Mueller's Bakery

Colonial Bakery is a must if in Lavallette, NJ. What a lot of patrons in line didn't know (maybe…read morethis is new) is that online ordering is available for next-day or future pickups. Seems like that is the way to go if you're a summer local or are looking to do something time sensitive. The requirements for this are detailed on the website. If you're coming for the summer and don't mind the whole experience of taking a number, waiting in line, talking to East Coast locals, and taking in the sweet smells of the bakery...then enjoy the wait! The "Crumb Bun" or crumb cake as we call it, is what we also come here for because it's the "it" thing us West Coasters don't get on our side. What I noticed is they do individual pieces, a whole cake that serves 6-8, platters, with Bavarian cream, filled with slices of cinnamon apples, and a bag of "just the crumbs". We went with a whole crumb cake to take back to feed the family/guests, and a few decorated Sesame Street cookies. They have everything here though - from donuts/pastries, bagels/rolls/bread, fun cookies, cupcakes...you name it. They also have coffee! All in all get there close to opening, pre-order if needed, or just enjoy the crumb cake ride.

Best crumb cake on the Jersey shore. Be prepared to grab a number and wait if you don't order…read moreahead. Always a line here--even at 7:00 am. Prices are high, but, they gotta make their money for the year in just a few months. I will return.

Our custom cake turned out great!

See all

502 Baking Company

4.6(78 reviews)

5.3 mi

6/2024: it's summer and back at the PP beach…read more Toni, the bakery owner, was so gracious and accommodating with us and replaced the strawberry pie from our Thanksgiving visit. She's hard working, and so sweet to offer us a key lime pie. Also, the crumbcake cheesecake (we discovered the delicious dessert at Atlantic Offshore FishRey & Restaurant over on Channel Dr., PP, NJ) and had to source the baker. A combination of cheesecake and crumb cake makes a truly tasty treat. So yummy. Thank you for rectifying the issue. It was nice to meet Olivia, store clerk, too. We'll be back to try the chicken pot pie in the Fall; read it's really good!

This is my go-to bakery for special occasion cakes, among other treats. My twins were celebrating…read moretheir 17th birthday and I called Saturday morning to see if they had any cakes available. Generally you need to pre order and I forgot to do that. Lucky for me they were making an order and could make an extra one for me. Leslie was so kind and helpful and I was thankful for the accommodation. Do yourself and them a favor next time you need a cake--give them a few days notice and you'll guarantee getting a cake. My kids got the cake and their driving licenses!

Chocolate cake with chocolate filling -- delish!!

Pastry case

See all

Crust And Crumb Bakery

4.2(97 reviews)

36.1 mi

We stopped in here today. Their last weekend of the season is Halloween this year. Every baked good…read moreis delicious! Their cookies are the size of my head, not even exaggerating. They have a vegan and gluten free dessert case that's separated from their other baked goods as well. Very accommodating when it comes to tree nut allergies also. Always a pleasure coming here. Have a great winter and we'll see you in the Spring for more goodies!

They are so helpful and accomodating. Friendly service and their cakes are beautiful and they are…read moreso creative. Their elephant ears are delish. We always make a point to stop in while we are in town.

See all

Apple pie crumb cake

Papa Ganache Bakery

4.0(32 reviews)

3.5 mi

Normally I really don't go out of my way for vegan food-but you wouldn't know it was vegan unless…read moreyou knew. Strong flavors, great taste.

The staff- There was only 1 person working, and she was SO unfriendly, and rather rude…read more The food looked pretty good, but it was kind of pricey. (Although I guess it is a GF bakery, but some prices were considered unreasonable.) The whole bakery itself was ok. I did appreciate how they were giving out free stickers. But overall the whole experience was mid. I don't know if I'd come back, but it was alright.

Almond and regular croissants

See all

Inside the regular croissant

Del Ponte's Bakery

4.2(208 reviews)

9.3 mi

Huge variety, everything is delish. The biscotti is by far the best and so many flavors. Also has…read morethe best, fresh butter cookies.

This place had everything-donuts, cakes, biscotti's every flavor, cheesecake, cookies. Don't miss…read morethis wonderful Italian bakery.

See all

Simona's Bakery

3.6(103 reviews)

4.6 mi

Simona's bakery has a great selection of cookies and other desserts. I really enjoy their large…read moreselection of biscotti's and different flavors as well as they have two different types of rainbow cookies, one with a apricot jelly and one with what I think is a traditional raspberry jelly. They also have a selection of butter cookies which are really great if you're bringing a box of something somewhere. The last time I came in I tend to be indecisive with so many selections and the woman behind the counter was very kind and patient with me waffling on what I wanted to get and how much of it I wanted to get. She even happily wrapped up the box because I was bringing it over to my sister's house. The shop is small but it does have a lot of items and to be honest if it was much bigger, I don't know if it would change much outside of having space for people to sit down which seems outside their business model. This seems like a great place place to stop if you were going to someone's house and needed to take a box of something or if it was the holidays and you wanted to get some desserts to bring. There is also the occasional self-indulgence and I really enjoyed the rainbow cookies.

Unprepared when they open the doors at 7 AM. Empty shelves and still baking stuff that should…read morealready be on display. Quality of bake goods is menza menza. Had to go back three times today for simple bread rolls that should have been out when they opened up an hour ago. Counter service is weak and slow which only adds to a negative experience here. Bottom line: NOT recommend! Muller's bakery of Bayhead eats their lunch all week long and then some. Go here instead, it's worth the drive..

3 layered cake chocolate & vanilla with chocolate pudding and cannoli fillings, fresh whipped cream frosting.

See all

My cookies

Nick + Sons Bakery

4.7(42 reviews)

5.7 mi

Love this place. Always fresh. Best croissants at the shore. Go visit nick and sons asap.read more

FABULOUS croissants. My hubby just had surgery and couldn't eat for over 24 hours. When he could,…read moreall he wanted was a croissant from Nick + Sons!

Croissant

Jazz at Nick's

See all

Jazz entertaining the crowd

Anello's Pastries

5.0(3 reviews)

2.5 mi

Tried Anello's for the first time today with a Too good to go surprise bag. So many yummy treats!!!read more

I know Anello's is off the beaten track (Higgins Ave, Brielle), but it is well worth the visit…read more Whether stopping in for a quick, last minute item or a pre planned order, this bakery is great. Their Magic Bars, Funfetti Bars, and Key Lime Bars are a hit. They have a selection of Gluten Free items. I've pre-ordered cheese cakes in the past and they are amazing. This place is a must try!

See all

Confections Of A Rock$tar

4.3(267 reviews)

10.2 mi

Good quality and friendly staff. Fresh ingredients, thoughtful help to decide on appropriate menu…read morefor a planned event

Stumbled across the place while a doing a 5k in Asbury Park. There was a decent line of…read morecustomers. The walls have pictures of musicians and they were playing rock music over the speakers which fit the name and the vibe. I ordered the Ice Ice baby which a brownie with frosting and also the Not you Little Debbie (Gibson) oatmeal cookie crème pie. They were delicious. Next time I'm in the area I'll make sure to stop by again.

Cinnamon bun in its packaging

See all

Inside decorations

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Maxwell R.

9 years ago

Based on the multiple raving reviews about their crumb cake I had to give it a try; sorry, not a fan. Cake was dry and crumbs tasted like compressed sugar drowning in I what I thought was powdered sugar. But it tasted weird, not like sugar. I guess I like more of a "cakey" crumb cake. Did not have the opportunity to try anything else here. Not worth the drive for me...comparable bakeries closer with a lot less traffic. read more

Becca B.

7 years ago

Mueller's is the best bakery in New Jersey! Always fresh and delicious! Their pastries are unbelievable AND they are now offering vegan and more gluten free options! They stay current and actually care about their customers! Would definitely recommend and agree that this bakery is 'Where quality makes the difference' ! read more

Dee F.

14 years ago

Best crumb cakes in the world. Period. End of story. Growing up my dad always bought the family crumb cake a local bakery on Sunday mornings. I have a soft spot for crumb cake but I'm picky about it. I'm all grown up now, lol, and found this place in 1998 and I don't need to go for my crumb cake any place else. read more

Ashley C.

12 years ago

Crumb Cake!!! Powdered was super the glazed was a little too sweet for me but when you walk into a place 15 minutes after it opens and you're number is 64 you know why its so famous. Bear Claw was soft and fresh and the girls behinf the counter take care of you quickly. read more

Spencer L.

11 years ago

Delicious treats! Especially the powdered coffee cake (Or is it crumb cake?). One caveat, long line on summer weekend mornings. If you know you will need something, call a day ahead and they will have it ready for you then (Skip the line!). read more

Dennis M.

18 days ago

This place has the best vibe! The cupcakes are so good. Fluffy on the inside with a nice crisp crust. The cakes looked really good too. Also, so did the cookies. Total deli vibe. Take Apple Pay and cash. read more

Karen B.

4 years ago

Everything is awesome, see for yourself you will not be disappointed. Get there early to avoid having to wait.

Nicholas B.

3 years ago

The crazy thing is I am normally a complainer. I can't say anything bad about this place.

Jeanette K.

5 years ago

The crumb cake is delicious but very overpriced!

Mueller's Bakery - bakeries - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Coffee near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Breakfast near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Things to Do near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Desserts near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Restaurants near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Ice Cream near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Lunch near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Shopping near Mueller's Bakery

BEST of Bay Head, New Jersey Flowers near Mueller's Bakery

Best of Bay Head

Things to do in Bay Head

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Mueller's Bakery also viewed

Park Bakery

4.3

(86 reviews)

Original owner passed away but bakery was taken over by second best in the area. (Colonial of…read moreLavallette ) Very convenient for Seaside Park residents and great all around but Ob-Co is worth the drive. Just saying Also, we miss the special events. Everything from 1960's stars like Gilligan's Island to Lost in Space. Wish Colonial bought his contacts list.

Great bakery with good coffee options as well. Good service and reasonable prices for the shore…read more They made a Boston cream cake for my grandmother's 96th birthday. She and the rest of the family were really happy with it.

Colonial Bakery

4.1

(30 reviews)

Being Partial to Muellers & Park Bakery for crumb cake & Buns in the morning I kept hearing you…read morehave to try Colonial. Well, this past week we finally did and boy are we happy we did so. Hands down the best crumb cake I have ever had in my life. Perfect balance of cake & crumb not too sweet simply delicious. The jelly donuts and Boston cream donuts were exceptional as well. Going to have to try some other items as well as their cakes in the future! As good as it gets.

Lots of great baked items to choose from. I had to try the crumb cake, it's a must especially if…read moreyou have tried the other local competitors to see which you like the best. Crumb cake was delish but it has little to no "cake" it was mostly crumb. I also had the banana and strawberry smoothie with oat milk. It was refreshing on a hot summer day. I was in and out if there mid day and mid week in 10 min.

Elisa's Pastry Shop

3.5

(97 reviews)

The most delicious pastries in the area. Stopped on Father's Day in pm & still a fantastic…read moreselection available. Cannoli was fantastic, just the proper crunch with sweet cream. Service was great & very helpful. Highly recommend!!!

Amazing products. Too expensive though so make the prices fair and increase profits tremendously,…read moreso it's a grammar school principle

Sophie G’s

3.4

(11 reviews)

Lovely space and delicious cookies and cakes..The owner is so wonderful..Please support small…read morebusiness in your community.

Best Bakery 2026!!…read more We came for a sweet 16 celebration. Ordered ahead with the bakery and could not be more accommodating, pleasant and reasonable priced. Absolutely gorgeous tiered, iced strawberry shortcake! Eat your heart out those who delayed in answering this is THE PLACE TO GO!!! We also bought some pastries as a goodie they were spot on! Cream was perfect, not too many or little chips, shell baked just right!! If you love your sweets and miss this place you didn't get all Seaside had to offer!!!

Ocean Grove Bake Shoppe

3.0

(66 reviews)

A perfect little stop while exploring the charming streets of Ocean Grove…read more The Main Street area is lively, with plenty of small shops and cafés, making it a great place to take a break. We stopped here for a quick coffee and snack before continuing our day. This family-owned bakery has that classic small-town charm, with shelves filled with fresh breads, pastries, cookies, and cakes. We grabbed a croissant and coffee, and both were fresh, simple, and satisfying. Whether you're spending the day at the beach or just strolling through Ocean Grove, this bake shop is definitely worth a quick stop for a tasty treat and a cup of coffee.

Mad stale. Especially the choco croissant :/ would not recommend coming here for baked goods.read more

Donuts Plus

3.8

(58 reviews)

This spot is so much more than donuts, FYI…read more They are the most kind people and created an absolutely adorable moment for our kiddo by bringing him a tray to decorate his own donut with icing and sprinkles. It was so cute ~ the tray included a fresh donut..this one small gesture helped to create such an amazing morning for our family. There's a sign outside that mentions 'iced coffee' which is the real reason we pulled into the parking (adjacent to building), but once we stepped inside, we knew we would be grabbing a few other items. The bakery cases were lined with fresh bagels, rolls, donuts, the cutest Crab (and other fun design) cookies, and more. They offer fresh brekky sandwiches, so we couldn't pass up a pork roll moment (IYKYK). They sell merch, and we purchased a keepsake of a framed painting from a local artist that now has a spot in our kitchen. Love supporting local artists through small businesses! They have seating outside if you want to have those bagels/pork roll sammies/treats in-the-moment. Def recommend if staying down the shore!

Had another amazing morning at Donuts Plus! We loved sitting outside and enjoying our…read morehalf-chocolate and half-glazed donuts!!

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef

3.5

(36 reviews)

Was reluctant to leave this review but it's happened too many times I've come here…read more First, the aggressiveness of the associate the minute you step into the store they are asking what you want. My hand wasn't even off the door from entering before one girl ran to the counter and said can I help you. I said please give me a few minutes. There are a lot of things to choose from. Also the associates are not friendly at all and act annoyed, like you are bothering them. Zero personalities. Young girls I'd say all in their 20's. Second, the pastries all taste the same and were not fresh. You can tell a fresh pastry from one that's been sitting in the case for days. These ones I purchased were days old. This place is pricey; the items should be fresh. I stopped going to Caputo's years ago because they are also subpar. Long gone are the good bakeries.

Should have taken pics of my crumb cake. First time here. Delightful cozy fresh bakery. Has a good…read moremix of sweet and breads and even bagels. Only had the crumb cake which was fluffy then crunchy fresh on the crumbs part. Coffee was very good too. Will be back! Friendly low key service.

Mike’s Crumb Cake Factory

4.6

(44 reviews)

Delicious and moist! Friendly staff m. The vanilla crumb cakes, Delicious. Pistachio crumb cake is…read morevery good.

I come here all the time for that crumb cake and it's never bad idea. They have a bunch of…read moredifferent flavors of crumb cake my personal favorite is a tie between your normal crumb cake and cookies and cream flavor. I have them put some sugar on it and it just tastes amazing when I bring it home. They have individual slices and you can get a whole cake. They are cash only mainly but they'll also use pay apps like venmo They don't take credit cards. There is also no seating there so you have to take it to go but it's definitely worth a visit. It's one of the best crumb cakes I've ever had

Sweet Bites by Angela

5.0

(3 reviews)

This is place is great. I recommend it to anyone in the area that wasn't quality baked goods!read more

I ordered cupcakes for my dads birthday and Angela did not disappoint! It was so easy to order with…read moreher and she was super professional! Beautiful presentation by just looking at them in the container! My whole family raved over the dessert! The pistachio cupcakes with buttercream frosting with a chocolate cover espresso bean.. oh my goddess I could eat the whole dozen myself! So moist and full of flavor! I already placed my next order and know I will be getting my money's worth every time! Thank you again Angela!

The O G Creamery

3.9

(22 reviews)