Delicious pizza Sourdough Tried several kinds and each one was amazing Always ready when you pick up. Staff is friendly. Give it a try !!!! read more

Best pizza that I've had in Westerly! We ordered two cheese pizzas online for pick up and they were ready within 20 minutes. read more

Mr. Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

My absolute favorite next to Caserta in Providence. The dough and tomato are perfect. Perfectly cooked and flavorful. Stumbled upon this place last summer and was never the same. Best in RI for sure. read more

Decent, albeit pricey pizza. Tasted fresh and a good sauce and cheese blend. Cooked well. No option to dine in, and people were friendly in my brief exposure to them. If I lived closer to westerly, I'd probably go back, but it's definitely not worth a 2nd visit from me. read more

See all

we got takeout pizza and got five pizzas. The order was rather quick and the pizza was really good. They have some interesting pizzas that are worth trying and will definitely be back for more when we're in town! read more

A real artisan pizza dough will give you a billowy soft crust, blistered bubbles and a crispy bottom. It uses a high hydration and long fermentation time for maximum flavor and the perfect crackly, chewy texture. Mr Pizza claims to offer artisan pizza but something has gone wrong somewhere in their process. We have ordered 3 times now and It doesn't matter how well done you ask them to cook your pizza, the crust is still floppy and soggy. If you pick up a slice of pizza from the outer crust and the slice immediately bends and faces the floor, something went wrong. The crust is completely saturated with moisture all the way from the center of the pizza to about an inch from the outer edge. The flavor is good but not good enough to overlook the faults in the crust. read more

Best pizza in Westerly, bar none. The dough so much better than anywhere else around here. The sauce is great, and the amount of char is just perfect. read more

Great pizza, friendly service, and fair prices! I ordered online and my order was ready every quickly. We also got the wings and chicken nuggets for the kids. Fries were great. A wonderful bonus was the chocolate chip cookie - It was fantastic! The tshirts they sell are pretty awesome but they didn't have our size in stock - but next time I shall grab one! Give Mr. Pizza a try! read more

Excellent pizza. The crust is made in house and excellent. This will be our new go-to take out pizzeria!

We're only in town for one night. Great pizza, no complaints from our fam. Took the standard 15-20 minutes for it to be ready. Negatives: Only one size pizza (14") & no dining in. Took the kids down the street to frozen lemonade place while we waited. read more

Mr. Pizza - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

I loved it! Definitely the best around. Reminds me of newhaven pizza Highly recommend. Holding longevity and abundance over this business read more

Yep, Westerly had a pizza problem. In fact, there was a 30 mile radius centered in Westerly where mediocre pizza was the only game for miles. For about a minute there was a coal-fired place that was slightly better than all other options, but that's now long gone. Welcome Mr Pizza!! Mr Pizza is a game changer for Westerly pizza. The guy running the place isn't playing any games. He knows the business and he is committed to making every other place wish they could make pizza like Mr Pizza. When it's time to blow up the diet, or you just really want some pizza, don't waste your money, calories, or satisfaction on pizza from somewhere else, Mr Pizza is where tots at. We get meatball and sausage and it's not dripping grease like those other pizzas. The deep dish is a real treat when available, and they seek that by the slice too. They have chicken wings and other stuff but it's called Mr Pizza for a reason!! Always just a phone call and 20 minutes to happy belly. It's take out only at this point and probably forever, the guys are always friendly and Westerly finally has real pizza. read more

Dough, crust are amazing in all the right ways. I can't seem to get a flavor of their sauce. It doesn't stand out at all to me.

Wow, wow, wow! This pizza was incredible. We prefer thin crust pizza and this crust was spot on. The sauce was fruity and delicious add that with great customer service and this will be our new go-to pizza place. read more

Mr. Pizza - Cheese and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

It is really easy and convenient of course I wish they did delivery but the pizza isn't too greasy and they have good salads. The service is fast and it is a good take out place. read more

All about the crust - I feel like a hungover Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle woofing down this 'za. Really good, crispy, cheesy, and the crust is charred a bit in a good way. Only thing I'll say is this is no skinny girl pizza - it's pretty greasy and layered on with cheese. It's not first date food but if you have someone you can split a pie with and watch Seinfeld reruns in sweats on the couch this pizza is the move and I think your relationship is going to last. read more

Mr. Pizza - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

See all

I've driven farther than I'd like to admit for good pizza but I don't need to anymore now that Westerly has a legit pizza shop. The crust is fantastic! You can taste the work that goes into it and it's the perfect base for all their creations. The Vincitori is prime pizza - that is what pizza should taste like. It's no coincidence these guys sell out constantly and the exclusivity of it kind of adds to the draw. So glad to see this small business killing it. Love this place. read more

Mr. Pizza stands out in Westery, which is a great pizza town. They use high quality ingredients and are on par with if not better than Nana's, which is pretty consistently excellent. The people who work at Mr. Pizza are exceptionally friendly and professional, and the restaurant is for pick up/take out, but is always immaculately clean and the people who work there are attentive. read more

absolutely the best pizza around. the pepperonis pucker up. I've lived in town for 25 years and I am so happy this placed popped up. call early because they sell out often!! read more

Great pizza! I really dig their crust and the toppings/combos are spot on. The Vincitori is sooo yummy and I highly recommend trying the Brie and Apple pizza. Also the fries are very good. I tried the poutine but wasn't feeling their gravy. I've ordered at least five separate times since opening week. And, Mr Pizza, please get your shit together. Most restaurants get better the longer they are open but you guys are slipping. Arugula that should have been thrown out served with the prosciutto pizza. Balsamic vinaigrette that was so emulsified that it looked like mayo and could not dress the salad. Could also use more dressing for the salads. Hot fries put into sealed plastic containers and sitting on a counter for 20 minutes while the rest of the order is being put together really hurts the quality of those beautiful fries! Return to the paper based containers! Mr Pizza, I know we are now dating but please keep up the effort like when we first met. read more

I think the Proclaimers wrote that 5,000 mile song about this place. Absolutely outstanding pizza. The sauce is simple, bright and fresh. High quality ingredients. The star of the show is the dough. The crust is crispy but has an unbelievable chew to it and this was after being in the car for 45 min. This some is the best pizza I've had in Rhode Island, Connecticut and Massachusetts. The guys in the shop are good dudes and I will be back. I urge you to give them a try and support your local pizza shop read more

These Guys kill it... Great Pie..Sourdough crust is great (if a bit chewy) but order it well done and save a trip to new haven...Grandma pie At Vittorias and mr. Pizza are the best pies in westerly read more

I've had deep dish at the great Chicago spots, pizza's from all over Southern California, New York style from all over the city - this is the best pizza I've ever had. Why they have one operation out of Rhode Island only open 5 hours a day without delivery is beyond me. read more

Absolutely delicious! Heard really good things about it had to try! Service was absolutely on point! It's friendly faces behind the counter and the atmosphere was also considerably friendly. Will DEF be back ! read more

We have a ton of pizza options between Stonington and Westerly and Mr. Pizza may be the best. Homemade sourdough crust thats not too charred but not doughy, great toppings, and a good size for the prices. The pizza even reheats well! read more

Mr. Pizza is not only the best pizza in the Westerly-Stonington area, it may be the best pizza I have ever had. New Haven be warned. Yes, you have Frank Pepe, but you don't have the sourdough crust these folks have. Everything is so fresh; the toppings are bountiful. Red Sox fans beware - lots of Yankee loyalists working there, but give them a break - they make up for it with pies they create. read more

Excellent pizza place! There is a pride of ownership here. First class crust and very good red sauce. Ratings 1-5: Margarita: 5 Pepperoni: 5 Vincitori: 5 Buffalo wings: 4 Buffalo chicken pizza: this is a miss, gorganzola too strong. Just stick with a side of the wings themselves, which are solid. Garlic bread: this is just baked pizza dough (which is delish- just don't order if you're expecting to get get a more traditional loaf of bread) My new favorite in Westerly. read more

Sad to see a small new business that opened during a pandemic receive a 3 star review, as it's only review. I personally loved the pizza, and being vegan, especially enjoy the margarita pizza with no cheese and loads of toppings. My husband loves the white ricotta and spinach pie. The crust is the best around! read more

My favorite pizza place in town the pizza is literally so good and consistently good each time 10 out of 10!

This review is long overdue. Been taking out pizza from here since they opened. I've lived in Westerly for 50 years and this is the best ever! Everything is so fresh and tasty. The sourdough crust is delicious, and even though they use a conventional pizza oven, they manage to get a char that rivals wood or coal fired ovens. We recently tried the white potato pie--unique and terrific! My only wish is that they do a fresh clam pie to rival the legendary Pepe in New Haven (Pizza Place in Westerly also makes an excellent clam pie.) I hope that Mr. Pizza lasts here for many years to come. read more

Excellent pizza. Love the crust and the sauce. Pizza lover here and very fussy. Winners, won't be disappointed

This place is amazing. My husband and I are huge pizza eaters and this is one of the best we've had on the east coast. If you're in town, this is a must try! read more

The pizza was great. Got a mozzarella and was impressed. Dough was very good, all the ingredients seemed fresh and everything was reasonable for just $12.00. Might just be the new spot for pizza, it reminded me a lot of Pizza and suds or pizza place whichever you call it. Similar style with crust and taste but that's a good thing! Keep up the good work! read more

Mr. Pizza - Mozzarella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

This place is worth the time to review. Pizza is fantistic. It took a long time for Westerly to get a good pie and finally it's here. Don't change a thing Mr. Pizza your Hot Potato is brilliant and so are your other pizzas. I'll be back and my friends will too. Thank you for your service ! read more

This was one of the worst pizzas I've had...ever. I ordered a white pie that had a mostly burnt and bitter tasting crust but yet was soggy greasy in the center at the same time. The basil was overpowering and the garlic oil was pretty disgusting. Don't waste your money or the gas for the trip to get one. read more

Best pizza in town. Order early on weekends. Weekday orders take 15 min but weekend orders can take over 90 min. Best crust ever!! So happy to finally have a great pizza place in Westerly! read more

Delicious! Try the soupy pizza! Also the wings and French fries are great as well as the service! This place is amazing and you should definitely give it a try! read more

Finally a good pizza place in Westerly! So delicious. Ordered the potato pizza and a cheese pizza. Both were excellent.

What a freakin amazing pizza and salad!!! Omg!!!! These guys are seriously on point! Recommend to anyone for the best pizza, on time and absolutely delicious!!!!!!! read more

Not too good floppy crust and very oily. Staff is very arrogant price us ok at best. Won't return.