Monical's Pizza Greencastle

The staff here are great! We were greeted by a friendly hostess and then Logan, our waiter, was…read moresuper helpful. We started with the charcuterie which had 2 salami's and a prosciutto as well as 2 soft cheeses and 1 hard and a little fig jam. They also gave us a large basket of toast points. It was fabulous! I had the funghi pizza (on Logan's recommendation) and he was not wrong. It was a mix of mushroom and truffle with an arugula topping. I haven't tasted anything like it before. I'll come back for that. My daughter had the pork belly with polenta and sweet chili and wilted spinach. That dish was awesome, super rich and all the flavors worked perfectly together. She also got the winter sangria which was very nice and paired well with her dinner. It helped to break up the richness with sweet and tangy notes from orange and what seemed like cranberry.

A Local favorite!!! Never had anything that wasn't good. Salads, pizza, wine, dessert all super…read moretasty.

Creme Brulee

See all

Marvin's

3.3(69 reviews)

1.8 mi

Marvin's continues to Deliver!! Had a great lunch and introduce some friends to all things Marv's!!read more

I'm a tourist/visitor in the area for a wedding. So this dinky very causal place was great for a…read morelarge group, and simple items. I can't determine if this place is better than another. Serve yourself but overall it's slow. If you're down to support and OG place not expect much, this place is it. This place is known for their garlic cheeseburger? Friends got those, tenderloin and other items. For a dairy sensitive person, I stuck to the salad. The staff was willing to show me the large salad dressing to read the ingredients on my own. This place does remind me of a local sandwich place near my old college campus. Glad we can support a local place.

Foundation soda with mello yellow

Salad

See all

An Iconic Banner

Pizza King

3.4(19 reviews)

1.5 mi

Great food the only issues don't deliver locally . Think there could be better served if the could…read moredeliver j

Somehow, this little "pizza spot" in the middle of greencastle figured out the right mix of good…read moreownership that cares about their product, staff that's naturally friendly, and food that just slaps. Big ups to the King of za!

Deluxe Calzone. Good size, good value. Very flavorful.

See all

Carryout still open

Papa Johns Pizza

4.0(9 reviews)

1.6 mi

Every time I get a pizza from here it's amazing, the staff is great, friendly & hard working!…read moreThey're open til midnight most nights but have good attitudes. Today they are SLAMMED. Every other restaurant in town is closed because we had a major storm come through where most people lost power, and these guys are still going strong with over an hour wait time & I saw their pizza box order stickers 5' long! Wow! My pizza was hot & delicious! These guys deserve the praise! Well done!

This is why I don't really order from this store anymore the manager is really rude and I always…read morefind hair in my food the customer service sucks there delivery service sucks and the driver shows up in deity clothing

Hawaiian bbq pizza! Fresh from the oven!

Chicken Alfredo

See all

The Fluttering Duck

3.3(47 reviews)

Sorry if I am just a student but the overall food choices and quality is not good. The service is…read moresometimes okay but some of the waitstaff is very disorganized and I was charge more than once for food I did not receive on multiple occasions. The options of menu items is not good either needs more options either than fried items and fettuccine alfredo pasta that doesn't have any flavour and is watery. I also usually get sick like throwing up after eating the food here. Same with Hoover Hall Food as well. The overall ambiance is terrible can't hear a thing in that place. Fridays with Jazz good luck trying to hear the person next to you speak loud.

Great for bar food and decent drinks. Food is just typical bar food. Our service was well enough.read more

Fall colors in full display on patio

The Fluttering Duck on the backside of the old Bus Station.

See all

Outdoor Dining!!

Dominos

4.0(6 reviews)

1.5 mi

Don't order food often and decided that I would tonight. Hot, fresh, delicious pizza in 20 minutes…read more Even called the store to tell them that it was awesome!

I don't eat here very often but when I do it's usually late at night. Everytime the pizza have been…read moreso good! Fast and on time, fresh, delicious. Tonight was no different! I mean check out the spread !! The people working are killing it!

Chicken Alfredo with onions and jalapeños

See all

Parmesan bites

Pizza Hut

1.7(12 reviews)

0.4 mi

Really nice experience, everything inside was very clean, went a little later in the evening so the…read moresalad bar was put away. The staff was very friendly, polite and brought our order to us in a very prompt manner and it was definitely worth it. I mean I know pizza is a very common thing but good pizza is always worth mentioning. Will definitely come back soon!

I ordered online. So I get to the store to pay card machine was broke so they had to take my card…read moreto the back to run it. Employee was pleasant and service was quick. The store was desserted other than the employees so it was very quiet. So I take my food and head home. I get home with the food I start with the wing's they were average at best. The pizza was horrible it had no sauce and the pepperoni tasted like baloney and the crust tasted like a biscuit. The cheese bacon bread also tasted like a biscuit. This all reminded me why I don't go to Pizza Hut.

Tavern style pizza

Bacon Parmesan cheesy bread

See all

Garlic bread with cheese

Almost Home Restaurant & Bar

3.7(102 reviews)

Today we stumbled on Almost Home. What a wonderful gem in Greencastle. I had the smokehouse…read morebourbon burger and my wife had the chicken salad sandwich. Both were amazing!! And the French fries were out of this world good. For dessert we shared an amazing chocolate cake (sorry did not catch the name of it) but OMG!!!! It was so amazing. As for the service, the building, the ambience.... All were incredible. We would highly recommend stopping in at Almost Home if you are ever in Greencastle.

Almost home has always been a staple in Greencastle as long as I can remember! The sandwiches are…read moredelicious & the broccoli soup is wonderful, that soup was always a favorite of my late mom & she would ask for it often if I was in town. The service is always good & the desserts are so very delicious! It's a nice local restaurant that is loved by many. I suggest the desert called strawberry pizza, but all the desserts are homemade & fantastic.

Ceiling

See all

Scoops Ice Cream

4.8(25 reviews)

Cute little gem just off the square in Greencastle. We got the sampler of 4 mini scoops to share…read moreand it was great. Pumpkin was very flavorful. Buckeye was fine. Banana pudding and cookies & cream also really good. Pleasant quick service too.

I know it is an ice cream location but they also have great smoothies if you're needing one. The…read moreice cream was 10 out of 10 however. The service was excellent! Super clean and friendly inside.

Berry smoothie

See all

Casey's

4.0(1 review)

1.6 mi

Really enjoy the pizza here. They also have great customer service. Very clean and very attentive…read more Are baked goods are good also.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Ashley S.

8 years ago

Great and Friendly Staff! Never have any issues with them!

Lynette Z.

15 years ago

Good pizza, wonderful staff. :)

Monical's Pizza Greencastle - italian - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Monical's Pizza Greencastle also viewed

Pizza Niche

4.1

(14 reviews)

Tried this place when in town. It was a good pizza place in this town. Very limited menu and a…read moresmall dining area which was well decorated and clean. We ordered the deluxe pizza. It had mild peppers which I like but the wife didn't but never had that on a deluxe pizza before so it was a first for me. I believe it was a truly deluxe pizza with a lot of toppings and it was a thick pizza. The crust was done where the toppings didn't sag it but it didn't have any taste and reminded me of a frozen pizza crust which I don't think it was but just reminded me of it. I make my own pizza crust from scratch which has a flavor. But this was a great pizza place to get a pizza if you are in town.

Clearly Indiana is not a pizza Mecca, but Pizzia Niche can do better. Positives- the sauce was…read moregreat. Tastes home cooked and is well seasoned. The cheese had great flavor, Might be Sargento? Improvement opportunities- The crust was just bad, seemed like a frozen disk that was hard! Please consider a hand toss option. There is a great debate on toppings under or over cheese. Please move toppings that benefit from cooking to the the top, they are after all they are "toppings". The pepperoni was completely lost under the cheese.

Lizton Pizza

4.2

(12 reviews)

Ordered a medium pepperoni and breadsticks. Everything was excellent. The breadsticks were the…read moreright combo of soft, airy, chewy, and crispy. The pizza was loaded with cheese and the crust was great. Again, the perfect combo of thin and crispy with the right amount of chew. Will definitely be back.

The pizza and breadsticks are great. A definite step up from chains like Papa John's and Pizza Hut…read more The staff. Is quick and friendly. I love it. Will be back again and again.

Sal's Famous Pizzeria

3.3

(189 reviews)

Sal's is our go to pizza place in the area. The wood fire pizzas from here are unbeatable and truly…read moreworth the money.

Definitely the best pizza in Plainfield, but a 3/5 star slice overall. A little undercooked, but…read moregood sauce and decent cheese. The garlic cheese knots are very good!

Pizza King

5.0

(10 reviews)

Great service and delicious food. They are always happy to custom make my special Stromboli…read moresandwich to perfection.

Oh man, ALWAYS a treat when we go to Clayton Pizza King. Even though I can't wait and burn my…read moremouth, there is NOTHING like the snap of that hot crust as you bite it while hot. No soggy crust here!!! And then there's the dessert breadsticks. WOW. Such nice people and happy to chat. Thanks for a great meal and see you again soon!!!!

Pizza Twist

4.3

(63 reviews)

I love the fact they have a variety of Indian as well as more traditional options…read more The pizza was great. Nice crust. Even toppings. Very flavorful Service was very good and personal

Stopped in for a quick lunch on a Saturday. We had been here several times in the past and was…read morecraving it again. We've always been pleased with the food and service and this time was no different. The restaurant is in a somewhat older building and the inside shows. It could use a little updating and maybe a fresh coat of paint. However we were greeted and seated right away and they are always attentive and helpful if you have any questions since the menu can be a little confusing. The main food menu is pizza, wings and pastas but the twist is, the flavors are Indian based. Everything we have ordered has been amazing. We will definitely be back many more times.

Papa's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine

4.3

(70 reviews)

Authentic NY style pizza, convenient curbside pickup, and friendly service. I can't believe I…read moredidn't discover this place sooner. By far the best pizza in Brownsburg and the best NY style pizza on the west side. They have delicious breadsticks as well. Pizza is always hot and ready when they say it will be ready.

If I could leave a zero review, I would. Ordered via their system. Apparently they won't take…read moreorders by phone. I had a hard time finding a number. I ordered online and then downloaded an ap called slice (which I have now removed). The restaurant uses an Uber service. My pizzas never arrived. I paid around $54 which I am told will be refunded to me within 24-48 hours. I gave a 20% tip in advance. So I call the restaurant and am told for some reason the driver cancelled my order, though the pizzas were made and picked up. So the driver apparently has my pizzas AND my money. Also, when speaking to the manager of the restaurant, he tells me they will make my pizzas again and deliver themselves. I am talking on the phone with him, and he literally says he cannot take my order, that I have to order online. SERIOUSLY? So no accommodation for me the customer, given what happened. He should have taken my order and it should have been free. I am still SMH! I'll be watching my account to see IF my money is returned. If not, I will be pursuing this. My husband is a lawyer.

Papa Murphy's

3.4

(7 reviews)

Decided to order for dinner like we used to when the kids were young. Pizza was good and like that…read moreyou can customize and get two pizzas in one. The keto meal was ok, a bit too much cheese for me.

Depending on which one of us is busy, either me or my dad come in every Tuesday to pick up a pizza…read more Andrew the manager is always awesome. The staff is very friendly too, and of course the pizza is consistently delicious. (HALF THAI CHICKEN, HALF HAWAIIAN ADD BLACK OLIVES + ONION I'M TALKING TO YOU.) The $10 large pizza deal on Tuesdays is where it's at y'all. Sadly, I found out yesterday that Andrew the manager will be moving away, and I'm so sad!! He will be missed! Over the many months me and my dad have been stopping by to pick up a pizza, he has made such a great impression. He's always so nice, remembers my order and even knows it's me when I call lol. That isn't something that I expect from anyone who works in the food industry, but I think it's just cool that he remembers customers and really makes the pizza pick up an experience. Makes the customer feel appreciated, you know?. FOR example, Even when the odds were against him yesterday (the water stopped working and put him 2 hours behind on making dough), he knocked it outta the ball park by the time I was there by 6pm (which tuesdays are ALREADY very busy due to the $10 deal), all while remaining friendly and helpful to each customer that came in. Anyway, papa murphys is fantastic, and Andrew will be hard to replace :/ I have faith though!~

Arnold’s Pizza King

3.3

(4 reviews)

I usually don't leave reviews like this but this was the worst pizza we have ever had. We bought 2…read morepizzas and it was $50. Toppings were stone cold and cheese wasn't even melted. I do not recommend this place. Should have just drove to Danville for some good pizza.

Wonderful service and staff. Pizza is great- always fresh from the oven! Love that it's family…read moreowned.

Perillo's Pizzeria

4.6

(139 reviews)

Grabbed a birthday lunch at Perillo's today…read more My lunch partner is not much of a pizza eater, so decided to just grab a 2 topping slice and a meat ball sub for myself. Slice was pepperoni and fresh mushrooms, NY style. Delicious. (Took a bite before I took the picture). Meatball sub was very good with good crunch on the bread, and nice melty cheese. Meatballs were really good, and sauce was very tasty. Lunch partner had the Philly cheese steak. Said it was piping hot and very tasty. Came with a cup of melted nacho cheese on the side. Service was quick and very attentive. As regulars know, it is cash only. Will be back sooner than later this time.

Stopped in for lunch today and had their $8.99 pizza lunch special. It's good for one 12" pizza…read morewith 1 topping or a lunch spaghetti. I went with a cheese pizza with extra cheese and two garlic knots with cheese dipping sauce. In no time my food was out and piping hot. The garlic knots are always a given to be super delicious and did not disappoint once again. The cheese pizza was a lot larger than I expected and was very flavorful and cheesy. The place was not very busy but I did come in right at opening. The interior is small and cozy and the comfort food they serve is always delicious. If you haven't tried them yet come over to North Salem and give them a try. They have great salads as well.

Rockstar Pizza

4.1

(233 reviews)