Tried this place when in town. It was a good pizza place in this town. Very limited menu and a small dining area which was well decorated and clean. We ordered the deluxe pizza. It had mild peppers which I like but the wife didn't but never had that on a deluxe pizza before so it was a first for me. I believe it was a truly deluxe pizza with a lot of toppings and it was a thick pizza. The crust was done where the toppings didn't sag it but it didn't have any taste and reminded me of a frozen pizza crust which I don't think it was but just reminded me of it. I make my own pizza crust from scratch which has a flavor. But this was a great pizza place to get a pizza if you are in town. read more

Pizza Niche - Pizza Deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Cloverdale, Indiana

Clearly Indiana is not a pizza Mecca, but Pizzia Niche can do better. Positives- the sauce was great. Tastes home cooked and is well seasoned. The cheese had great flavor, Might be Sargento? Improvement opportunities- The crust was just bad, seemed like a frozen disk that was hard! Please consider a hand toss option. There is a great debate on toppings under or over cheese. Please move toppings that benefit from cooking to the the top, they are after all they are "toppings". The pepperoni was completely lost under the cheese. read more

Amazing pizza , they don't short you on toppings. Very good. Nice people and great service.

Great little stop on Cloverdale. Food was delicious! No complaints on any of it! Little lady that took care of our order was so kind! Definitely a hidden gem! read more

See all

So let me just start off with saying, I've been curious about this place for a long time. Well my wife and I finally decided on a night when we were just wiped out from work and needed something for the family and not a lot of time to try it out. Boy are we glad we did, I also will point out that we tried placing our order through Yelp! And there was a lot of confusion at first, we were worried because our order was processing, but yet it was placed through grubhub which we have never used. So out of curiosity and concern I decided to call and ask about the status of our order, the young lady on the phone was confused at first, saying she had not received it but then I heard the ding and she was very apologetic and offered to make our order as quickly as possible, but once we got it figured out she was very kind and understanding. I offered to come in and get it as we were positive at this point no one from grubhub was going to deliver our order (which is not what we asked for but not the business' fault at all!) she offered to keep it in the hot box so we wouldn't have cold soggy pizza by the time I got it back home (thank goodness cuz three kids plus cold soggy pizza equals bad times) plus extra punches on the loyalty card they have as another way of apologizing. Overall the customer service was definitely a refreshing experience that I've missed and not had in a long time! So now let's focus on food, we ordered a large cheese and bacon pizza nothing fancy but it was simple executed to perfection, the bacon was just crispy enough and definitely was not the run of the mill stuff you get from everywhere else. The crust was the best crust I've had in a long time, not too thick not too thin but when you bit into it it had that delicious crispy crunch that you just can't get from most places anymore. We also ordered the garlic butter breadsticks, which they use the extra large portion cups instead of the dinky little things you get from the big places, plus she threw in extra cheese for no extra charge! Then an order of boneless buffalo wings which again she included a couple extra pieces, and again no extra charge! So even without the extras as an apology the portions were definitely more than enough and worth every bit! It's a smaller place and not much for indoor dining but it's quant and quiet if you just wanted a place to have a lunch or dinner to hang out and not be surrounded by people or anything like that. I even ran into my in laws when I was walking in and we got to talking about how much they love it there too. All in all I'm sold and hooked, this is a great little gem for a small town and I actually feel sorry for towns or cities that usually overlook smaller businesses like this because they don't know what they're missing! This isn't your run of the mill cookie cutter corporate franchise like dominos or Pizza Hut, this is a local business ran by real hard working folks trying to do there best every day and it shows. Oh and almost forgot with all that food and to feed a family of 5 for $50 in the current times and economy I'm certainly not going to complain! My wife and kids were blown away and happy and that's something I would never put a price tag on. So thanks Lilly's Pizza Niche, you will always have our business! read more

Food is always good never had a problem! Service is spot on. Good ambiance around always.

Hello. This is the best dang pizza that exists on the planet. Everytime I step foot in the state of Indiana, I make sure that Pizza Niche is on the list of things to do. I remember eating the Supreme as a kid and am gonna tell you that's what you need. I don't eat meat anymore but actually will crave the Supreme from the Niche. The veggie pizza is still worth it. They load up the toppings. read more

Pizza Niche now open. We ordered two pizzas while visiting husbands family. One pepperoni and sausage. One sausage, black olive, mushroom. I could have used half as much sausage and twice as much pepperoni on the one pizza. Crust was good as was the sauce. Mother in-law and Nephew really liked the Sausage, black olive mushroom. Person on phone was friendly taking order. Friendly inside at pick up. Everything looked shiny and new and clean. They were a little expensive two pizzas around 45$. Chicago's pizza is a bit cheaper and they have great bread sticks. No mask wearing inside which seems the norm in Cloverdale. read more

See all

They have been here for years. The strombolis are phenomenal. The pizza is good as well. Smiling faces, even in unknown places. Enjoy.

delicious pizza and yummy garlicky cheese bread. This is one of our favorite pizza places.

Ordered 2 large pizzas, BBQ and Buffalo wings. All were very delicious. Definitely recommend eating here. Also very friendly and good service. Received my food rather quickly which was nice. read more

Better than Kris McGrumpy and Beth C reviewed it. Comparable to a Bobs tu your door or Jacks pizza in indy. Stick to pizza classics pepperoni or sausage. If you want breadsticks Chicagos up the road is the spot. read more

Unfortunately, I should have listened to the person that gave this 2 stars. They were being generous with 2. Pizza was so bad we couldn't even eat it. If you think you can't screw up breadsticks, think again. The only one that ate good tonight was the dog. Total waste of $30 read more

I've only eaten here twice. In 2012 and 2013. I was not impressed. Pizza was sub par and prices above average. Much more satisfying at Chicago's right down the road. With a location right in downtown Cloverdale, I think the spot could be utilized in a more efficient way to make the Pizza Niche more of a "go to" place for the residents of the town. read more