Montarra is an elegant upscale restaurant so we're not getting here super often. They've got an outstanding wine, whiskey and cocktail list too. We started with their Petite Filet Mignon Crisps, an excellent appetizer. Dinner was Duet of Beef Tenderloin Tips & Bacon Wrapped Jumbo Scallops and the Caramelized Jumbo Maine Sea Scallops. All of the food was cooked perfectly, well-presented and tasted great. The table service here was above average. Reservations recommended and you'll need about $250 for two. read more

See all

Amazing wait staff and food. Not inexpensive but WELL worth the cost. One of the best "burb" restaurants around. Don't let the strip mall location stop you from trying this top notch restaurant that can stand up against some of the best downtown places . read more

Always fabulous! Excellent service, wonderful ambiance, and the food is always amazing and cooked to perfection! It's our favorite Chicagoland restaurant! Alex is always an amazing waiter! read more

Excellent food, excellent service and real nice atmosphere. You wouldn't think you would get this from a restaurant in a strip mall but you absolutely do. The food is top notch. I had the braised short rib and my wife had the pasta. Both were so good. I'll be back!! read more

Montarra - Braised short rib - New American Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

The Chef is amazing. I never had anything that was t amazing. Highly recommend if you have the opportunity to try this gem.

Food and service were outstanding. Alex was our server and he was great! We also alway appreciate Martha. She is such a hard worker and is very attentive! read more

Incredible service and food. Intimate ambience. We went for Valentine's Day and they had a live violinist that made it feel special. The foie gras, goat cheese croquettes amazing and the bouillabaisse was good, but a bit too much of a tomato soup like base. I'm eager to go back and try so much more. read more

My wife and I ate at Montarras in early November. The service was good. My wife's vegan dinner also was good-maybe not as good as our previous visit. My ribeye was fatty and for some reason had a brown gravy on it. Not the quality that I expect or have had at other area restaurants. It was listed at $68 on the menu but we were charged $71. That may be because I substituted asparagus for the included broccoli. I couldn't tell from the bill. We'll probably not go back for a while. read more

A lot of positives with a few not great things. When you're paying what you pay to eat a nice meal at this type of restaurant, there's a few minor things you expect and that's where they missed for us. On the plus side: Great drinks, great ambiance, food was delicious and the servers were very friendly! Deltas: We had a super small table that was pushed against a large curtain which draped onto us and our table. We were celebrating both our birthdays and although we watched them deliver a slice of birthday cake to other tables, they only offered us a dessert menu... Lastly, the wait from our soup to when we received our entree was nearly 30 minutes and then I flagged for our bill and our waitress saw and didn't come over for another 10-15 minutes and brought the dessert menu and not our bill. I'm not sure if they saw two younger diners and figured they could focus their efforts on the larger parties or what it was. We've dined there before and had better experiences but they really fell short last night. Again, good food but when you're paying a certain amount for a quality meal you're going to want to go somewhere with consistent service and that's probably not Monterra. read more

Montarra - Red Wine Braised Short Rib Plate - New American Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

See all

Love Montarra. 16oz Prime Ribeye, Ahi Tuna Tostada, 8oz Filet top notch. You know you're someplace special when my 21-year-old daughter raved the Onion Soup. Terrific vibe. Say hi to Kari & Martha. They rock! read more

Fabulous hidden gem on Randall Rd. It's been several years since we have eaten here. We still love this for the food, atmosphere, and service. Today we returned for our anniversary. Jennifer (Jen K.) is the best server. She knows when to ask questions and when to walk away. She is happy, shows pride in this restaurant. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal and she was thrilled. Covid-19: All indoor seating is every other table; outdoor seating is very well spaced for social distancing. We had reservations for 5:30 pm. We arrived and were promptly seated. They made personalized menus just for us. What a special touch. We felt very special by the attention to details. We shared a Wedge Salad which they plated for each of us. Hubby ordered the 10oz Filet Mignon with burgundy mushrooms, Boursin mashed potatoes. He loved every bite. I ordered the 9oz Wagyu Beef with roasted rainbow carrots. Every bite was a treat. Ended with a flourless chocolate cake. Best I've ever had. It was almost like fudge. We thoroughly enjoyed our anniversary dinner and hope to come back. read more

See all

My husband & I had been to Montarra once or twice before we decided to get married and it was always delicious. We had our wedding at the courthouse then we (my husband and myself, our son and daughter plus my parents who traveled to Illinois from southern Louisiana) went to Montarra for our wedding lunch. We walked in, ready to eat but when we arrived, there was a long banquet table in the center of the restaurant (which was on a riser & quite lovely). The banquet table was decorated lavishly, all menus had my & my husband's name across the first page of the menu... Montarra went above & beyond to make my family's day absolutely amazing. My dad announced we could order anything that looked remotely delicious & it was ALL delicious. We had so much amazing food, the staff was incredible & my dad bought dessert for the entire restaurant. Best. Day. Ever! Kudos to Montarra for being so professional, creative & kind to our little wedding party. I have nothing but wonderful things to say about Montarra. Thank you! read more

Great food and better service One of the tapas places in the area. Everything was so fresh and tasty! read more

It has been a long number of years since I ate here. This place is close and we loved it but they stopped their Mother's Day brunch and we really loved those events! We came for our 23 anniversary and loved it. We had already enjoyed a nice Merlot earlier in the day so my wife got a martini while I got the Belvenie 14 year Caribbean Scotch; we loved our drinks. I had ordered a double Scotch on the rocks, thinking the pour would be smallish, but their pour was quite nice and my glass was to the rim with delicious Scotch. We started off with a wedge and it was great; they even split it for us. My wife got the Wagyu Hangar Steak while I got a 10 oz filet done Montarra style. The steak was done perfectly and we loved our meals. We ended the night with a dessert that we split and it was also great. Our server, Jennifer, was always around, always timely, but never obtrusive. It had been some many years since our last visit; it will be far less before our next. read more

See all

I could sit here and write endlessly about how incredible this place is but I will (try to) keep it short and sweet. The food is absolutely phenomenal, with specials being changed to follow seasonal approaches; From their small plates, to salads, to entrees and dessert. I don't think I've ever tasted one thing that I couldn't agree with if I tried. Their cocktail menu is exceptional along with their choices of wines to fit that certain dining budget, all the way to the impressive Birthday or Anniversary splurges. The staff there is *beyond* friendly and extremely knowledgeable with everything they offer. I'd also like to add that if you want to personalize said Anniversary or Birthday Dinner, feel free to call in advance for that specific shout-out on the menu. It's a nice touch and they're always sure to personalize the dessert you order or congratulate you on the milestone you're there to celebrate for. This place is great for any occasion and I would (and do) recommend it to literally everyone. Be sure to look at the ceiling with their hand blown glass chandeliers hanging from above and obviously that waterfall to add to the overall experience as well. 10 out of 10 every time and special shoutout to Ben, Amy and Andrea. You guys are backbone to that place and make sure everyone else follows suit. *Chefs kiss* read more

The chef, Josh really knows his way around a block of tofu. Last night I was in the area with my husband and we had heard good things about this restaurant but with it being a steakhouse and my being a vegan, I have never bothered to check it out. I'm glad I did because my vegan dish was incredibly delicious. There's no description of the dish, it's just chef's choice. I'm always down for that. The chef served a generous portion of a beautifully pan seared tofu, about half a block, that had a nice crust and sort of a sweet-and-sour thing going on over a delicious bed of finally diced crispy cooked vegetable medley that had beans, carrots, asparagus, mushrooms, and two or three other veggies that I couldn't make out because of the fine dice. Taking up about a third of the dish was an expertly steamed side of broccoli that had a delicious savory sauce or broth. Every component of this dish was bursting with flavor. The best part was that finally there was enough food. Unless it's a predominantly veggie restaurant chefs don't realize that vegans need larger portions due to lack of animal protein. A cute side of broccoli or thimble full of rice is nothing for me. Josh really piled the veggies on, and every bite was loaded with flavor. I was so surprised to find that I couldn't finish all of my food, but my only Vegan at home husband had no problem polishing it off and he loved it! He had the halibut and really enjoyed it as well. Michelle our server was extremely attentive and very friendly. The service was excellent! read more

If you're looking to stay local in the suburbs of Algonquin, Montarra offers American dining. Their website boasts elevated small plates. I definitely agree with this description. Great shareable plates with the option of outdoor tent or indoor dining. We opted for the lamb chops-tender and flavorful. Also enjoyed the bacon wrapped dates, wedge salad, bulgogi beef eggrolls. The have a decent cocktail menu. Their Savannah Peach was a great summer refresher. I do think they need to elevate their cocktails by offer single cube ice for their whiskey/Old Fashions/Manhattans. The slushed ice isn't classy. read more

See all

Best restaurant in Algonquin! Perfect place for a special occasion! Have never had a less than a great meal and service! read more

The food was great service excellent but the prices were to high will only go back for a special occasion

As always, everything was fantastic! We stopped in with friends for drinks and appetizers and a great time was had by all! The food, the drinks, the service, the overall vibe of Montarra is simply awesome! read more

Went here for a special dinner with my wife. The place often gets fully booked on weekends, so be sure to make reservations in advance. They have a large tent out front for those wishing to have an outdoor dining experience. We chose to eat inside and requested a secluded table. The location in a strip mall seemed a little out of place for such a high class place. Don't let the location discourage you. Ordered the bacon wrapped dates appetizer and filets done Montarra style. The bacon wrapped dates were phenomenal. Perfectly crisp bacon combined with sweet and tasty dates make this appetizer a must do. We would come back just for this appetizer! The filet came with garlic mashed potatoes, spinach, and diced tomatoes. The filet was wonderfully tender and delicious. The spinach was cooked perfectly and the tomatoes were well seasoned, a little reminiscent of what you'd find on bruschetta. Our server was very attentive and helpful. We also ordered a couple of their specialty cocktails which were fantastic. While this was a fairly expensive meal, it was outstanding and we will be back again. read more

Montarra - 6 oz. Filet "Montarra style" with garlic mashed potatoes - New American Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

Great place , I have come here several times over the past years and it is always very good. Last time we ate in the bar area and the atmosphere is very comfortible , servioce was excellent and the food was great I highly recommend this place. read more

From the time you walk in the door you are treated special, everyone knows what's going on how to treat people who want an extraordinary experience, the food is absolutely amazing great wine list and for birthdays or anniversary's they have a special menu for you, I highly recommend Montana grill read more

This hidden gem is such a cute spot if you're looking to splurge a little! The set up is really cute and there's both an inside and semi-outside option that's covered by a tent. For food, I had the bouillabaisse dish and it was AMAZING. It was perfectly portioned, very flavorful and overall just really good. I also had part of a wedge salad and that was really good as well. I would recommend this place to anyone visiting the area and if someone needs a good "date night" spot. The ambiance is great, the service was good and the interior was very elegant. The restaurant is on the darker side, so keep that in mind. Super cute place! read more

My wife and I went here for a date night. The food was excellent and the atmosphere was good. The service was also good. I got the pork chop which was probably the second best pork chop I've ever had. That being said, we spent over $200 for two entrees, two appetizers, and one drink each, which I consider to be way overpriced. read more

The atmosphere was too dark I could barely read the menu. Our steaks both had too much chewy fat on it. A filet should not have chewy fat on it. It didn't have much flavor either. Same as my husband's. He had the ribeye. Not worth the money. Thankfully I had a gift certificate and didn't spend my own money. My husband makes better steaks at home. read more

Montarra's is a restaurant that is Exceptional!! The Staff and food are outstanding!! (I would suggest making a reservation to make sure you get in!) read more

Everything was very good. I was told if we let them know of an anniversary or birthday they'd go above and beyond, however, we didn't experience anything different so not sure why that's advertised. Food was delicious, drinks were great, atmosphere was typical for that kind of place, and service was for the most part pretty good - until it took 20 minutes for the server to come back to see what we wanted for dessert, so by the time she came back we decided against it since we were just ready to leave. All in all, a pretty good experience but there's always room for improvement... read more

Fancy, tasty and pricey with excellent customer service. Well worth every penny. There were 7 of us and everyone stated how happy they were with their meals. After sharing yummy appetizers, I was getting full so ordered "small plates" for my dinner as well. The French Onion soup is fantastic and served in an onion. The lamb chop appetizer had 4 small chops covered in a yummy sauce with blue cheese spread and pistachios - so good!! read more

Montarra - French Onion Soup served in an onion - New American Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

Happy to return! This is our go-to favorite place to stop when we are part-way home from family business in St. Charles or beyond. Because of the pandemic it had been well over a year and it felt so good to be back. Ben is always welcoming and informative about the latest additions to the menu. He offered an alternative (WhistlePig) to my choice of a Rye swap to the traditional Bourbon in the House Old Fashioned. It was excellent! We both ordered his recommendations for food, Foie Gras for me, Berkshire Pork Belly Bao for my "boyfriend" (aka husband). Both were amazing. Desserts were wonderful as well. We wish we lived closer! read more

See all

Great ambiance, comfy seating. My sweetie and I celebrated my 60th birthday with a lovely meal. We had the steak special that night along with the wedge salad and crab stuffed mushrooms. Everything was excellent! Our server was a wonderful woman who made our first experience at Montarra amazing! Wish I could remember her name but her attention to detail and service was top notch! I would love to go back and sample more of what they offer. Delicious! read more

High cost for no atmosphere! No table cloths, crowed seating. The food is ok, not the greatest.

Context: We went here for a special occasion and the bill for 4 was $250. Pros: the drinks were delicious and made to perfection. The food was good and served in a timely manner, the wait staff was pleasant. Cons: We all ordered the soup of the day and it was only mildly warm. If this was a $40 dollar meal that would be one thing but it was $250 so I expect better. The response was "I'll tell the kitchen". As you should, however I would expect that more would have happened..... for instance the manager could have come by and offered free desert as compensation. Something to offset the poor soup experience in the guests mind would have gone a long way. At this level of a dining experience one expects and should deserve better. read more

Great food service and ambience. Great way to spend an evening with your wife or husband.

I expected much better. We were a party of 6. They seated us shortly after we arrived per our reservation, which was good. They badly over-cooked a ribeye steak (ordered medium rare, served medium well), so one of us had to wait another 15 minutes for a new steak, while the rest of us ate our entrees. The food was good, but it's priced like they are in Chicago, not the far NW burbs. It's very easy to spend over $100 per person. Out here, that usually means it will be a special, memorable experience, but it was pedestrian. Maybe they just dropped the ball this time. read more

Montarra is a hidden gem as it's located in a strip shopping center but when you enter you feel as though you have entered a high-end steak house. They have a full menu beyond steak and every menu item has arrived to the table with special touches for a fancy presentation followed by full flavor. read more

Was excited to try this restaurant and dined with some friends for first time. Hit and miss! The atmosphere is classy and food presentation is artistic. The actual food failed to meet the visual expectations. Bread rolls and butter were underwhelming for a restaurant of this caliber. The French onion is served in an onion was pretty good. Ordered beef tenderloin tips, bacon wrapped scallops on polenta cake $34. I typically love polenta, but Monterras polenta cake was bland-tasteless. The portion on tips was small and they were not very tender (little tough) and bacon not crispy. I was full enough that I did not finish the last scallop- but just as well because the last one had some grit. The flourless chocolate cake and double espresso martini were delish. read more

Montarra - New American Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

See all

This is the downtown experience but conveniently located in the burns. Food and atmosphere were great, I almost liked it better than region. I hunt for the best tartar and this place is definitely in my top 3 now. The apple cake old fashioned was so good and don forget to order the toffee cake for desert! read more

Montarra - Steak tartar and bulgogi - New American Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

Amazing food, drink, and fantastic service. It's been years since we've been to Montarra. We were reminded how we need to come back sooner! read more

Celebrated my husband's 70th birthday and what a perfect meal we had. Our server was awesome. We started with Bulgogi (?) egg roll. It was very, very good. He got the surf and turf. He said it was the best, most perfect steak he's ever had. I tasted it and can attest to the flavors and tenderness. I got the twin lobster meal. Lobster done perfectly. The grilled asparagus was tender, perfect char and sweet. Gouda scallop potato--so good. We'll be back. Kudos to the chef. Thanks for making my husband's birthday a day to remember. read more

Montarra - Bulgogi eggroll. - New American Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois