Was reluctant to leave this review but it's happened too many times I've come here. First, the aggressiveness of the associate the minute you step into the store they are asking what you want. My hand wasn't even off the door from entering before one girl ran to the counter and said can I help you. I said please give me a few minutes. There are a lot of things to choose from. Also the associates are not friendly at all and act annoyed, like you are bothering them. Zero personalities. Young girls I'd say all in their 20's. Second, the pastries all taste the same and were not fresh. You can tell a fresh pastry from one that's been sitting in the case for days. These ones I purchased were days old. This place is pricey; the items should be fresh. I stopped going to Caputo's years ago because they are also subpar. Long gone are the good bakeries. read more

I totally agree with the other review from Joe they are snippy and snappy as soon as you try to order something and want you to hurry quickly always dislike that However, the scones raisin scones were the only thing I went there for most weekends . I just tried to order some for Saint Patrick's party and they're telling me they don't make them all the time and they're not taking an order for them. I said I understood that however you don't make wedding cakes all the time, but you take orders for them and specialty cakes . The manager said yeah that's right, but we cannot make them and we're not taking an order. Who is a woman? I don't know her name. Don't really want to know her name. is the rudest most ignorant uneducated person you can ever speak with. Oh my God she needs to be thought some serious manners, big time !!! has no idea how to speak to people just classless!! Talk about a lousy pastry shop. I will not be going here again. That's the end of my shopping here for sure !!! They do not appreciate anybody's business they have no sense of customer service or how to speak to people. Some of the young high school college girls are polite, but the manager is exceptionally rude and nasty do yourself a favor and go to uncle Giuseppe's. They make awesome cakes, pastries, and it's always fresh and the staff are fabulous and friendly there!!! read more

Should have taken pics of my crumb cake. First time here. Delightful cozy fresh bakery. Has a good mix of sweet and breads and even bagels. Only had the crumb cake which was fluffy then crunchy fresh on the crumbs part. Coffee was very good too. Will be back! Friendly low key service. read more

Frequently come here, always great pastries! Staff have always been friendly and service always good.

Very good assortment of fresh pastries. The staff is very friendly and the prices aren't bad either. I would definitely recommend giving this place a try. read more

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef - Assorted pastries - Desserts Near Me - Tinton Falls, New Jersey

The Pastry Chef has always been my go-to bakery (12 yrs) when I'm in the area. They're a full service bakery w/great presentation and freshly-made product. I ordered a buttered egg bagel w/caffe. Very crispy. I cannot review the cakes here due to the fact of never having ordered one, but I can say from previous visits that the pastries were very fresh. The bakery is super clean as it should. Parking here in Tinton Falls Centre is ample. The staff is always polite & attentive. read more

See all

My wife and I have been coming here for many many years and the cakes and pastries and cookies are simply amazing! I admire their consistency. The cake is not too sweet, just right. We tried a new vanilla cake last night and it was drool-worthy. In my never ending search for the best crumb cake on the Jersey Shore, I may have found the winner at Pastry Chef. I have tried many, but I think theirs is just perfect, with a perfect balance of crumb to cake and moistness. Also, the girls up front are always attentive and polite and do a great job. Just FYI, some of the girls have better handwriting than others, in case you need lettering on your cake. Love this place. read more

This would be a 5 star review if my cake wasn't spelled wrong and I wasn't told that it was, in fact, spelled correctly and that is what an "N" is supposed to look like. Someone needs to go back to where they learned piping and fire that instructor or that instructor needs to learn their alphabet. Clearly something was smuged off of the cake or someone messed up while decorating the cake but played off that it was right. Take a look at the picture and see for yourself. "Comgratulatioms" should have an "M" in it. Compare it to the "M" in my name. I see no difference. Otherwise the cookies from here are delicious and the best in the area. The cake itself was a cannoli cake and it was so good. read more

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef - Comgratulatioms??? Really? "But that's how it's supposed to look." I DONT THINK SO. Someone messed up and won't admit it. - Desserts Near Me - Tinton Falls, New Jersey

Great place with a wide variety of pastries, cakes and more. Everything is so yummy. Will definitely be back for more!

Classic Northeastern NJ style bakery located in northern central NJ. Italian cookies $12 a pound, good pastries and breakfast buns. Fantastic buttered hard rolls (plain, sesame or poppy). Great coffee selection, cakes, custom cakes & bread. They cater. There is one small table with two chairs for eat in. read more

These reviews are nonsense. I am a tough critic and their pastries are high quality, consistent, fresh, and delicious. The only things I haven't been a fan of are the carrot cake and the cannoli cream (too spiced for my liking, I prefer more of a vanilla flavor to my cream). Everything else has been outstanding. Def. go for any of the flaky pastries, you cant miss. Theyre all good. Just go. It's good stuff. read more

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef - Desserts Near Me - Tinton Falls, New Jersey

See all

Desserts are adequate. Nothing to "knock your socks off " . Decent stuff. One of the elder staff members always handles and touches all the bakery products with her bare hands when serving them . So be on the "lookout " after ordering . Place is clean though . read more

It is one of the best bakeries in the state. Everything always fresh. Quality is excellent. read more

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef - yummy vanilla cupcake - Desserts Near Me - Tinton Falls, New Jersey

We always order our holiday/party desserts from here. My son's first birthday cake was outstanding and the Easter cake this year was amazing! Delicious and gorgeous! Alex is the nicest business owner ever and always treats my little guy like the most important customer when he comes in (he's only 2 lol). I know that even when I forget to order ahead of time (which is almost always), there's always amazing selections ready to go! read more

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef - a chocolate easter cake - Desserts Near Me - Tinton Falls, New Jersey

See all

Tinton Falls Pastry chef fills a much needed niche in the baking industry in Nj. In the surrounding area the seems to be a plethora of Italian style bakeries. Pastry chef breaks from the crowd and for the most part doesn't disappointment. You can start out with their breakfast pastry the croissants, danish, coffee cake are all delicious and are big enough for two. Beware the bagels they aren't the best and seem to harden fast. The cakes and pies are a crowd pleaser, never have I served a cake or brought one as a hostess gift and not been asked," Where did you get this... fill in the blank". I have hit gold everytime. I think the coffee could be a bit better and a I wish they would bring back their old adorably decorated cupcakes. Overall, I think the place is definitely worth a try. read more

We had our wedding at the Crystal Point where Tinton Falls Pasty Shop provided our wedding cake. After the tasting at the CP, we were given a box of different cakes to take home. Everything was so tasty, it was hard to make a decision. Ultimately, we decided on white cake with cannoli cream and raspberry preserves, a little unconventional, we know. Nonetheless, the Tinton Falls Pastry Shop created our idea, and it was a massive HIT with our guests. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't eating it now while I write this. We gave them a picture to our Maitre'D for inspiration and it looked exactly how we dreamed. Honestly, out of this world! We'll definitely be making trips to this bakery for years to come! read more

Went in today and ordered two Cannoli and two carrot cake squares. Rather than filling up the cannoli when purchased, they fill them up ahead of time and the pastry surrounding the filling was like damp paper towels, not crispy at all like they're supposed to be. The carrot cake squares were equally as bad. The cake itself was dry and lacking in flavor and the cream cheese icing was almost all sugar and seemed like it had spent way too long in the cold case. After tasting one of each, I threw the remaining items into the garbage can. Keep on driving past this bakery, nothing good to be had here! read more

Started out not being a fan - I just moved to the area and was looking for a new bakery as I have a lot of events coming up this summer. I brought in a line drawing for the top of a cake and the young girls working in the front were not the most pleasent nor very helpful and I nearly cancelled. I am so glad I didn't! The cake turned out amazing -chocolate with fudge filling and icing - wow, so moist and delicious. And the line drawing came out so adorable! I was thrilled with all of if and also found the prices to be very reasonable. I will definitley order from them again. A note to the management - perhaps a lesson in customer service would be helpful for some of your younger employees... read more

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef - They copied this from a line drawing - came out great! - Desserts Near Me - Tinton Falls, New Jersey

I want to give zero stars, but that is not an option. I had (now past tense) been going to this bakery for years. Called to order a cake on Friday AM before 10 for Sunday pickup. Was told that "we are no longer taking orders for Sunday." WHAATTT???? Really poor customer service...guess they don't want my business. read more

The Rasberry Cheesecake and Tiramisu was delicious, the coffee was good as well. Cant sit in though, one tiny table. read more

Tinton Falls Pastry Chef - Desserts Near Me - Tinton Falls, New Jersey

My parents just moved to the area and decided to give this place a try. The staff is real nice, but the pastries on the other hand are truly disappointing. Huge eclair fan and the eclairs were so dry! That being said try their S'mores cup. It's actually decent, probably the only good thing here. Unfortunately this place only deserves 3 stars. read more

I've been here many times since my parents move to Seabrook and they always have something nice to bring to their place. We've tried many different pastries, cookies and cakes and were never disappointed. My favorite is the 7 layer cake! read more

Delicious Cannoli Cakes! Look pretty with fondant, even if I do peel that off when I eat it. Very good birthday cakes. Most priced around $20 range, I believe. (Make sure whoever writes on the cake has good penmanship, though!) I thought the regular cannolis were good! Contrary to other reviews! Smells like an old-fashioned bakery when you walk in, too. Italian Cookie trays were a little pricey 2lb for $24.00. read more

Not a lot of options and quite disappointing that they didn't have any any regular goodies like chocolate chip cookies (which is what I came in search of). Prices aren't bad, but I would've felt better in paying more $$ for better-quality desserts instead. Not too expensive, $9.00/lb of goods. read more

I believe this place needs a good rating. I ordered four cannoli, tiramisu, and two strawberry cheesecakes. The desserts are good. Tiramisu didn't taste the rum. So if you don't like bitter then get this tiramisu. I personally think these cakes are good but I wish it had less sugar. I like desserts were there's barely any sweet tastes. But overall, good job. read more

This bakery has the worst parties. I've also ordered whip cream birthday cakes from them and they always have a funny aftertaste. I wouldn't recommend going here! read more

And the coffee isn't bad either. Probably a tad better than the Dunkin Donuts across the street. Cheaper too.

I found the Pastry Chef one day as a result of our usual bakery not taking an order that I wanted filled. I was very pleasantly surprised. The cake we ordered (a coconut lemon) was fresh, tasty and did not have a lot of off-putting heavy buttercream icing on it (which I have found is fairly common). Our guests gave many compliments on the cake! On other occasions we have purchased the chololate bundt cake with chocolate filling...also excellent! and the brownies, all very good. The only other feedback for the Pastry Chef would be that once in a while one of the girls behind the counter has a bit of an attitude. I don't mind the attitude, I find it amusing, but I can see how other customers would focus on that part of the experience. So, some customer service training may be warranted. With that said, overall the staff have been very nice and the place is very clean, which we can all appreciate. Looking forward to my next cake! read more

This is a great little neighborhood bakery. I go there at least once a week. Every Sunday for dinner bread and once a month for the bagels. They're great not too big and overwhelming. My favorite is the whole wheat everything. The coffee is always hot and never stale. Yummy cupcakes, scones, and danishes. read more

My husband ordered my Valentine/birthday cake and it was dry or maybe stale. We brought it back and the manager (Tiffany) and the store owner cut it all up and said there were some dry areas but that was normal. HELLO!!!! That is totally unacceptable, cakes should never be dry, especially at $22.00. The manager was snippy and reluctantly gave me a store credit (which I will not use). I can assure you, I will never step foot in that place again. You don't treat customers that way and I would warn anybody against shopping there. Wegman's makes cake that are 100% better and far cheaper. Amen, hallelujah, never going there again! read more

Let me start off by saying I was a loyal customer for 6+ years, ever since I moved into Tinton Falls. They made my wedding cake (with several hundred in upcharges), my gender reveal cake, many holiday and birthday cakes as well as pastries to bring to family gatherings. Heck, they even follow me on IG. So I never expected to be treated the way I was when ordering my daughter's first birthday cake. When I went in to buy my husband's birthday cake on 2/22, I asked them if they could do a unicorn cake for my daughter's party on 3/31 - I was told to call them a week before and it would be no problem (I've done this before with cakes from them so didn't think twice about it, plus they've done the cake before). So, that's what I did and was then told my order could not be placed because they were focusing only on Easter cakes, so if I wanted a custom bunny cake, they would do it (ha!). I relayed my exchange from the month prior and after I asked to speak to a manager (who wouldn't get on the phone), was told they will do the cake but I have to buy the horn, ears & eyelashes elsewhere for them to put on instead of them being made out of fondant. I said I will call back if I can find them, which I did on Amazon, and placed the cake order over the phone with a sweet girl. She let me know of the initial cost, took my credit card info and said she will have someone call me back if there are any upcharges - she also advised the owner decided the cake decorator could not put the accessories on the cake and I would have to do it (I was initially going to drop them off). The next day, I get a call from Tiffany. Oh boy, that Tiffany. She has an attitude that could make anyone's blood boil. She let me know of the upcharges, which were crazy - I.e. they have to make the cake a little taller so they charge more, if I want swirls as the unicorn mane instead of flowers, that costs more, etc. To offset the rising cost of the cake, I asked what the serving size would be of the cake one size smaller. Tiffany huffed and puffed in the phone, stating they were very busy in the store and she doesn't have this info readily available to give me and I was wasting her time. I asked her why she has such a horrid attitude towards me and she simply exclaimed "we shouldn't even be doing this cake for you, we are doing you a huge favor." Oh, is that so, Tiffany? I'm paying you a ridiculous amount of money for a cake which I gave more than a month's notice for AND giving you business -- and YOU are doing ME a favor? The end result: called up The Chocolate Carousel in Wall, they happily took my order, made all the accessories from scratch without any upcharges, made the cake taller without any upcharges, made the swirls without any upcharges and had the most pleasant attitude in dealing with me!! My daughter had the most gorgeous unicorn cake for half the price of the Pastry Chef and without the headache. My family will never set foot in the Pastry Chef again. read more

The cookies I bought were so stale that the lemon filling was rubbery! They also had a fly in the case and when I brought to the attention of the young lady, she said "ok"! The last few times I experienced the same thing. Will not go back! read more

This is the best bakery around. Very creative and everything is fresh and tastes as good as it looks!

I ordered 200 miniature pastries for my daughter's graduation party. They were so delicious, everyone raved about them. Would definitely use Pastry Chef again. Thank you. Valerie D. read more

They have the most amazing pastries, cakes and cookies. I order from them for every big party or event and people go crazy for the cakes!!

I have a problem with any counter business that makes people feel uncomfortable not leaving a tip. I am a generous tipper but I do not tip counter help. In the past I have had a counter person pick up the tip jar and rattle it in front of my face. I just came from Pastry Chef where the young girl saw I was not going to tip and she tossed the order on the counter in front of me. Really, do these people tip gas station attendants who stand out in the elements filling up there car. I bet not!! There, I feel better. read more