I don't enjoy Piezanos enough. Great flavor, even better crust. Our family favorite is the around…read morethe world.

If you like thin crust pizza this is a must eat. This pizza is incredible. I ordered a large pizza…read morewith regular sauce and cheese, I got it with pepperoni and jalapeños, and I had it cooked well done. This pizza completely exceeded my expectations. Phenomenal pie.

We decided to try this for lunch and we were pleasantly pleased. The restaurant was limited on…read moreseating and we were glad that we got there early for lunch because it quickly filled up. There are two rooms to dine in. But not a lot of tables so avoid busy times. They have a salad bar with lots of selections and a pizza bar as well. Plus they had soups and breadstick. You can't go wrong with all this food and it was only $13 per person. We had quick service and the waitress was hopping taking care of the lunch crowd

If you are a fan of NY style pizza this might be for you. For us not so much…read more The crust couldn't even hold its own weight it is sagging times two. We ordered extra cheese, there must be NO cheese on their regular pizza, because we didn't notice "extra" cheese. This was the second time we tried rockstar. Don't think we going to spend $36 for a large pie there again. We had the pizza delivered by Uber Eats. It was delivered in a very reasonable time on a Saturday evening (6:30). Kudos to Über Eats.

We had a great experience at Tomato Pie Pizza! It's a friendly, family-oriented restaurant with a…read morewelcoming atmosphere. The staff was warm, attentive, and very helpful. Since it was our first visit, we asked our waitress what she recommended, and her suggestions did not disappoint. We ordered a small Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza, a small Deluxe pizza, and an order of breadsticks with cheese. Everything was delicious, but the breadsticks really stood out. They were perfectly baked with a wonderful crisp snap when you bit into them while still being soft and flavorful on the inside. Both pizzas were fresh, loaded with toppings, and full of flavor. If you're looking for a cozy place with excellent pizza, great breadsticks, and friendly service, I highly recommend Tomato Pie Pizza. We'll definitely be back!

Excellent service and delicious food. Clean and fun atmosphere. We will be back again soon.read more

Ordered a medium pepperoni and breadsticks. Everything was excellent. The breadsticks were the…read moreright combo of soft, airy, chewy, and crispy. The pizza was loaded with cheese and the crust was great. Again, the perfect combo of thin and crispy with the right amount of chew. Will definitely be back.

The pizza and breadsticks are great. A definite step up from chains like Papa John's and Pizza Hut…read more The staff. Is quick and friendly. I love it. Will be back again and again.

Drove the 40 minutes and tried the dinner buffet tonight for the first time. It included chicken…read morestrips, potato wedge-like fries, and fried chicken legs (no wings, thighs, or breasts), salad bar, and of course, pizza. Pizza fare was the usual Pizza King styled pizza. Round pies cut into squares. 4-5 different pies at any one time. It was hot, cheese was melty, and the usual thin crust was on point. The chicken was so/so. It's a nice option, but not overwhelming. Legs weren't crispy, but had more of a softer skin layer. They were very large legs (bonus) and the place includes Buffalo, BBQ, and Texas Pete hot sauces. I was disappointed there was only a leg option and no other pieces. The tenders were the normal commercial tenders. Not bad, but not great. The wedge-like fries were terrific. Crispy, seasoned, and hot. Same sauce options as well as a cheese for dipping. A+ for this item. Strange that, instead of breadsticks, they had garlic bread as an option. I was hoping for breadsticks from a pizza place to along with the cheese sauce. The garlic bread seems out of place. Salad bar was decent. Fine array of toppings and three kinds of cheese (my personal favorite). Overall, I'd give them a 3.75 out of 5. Will I return, probably. But I'm not sure it's top of the list.

Service was amazing, so friendly and attentive. The food was fresh made and perfect temp. Might be…read moreworth a trip back to check out the lunch buffet. The only thing I noticed was it was a tad warm inside but it likely is due to the extreme high heat and ovens being used. Other than that, it was nice and clean. We took our order to go and enjoy at home. We'll be back!

Staff is very rude and unprofessional I used to order here all the time but anytime we're put on…read morehold they will make fun of you and laugh about what you're ordering. Definitely don't waste your time going here Chicagos is right down the street!

We just discovered Small Town a few months ago. They are our favorite local pizza shop, and they…read moredeliver. The pizza is good, subs are good. The sauce, crust, and cheese are all good! Employees are nice and friendly, wait time is always decent, and the parking is easy if you do pick up!

If you like cardboard with something that resembles Cheese, you might like this. Crust may be…read morepremade frozen, don't know for sure. But it is literally what I would imagine cardboard would taste like. Absolutely disgusting! Cheese is a very low grade product if in fact it's real cheese. Looks like plastic. Waited 1 hour and 24 minutes for this product. ( Not a pizza)

The pizza is very good and the family always likes when we order pick up from here. Also get…read moreexcellent service every time we order from this restaurant.

By far, THE BEST pizza in the Midwest, hands down!! (I…read moredon't want to offend many people by writing best pizza in the USA, but I DO say this to everyone I mention Magoo's to) My favorite is their classic Creamy Garlic Sauce Chicken Tikka Pizza...Zabiha Halal meat, generous toppings, top-notch quality ingredients and the most unique and heavenly white garlic sauce (Everything else on the menu is pretty yum too) Also, I must mention that eating it at the restaurant vs takeout makes an immense difference. Although the pizza sits well at room temp too and also after reheating (air fryer/toaster oven works better for pizza than microwave), eating it fresh and hot hits different, and totally melts in your mouth. If you haven't tried Magoo's pizza, you have NOT had great pizza at all.

The last review is not kidding, this is the best pizza in the Midwest! We've been eating here for…read more10 years and it's still my favorite pizza spot. The food is consistent, fresh, & the customer service is excellent at all of their locations. My go to pizza order is always the hand tossed, Garlic sauce, Chicken, & chopped jalapeños. Warning- if you try this pizza you will love it and so will all your friends. The combination is so flavorful, with the garlic sauce it's not spicy at all, even my grandma loves this pizza! Our second favorite is definitely the bbq chicken pizza, plenty of sauce & chicken. All of their pizzas are very filling, evenly spread toppings. Inside the store they have 6-8 tables, always a movie playing, great for families, and feels like home! Lastly, The house made ranch dressing deserves an honorable mention, I think the pizza is great as it is but the ranch is actually quite nice for dipping.