The place is amazing, it's like food porn. I went in for one item and left with $ 50 worth of some of the most delicious baked goods. The staff is so pleasant and helpful, every time I'm in the area I stop by. read more

Got a beautiful cake for my Nana's birthday! Everyone loved it- super light and fluffy icing and spongey cake! Picking it up was quick and easy, too. Needed a new place to get cakes since Fumosa in Ortley closed! Will definitely be back for more! read more

Mueller's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

The best bakery ever! Such a staple in Bay Head. Everyone is so kind and the baked goods are absolutely delicious. Love the cookies, crumb cake, and donuts. read more

Love this place, as does my sister who comes to visit from SC. It's a place we MUST go when she's here. We didn't get there until about 3:30 on Sunday and I was afraid nothing would be left. But, they was plenty to choose from. While I love their large turnovers, we got a strawberry shortcake as our dinner dessert. Everyone loved it! We also got small eclairs, cream puffs, and an assortment of Italian cookies. I only have a few of the cookies left to show as a picture as everything else was eaten (or taken home with my sister!). The place can get very crowded but it was not when we were there. The staff is friendly, helpful and knowledgeable about their products. It is truly the best bakery around! read more

Mueller's Bakery - Italian cookies, chocolate chip, chocolate covered with Carmel inside and iced lemon ricotta cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

The nice folks at the Food Shack in Point Pleasant Beach sent us here after I admired their pork roll sandwich, which came on Mueller's raisin bread. There was about a five minute wait on a Sunday morning in mid-May -- a lot of people in the store and a lot of servers to serve them. Tried an excellent soft pretzel, two variations of their crumb cake squares (blueberry cheese and apple), a loaf of raisin bread and a large cannolo. Note that there are two kinds of raisin bread - and when I return I will stick to the smaller, more cake like variant which the Food Shack used. The larger, airier one I purchased was quite good, with a bit of sugar topping, but it is the smaller, sweeter loaf that is most crave worthy. The crumb cakes are also particularly excellent and justify a visit. Everything tastes as if the freshest, highest quality ingredients are used. The old fashioned decor and vibe add to the wholesome gestalt. read more

Their cheese danish and cheese coffee ring are delicious. The Boston crème and jelly donuts were disappointing as there was hardly no filling in them. read more

This place is crowded on the weekend! I stopped in to try a few donuts and WOW. I was pleasantly surprised. They had some of the best flavored jelly I've tried. I will absolutely be coming back. I also noticed they had beautiful AND affordable pre-made cakes ready to go. So glad I found this spot! read more

Mueller's Bakery - cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

See all

We've also been coming here for years and they are not only always consistent, but just a staple in the Jersey Shore summers. We are always picking something up whenever we need to bring something to someone else's house and it never fails to be a great gift. read more

Impeccably clean , fast moving , small old world Americana charm. Cases filled top to bottom. Counter women will answer any and all questions and make great suggestions. Even with line your in and out. read more

If ordering online to send out of state, buyer beware. Sent 3 orders of goods out of state, two were received in timely manner. Yes, I did see Muellers comment about once product leaves they take no responsibility. But I thought, it's Muellers, shouldn't have an issue. Sent items in March and 2 arrived in 3-5 days but a third order arrived yesterday 4/14- arriving 21 days after sent date. Both buying and receiving parties have been loyal Mueller customer's for over 50 years. All were really disappointed. Save your money. read more

Easy online ordering system, cake was prepared as requested and very tasty! Only downfall, I selected strawberry inside and it barely had 1 single cut up strawberry. It was maybe 3/4 tiny pieces in the center. I would definitely order again, taste was great, but would be sure to ask for additional strawberry beyond 3/4 little baby pieces inside the cake. read more

Mueller's Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

I drove all the way from ocean grove to buy an entire crumb cake that costs $18. A few years ago a fellow employee used bring them in. They were double the size and soft melt in your mouth crumbs and cake. This was flat, stale and small hard crumbs . What a shame it was nothing like in the past. NJ was known for this crumb cake I have had much better! I will never go back or recommend. We gave it away to a neighbor ! read more

Mehhhhh. The coffee was not good and the cup was scalding. The cheese ring was 8 out of 10, a tad bit too sweet. My husband said the powdered jelly donut was "awful". My daughter loved the small tie dye rainbow sprinkle cookies. Will probably return just for the cookies. read more

See all

I love this spot for their sugar cookies - it's nostalgic and reminiscent of the cookies I had growing up. I've also tried a few of their pies and cakes, and they're quite good. When it comes to service, this is a local shop and extremely busy, especially during the summer months. Therefore, their line is insane and when they call your number, there is never really time to properly browse what they have to offer. If you try to browse before your number is called, as you should, it feels a bit too crowded and unseemly to try to poke towards the front and see the display cases properly. read more

Fabulous bakery! Huge selection of danish, crumb cake, etc. etc. very busy, yet so worth it. Staff efficiently move things along, very pleasant. Parking can be a challenge, yet once again worth it! Enjoy! read more

We love Mueller's coffee cake! We bring it to my great-grandmother's house every year. This week, we celebrated my grandparents' 50th wedding anniversary, and we bought a cake from Mueller's for the party. It was a beautiful design (see attached picture!), and was topped with a delicious, fluffy whipped cream. The cake was a hit! Everyone came back for seconds. When we came in today (July 13) to buy coffee cake, everyone on the staff were very friendly and the line moved quickly. Mueller's also offers gluten-free cupcakes and cookies, as well as egg- and dairy-free cookies! read more

See all

Stopped in the evening before a fishing charter. Employees were very friendly and helpful. Bagels and baked goods were very good. Would definitely stop by again on my next stay in town. read more

After hearing from my sorority sister who works there about it for 15 years I finally visited and damn was it worth the wait! For the crumb to cake ratio alone! They also sell the crumbs by themselves which I highly recommend you microwave and put on top of ice cream! I also got a petit four which tasted like a love match between marzipan and cake dipped in gorgeous icing. I also got a brownie which was similar to the petit four in how moist, light and flavorful it was! I would love to go back and try absolutely everything! Jersey has some of the best bakeries I've been to throughout the world and this one is the epitome of what makes them so great! Beautiful variety, lovely service and absolutely delicious treats! read more

Mueller's Bakery in Bay Headis a delicious place with their renowned crumb buns (glazed or powdered sugar) , cakes, pies, cookies and bread! Also apple turnovers, gluten-free treats, and staff that are helpful, and to everyone's surprise----even if they work at Mueller's they all do not weigh 400 pounds! On the weekends and before holidays, you need to take a number, but the wait is not long....sometimes you can "luck out" and get in and out...when Superstorm Sandy hit....the rumor was as long as the First Responders got coffee and crumb buns...the Bakery's power would be restored quickly..... Come in once and you will be a return customer! read more

I was in Bay Head for 3 days and I went to Mueller's Bakery every day. So much variety to choose from, had to go back every day to try out all their specialities. The bakery had lines every day we went. It moved pretty quickly though. Like more places, mask is required to be worn prior to to entry. The crumb cake was pretty nice - it was different and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I ended up bringing a slab back to NYC as apparently it freezes well. My other favourites are the chocolate eclairs and the blueberry custard in a pastry topped with powdered sugar. Those were sooo good. Prices are pretty decent - definitely cheaper than city prices. Each purchase was nicely boxed with love. Cash and card are accepted. Will definitely be coming back here next time I am in Bay Head. read more

Mueller's Bakery - Crumb cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

See all

This bakery has everything! Wow-so many choices. I ended up bringing apple pie and banana nut loaf home. I really would have liked to have taken more home. The employees are very friendly and helpful as well. Make sure not to visit on a Monday as that is when they are closed. But always a good reason to come back! read more

See all

Bakery is good but prices are unreasonable. I'll make my own brownies at these prices!

Wow, what a beautiful and delicious spot! We grabbed 2 cakes to bring to a friends beach house as her family was inviting us! The crumb cake it delish but we also grabbed a blueberry pocket pie- the custard and crust is to die for. Loved it! We also grabbed a layer Beach cake, so cute and also delicious!! Would recommend you stop by, this is a MUST. I also noticed they had dairy free, GF, vegan options as well!! read more

See all

I go there for the crumb cake. Heavy on the crumbs, light on the cake. I have not tried their other cakes and bread.

Terrific bread, pastries, and pies. We grabbed a Key Lime pie to bring to a party in Manasquan, and it was well received. Prices are fair, given that it's in $$$$ Bay Head, loads of parking across the street, and the staff behind the counter keeps the inevitable lines moving quickly. A NJ shore classic! (Edited to add-the preppy blonde Bay Head moms are easy on the eyes, too)! read more

Yet another great bakery one of the few left in the area. It's well worth the trip. A little out of the way but the town parking lot across the street always has spots. read more

What might you think when you see people lining up to buy something and it's not even the day before a holiday? Maybe, they must be selling something pretty good, there. They are. Crumb buns!! In several yummy flavors! My favorite was the traditional (plain) though it was fun to taste the glazed and raspberry (?) glazed. Don't miss them. read more

We bought their crumb cake that everyone raves about. It was all crumb and very little cake. Disappointing. Delponte's bakery in Bradley Beach is still the best in my book. read more

Ok, yah, I'm a fan but on this fifth trip to Jersey shore this season, I stop by to pick up 4 or 5 different specialty items. Since It's blueberry season, I tried the blueberry flats, the blueberry crumb cake, the blueberry fritters and the blueberry strudel. I read on FB the bakery offered these challah bread pretzels powdered in cinnamon sugar and excited to try them. So disappointed in them (see photo)! They were baked on one side but underside was burnt and couldn't see that on display rack. I love sweets and we walk there while in town. Great job baking ladies, everything else was on point! read more

See all

Drove about 45 minutes just to get these frogs. Nostalgia for me. We used to get these every year for St. Patrick's Day but you can't find them around here anymore. These are just like I remember, overly sweet fondant, the icing in the middle was good, not too sweet. Icing in middle was pink which always makes me laugh when you eat them. Well worth the trip, took me down memory lane read more

Mueller's Bakery - St. Patrick's Day frogs - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

I am very sad to write this unfavorable review for this bakery, since I have used this establishment for years now! My daughter ordered ,in advance , 24 plus two egg free cupcakes for my twin grandsons 5th birthday celebration. All the cupcakes were so stale that even the children didn't eat them. $60.plus , Poorly spent! read more

Albeit long, Mueller's is offering a stellar delivering service during COVID-19 phase 3!! Their website is very clear, and warn customers that if you order delivery Fri-Sun (and you live in a 10 mile radius) you will receive your goodies the next day. MY Mueller's order was (eventually) hand-delivered to me in Sea Girt by 2pm the next day!! Prior to this delivery, I had never tried their blueberry scones! I have to say they are delicious and honestly taste like a one of the better blueberry muffins out there. read more

Mueller's Bakery - 1/2 pound "just crumbs" - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

Very good bakery. They are known for their crumb cakes. They were good. I wouldn't say amazing. But certainly good. Donuts might have been better. Also. Great service on a busy summer day. read more

Awesome ! Bakery goods excellent I have never been disappointed in their bakery products.

Updating this review-- Mueller's is back! My Grandma says this is the way she always remembers it! They definitely readjusted their pans and the crumb cake has been perfect. Lucious crumbs with very little cake underneath. Simply the best!! So happy. ---------------------------------------------------- read more

Mueller's Bakery - Ridiculously thin and even! Where are the crumbs?! - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

See all

Good classic NJ style crumb cake with thick crumb layer and yeast cake. $30 total shipped to PA. A little steep but worth the occasional splurge. read more

Visited this bakery while I was in the area crabbing and was told by my friend that they have great crumb cake. Stopped by when we were done and they were pretty busy for a weekday afternoon. I got right to business and ordered two pieces of crumb cake and also got a cherry/almond turnover because it looked really good. My friends got donuts too which are supposed to be very good as well but I decided to stay just moderately chubby and stuck with what I got. They have a huge assortment of cakes, pies, and pastries and the service was pleasant and quick. I will tell you that the crumb cake was some of the best I've had, the glaze added a nice touch....cherry turnover was really good too. They definitely got my return business when I'm in the area. Definitely recommended. read more

See all

The Beat Cookies, pastry and coffee on the shore! Worth the wait in line. A staple if you are in the Bay Head area. read more

Mueller's Bakery - The best cookies, pastry, and coffee on the shore! Worth the wait in line. - Bakeries Near Me - Bay Head, New Jersey

Actually better than before (is that possible) As good as I remember. It has been a few years since we were here as we skipped the shore on our last few visits back home. The bakery was hopping when we went on a Monday afternoon. They have increased their variety of goods, especially in their cakes. Still, though the best offering is the crumb cake square. It has become pricier topping out at $18; when we first started getting it in the mid 80's, I think it was like $3. Yikes! They also make the crumb buns with various jams. The staff was helpful and friendly so much so that I didn't care that I paid $18 for a 10 inch square. read more

People stand out here for hours waiting on their orders I don't understand why. Waiting over an hour for two donuts is just absurd. They need to hire more people or make a pick up line/window for quick pastry orders or figure out a better process. The crumb cake is okay I have certainly had better it's very thin and the cake part is not as tasty as others I have had . Their cookies are decorative but not tasteful read more