlet with a ham sandwich instead (#5 instead of the #15). Honest mistake and when I called to inform them, they were sincerely apologetic and even offered to make the chicken cutlet sandwich right now for me to pick up, which I happily declined, giving us a reason to go back and order that sandwich on my next visit! read more

See all

This is my third time coming here, and I've said before in my Google review but I'll say it again! Truly a local blessing! I used to go to Matera's on Park Ave (in Rutherford) but I've since moved and was looking for a sandwich shop that would actually satiate my cravings, and UGHHH KEEEPS HITTING!!!! I got the ham, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, with oil and vinegar and uggh!! So good! Their bread is also high quality -- crisp and crunchy on the outside, moist on the inside! Attaching image here (don't mind the banana peppers, I added them on my own when I got home!) read more

Wallington Deli - Ham, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar (#5) - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

Ordered for pick-up on a Friday at around 6:30 when I had a craving for a chicken parm sammie. I didn't want to order from a pizzeria because most of the time, the chicken parm is fine, but the bread is not good, which can make or break the sandwich. Then I saw I had Wallington Deli bookmarked and saw they had what I wanted. I got the chicken parm with vodka sauce and hubby had the meatball parm with vodka sauce. The chicken parm was really good because the bread was excellent. It was a ciabatta bread but it was fresh ciabatta bread, even at the end of the day. It's the kind that's soft on the inside, but crunchy on the outside, yet doesn't scratch up the roof of your mouth. There was also a good amount of chicken and cheese in there. The meatball parm wasn't bad but probably not something I'd order again - just because I would prefer the chicken or to try a different sandwich. But, I think we may have found our new go to for chicken parm sammies! read more

Wallington Deli - Vodka chicken parm - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

See all

I can only say 1 thing I hope you guys never leave.. Everything I've ever ordered from here has been absolutely amazing!!! The staff is always so kind and friendly!! Today's order just a simple anti pasta salad but man the freshness and taste Amazing!!! read more

Wallington Deli - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

Excellent food, friendly staff, and excellent service. The BEST bread you will ever eat when eating a sandwich. read more

So far Iv had chicken vodka parm, chicken cutlet pesto, Italian hero, buffalo chicken sandwich all VERY good, the people who work there are very nice. You can call ahead or just go there and order they get the food out pretty fast. Theres a small counter to eat at if you want to eat there. read more

So I have to say, this might be the best sandwich I have ever had. My friend got me hooked on this place. It's a small mom and pop shop with no bells and whistles but their sandwiches speak for themselves. I got their chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella and peppers. WOW! Their bread is to die for. Can't beat the prices... This is definitely going to be a regular for us. read more

It does not matter what sandwich you order from here they are all absolutely delicious and filling! Personally ordered the drunken parm they are always quick with the order as well. read more

Why did I wait so long to pop in here?!? Sandwiches here are AMAZING!! The bread is super tasty and fresh. Only down point was the wait time. Seemed a bit disorganized too so factor some extra minutes in when stopping by here but don't let that deter you! This place is a must try! read more

Wallington Deli - #2 for the win!!! - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

This is a very cool place. Reminds me of the old diner spots of the 50s and 60s. Food is well prepared and the service is friendly and efficient. read more

It's getting harder and harder to find a place that really nails classic Italian subs but these were exactly what we hoped they would be and at a great price. Will be back. read more

Ordered the # 2. Outstanding! Crispy bread, delicious Chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic dressing. My first time here and certainly won't be my last. read more

Wallington Deli - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

Best sandwiches around,... Just had a # 2 and a # 4 , I'm telling you, I can not think of a better Deli in Bergen County, There are good places, but for sure, this is the best fresh bread made all day long, Fresh mozzarella,... They don't skimp on the ingredients, Wallington Deli, As far as the food, and the people there , 2nd to no other place... read more

Great local deli that stands out even in this area with plenty of good/great options. They make their own bread which is what takes their sandwiches to the next level. Call ahead during lunch time as they do get busy. read more

Wallington Deli - Current menu Nov 2023 - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

Sandwiches are good, but pretty frustrating when they are closed very often when they should be open for normal hours. Especially weekends! Also never ready when they say it will be. Always have to wait. Need more help it seems. read more

Always awesome Thank you for always being on point Let us know when you start doing breakfast read more

Totally worth the drive. Number 2 and number 9 are everything. The bread is fresh, soft and delicious.

Got a Tuna Sub. Very good...a Solid 8... The bread is good , as previously stated Walked in and placed an order. Filled promptly read more

Wallington Deli - Tuna Sub - Delis Near Me - Wallington, New Jersey

Sandwiches area all fantastic. The bread is excellent. Light with a crust. The meats are all very thinly sliced. Very good!

During this pandemic, I have barely ventured out. I've done what a lot of people have done and learned to make what they yearned. Unfortunately for me, a good sandwich is nothing I learned to make. Why? Because although I DID learn to make bread, I did not learn to make good bread. That brings me to my next point... Wallington Deli has the most amazing bread in... ALL OF NEW JERSEY. Possibly the tri-state area. Possibly the world! Yeah, bold claim, I know. I stand by it. When I first saw the bread I was kind of like errr, man I don't know. It looked pale and dusty but when I bit into it, it was magical, warm and crusty. I have ordered their cheesesteak, chicken parm and roast beef sandwiches and the bread they use is incredible. I'm pretty sure they bake their own bread which is amazing in itself but it is the qualities of the bread that knock it out of the park. It's tasty, crusty, and soft on the inside. It's always warm and tastes like it was made with love. It is the kind of bread that reminds us how to enjoy the little things in life while also reminding us why the little things are so important to enjoy. Eating their bread alone warrants 5 stars but their sandwiches are so tasty too! I haven't had anything I didn't like. Their service is great too! They're friendly on the phone and my order is always ready when I get there. Definitely try this place! read more

Looks can be deceiving and don't be fooled by the appearance of the restaurant. This place makes the most amazing sandwiches I have ever had in my entire life. The bread and mozzarella alone make this place spectacular. The quality of the sandwiches blow Annabella's or Matera's out of the water. I don't think I would ever order a sandwich from Annabella's or Materas after trying this place. Not only are the sandwiches extremely fresh, flavorful and high-quality; the service is great as well. Orders are prepared within like 10 minutes. I've lived in Rutherford area for almost 20 years and I recently discovered this place, shamefully admitting, it was thanks to an Instagram influencer. read more