We get their menu sent daily at my office & this past week I drove over to try one of the lunch specials. I was not disappointed both with hot sandwich size & quality as well as a baked ziti lunch special. Lunch time is VERY hectic however staff keeps up with clearing tables & getting food to you & out the door. Parking is NOT the best outside the building; my suggestion is drive up the neighboring street for a safe spot. After eating the cardio workout comes in handy! Paying with cash avoids a card surcharge which is posted right where you order. read more

Last night my hole family got very sick from eating there grilled chicken, we all had very extremely bad stomach cramps & pains & diarrhea , an also not to be funny but we gave some of the chkn to our dog an last night the dog also had very bad diarrhea, so if 3 ppl & the dog all got very sick from eating there grilled chkn , well it had to be the chkn , we are all going to the doctors today , an also getting a case of toilet paper... I'm serious read more

Good pizza in the neighborhood. They have a ton of variety, and they sell slices, even at night.

Once again an incredible meal! Huge portions. Delivered in minutes and very fresh and hot. We got two meals out of it. Loved the specials! read more

See all

I love this pizzaria. They make terrific pizza. Trust me on this. A lot of places make specialty pies, and people like them because they are different, but they do them very very well here, and far better than the other places near by. Everything is fresh and tasty. The salads are all great. The pastas are delicious. read more

See all

I got the pizza wings and soda special. The pizza was good, had the perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio. When it comes to the wings you get a mix of some meaty drums and barely anything on it flats. But it was way too salty. If the wings didn't disappoint, I would have rated 4 stars. read more

Pizza Mania - Large Plain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

This has been a long time coming review from a few months ago: Ordered 6:51 online estimated delivery 7:51 Received a Call at 7:49 to say he is here - I said your not and kept giving the address. 7:56 showed up and said messed up with the address will be back in a few minutes and he just left. 7:58 We called the store to see what was going on and they asked do you still want your food. Yea we paid for it. They said they will send it out. No apology or explanation of what happened Different driver called at 8:19 lost and asked me to text the address. When he showed up at 8:26 still argued with me over the address. (Pretty sure I know where I live). Asked what happened to our first order ignored me and gave me the food said bye. No explanation or apology given once! Received a Voicemail in the morning from the owner apologizing about the problem with my order and was told we were getting a refund on our order for the inconvenience - never received refund. Used to consistently order from here have since stopped!! read more

Iv been coming here since they opened! Always the best!! Never once had a bad experience! Well done fella's!

I ordered a penne vodka with breaded chicken for delivery. I ordered over the phone; they answered right away when I called. They had my address saved with my phone number in their system which was helpful. I've ordered the chicken parm in the past which is also really good from here. I received my order about 30 minutes later. The penne vodka came with a piece of bread and a side salad. The pasta and chicken was absolutely delicious. It was a good portion too. I ate some for dinner, my toddler had some for his dinner, and I finished the rest for lunch the next day. I will most definitely order from here again. Their pasta dishes have not disappointed! read more

Pizza Mania - Penne Vodka with Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Decided to get lunch from this restaurant. I ordered the chicken marsala and mussels. When I arrived I parked in the small lot. I walked in and was greeted. The food was ready, and I paid and left. When I dug in, the mussels were delicious! It was seasoned to perfection. I also liked the chicken marsala pasta. I definitely enjoyed it, and it was super affordable. read more

See all

First, I'll start off by saying this review is towards the staff. Their food is delicious, but the last time we ordered was unfortunately our last. We've been ordering from Pizza Mania since 2018!!! So we were taken back when this last time we ordered, we received a call from a young lady telling me how they don't deliver to my area! Now, I'll be the first to admit I can understand delivering to a specific area, but since 2018 and NOW you're telling me you don't deliver to my area!!! She then went on to say that SHE'LL allow it this time!!! Suffice to say we enjoyed our last meal from Pizza Mania and they've lost a long time customer who ALWAYS tipped generously!! read more

Been a good customer for over 4 years I ordered a 16.00 eggplant platter. What I got was 3/4 lbs of pasta and one slice of eggplant. If I wanted pasta parmasean with a side of eggplant, I wouldn't spend 16.00 . I feel ripped off and am not sure if I want to continue as a customer. They some girl on the phone who said she was a manager but had no authority. She stated "I'm not the boss ." So the platters they advertise will mostly be more pasta and very little main entree. And I always took care of the delivery person wit 20%of total bill as a damn tip. Unless they ever make this right I don't think I will be a customer anymore. I'm sure they aren't worried about this issue they are too busy dropping this same hustle on everyone else. read more

Pizza Mania - Just pasta - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Always good food. We order in often and we are a member of their club so we take advantage of the specials quite often. Fast service and reasonable prices. read more

Just had their vodka chicken wrap panini and lemme just say....15/10. BEST. WRAP. EVER! Their chicken is like a blackened chicken which gives it such an amazing flavor and their vodka sauce is sooo good. This is now gon be my regular pizza/pasta spot. read more

Having ordered for delivery at this establishment previously, my partner and I have decided for a repeat performance because the last order didn't disappoint. Pizza Mania is located on Midland Avenue in Garfield. An order for a large plain pie with mushroom and rice ball parmigiana was placed with Yelp using GrubHub. According to the order confirmation would take up to 65 mins, but the door bell rang within 30 mins which was fantastic as we were hungry. The order was correctly received and still hot. The food was tasty and well seasoned. The pizza crust was crispy just how we loved it. The downside were the undercooked rice in the rice ball as they were crunchy and hard & not enough sauce and cheese on the pizza. Could have been an off day but will give this place another chance. read more

Pizza Mania - Rice Ball Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

Obviously a lot of people have different taste , but i don't think they deserve the rating being this low , i like their pizza

My husband placed an online order.He got a large salami and cheese hero and I got a minestrone soup. We get the delivery and it included an pizza that was not ordered. I looked at the receipt and my husband was charged $8.85 for an online fee!! Are you kidding me? Between that and a tip it came to $34.00 for $18.00 worth of food. So before placing orders online check if there is a fee. read more

They OVERCHARGE like crazy! A pizza that's $23.95 I was charged $29.85 (I asked to instead of ham sub peperoni) so they charged me $6 extra for the pepperoni. RIDICULES!!! Plus they charge for CC use. read more

Pizza Mania - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

The pizza was great it was the best one I've ever tried and the place is clean and the pizzas looked really good And the service was great read more

Hands down the best pizzeria in NJ! You have to try their Philly cheesesteak pizza - very filling and absolutely delicious! We often order catering from here as well and it's always a hit for our guests . The chicken franchise and veal Marsala are incredible! Can't wait to try out more dishes . Also the owner and staff are very friendly , great place to bring the family to for dinner read more

I frequently order from here but honestly never again. WHAT IS THIS. Then I waited for them to bring me a new one took a hour and the new one still looks terrible. read more

Pizza Mania - I don't even know - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Pizza mania is our go to for pizza and wings. They have a huge variety of pizza. Delicious

Haven't been in for a long time but I'm back and I'm having my favorite special of the day, grilled Roma chicken sub read more

Pizza Mania - Roma grilled chicken - my favorite - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

Got an Italian wrap it had one slice of each meat I was not happy such cheapskates I got this and a plain slice was 19 dollars unbelievable.. read more

Pizza Mania - No meat - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

Awful place, pizza made with cheapest ingredients. Shame on the owners. Keep delivering cold pizzas. Wayy to goo!

Always a delight when I order from here. The best part is the cross contamination, my FAVORITE! I always get an extra piece of grilled chicken when I order this wrap, they swear it's a mushroom, but I know they just want to keep it a secret. But yesterday this scrumptious piece of old breaded chicken was in my wrap. It was so chewy, it was like chicken flavored gum! Yuh-me! Can't wait to see what surprise is in the next thing I order! 10/10 would totally recommend, to the health department of Garfield! read more

Pizza Mania - Jersey Shore Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Val X. and I ended up grabbing lunch here one day after our first choice was closed. I had seen pictures of some interesting looking pizzas from Pizza Mania on Instagram, so I've had this spot bookmarked. Service is friendly, and according to Val, "They're perfect". There were many different specialty slices. I ended up getting the chipotle chicken and one covered with french fries, pepperoni, and burger sauce. Both slices were interesting, tasty, and extremely filling. I ended up going home for a nap instead of my usual gym session after work read more

Pizza Mania - Pepperoni and fries - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

Pizza is good , the girls that answer the phone are pleasant and nice . Never rood or mean like other places I call only got marg pizza and plain cheese both were good . read more

My first time here on the suggestion of another over the weekend. This place honestly is 3.5 stars, but I rounded up because the menu is so vast and I only tried a small sampling from it. It's a small joint with an Italian ice and gelato area attached to it. However the gelato wasn't available until May. Bummer because I really was craving it! However the fried calamari and two pies we ordered were very good. Not really the best I have had, but it was nice to try something different. Their crust is crunchy and the cheese was nice and gooey! The menu is vast and from the observance of the phones constantly ringing, I know there must be some great meals they prepare. I just haven't had the opportunity to try more yet. I will say though they do an amazing delivery business. There had to be at least 7 drivers in and out of there the whole time we were dining as they deliver to 15 surrounding towns!! I couldn't honestly even keep up counting the various delivery drivers! It was insane! I literally watched them take phone orders on 3 different phones and computers! The staff were super polite and friendly and the food came out promptly. I will definitely return and try some other items. Sign up for their club and instantly get a 20% off coupon delivered to your mobile phone number! read more

Pizza Mania - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

Im sorry but having tried all the pizzerias in the area the best plain pie in delivery distance goes to pizza mania hands down. Simple classic plain pie. No over complicating anything over saucing and over charging for a pie that comes too small or cheese all over or messed up. Consistency is key here and the plain pie is perfect. read more

always messing up my order!! dont order online or on uber. unless you want to get somthing you dont even want

It was my first time ordering from here and the pizza came cold not so great taste and I also ,ordered a caprese salad and apparently they don't know how to prepare it Wich I had to tossed , for me presentation means a lot and that presentation of the salad unacceptable . read more

I order from here all the time. Have never once stopped into the store because of their quick delivery. I love the specialty slices and the fried calamari. They make decent wraps too. Portions are good for the buck. I constantly see their drivers everywhere around town so they have a good following. read more

See all

This is definitely the most greedy and self interested owner of a pizzeria I have ever seen . He hires hs students then pays them below minimum wage (under the counter) and then gives raises to pieces of crap, and the food is 1000% over priced. I guess the quality is good but how is the place called pizza mania and the pizza sucks? Yea idc 1 star for u read more

We order food for lunch at least three times a week! Best salads ! Great food and customer service!

i've ordered from here a couple of times sometimes it's good sometimes it's not I had a sandwich yesterday that was a mouthful of salt so I had a couple of bites brought at home my husband eats it and tells me how salty it is what could you have done to a sandwich to make it so ridiculously salty. it was an edible and I didn't have the energy to call because the person I spoke to could barely speak English it was very disappointing read more

I'm giving 4 stars for an amazing tasting pizza, made with fresh arugula fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, drizzled with balsamic glaze. It's both savory and sweet, a perfect flavor combination. read more

See all

I can't even begin to properly eloquate how much I love this place! The food is delicious- from the salads to the pies- and it's clear they're made with care. On top of that, the customer service and delivery teams have always been extremely polite, considerate, and competent. (And let's face it... competence in these areas is hard to come by these days.) I would give this place 5/5 stars all day every day. (PS- faves include the caprese pizza and caprese panini. I've also had the burger and multiple salads... a rave review for all of the above!) read more

PIZZA COMES OUT BURNT and owner has his worker post fake positive reviews under Alex. Been going to pizzmania since they opened and it used to be good. Now the only consistency is the constant mistakes on orders, no one seems to listen or pay attention when an order is being placed. When they do get the order correct, the food is nothing to rave about. I finally stopped ordering pizza after every time I received the pizza, the crust was usually burnt. I used to go to pizzamania because it was local, but it's not worth it, there are way too many problems with the quality of the food. Sometimes they have pies sitting out that look a week old. The area has too many other good pizzerias to bother with this place, it isn't worth it. read more

Ordered a Specialty salad a New York salad. Grilled Jumbo shrimp, spring mix, tomatoes, red onions, fresh onions. I think the forgot the JUMBO SHRIMP! ! read more

Pizza Mania - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all