The food was SO good!! we got the appetizer of breadsticks & we also got this hawaiian & ham pizza. The taste is marvelous!!! The cheese, sauce, everything goes together so well! I've been to Chicago and tried their pizza at Giordannos and I honestly like this one so much better. I would rate 10/10 Everyone is so nice here. The manager is really sweet and attentive! He's so caring! Nichelle was our server & she was awesome! read more

The staff here were kind and welcoming. The restaurant was clean and well lit. Nancy's Chicago-style pizza is very dense, rich and flavorful. Everything (wings, pizza and Caesar dressing) was almost a tad salt adjacent richness. Which may be typical for a Chicago inspired. Everything was extremely filling after only one slice, two wings and a portion of the salad. Overall, everything was pretty good. I got everything in the smallest portions and there were so many leftovers that will be stocked in the freezer for later. My only suggestion is better bags for larger carry out orders. read more

See all

Food is OK was better in the past. Customer service is extremely slow. The girl in the bartender section was extremely rude. I went up to her to ask if there's anybody that can take her order and very snippy. She's like what do you want it's like I was bothering her. I drove half hour from ,Cary I passed up plenty of other pizza places I could've went to. Being originally from Chicago I wanted to go back because of food was great last time, but it's not always about the food. That's how you get treated as a customer and she was very rude.!! read more

See all

Downgrading from 5 to 2. The pizza is still some of the best in town, but the in-house dinning has become not worth going. The last two trips have been exceptionally long (1 hr+ for food for four), loud, hot, and little to no service. Wait staff are hard to find and inattentive. This last visit took 2 staff and 20 min just to run the card. Looks like they prioritize take outs. Thats what we'll be doing from here on. read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Thin crust meat lovers... there is a full layer of pepperoni on the bottom! - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

I know everyone knows Chicago for their deep dish pizzas, but I was craving the pizzas that the locals love- the tavern style thin pizza that is cut into squares. I've been searching everywhere for it and found Nancy's Pizzeria on Reddit. I was not disappointed!! I got two thin pizzas, I ordered mine with italian beef and onions on it. At first look, it looks like it had no toppings on it. But the toppings were actually under the cheese. This was honestly one of the best pizzas I've ever had and I've been wanting to go back to get the same exact one since I tried it. I will say they are a little pricey- both pizzas (mine a small, the other a medium) came to around $50. I could probably eat the small alone if I was hungry enough. Either way, the pizza looked fantastic, tasted delicious, and I loved it and can't wait to come back and dine in and try more. read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

See all

Party of 4 on a Friday and we were seated in less than 5 minutes. Our waitress rolled her eyes when we ordered the extra crispy stuffed sausage based on great online reviews. Those reviews... I don't get it. The cheese didn't bring much flavor to the party and the Chicago style left me underwhelmed. This was my first experience. The breadsticks were good to half our party and not loved by the other half. The rustic crust spicy pepino was my favorite of the night but it's more about the toppings than the crust. I probably won't make a special trip from Durham to eat here again. From my perspective there are several better places to eat pizza in the area. read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Beautiful cheese pull on the stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Yum! I finally got to try out Nancy's in person and I had a great experience. The restaurant is nicely decorated and all the staff were friendly and helpful. We ordered wings and onion rings for our appetizers and two deep dish pizzas for dinner. The pizzas take a while to cook and we were notified of this upfront. The wings and onion rings were both delicious, I really enjoyed the sauce on both of them! The "A Lot of Meat" pizza was super cheesy and meaty, just as I expected it to be. I will definitely be back, I can't wait to try more! read more

See all

This is a very nice restaurant and location. And it is not just a pizza joint. They have a fantastic menu and everything, and I mean EVERYTHING, is absolutely, melt in your mouth delicious. The owner goes out of his way to order the best possible ingredients. The atmosphere inside is very nice and the services is quick and friendly. This is a place for one of those special nights out. Or just anytime you want the best. read more

Missing out on a great Chicago-style deep-dish pizza is like a bad dream, You can almost smell the buttery crust, taste that savory sauce, and feel the glorious weight of that pizza in your hands. At this point, you'd trade your left sock, your dignity, and maybe even a distant cousin for just one bite. Nancy's is your "Windy City" connection to that saucy cheese lovers dream. It seems not much has changed at Nancy's, if nothing else it has only gotten better. That deep-dish masterpiece is like lasagna and pizza had a lovechild, and it turned out to be an overachiever, but when it comes to slices, you can't eat just one. The pizza is not the only barnstormer on Nancy's menu. Their fried mozzarella is like a crispy baton of pure joy--crunchy on the outside, molten and stretchy on the inside, with melty cheese that pulls into infinity like a delicious magic trick. Dunk them in the marinara or pesto sauce, but don't hesitate to share, these cheese logs can feed the table. If there is any room for desert, you can't go wrong with the classic cannoli. That fresh golden shell gives the perfect crunch before revealing a rich ricotta filling that's smooth and dreamy with just the right amount of sweet. Cheers! read more

Do not order online for a pick up order. It will cost you more. The website goes through yelp then goes through grub hub to place your online order. Make sure you download the app so you aren't price gauged. I was charged $5 more than if I would have called in or placed my order using the app. read more

Service was very slow (and it was not busy). I was shocked that a small pizza was $20. The chicken was very dry...disappointing experience.

The food is very good and if you are from Chicago, one of the only places in the area to get authentic pizza and sandwiches. That being said, the in-house dining service became very spotty, so stopped doing that altogether. Now, my recent experience with the carry out was just not acceptable. Picked order up-it was incomplete. If I didn't bring it up and check, would have left without the complete order. It was not busy, so not an excuse. Just not sure if it is worth driving 15 miles for any more, Hoping this was a blip. read more

Ever since my visit to Chicago a couple of years ago, I've been hooked on authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza. A few coworkers recommended Nancy's, saying it was the closest thing to the real deal in the area, and they weren't playing. I stopped by for takeout after work and was genuinely impressed. My small deep dish pizza, buffalo wings, and garlic bread were all still piping hot by the time I got home. The deep dish had that classic, hearty Chicago flavor I've been craving since leaving the "Chi". The inside has a welcoming vibe, with dimmed lighting, a bar and TV's, perfect for a casual get-together or a relaxed date night. I'll be hard-pressed to visit any other chain pizza spot. read more

See all

It is expensive but worth the deep dish, best in this area! Manager is great! So busy! Love this pizza!! read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Large Pepperoni and Sausage Deep dish - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Normally a 5 star pizza place for our whole family but tonight, and I guess all future Monday nights, not so much. Nancy's does do a great trivia night, especially at Christmas BUT now if you don't reserve a table for trivia on Monday don't bother showing up. Our 6:00pm arrival found zero tables available as all available tables were pre booked for the 7pm trivia. Three tables in the bar that nicely seat six, two of the table take by groups of only two. Maybe require three or four to use the table, especially when bar spots for two are open. More than a dozen patrons were turned away at 6pm despite a room of empty tables, all reserved for 7 trivia. This could be managed better. read more

Great pizza I have had in North Carolina. A little pricey but well worth the price. I always Door Dash never been at their restaurant.

Haven't been in years, so decided to try a take out pizza. Disappointing experience. Ordered one XL veggie pizza. Restaurant not busy at all. Was told a 15-20 minute wait time. Took 38 minutes for ONE pizza. No apology for the extended wait time. Asked twice where the pizza was...and then to be charged $47 plus tax- so $50.77 for a pizza. Pizza was good but not great. Poor customer service and not worth the price unfortunately. read more

We went for the Chicago style stuffed crust pizza. It was delicious and perfectly cooked!! The service was so so. They never refilled my drink. Although when asked if we needed anything I did ask. We had buffalo waffle fries. They were okay. If you really love blue cheese then get them. I will try something else next time. The restaurant is nice and clean. It does smell amazing when you walk in. It is a little spendy. read more

Ridiculously overpriced for what your get and overrated. Now let's get to the details. I have been wanting to try this place for a while. I've heard about how good the pizza is and I'm on a quest to find thee best pizza in the area. I ordered to go on a Saturday night. It was not crowded at all. Service was great. The host made recommendations and answered all my questions. The deep dish is the favorite but I opted for a personal size thin. crust with 3 toppings because the deep dish was too much for me. I also ordered a small pepperoni and peppers pizza rustic style (regular crust) and wings fried hard with Nancy's sauce. Total: $60. Yup for a personal size pizza and a small pizza and 7 wings. I should've stopped it right there but I was like oh this is the BEST pizza so let's go. Well, it was Not the best and it wasn't even good (the pizza that is). Now I'll say the wings were delicious. Hence the 2 stars. I didn't like the pizza. First the thin crust was sticking to the box. So when I got home I had to pry some pieces off the box to eat them. This made the top separate from the crust. So I just ate the toppings and soggy bread. Helllp Dominos! The sauce was lacking and it just was so basic. I expected better for the price because they charge a base price and then almost $3 for each topping. ‍ Harris Teeter has better pizza. The other pizza tasted a little better. I would not purchase the thin crust again. I would like to try the deep dish but I'm not in a hurry to do so. The place is cute and there's plenty of seating. Nancy's was a bust for me. So I continue on my journey to find the best pizza. read more

We were in Raleigh for our pups heart stent surgery at NC State. And I wanted a Chicago style pizza. So after some searches, Nancy's came to be my pizza of choice. Cool place. Very clean and welcoming. Our server was great. The food was absolutely amazing. I wanted pizza. But also had to try their Italian beef sandwich. I got the regular Italian beef with hot Giardiniera and sweet peppers. I really wish I had added some cheese on it. Because it doesn't come with cheese. And I love cheese. The sandwich was great. Very good taste and a lot of meat. The gravy to dip it in was tasty as well. I ate half of it, because I wanted to try it hot. And took the other half back to the hotel. I also got a medium stuffed pizza with pepperoni, bacon, and Canadian bacon. And this pizza was freaking amazing. The sauce was one of the best sauces I've had. The ingredients were fresh and there was a lot of them. Absolutely loaded with cheese. Which made for a heck of a cheese pull. I only managed to get 2 pieces down. And trust me, I can eat mass quantities of pizza. It is very filling. I'd say you could easily feed 4 people with the medium. My girlfriend who typically is very picky. Got a small thin crust Uncle Tony's special. And she absolutely loved it of course I had to try a piece. And I'm not usually a thin crust person. But it was perfection. She ate over half the pizza, which is rare for her. She's usually 2 slices top. Will definitely be back if I ever happen to be in the area again. Had a quick little conversation with who I'm assuming was the manager. And he was super friendly. Enjoyed my talk with him. Made us feel very welcome there. Definitely recommend if you're nearby and have a crazing fr some amazing pizza! read more

See all

Rating based on: consistency, cleanliness, quality, taste, and presentation Fam, let me put y'all up on game about Nancy's Pizzeria in Raleigh! And before any of my NYC fam comes at me - yes, I know my pizza, but this Chicago-style spot is hitting different! First things first, their deep dish game is BUSSIN' FR FR! But don't sleep on their thin crust either - it's giving main of character of Dune energy! The cheese pull on these pies? More dramatic than your favorite reality show - straight dripping like my iced-out Rolex collection (IYKYK). Let's talk about that Fettuccine Alfredo (or should I say Alfredo Fettuccine because it's THAT good). The sauce is so fire, it had me speaking in tongues! No cap, this sauce is the type you'd want to bathe in (respectfully). And them cannolis? SHEEEESH! They hit that sweet spot harder than your ex's "you up?" text at 2AM. The filling is so creamy and perfect, it'll have you acting up! ‍ The customer service? Impeccable! More reliable than your bestie's shoulder to cry on. And the ambience? It's giving cozy date night vibes but make it Italian! Perfect spot to take your significant other(s) - and that's all I'm gonna say about that! Listen up, if you're looking for some hearty, legitimate Italian food that won't have your wallet crying, Nancy's is the move! The portion sizes are giving generous aunt at Thanksgiving energy, and the prices are actually reasonable (unlike my therapy bills). the ambience I mean, I would take my side piece and my wifey to the spot.! This spot is so good, I'm considering moving closer just to get my weekly fix. And that's on period! Pro tip: Come hungry, leave happy, and don't forget to grab extra cannolis for later (trust me on this one). Nancy's Pizzeria is the truth! This ain't just food - it's a whole experience! read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Most consistent nice size portions! - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Had a really good experience here. Was craving some pizza and wings and decided to order some meatballs too while I was at it. The meatballs came out first and were extremely tasty and filling. Seasoned well and everything. Next came the wings. They were piping hot that I needed to let them rest a few minutes. Towered high and tasted great. Wouldn't say a top place for me for wings but a solid 3.5-4 on a 5 star scale. Lastly, and the star of the show was a personalized deep dish with pepperoni. It looked delicious and also fresh out the oven. Crust was buttery and had the perfect ratio of crunch to softness. The pizza itself was fantastic and brought me back to my days in Chicago! read more

See all

I've been going to Nancy's since it opened several years ago. I'm a traditionalist when it comes to Chicago pizza having been brought up in the city and always get their thin crust, which is the kind of pizza most Chicagoans eat. Do tell! The big news is they're under new ownership! From what I can see from a recent visit it's a really good change. The new owner is friendly and a hard worker and I'd say the same about the staff. We happened to be there on a Thursday night and they were offering half price on any size thin crust pizza, which is a bargain! They also had live music too. In the weeks since I've been there looks like the special on Thursday's has continued, but check their FB page or get the newsletter to verify or call them. Our pizza was great and was happy to see they're following the Chicago model to make a good representation of thin crust pizza. They still have Nancy's signature stuffed pizza too and the rest of the full menu. read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Thin crust pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

The wife and I ordered a deep dish pizza delivery and all I can say is: best pizza since we moved here from Dallas. We really like her deep dish pizza read more

Fun atmosphere, incredible food & even better service. Our bartenders Sarah & Caroline were very personable, knew the menu inside and out and gave awesome recommendations. (I even downloaded the yelp app just to make this review) We were already talking about our next trip on the ride home, can't wait to go back! read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

My food was well seasoned, service is excellent and the ambiance is very nice. I will come back with my family. read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Baked chicken tetrazzini - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Nancy's pizzeria is a well known Chicago pizza restaurant. I'm so happy that there's one here in Raleigh makes me feel like I'm back in Chicago. I highly recommend this place. Love the service and they even had amazing duo guitarists playing on a Thursday night. Great music great food. read more

Excellent customer service and good pizza! It's the only deep dish I've had and I like what I've had so far. Will be back. read more

Nancy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

I was in the mood for Nancy's again and choose the Stuffed Sausage this time. The owner was right, this is the right combo....it was really, really good. I ordered extra crispy but not necessarily burnt and it was spot on. Like I said before, I prefer thin but this was well executed. It was a busy night but staff is very friendly. Definitely on the go to list. read more

I had never heard of this place but my friend purchased a Groupon for it so we gave it a try. The business is located in a shopping plaza with a shared parking lot in front. Plenty of tables and a bar were inside. We came right in and were greeted by our server (Bobby Ryan) He joked with us and told us which items were popular and good. We ended up ordering a thin crust pizza and wings. The pizza toppings are charged separately so it can add up quickly depending on how many toppings you get. We got a medium pizza with 4.5 toppings. The pizza def looked smaller than a medium size I am use to. We also got an order of 7 wings. Our bill was $52. There were only 4 wing sauce flavors to choose from so we got the hot wings. One sauce that we had never heard of so our server let us sample it. I thought it would be an ok dipping sauce but not something I would want on my wings. Overall our server was nice and the food was good but having the Groupon deal helped cushion the price. read more

See all

So if you're a Chicago style deep dish pizza fan and you have not yet eaten at Nancy's, you're in for a real treat when you get there! First know that if you're a first timer and don't do well with a loud restaurant, check their schedule on their website for trivia night and nights they have live music. It does get loud. So back to the menu; their salads are amazing, my wife ALWAYS gets the blueberry pecan salad, I love the breadsticks, and we ALWAYS do one of the Chicago style pizzas. Once you go, you will continue going back for their delicious pizza! read more

When friends from Chicago recommend Nancy's stuffed pizza I knew it would be delicious. The restaurant was quiet and with no waist. We started with Italian breadsticks and chicken wings. The breadsticks were delicious. The wings were crispy and well sauced. The thin crust was addictive but the stuffed pizza truly knocked it out of the park. Service was good but a little slow even though there were only two other parties there. I would definitely recommend and return! read more

For our last night in Raleigh we decided to celebrate with some deep dish, and (according to local friends) apparently Nancy's is the place to go! We started with some fresh local beers on tap, and a couple glasses of merlot, then nommed on a tasty caesar salad before the main event arrived: TWO beautiful, GINORMOUS, cheesy, thick, delicious deep dish pizzas. It's been a hot minute since I've been to Chicago and (see previous review!) had the amazing fortune to go on a work-sponsored deep dish pizza tour. So I can't say if this pizza was as good as some that we experience on that epic #pizzajourney. But if nothing else it was close! And just like my Chicago journey, I was only able to enjoy two slices before I was too full to do anything else but go back to our accommodations and take a long winter's nap. The prices were pretty chunky here, but that seems to be the norm these days. Our waiter was fantastic and friendly, and the drinks and food came out fast! read more

See all

Legit Chicago Style pizza! Picked up a pie for dinner at home and it was spot on. Will go back and try dining in. No comment on service or ambience. Pricy but worth it. read more

I went to dinner tonight and the service was terrible the food was a pure disaster my friend was ready to leave an I was willing to give them a chance but I waited 45 minutes for food my mixed drink was so weak an the server hand our food never came back to check on us charges for 3 items we did not even order an on top of it all not even a thanks for coming in bad customer service I will never return an advise any one to go there sad part I am a chef of 41 years this place is a company that is ripping people off please don't go there read more

Quality of food and taste is in a league by itself! Only ordered delivery but food was in packaging so the food would remain hot

They're deep dish. Pizza is absolutely phenomenal. Caesar salad is great as well. Very much. Enjoy dining here. We definitely recommend.

All of the food is so delicious. We have tried their pizzas, salads, fries, pastas, meatballs, etc...all of it was really great. This is one of our favorite places to order from when we have company, because there is truly something for everyone. read more

Real Chicago Pizza thick and thin with a well stocked bar Salads were fresh and tasty

Great chopped salad! Rigatoni also a good option and these are not even their specialties! Service is OK but the food makes up for it! read more