Cancel
Open app
Search
Sign Up
Log In
Nearby
Bookmarks
Start a Project
Add a Business on Yelp
It's easier on the Yelp app
Continue
Stay on browser
Add Review
Call
Directions
Website
Taco Bell
$
Phil B. said: Fresh great food. Probably the freshest tasting and best filled taco… read more
More like Casey's
Donuts
Breakfast
Lunch
Tacos
Start your review...
Get app
6 years ago
Really enjoy the pizza here. They also have great customer service. Very clean and very attentive. Are baked goods are good also.
1215 S Bloomington St
Greencastle, IN 46135
(765) 653-2959
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.caseys.com
Full menu
Hours
What time does Casey's open?
Casey's opens at 4:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
What time does Casey's close?
Casey's closes at 11:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
Mon-Sun 4:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Does Casey's take credit cards?
Yes, Casey's takes credit cards.
Does Casey's have catering options?
No, Casey's does not have catering options.
Does Casey's serve alcohol?
Yes, Casey's serves alcohol.
Does Casey's have outdoor seating?
No, Casey's does not have outdoor seating options.
Does Casey's have parking?
Yes, Casey's has parking options.
Does Casey's have free WiFi?
Yes, Casey's has free WiFi.
People searched for Pizza 190 times last month within 15 miles of this business.
A Local favorite!!! Never had anything that wasn't good. Salads, pizza, wine, dessert all super…read moretasty.
Met family here for a dinner while back in town- aka used to be home. I'm a complete pizza lover…read moreand learning that there is a real pizza oven here, it wasn't up for discussion- that is what i was having and it was worth the .0002 it took me to decide that. It was GREAT! DH had a salat which was also really good, the 'rents weren't too pleased with their choices but in the defense of Bridges, one started their order while we sat at the bar with do you have any beer that comes in a can.... The evolution that in the 20ish years since I've left 'home' places like this exists, I'm sure it's not up to everyone's likes or affordability which is the real shame here. When back in town it will be on the list of places to hit, to get a good meal can't wait to ty more.
Creme Brulee
See all
I'm a tourist/visitor in the area for a wedding. So this dinky very causal place was great for a…read morelarge group, and simple items. I can't determine if this place is better than another. Serve yourself but overall it's slow. If you're down to support and OG place not expect much, this place is it. This place is known for their garlic cheeseburger? Friends got those, tenderloin and other items. For a dairy sensitive person, I stuck to the salad. The staff was willing to show me the large salad dressing to read the ingredients on my own. This place does remind me of a local sandwich place near my old college campus. Glad we can support a local place.
Perfectly decent pizza, and open on Sundays, unlike the other options around town…read more Not really anything too flashy, or special, but nothing to complain about either. Prices are good, and there's a fairly decent range of options.
Foundation soda with mello yellow
Salad
An Iconic Banner
Great food the only issues don't deliver locally . Think there could be better served if the could…read moredeliver j
Somehow, this little "pizza spot" in the middle of greencastle figured out the right mix of good…read moreownership that cares about their product, staff that's naturally friendly, and food that just slaps. Big ups to the King of za!
Deluxe Calzone. Good size, good value. Very flavorful.
Carryout still open
We love Monical's pizza. It is always fresh and delicious. The restaurant is always clean and the…read moreservice is friendly. Rather we eat in or out we have always been satisfied. They also have great sandwiches, and a good side salad. Keep up the good work!
Great pizza! Just pretty expensive for what you get and how the restaurant looks these days…read more Nothing fancy and the service is ok. A little slow, but they are very friendly eventually take care of you. I really enjoy the personal pan pizzas (8 inches).
Thin crust meat extravaganza.
Every time I get a pizza from here it's amazing, the staff is great, friendly & hard working!…read moreThey're open til midnight most nights but have good attitudes. Today they are SLAMMED. Every other restaurant in town is closed because we had a major storm come through where most people lost power, and these guys are still going strong with over an hour wait time & I saw their pizza box order stickers 5' long! Wow! My pizza was hot & delicious! These guys deserve the praise! Well done!
This is why I don't really order from this store anymore the manager is really rude and I always…read morefind hair in my food the customer service sucks there delivery service sucks and the driver shows up in deity clothing
Hawaiian bbq pizza! Fresh from the oven!
Chicken Alfredo
Sorry if I am just a student but the overall food choices and quality is not good. The service is…read moresometimes okay but some of the waitstaff is very disorganized and I was charge more than once for food I did not receive on multiple occasions. The options of menu items is not good either needs more options either than fried items and fettuccine alfredo pasta that doesn't have any flavour and is watery. I also usually get sick like throwing up after eating the food here. Same with Hoover Hall Food as well. The overall ambiance is terrible can't hear a thing in that place. Fridays with Jazz good luck trying to hear the person next to you speak loud.
Great for bar food and decent drinks. Food is just typical bar food. Our service was well enough.read more
Fall colors in full display on patio
The Fluttering Duck on the backside of the old Bus Station.
Outdoor Dining!!
I don't eat here very often but when I do it's usually late at night. Everytime the pizza have been…read moreso good! Fast and on time, fresh, delicious. Tonight was no different! I mean check out the spread !! The people working are killing it!
Everyone I have had an encounter with any employees here they were unnecessarily rude, dismissive,…read moreand treated customers with very little respect. It came across as though they felt entitled and acted like helping customers was an inconvenience rather than their job.
Chicken Alfredo with onions and jalapeños
Parmesan bites
I ordered online. So I get to the store to pay card machine was broke so they had to take my card…read moreto the back to run it. Employee was pleasant and service was quick. The store was desserted other than the employees so it was very quiet. So I take my food and head home. I get home with the food I start with the wing's they were average at best. The pizza was horrible it had no sauce and the pepperoni tasted like baloney and the crust tasted like a biscuit. The cheese bacon bread also tasted like a biscuit. This all reminded me why I don't go to Pizza Hut.
Really nice experience, everything inside was very clean, went a little later in the evening so the…read moresalad bar was put away. The staff was very friendly, polite and brought our order to us in a very prompt manner and it was definitely worth it. I mean I know pizza is a very common thing but good pizza is always worth mentioning. Will definitely come back soon!
Tavern style pizza
Bacon Parmesan cheesy bread
Garlic bread with cheese
Today we stumbled on Almost Home. What a wonderful gem in Greencastle. I had the smokehouse…read morebourbon burger and my wife had the chicken salad sandwich. Both were amazing!! And the French fries were out of this world good. For dessert we shared an amazing chocolate cake (sorry did not catch the name of it) but OMG!!!! It was so amazing. As for the service, the building, the ambience.... All were incredible. We would highly recommend stopping in at Almost Home if you are ever in Greencastle.
Almost home has always been a staple in Greencastle as long as I can remember! The sandwiches are…read moredelicious & the broccoli soup is wonderful, that soup was always a favorite of my late mom & she would ask for it often if I was in town. The service is always good & the desserts are so very delicious! It's a nice local restaurant that is loved by many. I suggest the desert called strawberry pizza, but all the desserts are homemade & fantastic.
Ceiling
Menu
I know it is an ice cream location but they also have great smoothies if you're needing one. The…read moreice cream was 10 out of 10 however. The service was excellent! Super clean and friendly inside.
Checked out scoops during a work trip, it's a cute shop off of the court house square, the staff is…read morevery friendly and they have a great assortment of flavors! I had a hard time choosing but ended up getting the key lime pie, savory and perfect for the crazy hot weather we have been having here in Indiana! Check them out if you are in the area!
BEST of Greencastle, Indiana Restaurants near Casey's
BEST of Greencastle, Indiana Coffee near Casey's
BEST of Greencastle, Indiana Breakfast near Casey's
BEST of Greencastle, Indiana Dinner near Casey's
BEST of Greencastle, Indiana Burgers near Casey's
BEST of Greencastle, Indiana Sushi near Casey's
Restaurants in Greencastle, IN
Breakfast & Brunch in Greencastle, IN
Breakfast in Greencastle, IN
Donuts in Greencastle, IN
Barbeque in Greencastle, IN
Lunch in Greencastle, IN
Hip New Restaurants in Greencastle, IN
Ice Cream in Greencastle, IN
Burgers in Greencastle, IN
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Greencastle, IN
Dinner in Greencastle, IN
Sandwiches in Greencastle, IN
Pork Tenderloin in Greencastle, IN
Delivery in Greencastle, IN
24 Hour Restaurants in Greencastle, IN
Takeout in Greencastle, IN
Salad in Greencastle, IN
Restaurants Open Sunday in Greencastle, IN
Pizza Delivery in Greencastle, IN
Tacos in Greencastle, IN
Wings in Greencastle, IN
24 Hour Pizza Delivery in Greencastle, IN
Restaurants Open Now in Greencastle, IN
Restaurants Open Late in Greencastle, IN
Best Appetizers to Enjoy Around Greencastle, Indiana
Best Bagels Available in Greencastle, Indiana
Best Bar and Grill Experiences in Greencastle, Indiana
Best Fish & Chips Restaurants Near Greencastle, Indiana
Best Korean Fried Chicken Spots Around Greencastle, Indiana
Best Places for Brunch in Greencastle, Indiana
Best Rooftop Restaurant Experiences in Greencastle, Indiana
Best Soul Food Dishes in Greencastle, Indiana
Best Vegan Restaurants to Try in Greencastle, Indiana
Best Wood Fired Pizza Available in Greencastle, Indiana
Delicious Soup Spots to Try in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover Authentic Filipino Food in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover Authentic Indian Food in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover Authentic Italian in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover Popular Sunday Brunch Places in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover Top Asian Food Options in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover Top Mediterranean Food in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover the Best Breweries in Greencastle, Indiana Today
Discover the Best Romantic Restaurant Options in Greencastle, Indiana
Discover the Best Sushi Spots in Greencastle, Indiana
Enjoy Casual Dining Options in Greencastle, Indiana
Enjoy Classic Hamburger Options in Greencastle, Indiana
Enjoy Delicious Hot Dogs in Greencastle, Indiana
Enjoy Fast Food Favorites Across Greencastle, Indiana
Enjoy the Best Cocktails in Greencastle, Indiana
Explore BBQ Restaurants Near Greencastle, Indiana
Explore Delicious Vegetarian Food in Greencastle, Indiana
Explore Popular Cocktail Bars in Greencastle, Indiana
Find Family Friendly Restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana for All Ages
Find Fresh Salmon Dishes in Greencastle, Indiana
Great Diners to Visit in Greencastle, Indiana
Highly Rated Japanese Restaurant Locations in Greencastle, Indiana
Highly Rated Steakhouses Around Greencastle, Indiana
Order the Best Chicken Wings in Greencastle, Indiana Today
Order the Best Deep Dish Pizza in Greencastle, Indiana
Savor the Best Burrito Flavors in Greencastle, Indiana
Taste Delicious Korean Food Options in Greencastle, Indiana
Taste the Best American Food in Greencastle, Indiana
Top Gluten Free Pizza Spots in Greencastle, Indiana
Top Gluten Free Restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana
Top Outdoor Dining Spots to Try in Greencastle, Indiana
Top Rated Seafood Dishes in Greencastle, Indiana
Top-Rated Spaghetti Dishes to Try in Greencastle, Indiana
Try Pizza by the Slice Near Greencastle, Indiana
Try the Best Banh Mi Sandwiches in Greencastle, Indiana
Birthday Dinner near Casey's
Chicken Caesar Wrap near Casey's
Chicken Noodle Soup near Casey's
Chinese Buffet near Casey's
Cinnamon Roll near Casey's
Coffee Truck near Casey's
German Restaurants near Casey's
Korean Restaurant near Casey's
Meat Processing near Casey's
Sports Bar With Tv near Casey's
Stromboli near Casey's
Study Spots near Casey's
Thin Crust Pizza near Casey's
Things to do in Greencastle
Casey's General Store
Articles by date
I usually don't leave reviews like this but this was the worst pizza we have ever had. We bought 2…read morepizzas and it was $50. Toppings were stone cold and cheese wasn't even melted. I do not recommend this place. Should have just drove to Danville for some good pizza.
Wonderful service and staff. Pizza is great- always fresh from the oven! Love that it's family…read moreowned.
Love the pizza's, all fresh ingredients. Cute little cozy restaurant. Excellent and friendly…read moreservice. The owners are wonderful people!
The pizza was delicious! We were staying at Turkey Run State Park Inn & Cabins, celebrating the…read morebirthday of one of our granddaughters and, as a typical 14 year old, she wanted pizza. A phone call, a quick drive to the edge of Rockville, and -voila! 3 large pizzas with great toppings. We even got 3 packets of ranch cheese, red pepper flakes and Parmesan. Not to mention, they threw in paper plates! Perfect for our needs.
Pizza buffet Sundays 11-2 and thru the week as well as Wednesday nights!!…read more Dawn was amazing! Asked us if we wanted any specific pizza made and let us know when it was out. Breadsticks were phenomenal. The cinnamon could use some icing. ( as I was leaving saw a sign u can ask for it) They have a salad bar, could use a few more toppings and dressing options as well. French, ranch and thousand island only. Maybe add Italian and bacon bits:) Overall I will definitely go back.
I visited a Danville because my friends were new parents. And I wanted to take them dinner…read moresomething quick but thoughtful just because I wanted them to not think about dinner. I called the number for this Pizza Hut and got an automated service. Which I hate that they do that because per usual, they messed up my order and wasn't trying to give me a promotion that I saw on Pizza Hut's website however, when I got there, the man at the front desk, heard me say my peace and gave us the discounted price for the pizza. I was pleased at the customer service and the time it's for us to get our order.
Excellent pizza wings and services Best Meat Lovers pizza I…read morehave had Recommend to all
Very poor service and quality of food is a 0 star items on the pizza are not fresh and the price is…read moreexpensive for a poor pizza
Tap wall!!! Sit in the taproom much quieter . Sunday is the pizza buffet and it's delicious!!!…read moreService is superb!!! Pizza always changes and the pepperoni stuffed knots are to die for!!!
Excellent pizza and ambience! They have separate rooms for kind of dining experience you are…read morelooking for - fun (pinball, air hockey and kid games) quiet with pizza and salad bar and a tv bar area with different self-serve tap beer you can taste! Totally cool!! On the "meh" side, the gal who took our order had trouble using their electronic ordering tool and took an inordinate amount of time to input our order and both pizzas came out wrong, which they fixed one and we just picked off what we asked not to be put on for second one. Also, they don't have an accessible bathroom, which was surprising since the place has been updated since 2012. I highly recommend they get that taken care of to be compliant with the American with Disabilities Act.
Always very good service. We like the option to get our own versions of pizzas. Don't hesitate to…read moreask for a little more on the ingredients. They will supply what you need. Something about the crust makes these really, really tasty. Go with the Big Zip and take some leftovers for an evening snack!! It reheats very well.
It was my first time there yesterday. I tried something I never had before and that's the garlic…read morebutter sauce. The pizza was fantastic but I think if I ordered the same thing again I would ask them to half the sauce I thought it was a bit too strong for me personally.
Great pizza , stuffed bread sticks and sandwiches. Get it…read moredelivered or eat in ....
Best pizza next to P&T Video. Great bowling alley marta abuadato also known as marta k wimsett is…read morethe one that hit the side of ur building the insurance and cars are always in chuck abuadatos name
Delicious cheeseburgers. Arrived 20 minutes after morning closing (1:20 PM) to find Charlie and…read morestaff preparing for afternoon service. Asked about other food in town and Charlie offered to make us cheeseburgers and allow us to stay and eat while they were working. We asked for the burgers "to go" as we didn't want to get in the way of their prep. Tidy hometown business staffed by wonderful people.