Wallington Deli

(99 reviews)

1.3 mi

Annamaria's Deli is on Point!! It reminds me of the must go to sandwich shop in Rome Italy called…read more"All'Antico Vinaio" restaurant... it's a neighborhood hood sandwich shop that also sells limited Italian groceries too. There's many sandwich styles to choose from and I had the Anna Maria and it was excellent. The fresh meat cut for your sandwich is piled on and the other ingredients speak for themselves as the flavors keep you wanting more. I asked if I could change the hot pepper spread for the sweet "No Problem ". The service is top notch! I don't think you can get any closer to the taste of a sandwich in Italy so this is the next best thing. Make sure to stop by and find out what's your new favorite sandwich!

The Annamaria and Anthony sandwiches were delicious. The ratio of good quality bread to protein is…read morebalanced. Will surely try other items next time.

LOUIE - it's not roasted chicken which can be confusing, more like deli Turkey but enjoyed!

See all

Exterior

Uncle Tony's Deli

4.8

(19 reviews)

1.1 mi

Stopped here after a long day of errands. I just wanted a simple bologna and cheese sandwich which…read moreyou just can't get at a Jersey Mikes or Subway. Local delis are rare these days but this little place made my day. Clean and neat overall. Selections are more geared for breakfast but they have the basics for a good deli sandwich. Bread was fresh and the perfect chewy doughy Italian bread you want for a deli sandwich. They have Boars Head brand cold cuts and they slice to order. The owner was super friendly and we had a few laughs as he shared about why he had started the biz. The two local crossing guards were hanging having a cup of coffee before heading to their corners. The pricing was worth the sandwich. I was very pleased with the service and sandwich. Looking forward to stopping in again soon.

Great sandwiches for a great price! Bread and cold cuts were fresh! It's a small mom and pop place…read more The gentleman who made my sandwich was polite and accommodating.

Inside of the deli.

See all

Fresh Salads

Matera's Italian Market

Five stars for Maternas Italian Market. This authentic Italian deli in Rutherford New Jersey has…read moregreat food with real homemade taste. They welcome service dogs so my fluffy boy and I love this place. Highly recommend.

Delicious food plus excellent service equals amazing! I always look forward to going to Mater's and…read moretry not to spend too much because it all looks so good!

Inside

See all

Inside

Annabella's House of Mozzarella

I was looking for a solo lunch spot, and Annabella's was perfect. The dining area decor is a bit…read moreunderwhelming, but the food certainly makes up for it. My server was very pleasant and helpful. The Mozzarella and Tomato starter is a must order. The mozzarella definitely lives up to the hype. Creamy, and delicious! The serving is very generous, so it is perfect for sharing. Even though I ate it all by myself! I also had the Italian Steak Salad. This was excellent. Again, the portion is very large. The steak was cooked and seasoned perfectly. Everything was fresh and tasty. Finished the meal with a nice cappuccino. This was a great meal, and I would very much recommend it. I will return.

The seafood manicotti was excellent. Big pieces of lobster. . I come here every time I'm in town…read more I've also had chicken parmigiana sandwich and that was excellent as well. Enjoy the home cooked meal and live singing.

Deli

Fried Artichoke Hearts

See all

Dining room and back bar

Vinnie's Mootz

A sandwich-and-slice shop with a personality all its own. I had passed this lunch spot countless…read moretimes -- usually chuckling at the somewhat ridiculous name -- always telling myself I'd eventually stop in one day. After my first visit, I can say the tongue-in-cheek spirit of Vinnie Mootz's signage carries right through the front door and into its lineup of "SANGWEECHES." I ordered "The Nicky Mootz" -- cutlet, bacon, hot sauce, and fresh mootz -- and enjoyed it immensely in the friendly, medium-sized dining room. The pizza, which I plan to try on a future visit, looked excellent, and the small assortment of hand-stretched mozzarellas is reason enough to stop back in the next time I'm passing through. It's a Jersey sandwich -- excuse me, sangweech -- shop with all the charm, humor, and flavor you'd hope for the community!

Inside of restaurant was very clean and welcoming, with fresh flowers on the tables and welcoming…read moreworkers. It felt like I was walking inside a loving family home. Chicken Parmesan with vodka sauce (8.7/10) - Bread was toasty with a nice crunch. Vodka sauce was light and creamy, and the mozzarella was very fresh (lots of cheese pulls). The chicken was thin but crispy and tasty. A little more sauce and chicken would really take this to the next level. Italian Sub with the works 9.2/10 - Bread was very soft and gave a nice bite to the sandwich. They were very generous with the meats, cheese, and fixings. The veggies were fresh and mayo was good quality. All the ingredients came together nicely with every bite with no ingredients missing in any part of the sandwich

Looking for a higher resolution pic of you have one. Thanks

Vodka slice

See all

Legacy Deli & Convenience Store

5.0

(1 review)

1.4 mi

Got the breakfast sandwich here couple times, very food. The shop is new and clean. Would come back…read moreto get more breakfast

From the owner: Open 7am-10pm Monday-Friday. 8am-10pm Saturday and Sunday…read moreSnacks, sandwiches, smokes, platters with white sauce, lottery and much more

Store front

See all

Forest Dairy Cold Cut Center

Forest Dairy has been a go to deli for me since I was a kid. The sandwiches are fair priced and…read morehuge. They do put on a LOT of meat so if that is not your thing this may not be your place! The service is always fast and they are super efficient. Don't forget this place also serves as a mini mart / convenience store and so they have alcohol, basic foods like frozen meals and rice. This place is super tiny but they've got a lot going on inside!! Always can count on them for a filling lunch.

This place holds up for years and years. Long established location, could seem a little pricey but…read moreif you look at what you get for it, you get your money's worth, especially these days. If you are in the area and looking for a straight up American deli, this is definitely a good choice.

$4.99 six count onion rings

Chicken cutlet sandwich with fresh BREADED CHICKEN SANDWICHE

See all

$9.99 cheese steak

Michael's Salumeria

It's really expensive for what is basically Italian catering. I will say my rice balls were…read moredelightfully cheesy and chewy. It's a conflicting reality because I didn't agree with the prices of the food. But the quality in taste does show!!

Great Italian Deli. Home made dishes and great sandwiches. Nice decor and good staff.read more

Cannellini, tomato,celery, avocado salad $10 lb

See all

Pastrami Grill Bistro

Great food Great place…read moreGood service Good price Check it out Bring home to eat Fast service Will return Four star

If you live in northern New Jersey, you have found the PREMIER location for pastrami, corned beef…read moreand brisket! No longer do you have to drive or commute into NYC. The Pastrami Grill Bistro in Garfield, New Jersey is hands down the best place to indulge in one of these sandwiches! The breads, condiments and cole slaw is off the charts also. A big parking lot with ample parking seals the deal!

The kitchen

Rueben sandwich - wow!

See all

Suprema

This is definitely a must go to restaurant in Rutherford , NJ. This place has both indoor and…read moreoutdoor seating, very beautifully decorated and designed. Has classy but laid back style and energy. Staff are all very kind and service is definitely on point. Experience was great from beginning to the end. Of course the star of this show was the food. I got to try the special which was Ribeye grilled cheese sandwich on sourdough bread with house made gravy. It was amazing! Hat goes off to the chef, this was a great creation. Would try this again without a doubt. I also tried the Beef Rib Ragu pasta dish on their regular menu which was amazing as well. Looking forward to trying other items here on the menu. Can't forget I also ordered a cappuccino which was also delicious. Was not disappointed by anything during this entire experience. Great vibes, great staff, and great food!

Highlights: Fried Calamari and meatball appetizers were great!…read more Mid-lights: The vodka chicken parm with rigatoni was good, but the chicken was a little too soft/soggy. Also the portions were a little small. Lowlights: The restaurant was a little understaffed, wait times for water, to take our order, to get our food was extremely long. 4 dishes ordered and dinner was 2.5 hours... Overall the food was good but pricey for what it was.

Waldorf Chicken

See all

Park ave sandwich

Red Bowl Asian Kitchen

My go to Chinese restaurant in the neighborhood nice family owned Chinese restaurant. They do…read morequality food. They're very pleasant. Call ahead when you get there. Your order is ready. I'd recommend this restaurant.

Wife and daughters very nice, the husband is mean and rude makes me feel uncomfortable. No thank…read moreyou No hello No nothing just stairs at you . What a jerk i feel bad for his family.

General tsos with egg roll

Hot and sour soup

See all

Krakus Restaurant

We arrived at 8:30 and they close at 9 and they were so nice. We ordered 4 dishes and they each…read morecame out quickly, were hot thru and thru so I think they finished them all just for us. The potato pancakes were nice sized, six to the plate and split even to the three of us. The kielbasa over sauerkraut was delicious. The kraut was almost sweet tasting. The chicken cutlets were crispy on the outside and soft and hot in the middle, and plenty big. The big hit was the cheese stuffed fried chicken [Chicken Devolay] . Breaded and crispy fried chicken cutlet wrapped around cheese. When you cut it open the cheese just poured out and made a fantastic dipping sauce. So much so we each used it as a dipping sauce for the chicken cutlet after the Devolay was all gone. More people need to go to this place. It is awesome for some feels like home cooking.

OMG. A long time I am trying to have a good beef goulash and Kraku gave me it…read more Food was amazing. Diana was lovely . My husband had pork cutlets it was fenomenal. I highly recommend recommending this place.

Polish platter. Potato pancakes, kielbasa, stuffed cabbage and pirogi!

Pierogies

See all

Polish platter (Polski talerz) Potato pancakes, pierogi, stuffed cabbage, kapusta, and polish sausage

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Yermy V.

7 years ago

Best chicken cutlet and fresh mozzarella around. All sandwiches are fantastic. You won't regret after you tried the food of this place. My favorite is phillie cheese steak sandwich. They also have different special dishes everyday. read more

Charles I.

5 years ago

Sandwiches are perfection. Hand pulled mozz, fresh made bread. They're always busy, don't don't be surprised if you have to wait a little while for your food. read more

William Q.

2 years ago

Hands down the best sandwich shop in the area. You have to wait on line for your order but its worth the wait. The bread alone is fantastic. Great job guys. read more

Barbara H.

5 years ago

Excellent sandwiches. The bread is just fantastic! Will definitely be going back.

Wallington Deli - delis - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Wallington Deli also viewed

Annamaria's Deli

(99 reviews)

The Annamaria and Anthony sandwiches were delicious. The ratio of good quality bread to protein is…read morebalanced. Will surely try other items next time.

Uncle Tony's Deli

4.8

(19 reviews)

Great sandwiches for a great price! Bread and cold cuts were fresh! It's a small mom and pop place…read more The gentleman who made my sandwich was polite and accommodating.

Terrace Ave Deli

4.5

(10 reviews)

everything about this place is amazing. Thing to recommend - steak and fries : steak was so juicy,…read morefries were so crispy. Will definitely come back to try everything else on the menu !

My friend suggested this spot and mentioned they served a steak and fries dish that looked really…read moregood. I've always wanted to try steak and fries served this way, so I was looking forward to it. I stopped by on a Friday afternoon. Once we walked in, the place was bright and had a wall covered in greenery, which made for a nice backdrop if you want to take photos for social media. I ordered The Knockout Steak & Fries ($22.99), cooked between medium rare and medium (I know... odd request). The guy at the counter mentioned it would take a little longer since everything is made to order, which was great to hear. When my order came out, it looked amazing. The steak was cooked perfectly to my liking. The combination of the chimichurri, pico de gallo, garlic aioli, crispy fries, and juicy steak was delicious. The portion was huge, and I did my best to finish the fries, but I just couldn't. If you're in the mood for steak and fries, I would definitely recommend checking this place out. * Street parking * There is a parking lot in the back but not sure available for customers. Park at own risk. * Lotto available

Pete's Delicatessen

4.3

(86 reviews)

They didn't have what I was looking for - roast beef club - so they did their best to approximate…read moreit, and here's the kicker: this was $11. Look at the pictures. These days you can't open your front door and take a deep breath without it costing you more than $11. Look at the size of this sandwich! I don't know how they do it, but this place is absolutely recommended. Talk about bang for your buck, and GOOD! Please go and enjoy.

Pete's has been serving up the neighborhood for a very long time…read more We used to go at lunch in HS and get dollar subs. They were good sized sandwiches geared to us broke kids. It was a blessing at the time. My go to was and still is, cajun turkey, yellow American, lettuce, tomato, mayo on a round Portuguese roll. They also make incredible pepperoni bread, potato salad, chicken cutlets and a bunch of other goodies. I saw they had brownies, donuts, and crumb cake last time I was in.

Cappelluti's Deli

(44 reviews)

They make the best sandwiches. Most places are cheap with the deli meat, and I am always amazed…read moreabout how full I am after eating. Sadly, they are selling the business, but I will recommend trying it before they do. I'm honestly scared. It's gonna turn into something else.. I hope whoever decides to buy this business keeps it the same. It's right at the end of KEARNY and such a welcoming place. The owners are always kind to my kiddos and very family friendly. It has an old school vibe, but it is perfectly clean! I highly recommend you give this place a try you won't be disappointed I promise.

(There's a pang of sadness when I see any of my old reviews that mention Clinton's iced teas. I…read moreguess I can find comfort that I drank entirely too many of them in my youth and even my own kids got to try them once or twice before the company went kaput.) Onward and upwards... it's now (almost) 2024 and while the the shelves are a bit more sparse than I recall and they got rid of their lottery machine (which seemed to bring in a lot of old-timers) - what I'm here for is their sandwiches. Specifically their #1 Italian. And I'm happy to report: they're still the best around. (And it tasted even better after a recent not-so-good visit to a Jersey Mike's in my hometown.) Besides their incredible subs you'll find the usuals (chips, soda, ice cream) and a few random items (aspirin, Chapstick). Cool crew behind the counter. Good pricing for such a quality product. Trying to find parking is still a nightmare. 'Enjoy every sandwich.' -- Warren Zevon (No truer words were ever spoken.)

My Sisters Gourmet Deli

4.2

(44 reviews)

Sister's Deli is such a great spot to enjoy your lunch. The deli is small but cozy. You can grab a…read morebite to eat and then head to Garret Mountain. I had the number #9 the tattletailer panini sandwich and it was so good! I love the pesto sauce and the toasted focaccia bread - yum!! Sandwich also came with a bag of chips. Customer service is always amazing here. The owners are always super nice. They also have specials of the day. I had the chicken Marsala with rice. Great prices for the amount you receive. Food was great! They open early and close by 3:30. If you're near the area- give it a try, you will not be disappointed!

Sister's Deli is one of the best places I've been to in a while. It has such a warm and welcoming…read moreenvironment. Right as I walked in, I was greeted. The staff is all super friendly, kind, and caring. The food is excellent; it's super fresh, and they made it really quickly for me. I plan to start coming here to support their business much more often. They truly are one of the greatest places I've ever stopped into.

Cousin Deli

4.0

(9 reviews)

Ordered me a nice pastrami sandwich. Cheese couldn't have been melted a bit. Curly fries were good…read morebut not crispy almost little soggy. For a few empanadas. They were really good. Hot fresh and pretty filled up. Definitely would go again.

This place is a dump, it got mold somewhere. I saw some silverfish and two roaches (the coco, not…read morethe weed) kind. I started asking questions and the guy behind the counter, with the monotone, yet can't understand anything in life, mad at everyone kind of employee, it was in my best interests, I told him, but the response like, "what else is new mo fo?" this is how I roll!" Hopefully, you read this and use word of mouth to promote. Because the guy behind the counter likes mold on his food, do you want mold, silverfish and a roach(two) to come hangout on yours?

Agamie Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers

(89 reviews)

Fantastic dishes, delicacy, cold, cuts, sandwiches, hot, or cold like they used to be in back in…read morethe day‍. What a delightful atmosphere and friendly staff. My cheesesteak sandwich was custom with shredded lettuce and flavorful chopped steak . Also, the Italian Classic sandwich is above the best deli.

Delis like this are all but extinct. Live that this place still exists…read more Think 1980's and you will be transported back in time. Not much special here just your run of the mill deli which I love. Their bread isn't great but it goes well with their meats and cheeses.

Torpedo Base

4.6

(64 reviews)

Bacon Roast beef Eggs lettuce and onions. Had it for the first time. Never going back. Super sloppy…read morewasn't cut in half. Bacon was limp not crispy Bread was squished wayyyy tooo much mayo that taste bad (def not Hellman's) too overwhelming to taste the rest of sandwich asked for onions lettuce didn't get any of that and there was a hair in between the eggs and cheese. Counter lady was rude On top of the fact that they charge 2$ for card use. SMH overhyped sandwich spot. Don't go here!!!!!

A classic spot that's been open for decades, making delicious torpedo sandwiches and giving great…read moreservice. My love for sandwiches started here, when my father would bring me as a kid. I remember fully loaded subs with mayo, lettuce, tomato, onions, and dressing. Another classic is the warm pastrami sandwich with mustard and cheese. Amazing to taste something that brings you back in time. An absolute must try.

Muriale's Trattoria & Italian Delicacies

4.1

(40 reviews)