Came here on a limb because we got a Mountain Mike's coupon for 15% off and didn't have high expectations for it because I have my favorite pizza spots, but needed to eat dinner. Decided to eat in on a Tuesday night; it was completely empty besides the 4 or 5 workers. What really surprised me about this location was that they have a few seats to the left when you walk in but as you go down a narrow hallway, you'll pass some coin game machines and further ahead are several long tables and an upstairs with plenty of seating to accommodate large parties. This place hosts a lot of local school/sport and adult team dinners and events. Seating is not an issue here - small or team size, they've got you covered. If you have small kids or enjoy claw or arcade machines, they have a variety to choose from at the back of the restaurant to play while you wait for your pizza near the salad buffet section. The pizza came out within 15-20 minutes. Each slice had a good topping proportion and tasted pretty yummy! I'm not usually a big crust person; however, the crust on this pizza had the right amount of softness and firmness and it wasn't too thick which was perfect for me. I ended up eating every bite and made sure no crust was left behind :). If you're in the area or are needing a spot to host a team event, consider checking out Mountain Mike's pizza in CV! read more

See all

It's been a long time since I last ordered from here, so I decided to give them another chance. I ordered two pizzas for takeout. Both not met my expectations and the meat was way too salty and the crust was very dry. read more

Had another delicious pizza today. Been going there for years Great staff, delicious pizza, salad bar too. Recent remodeling is nice. read more

Occasionally their pie dough are under cooked. I request extra time, or well done crust.

Mountain Mike's is one of our new favorite spots! Not only is the pizza always fresh, hot, and delicious, but the whole place is super kid-friendly. My kids absolutely LOVE the little $1-25¢ toy machines -- it keeps them entertained while we wait for our food and gives them something fun to look forward to every time we visit. The staff is always welcoming, the dining area is clean, and the atmosphere feels relaxed and family-oriented. It's the perfect place to grab a meal with kids without any stress. If you're looking for good pizza and a place where your little ones can have a great time, Mountain Mike's is definitely worth it! read more

i love pizza so me and my sister went to mountain after shopping at the max near this pizza shop i order wings and my sister ordered cheesy garlic bread 10-15 minute wait time wasn't to bad food was super good would come back also the service was really good the person who took my order was very nice read more

go to pizza spot. I always order for pickup never had an issue. only negative about this place is they are stingy with the ranch. depending on who your dealing with they won't even give you 1 free ranch. but usually they coo read more

Ordered a large pizza at 630pm and it said it would take 30-40mins here I am and it's 8pm and had to call and the driver is still 15 mins away read more

I Placed the order online, and after 2 hours the order didn't receive. Called the store and the person is rude and not even apologizing, he suggested to call the store instead of ordering online and he hung up the phone. Never order in this place ever again. read more

Great pizza Dine in or take out In house delivery available. Good food Deserts Refreshment s Excellant staff real Pleasing They have plenty of nice seating for dining birthdays holidays sporting events.... Big screen Enjoy I did! read more

See all

The service here is ok . The pizza is not bad just sometimes it can be a very long wait

Picked up pizza here and for some reason the code didn't work. Naya was able to improvise and take care of my order. We need more people like her who gives great customer service. She went above and beyond and for that i am thankful. Definitely will be coming back and recommending this location to friends and family. Keep up the great work! read more

A Pizza Party Legend in Our House! Mountain Mike's is basically part of our family at this point--right up there with Grandma's potato salad and our dog who steals crusts off plates. Whether we're dining in, ordering delivery, or hosting a last-minute bowling party next door (because, yes, that's a thing), Mountain Mike's *always* delivers. Literally and figuratively. Our go-to lineup: wings that slap, cheesy bread that disappears before it hits the table, and pizza so good we've had actual debates over who gets the last slice of combo. Even the salad is fresh and crisp-- not the sad, wilted afterthought you get at some places. The staff? Angels in pizza aprons. Super friendly, fast service, and once, when we got regular soda instead of diet, they offered to come back with the right one like we were royalty. Who does that anymore?! Mike's crew, that's who. They're pros at managing big orders and keeping the chaos of kids' birthdays and playdates running smoothly--even helping the little ones with the games (which, let's be real, is basically a public service). Only "meh" moment? The bathroom could use a glow-up--maybe some new paint and flooring would turn this place into a proper Pizza Palace. Thank you Mike and team for being our go-to for laughs, memories, and carbs. It's Sunday those are the Lords carbs and he wants you to be happy. He's the only one who can judge me. See you next party! Lol read more

great food and service . Long time customer and they always take care of us well, much appreciated!!

I placed an order at 4:05 and didn't get my pizza until 5:40... it was supposed to be here, at the latest 4:50. I called at 5:03 to ask about it and the guy told me it had been dispatched, it still took almost 45 minutes. Once I received my food the driver let me know that he gave my 2 liter soda to someone else but he did pay me back with his own money, I'd rather have my drink but he was apologetic. My food through is barely warm and instead of the 4 blue cheese dressings I asked for, I received ranch. Probably won't order from this location again. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Cheese pizza, garlic bread and ranch dressing - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

0 stars if I could ! DO NOT GO HERE !!! Our pizza took an hour longer than expected to come out we patiently waited for it to come out . When we got home we served the food to our kids and guests after serving and started eating I realized there was a hair in my food and one of the kids bit into a raw piece of chicken!!! We called & explained to the cashier the situation she said if we would of liked a refund or the food she then placed us on hold after placing us on hold someone else picked up and in a very aggressive tone stated " why didn't you say that when you were here " I immediately hung up and drove to the store because this was not acceptable when I got there I said if he expected me to bite into the chicken before driving off or why would he say that comment and he rudely said " yes you should of " I could not believe this guy and he is the store manager . Absolutely unacceptable read more

Want $40.00 for a single pizza fb can't break a $100.00 bill what a joke. I would definitely not recommend this establishment

They were out of cheese, so there was no pizza available. Like how do you run out of CHEESE as a PIZZA restaurant. It wasn't even late, it was like 6 oclock. read more

Mountain Mike in Castro Valley must have changed management because the pizza has become the best I have had in a long time!! We order almost every night and the pizza continues the to be to our standards!! Best Pizza In Town!! Hands down!! read more

See all

Their food was absolutely amazing! The workers were great made the place worth it even professionally handled when some little teenage kids were making a ruckus. The Vibe Is Great ! And did I mention the food yes it was that good read more

There was a minor inconvenience while I was eating here first time and the manager who was on clock handled the seen very well, 3 kids came and was very disrespectful not cooperating and asked for water cups and got soda instead of paying for the soda. Manager called them out and said you can either pay or you can read this sign and do the following. They chose not to pay then started to be disrespectful and yell while I'm eating. Manger told them to leave and they started to record and cause a scene. read more

Walking in, this place is definitely outdated. There is a good amount of space in here for a large party. I placed my order online for a specific pick up time early in the day. I arrived exactly at the time and was not greeted warmly, he checked on my order and said that the person was making it at the moment which should take another 7 minutes or so. There was no one else in the place and it didn't seem like other orders were being made. No apologies that my order would be a longer wait. The pizza itself was nice and cheesy, with a good amount of crunchy small round pepperoni. Some of the pepperonis were stacked on top of each other that there were four of them once! The pizza had a nice slightly crunchy bottom. The pizza itself was quite salty. read more

Food is always tasty and I love their ingredients. The pepperoni crisps to perfection. I have always like the dough at mountain mikes and feel like I get a quality, consistent pizza every time. Prices are a little steep but that's what pizza costs nowadays! Sometimes the wait times can be a little long but it's worth the wait. They also have a yummy cinnamon dessert pizza. Add one to your next order and thank me later! read more

Ordered a chicken pineapple luau pizza, which was delivered from Grubhub in a timely manner and the pizza was fresh and delicious. Yummy!! Give them a try you'll be glad you did . Bon appétit read more

Great location, friendly staff. I like this Mountain Mikes they're super chill and my pizza is always delicious. Thank you guys!

Horrible place stingy with meats and sausages. We pay a lot of money for nothing, they don't care about the customers they just want your money read more

Place is pretty well maintained and clean. The pizza isn't bad for mountain miles better than expected. If you are looking for pizza place in Castro Valley I say give them a try there pizza actually is pretty decent. read more

Robert was exceptional,helpful other staff was pleasant food was great but Robert went above to help with party everyone had a good time and would come back read more

Love this place. Their pizza dough is so good. Ingredients are fresh and most of all staff are great. The best is delivery. Always on time!!! You go guys!!! read more

Castro Valley Mountain Mikes has really good consistent pizza and service. Right in the middle of a remodel, but the food is still excellent and can't wait to see the new look! read more

I was very hungry for some pizza today so I gave them a try. Then I've became disappointed that it didn't get delivered on time. What got me even more disappointed is 10 minutes after the expected delivery time I got a phone call from them that it was put in the oven 5 minutes after I received the phone call. So, I requested a refund and provided feedback that a customer should be contacted at least between 15 to 30 minutes after the order if was made if they are running late. I'm sure they wouldn't want one of their employees calling 10 minutes after their scheduled shift to explain that they are going to be late for work. What happened to common courtesy in this world? read more

The pizza arrived a full 45 minutes late. After it was 15 minutes late I called and was told it's out for delivery just give it "another" ten, fifteen minutes, "or so". The combo pizza finally arrived but it did not taste good to us and it was quite bready. The kid who answered the phone and the delivery guy were both friendly but that's not enough for us after spending $43 on one pizza including tip, sorry to say. read more

We had the most wonderful time in our monthly Wreath workshop! The service and setting the food are absolutely amazing. Just love our local Mountain Mike's! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Monthly wreath workshop - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

Ordered delivery last night. It came on time and was warm. Got the boneless chicken bites with the Asian Zing sauce, they were good. Pizza had a good amount of pepperoni (our only topping), but hardly any sauce at all. Unfortunately it made the pizza really dry. Guess I'd try extra sauce if I ordered again... read more

I ordered garlic cheese bread and medium pizza. If I haven't said it a hundred times, I'll say it a hundred and one times....CHECK YOUR ORDERs when picking up! My total was 27 bucks, which I thought was a little high for 2 basic items. They charged me for 2 orders of garlic bread and had them in the order. I told the cashier I only ordered one and: No response , just a stare, no apology or offer to remove the error. OK I'll take it, the family will eat them. I get to car and peek in the box to find over cooked, HARD garlic cheese bread! I called from car and they said they would make a new order. I asked how long because my family was hungry and it was getting late. They said "5 minutes". They brought it out and took the ruined order back. Just not a great experience and the pizza was cold by the time I got it home. Maybe this is not the friendliest, or best quality food location but I like Mountain Mike's overall..... read more

See all

I order delivery from this particular Mountain Mike's pizza often. However, for the past eight months their service has been horrible. Two times they forgot my 2 Liter but I still continued to order from them because people make mistakes. More recently, I ordered pizza breadsticks, and a 2 liter for delivery. They told me it would be there in an hour and 30 minutes . A hour and 45 min past so I called and they said he was on the way. Another 40 min past so I called again and the delivery guy is back at Mountain Mike's Pizza and said that he couldn't find me. I've been ordering there for over a year with the same address. He has my number and didn't call me to tell me he was outside and couldn't find my address? I called and complained they took about three dollars off of my order. Thanks! I got my pizza 2 1/2 later cold. I called today to order pizza with a coupon. He's telling me to give him a coupon code. Yet the whole sheet of coupons have no codes on them. He tells me he can't help me and he hast to go. I asked him his name. He told me his name is Mike how convenient is that? I called back to and asked to speak with him and they told me they had nobody there working by that name. They just lost a loyal customer. read more

We've been hanging on to a coupon for a free medium pizza and decided to finally cash it in. This place is not half bad! We did think that they forgot our order when we arrived because they couldn't find our pizza, but turns out our name was taken down incorrectly. No biggie. I chose sausage for my one free topping medium pizza, and the sausage was juicy and amazing. Super cheesy too, yum! I chose a supreme style pizza for the second one, and loved that the veggies were baked but not overcooked. I DON'T like when there is veggies on a pizza and they are raw while the rest of the pizza is cooked. This pizza was great, and had soft bits of chicken that were not overcooked. I had a good experience and would return! read more

See all

I have been going to this Mountain Mike's Pizza for years every time I go no matter who Waits on me they treat me excellent their customer service skills are five stars their pizzas five stars highly recommended if you love pizza check them out their customer service is excellent read more

This review needed to be written a while ago when I saw some of the staff in the area where the food is prepped, eating right over the vegetable storage. No one washed their hands and seemed to go right back into meal preparation. Today I called to place an order, as I have done the last 3 years and the man who answered claimed he couldn't hear me. I only raised my voice a bit because I repeated myself 5 times and he still coild not understand me and then he slammed the phone in my face. I called back and asked for a manager and each time I asked he replied with "who dis?" Or "who is this?". I finally said please put a manager on the phone and he hung up again. I called back after a few minutes and another rude individual answered the phone and seemed to be more than uninterested when I told him what just happened and asked for the manager. I stopped ordering from Bronco Billy's for this same reason where the staff act as though they have better things to do than the job THEY applied for. All good, plenty of other pizza joints with better quality pizza and sanitary practices. read more

Unfortunately l am a little late for the meeting today and the next one will take a little bit of a bit longer than Unfortunately l am a little late for the meeting today and the next one will take a little bit of a bit longer than read more