Cuginos Pizza

Awesome pizza! Came here for a quick bite with a friend after having walked by multiple times. The…read moreguy at the counter ended up giving us a slice for free. Thinest crust pizza I've ever had in this city and it was really good. Nice flavor, char, and taste without being overly greasy. Definitely coming back when I'm the area.

Really good pizza, perfect crust, friendly staff Quick…read moreturnaround... what's not to like? Just a bit pricey, that's all (Cheese pizza $28, ok that's on the high side but not exorbitant ... but Cacio a pepe $44.00... & mushroom pizza, $40.00...a bit over the top in my opinion ) Still, I'll be back once I get hungry (and flush $$ !!!) enough!

Kitchen Area

Mushroom Pizza Slice

See all

Koronet Pizza

3.6(721 reviews)

•$

Ok it has been a few years since I've eaten at Koronet. But I've eaten lots of Koronet slices over…read morethe years. Ate there a bunch late night as a undergrad from 2003 to 2007 and then as a grad student from 2012 to 2014. Was definitely there for my 10 year reunion in 2017 and the last time I taught a class at Teacher's College I bought a whole pie to celebrate the occassion. It came in two boxes. Mayor Mamdani also likes Koronet and once said he devoured two slices there. I think I did that once, but certainly couldn't do it today. In any case, Koronet is a reliable very good slice of pizza. At its worst it is not bad, and at its best it is delicious. Is it the best pizza in the world? No. But will it hit the spot all the time, particularly in the winter? Absolutely.

Nostalgia tour - been 11 years since my last slice. This was my first food spot I hit after we…read morearrived. Went with my son and we had a great time. At least 3 languages were spoken after midnight, and the fresh huge slice was amazing! Same as it ever was. The updated paint over the brick opens the storefront up as do the all new counters and hipster pipe and wood table installs. Service is fast, friendly, and efficient. Great huge slice - not nearly the best, but the largest, and consistent for 40 years of my life!

IPhone 15 ProMax for scale.

See all

Morones Pizza

Famous Famiglia Pizzeria

3.3(97 reviews)

•$

Famous Famiglia has been around for years, but my experience the first 2 times at other locations…read morein town decades ago made me want to never come back. That being said, thought I give them another chance given all the slice places within a few blocks in this section of Morningside Heights. While a reasonably priced basic cheese slice, but not the cheapest, don't be fooled by their pizza's appearance. Although the crust was OK, the excess grease that slid off of my pizza was: 1) something no one should ingest and 2) required a bib to avoid staining clothes. Maybe Famiglia's "famous" recipe is for clientele are out-of-towners (and a few local bozos) who eat their slice with a knife and fork! My reco - If you're hungry for a classic New York slice and want the real local thing, go to "old school" Koronet immediately across the street!

There's nothing fancy or hype-worthy, but it's a solid slice and a friendly, calm atmosphere. I got…read morethe knots, a salad, and a slice of cheese. Simple, basic, and comforting. The knots are very garlicky and come with a side of marinara. The salad is iceberg, grape tomatoes, and cucumbers. The pizza was my favorite part--a bit chewy, but still crisp, and lots of melty, delicious cheese and sauce. I wouldn't make a trip just to eat here, but if I was in the neighborhood again, I would happily eat here.

Famous Famiglia 2859 Broadway Storefront

Famous Famiglia Classic Cheese Slice - Beware the grease that comes off it!

See all

Simple cheese.

MAMA'S TOO!

3.6(984 reviews)

1.8 mi•Manhattan Valley

Definitely an elevated NYC slice…read more Mama's TOO lived up to the hype. We tried 4 different slices and every single one had something unique about it. The house slice was freaking amazing and easily stole the show for me. The thin slice had the perfect crunch, with a great balance of sauce, cheese, and crispiness in every bite. The place was packed the entire time, and there were constantly pizzas being thrown in and out of the oven, which honestly added to the energy and experience. My second favorite was the square bruschetta slice, which was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly baked. You can tell they care about quality and consistency with every pie they make. Amazing pizza overall and we will definitely be back.

Came around 1:30pm on a Saturday and there was actually a short line. It did take about 10-15 mins…read moreto order and then wait for the slice to be heated. I got the angry nonna, and the hot honey flavor went so well with the slice, but I was underwhelmed. Perhaps, it could have used a little more tomato sauce for me. I do want to try more slices before making up my mind.

1.9 mi•Morningside Heights

Interior

Sandwhich

See all

Steak Pizzaiola Sandwich

V & T Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.2(429 reviews)

First off, not sure why there's any bad reviews about this place because Google reviews showcases…read moremore on this establishment. I came here for dinner and was shocked at how friendly every single person was. Immediately greeted, service was quick, and every person that came to our table was so helpful. I got the chicken Marsala and my partner ordered the Clam Chowder which was AMAZING. I also ordered garlic bread with a very tasty Pinot Grigio. Really picky about my Italian wines but this place did not disappoint. Highly recommend if you're looking for a cute intimate spot in the city. Will definitely be back.

Finding a traditional Italian restaurant with good food and ambiance is always a plus in any city…read more I had hoped that V&T Pizzeria might be just that, a great place for simple pasta dishes with an old-world feel. While the food was fine, the real issue with the restaurant was the environment. My partner and I were seated two tables away from an older woman who proceeded to take a very long call on her phone at the table, using her speakerphone setting. A short time later, another person at the back of the room started the same. Having two loud conversations throughout dinner due to someone on speakerphones did not make for a pleasant experience. The goal of any restaurant should be to create as comfortable an experience as possible for patrons so that they are encouraged to return. While the food experience would have warranted that, the lack of staff management over the disruptive issue of people on their speakerphones during dinner ruined the entire meal. My partner or I could have said something to the customers, but we feel it should be the job of staff or management to handle this, not the patron. And while some will say that this is the way of the world today, we can't accept that. There is a way to act in public, in polite society, which includes stepping outside to take a phone call so other patrons are not disturbed. Other than this significant issue, the waiter was friendly, the food service was quick, and the food was flavorful for the most part. The garlic bread was not of the quality we expected: The bread had been haphazardly coated with a garlic mix that contained very large chunks of garlic, and was not very enjoyable to eat. The bread itself ws simply a piece of French bread cut in half; again, not much effort put into the quality or presentation. One of us ordered Ravioli, and it was clear that the pasta had not been drained properly. There was significant water collection around the sauce. While we might try V&T again, we are inclined to hesitate the next time we are in the area because of this experience. We hope the management discusses this issue and decides to encourage patrons to step outside for their phone calls.

Interior

See all

Ortomare Ristorante Pizzeria

4.7(177 reviews)

2.0 mi•Manhattan Valley

I've been here numerous times and always had a great meal. I believe the restaurant was sold and…read moreis under new ownership. The reviews are still good but my dinner last night was just ok and actually I was a little disappointed. We had 7:30 reservations and the restaurant was crowded a nice table in the corner was waiting for us. Service still is impeccable. It was just the food that was fair. Started with Mussels in White Wine sauce. The sauce was a bit salty for my liking. Next up was the Seafood Pasta that was the house special for the night. I've had this before but tonight's dish was very bland and tasteless. Most of the tables were ordering Pizza, so that may be the way to go.

Came here for dinner and had a great time…read more Pros: - Ordered the Tartufata pizza and Branzino. Both were good and shareable between two people, but they didn't quite stand out for a perfect score - Friendly service - Clean bathrooms Cons: - None!

Ortomare Ristorante Pizzeria - Prosciutto Crudo Pizza - mozzarella, tomato, prosciutto, arugula and shaved parmesan cheese, baked in wood fire oven.

Prosciutto Crudo Pizza - mozzarella, tomato, prosciutto, arugula and shaved parmesan cheese, baked in wood fire oven.

Ricotta Cheesecake with homemade strawberry sauce.

See all

Polpettine - Slowly cooked meatballs in tomato sauce from our brick oven

Marlow Bistro

3.9(426 reviews)

1.9 mi•Manhattan Valley

Hidden gem alert. I…read morestopped by on a whim for dinner, and walked inside this cute bistro with a few friends. We were quickly seated and split a few items from the menu which were all excellent. We had the tartufo pizza, citrus and beet salad and brussels sprouts. Service was quick and attentive. This spot is perfect for a date or a dinner out to catch up with one or two friends. I will definitely be back, and I can't wait to try out more items off the menu!

Came here for restaurant week and was not disappointed! We got the three course Prefix option for…read more$45 which was a steal in my opinion. I got the tuna tartar, chicken mileanese and panna cheese along with drinks. The Tuna Tartar was outstanding! Very fresh and delicious, I would go back just for it alone. We sat outside as the weather was beautiful. Service was swift and very friendly. Would definitely go back to try the other menu options.

Pineapple Coconut Cake - Gluten Free!

See all

Starfish

Fumo

4.1(345 reviews)

1.7 mi•Manhattan Valley

Fumo has been a staple for me for many years, and it truly remains a neighborhood gem. It is rare…read moreto find a spot that maintains such high standards over time, but they continue to exceed expectations. The pizzas are, quite simply, perfection. The crust is always "just right"- crispy, fresh, and consistently delicious. Beyond the food, I am so happy to note that the evening ambiance has evolved beautifully. The music is no longer as loud as it once was; it's now at a volume that allows for great conversation while still maintaining a vibrant energy. What really makes Fumo shine is the service and the attention to detail. The staff is incredibly friendly, and the service is nothing short of exceptional every single time. I also have to mention the personal touches that add so much character to the space - the real candles in crystal-like holders create a warm, elegant atmosphere that does not go unrecognized. The entire restaurant is always very clean and welcoming. If I had one small "wish list" item, it would be to see some tap beers added to the menu - I would absolutely love to enjoy a Peroni on draft with my meal! Thank you, Fumo, for years of wonderful meals and for being such a reliable and delicious place to enjoy some brick oven pizza.

Came here to celebrate my daughter's birthday with a party of 7 (3 kids), and it was such a great…read moreexperience from start to finish. My daughter ordered a lemon drop and OMG--it was so good. I had a Pinot Grigio and was happy they still had happy hour going. The kids had iced tea, and the staff was kind enough to make a raspberry lemonade for them, which they loved. I also really appreciate when restaurants notice kids and automatically bring cups with covers--small detail, but it makes a difference. For food, I ordered the rotativo bolognese--WOW. So much meat and packed with flavor. My mom had the burger and especially loved the truffle fries. The kids got spicy calamari with sauce (I don't usually like seafood, but it honestly looked amazing). The other adults had chicken penne alla vodka and chicken parm with penne, both enjoyed. The kids also ordered sausage and pepperoni pizza, and we accidentally ended up with a margarita pizza too--no complaints there! Service was elite--attentive, friendly, and made the birthday feel special. The place itself is nice and cozy, perfect for date night or family outings. We ended with cheesecake for the birthday girl, which was the perfect touch. I know they have other locations, and we'll definitely be checking those out too.

Bathroom (with a Black Toilet!)

Lobster pasta (substitute with penne sauce)

See all

Spritz

Hex & Company

4.2(114 reviews)

•$

I like this location of Hex & Co. I came for an event and we had access to the back room which is…read morereally big. Service at the cafe was quick. Prices are reasonable. Plenty of board games to play and for sale. Noise level is pretty loud as people are playing games. Bathrooms are clean. This is a nice "third place".

Games galore. Any board or card game you want to play they probably have. It's truly a great…read moreconcept and their collection is impressive, but whatever you do, please do yourself a favor and skip the food. I think this experience will have me scarred for a bit. We had the unfortunate idea to grab some food here as we enjoyed some games (btw it's $15 a person to play indefinitely as long as they have space for your group). We ordered the burger, chicken sandwich, Cajun fries, hummus and pita and tater tots. For such a spacious location, they must have a play kitchen because most of the food was inedible. The "best" thing about my chicken sandwich (three tenders- was not even a patty) was the brioche bread. The "best" thing about the hummus was the pita. My friend took two bites of the burger and felt sick. We thought we had been pranked but felt sad about throwing so much food away. Just don't do it. I don't want to think about this food ever again. If you must, apparently the coffee was good and they have other drinks and pastries (which they hopefully outsource!).

Bar

See all

Bosino

4.5(118 reviews)

1.9 mi•Manhattan Valley

The sweetest staff with the best pizzas! Came here with a friend for a Sunday night dinner and it…read morewas busy, but they were able to seat us. The space itself is small, maybe only fits 20 people inside and 10 outside in their covered patio. Food wise, tried the Affumicata pizza which was incredible! Spicy sausage and smoked mozz is a match made in heaven. The crust is also so good, a tad chewy which I personally love. Also started with the bufala caprese which was delish, but the pizza is really the star of the show. Staff is also so so sweet! Truly the kindest people and make you feel so welcome.

This is one of those places that is so good you almost don't want to give them a good review…read morebecause you don't want too many other people to go and make it hard to get a table. Really cute little place with great service and amazing food. We had two antpastis, a caprese and an eggplant dish, two pastas, and a pizza, and everything was amazing. The lava cake for dessert was amazing as well. We had a few espressos and a cappuccino and they made the most amazing face drawing in the cappuccino foam. We don't live in the area but we'll definitely be back.