Staff were amazing! They had a great selection of nigiri, sushi, hand rolls. Loved the Pompton special roll and great selection of apps. read more

See all

Love this byob over 20 years in business! The owner is so nice! The fish so so fresh! I love the small quaint ambiance and it's so cute! The apps were so good too and I loved all of for rolls! Plenty of parking and BYOB!!!! read more

See all

Recently moved to the area and have been on the hunt for a new sushi place. This is a convenient spot to get to and I was able to find parallel parking pretty easily. The sushi was all very fresh! My only negative was that it had a lot more rice than I would like. read more

This was not a good experience for me. Ordered for delivery thru Uber eats and all three rolls were packed into one round aluminum container. The avocado was hard as a rock , the rice was stale and just not a pleasant taste. Not for me read more

See all

Really gross sushi. Sweet warm rice. Barely any fish in spicy tuna and spicy salmon rolls. read more

Mr Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Dami was closed on a Tuesday, so we went here instead. Sushi just average, nothing special. Place looked tired, could use some tidying up and a good cleaning. Doubtful we'll return. read more

This place is very yummy and the service is great. I usually come here with my daughter and we always leave with happy bellies. I recommend the garlic edamame and the crab cakes. Everything else is just as yummy but these are two of my faves! Give them a try if you're in the area. read more

This Sushi place was horrible!!!!! I had accidentally ordered the wrong noodles, I called the place asking if they could make me something else, the lady working was being highly rude and when I was still speaking she hung up on me. Horrible customer service, she blamed it on a disconnecting call which was false. I would recommend trying another place, never going back again! read more

Food is always fresh and well prepared. Service is excellent both by delivery or eating in the charming dining room. All the sushi is tasty and fresh. Same thing for other dishes. I highly recommend Mr Sushi. read more

Always quick, always fresh wish they updated their menu. I have only had this for take out although I live in town I have never actually ate there. I will say it is very small and does smell fishy to me. With that being said I have never had bas sushi from them so not sure why it's always smelly in there to me, maybe it miso lol but solid yummy sushi read more

Small dining area with seating for maybe 20 people tops. I popped in after a hike and got the salmon lovers combo which was really good. The waitress was very friendly and service was fast. It was just me and two other people eating. Lots of pick up orders. Prices are very reasonable with the special rolls being in the $13 range, with most other places charging upwards of $20. My salmon lover combo was $17 and included 2 pieces of sashimi, 2 sashimi and a salmon cucumber roll. Overall I was very happy with my experience and the salmon was tasty. I would recommend and stop by again when I'm in the area. read more

Mr Sushi - Salmon Lovers Combo - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Duh-mazing!! This place is so good, I had to create new word. Their food is incredible in both quality and taste. Too many places rely on salt and additives to make up the flavors. This place uses real ingredients to make the food authentic. Notice that I said, make the food authentic, not make it seem authentic. Their delivery time is great. Unfortunately, I haven't eaten there for a while, so I can't comment on their ambiance. The only things I had an issue with were: 1. The bubbles in their bubble tea were much harder than they should have been, 2. There were no flavor options for the bubble tea (what if someone is allergic to the one they default to?), and 3. The website (when you bring it up on your phone) doesn't show the monthly specials. Aside from these few things, I can't foresee a reason to not come back. Hopefully we will be ordering from them more often when we want great sushi. read more

I had a wonderful experience dining in today at Mr. Sushi in pompton lakes. I ordered the chilI chili gyoza and the salmon lovers deluxe. The flavor the gyoza was very nice and the salmon was so fresh and tasty. Miranda was a great server and was very attentive and friendly. I will definitely be coming back! read more

The food was s very authentic and delicious. I got the Chicken Katsu Bento Box Special which was amazing. They were able to switch out the California Roll for the Chicken tempora roll. There was a price difference but it was not to bad. Service is a little bit slow. If you are in a rush be prepared to wait for a little bit. The ambiance is nice. A small interment location. If you are in the area definitely a good place to visit. Out in the area for work. Would go back when in the area. read more

Mr Sushi - Miso Soup - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Mr. Sushi has been my go-to for close to a decade. Unfortunately I learned tonight that Mr. Sushi is no longer amazing. I'll say this: I've never had a shrimp tempura roll that had been sitting around so long that the tempura got soggy and gross inside the roll, until tonight. Spring rolls were soggy and cold, too. Plus, a two person delivery team, Mr. Sushi? Is that why you have to charge $5? read more

Just went here for lunch... the place is super small but it was really cozy and the waitress was awesome, so friendly and attentive. I have to say this is some of the best Japanese food I've ever had. We didn't really get sushi, my friend got the salmon poke appetizer and enjoyed it, I got teriyaki wings, sauce on side, they were amazing! Then I got a no rice roll, the Mountain Fuji roll, quite possibly one of the best rolls I've ever eaten, it was so delicious. My friend got the tuna sandwich but subbed salmon, omg another amazing delight, so good. There's only one problem, I love a half an hour away!!! Trying to figure out how/ when I can go back. Try it, my friend and I thoroughly enjoyed our time here! read more

Mr Sushi - Mountain Fuji Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

We loved it the first time we went, but the last two times the fish wasn't as fresh. The appetizers are great, but you can't serve sushi unless your fish is really fresh. read more

This place always takes forever. Dining room is dirty with trash all over the floor. Staff is unprofessional and way too casual with how they speak to customers. read more

It's very good! Nice sized rolls for a big guy like myself. The Superman, tropical mango and fried chef's special are awesome.

Love this sushi place...delivery is fast and in house sit down is also amazing. The spicy tuna sandwich is a must and the ginger green tea that is made in-house is delicious read more

Mr Sushi - a teapot and a cup of tea on a table - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

This location was a great post hike experience. Even though it took quite some time for us to get the food, it appeared that everyone was working hard and that they often get a lot of orders. Food: Good sushi, and very unique rolls. I think the price point was fair, and it was definitely delicious. Service: I absolutely love the fact that they provide a small flower with your order, it's such a nice touch to their service. Even though they were running a little bit behind, they kept me in the loop about how much longer things were going to be. Very polite. Aesthetic: An interesting space that combines pictures of their company's growth on one wall and a beautiful shot of a Japanese alleyway on the other. Definitely a small sushi shop vibe. read more

All delicious sushi. Nice workers. Select some of their chefs choices and you will get Great value

They have a really great lunch special and the people were very kind and attentive. The sweet potato roll is delicious

This place was worth the long search! After moving to a new area, you usually spend some time searching for some new staple places: a place to get pizza, or Chinese, or Tex Mex, etc. I hadn't gotten around to finding a new sushi place before the time for quarantine came around. But suddenly, when you can't go out to places, you start craving what you can't have! After looking for reviews on Yelp, I decided to order take out from Mr. Sushi, and I was not disappointed. As a Saturday night order, I ordered online and it gave me only a 30 minute wait for pick up! The place itself is very small, but sometimes that's where the best food comes from. The people were very nice and those who were packing the food had gloves on and bagged everything in plastic. I ordered 2 special rolls and 3 regular rolls. The Volcano roll was my favorite! They even added sweet gesture of sending fruit along with a message of a "boost for your immune system". I will definitely be ordering again from Mr. Sushi. It looks like I've found my new sushi spot. read more

Mr Sushi - Packaging (outside of plastic bag) with cup of fruit included - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Very delicious and authentic Japanese cuisine. Loved it. I love sushi and visited many different places, but comparing to other Japanese restaurants Mr. Sushi has variety dishes to choose from and of course each dish loos beautiful as it tastes. I am so envy that township of #pomptonlake has such a great restaurant like #mrsushi in town. read more

See all

Ordered from here yesterday at 7:47pm. Confirmed less than a minute later for an 8:02 pickup time. I got there at 8:10 and they told me 10-15 more minutes. It actually took 23 more minutes. I waited 45 minutes with a 2 year old. Awful. And they weren't even a little apologetic. Borderline rude. The food is good but not worth the hassle. Pickup always takes forever, portions are smaller than they used to be and the staff is not great. I'm done here. read more

Ordered delivery via the website for dinner last night. Get a phone call that the driver can't find my address which is impossible since it's in reflective on the fence and house both visible from the roadway. So I go outside to see where she could be to help direct her and no where to be found. Finally she comes out from behind the house instead of just having gone to the front door like any normal delivery person...SMH I ordered the teriyaki wings, peppered tuna, beef negimaki, and Superman roll. Everything was delicious except the beef negimaki which felt old, stale, and dried out and had no sauce of any kind. This was my first time ordering from them so let's see how the next 2 orders go before I pass complete judgment! read more

Love this spot. I've never eaten inside as it's quite small, but I do take out pretty often. The sushi is always fresh and delicious, and pricing is reasonable. When I get delivery from here it's always delivered super quick. read more

My go-to pick up spot for sushi when I'm in the area. Order the spicy tuna rolls and add mango - you won't regret it!

Yes. Go here! (Wine is byob) My friend and her family took me out. Felt so welcome in their booth seating and their easy menu. (Drank some wine) (The vibe is chill not too stuffy) Order "The Tower". Trust me. The edemnomi was perfect too. I loved The Colorful roll! (More wine) Prices are reasonable and parking is easy on the street. (done with wine, and my friend is driving me home ) read more

Good sushi but not worth the frustration. I've ordered 3 times and 3 times it took over an hour to get here, this last time it took over an hour and a half! Each time I would call to ask about my food's whereabouts only to be told "it's already left with the driver" only to show up in the exact amount of time it would take to drive here (if you don't catch my drift, that food was definitely still at the store). This time I had to call back 20 minutes after my first call with still no food. Not a sole there seems to know what's going on and the girl said she would call the driver and call me back. She did not. I will DEFINITELY NOT BE ORDERING AGAIN. You have run out of chances, Mr. sushi. Do yourselves a favor and find a different sushi place that isn't run by incompetents. read more

Very clean, very nice people, byob, good prices, very fresh fish. Creative menu!! My only complaint was the spicy tuna wasn't spicy. In their defense maybe it was just a bad batch. They have a really awesome online ordering system, point and click and then eat! The delivered to Kinnelon and sushi was LEGIT. I wish there were better pictures of the rolls on their website but I was able to get some info from YELP to order. I will most definitely order there again (maybe tonight) read more

Mr Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Got sick sadly the last order. Threw out 70$ worth of food. It's going to take me a while to be able to go back. This is the second time.

Friendly service! Tropical Mango sushi was BANGIN!!! The mango with the spicy tuna was such a great combo! Philly roll was also good.. My sister always orders from here and she always is more than satisfied! read more

Mr Sushi - Tropical mango - Sushi Bars Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Sushi is just ok. I've ordered orange chicken a few times and it's been undercooked. Staff is very nice but I would not recommend

This place is always great! Over the last few years I've gone in for a few rolls with friends and family and I always want to go back. Most recently my Mom and I had the bento box lunch special and I was impressed with the amount of food we got and with how good it all was! I love having this place in town! read more

I've been going to Mr Sushi since they opened. In support of our local businesses I ordered from them last week. They indicated my food would be delivered in 45 mins. I called a hour later as it was no here. They said it was on the way. Still nothing. I called again and was told the same. After 90 mins my food was delivered - our sushi was smashed and our bento box was cold. I called and spoke with the Manager who indicated he could send another order but it would be 45 mins. I told him not to worry about it. He then said he would refund my order which I agreed to. I checked my account a week later and never got a refund. Another manager called who was openly hostile saying I had to give the food back if I wanted a refund. Something no one ever told me. I'm done giving them my money. read more

I am working in Paterson, but staying in Wayne, and I haven't found a good sushi place yet, until I ran into this place.. I ordered from their lunch menu, and what a deal it was !!! I also ordered 2 rolls from the regular menu, and they were amazing !!! My order was ready in 20 min. Definitely give them a try !!! I will order from them again soon. read more

See all

This is one of my favorite places to order from.There quick clean my order is always packed correctly, and they follow all the Covid guidelines. I normally go there on Fridays when I get out of work and pick up my food and it normally only takes about 20 minutes to a half an hour which I find to be really reasonable for how Busy they are, their staff is so friendly and helpful, and they always take time to explain menu items when I have a question. I like to order special rules and they're never made incorrectly, also I love the bulgogi it's one of my favorites. Not to mention how insane their basic staples like green salad and miso soup and spicy kani salad and things like that are just always amazing. read more

I ordered pick-up and was told 15 min, when i went 15 min later i paid, and waited while they packed up food orders for people who were not even there, as mine sat out on the counter for an extra 15 minutes while i also just stood there waiting. Once i finally got home the Food was almost inedible. The crab cakes were still frozen ( they also are supposed to come with 2, which i clarified on the phone to the girl, and only one was given), and the sushi had zero taste, and the spicy tuna rolls were mushy and warm. They have young people answering phones, packing orders, waitressing, and sadly they seem to not know what they are doing. Mr. sushi used to be my favorite place and honestly this is the 3-4th bad experience i have had and i will not be returning again. read more