Food is delicious. They ice cream is yummy too. Just don't do delivery. It takes 2 plus hours 7 minutes away from restaurant.

It's just like the pizza in the mall...but better! Anthony's is tucked back by Heritage Lake and serves pizza by the slice or to order. They also have some spectacular looking calzones, subs, salads, etc. We ordered the pepperoni sticks and a 14" pepperoni pizza. The pizzas are large, great for feeding a family - 14" is actually the smallest size. Our pizza was slightly raw in the middle, it definitely needed more time in the oven. It was delicious, regardless. We loved the breadsticks with pepperoni in the middle as well. For a total of $27 we also got two fountain drinks. It took about 10 mins to get our order and we enjoyed playing darts while waiting. This looks like it would be a great place to grab a beer and watch the game. The staff is super friendly and I was surprised to see the young man in the back actually throwing the pizza dough. We are definitely going back! read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Pepperoni 14" - Pizza Near Me - Coatesville, Indiana

If you've tried their mozzarella sticks... Oh my God it's absolute heaven. I got the mozzarella sticks here thinking they're going to be average mozzarella sticks with some average marinara but when I took that first bite, OMG those were the best mozzarella sticks I've ever had in my life!! So I really recommend you to get the mozzarella sticks they're insanely crunchy but not the hard crunch where your teeth hurt, the cheese stays gooey and nice for a while but it's also not too hot. The marinara sauce pairs perfectly with the cheese and the breading, I absolutely recommend the best mozzarella sticks place which is Anthony's Pizza read more

Everything went Great....! Never Disappointed. Hot, Flavorful and Yummy‼ Our place for the times we don't want to Cook‼ read more

Food is always amazing! Service is always great! Would love if the TV's were always working rather than on with black screens

Always have been pleased with their pizzas and Calzones. Fast, tasty, fairly well priced. Definitely have gone back and will continue to go back. read more

They are absolutely amazing with there quality and quantity they have the most polite and generous employees. The food is always fresh and Hott and terrific. To sit inside or outside to eat is the cleanest and very private, the atmosphere is very relaxed and very positive... number #1 in my book,... please try it I guarantee that you will absolutely positively enjoy it!! read more

My go to is always there stuffed pizza slice. The marinara That comes with it amazing all is good delicious cheesy plenty of toppings. They've remodeled the old pizza Den and it is amazing what they done with it. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Stuff slice - Pizza Near Me - Coatesville, Indiana

See all

Great pizza slices , Stromboli's and pepperoni bredsticks followed by kind faces and great service !!

Great Pizza, Salads, Wings and service! Only negatives a little pricey and not open on Mondays or lunch During the week.

Love that they are so close to our house and have great food!! The best staff, always remember us.

This place has very friendly service and delicious pizza. We had the stuffed pizza and it was excellent!

Food is fresh and hot. Nice selection of items to choose from. Prices are a bit high for the portion size.

Have been ordering delivery from here for the last couple years and they are always hot fresh and delicious, now that they have a new store it makes dining in easier..highly recommend!!!! read more

Love the calzones wish they made Pepperoni only always pick the sausages out. Delicious Salads everything homemade. And they deliver

Outstanding! Appreciate the delivery service so much! Delivery driver polite & food arrives fresh and hot.

Top notch pizza and breadsticks! This is a casual pizza place with already made pizza they warm up as you order. Or you can order anything specific you want. The owner is so nice. Service is fast. Plenty of seating. read more

See all

Below average pizza, that I am pretty sure was made 2-3 hours prior to me picking it up.

Not really sure how to put into words how the food here tastes.....perfect, amazing, brilliant??? The Italian sub is so good. Add the pepperoni breadsticks to that and mannnnnn it's perfect. Of course have to get the slice of stuffed pizza, for later you know... love this place read more

Great scratch made dough! Garlic rolls are delicious! Wait for delivery is a bit long

We live the calzone and the garlic rolls are amazing. The prices are great and they deliver to our neighborhood in Danville. The meatball sandwich is also fantastic. The service is great as well. read more

We love Anthony's pizza! It's our place to go, close to home, great food, and great customer service. Rogelio and Braxton are usually up front every time my family and I go up there and they're always very pleasant to interact with! My husbands favorite is the philly cheese steak and mine is the wings and they have great salads!!! We highly recommend Anthony's. read more

In the state of Indiana, this place has (a) good pizza. I've only ever had the meat lovers deep dish. That's a 5 star pizza... I only give them 4 stars though because you can't pick your toppings. It's enough to feed 4 adults easy. I can't speak to the rest of the menu, but it's always crowded when I go there to pick mine up. read more

Travel to NY if you must, or stop by this gem. Traditional Italian/NY style Par baked pizza and Calzones. Stromboli is the best I've had this side of the Allegheny. Tvs, beer, nice atmosphere. Will be back often. Truly an Indiana gem! read more

I walked into this place 4 hours before they opened. Nick was working..... He invited me in for lunch anyways. After talking with him about the menu, he whipped up a very nice pasta dish that wasn't even on the menu ( it should be!) the place was very clean and the food was great! They have the normal soft drinks plus a selection of beer and wine. My only suggestion would be a nice house wine.......but not a bad place for the middle of nowhere read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - My awesome pasta dish - Pizza Near Me - Coatesville, Indiana

See all

Best Pizza in 4 counties. I like Anthony's so much that it makes me happy just to live nearby. This stuff is an excellent approximation of New York Pizza, and the larger salads are s very good value. The baked Ziti? It's the real deal. Anthony's is a good in the middle of the Indiana wastelands. I do like the pizza place in North Salem, but i give the edge to Anthony's for its excellent crust. read more

The Pizza is AMAZING! I love that they serve it by the slice whenever Im the only one eating. However there breadsticks.. leave something to be desired. (especially when they have a competitor right down the road with amazing breadsticks....) However its awesome that they deliver to the lake and they work with the kids in local schools to do discounts for club cards and such. I bought a club card JUST BECAUSE it had this resteraunt. Keep rockin the pizza! (but maybe update the breadsticks and the prices... :)) read more

Always such good food and friendly service I love going there to get food for the family taking it home and relax. Every time I go there I always leave satisfied quick place to get just a slice or a whole pizza I will definitely be back read more

Living in an area where we don't have a lot of options for restaurants, and no options for pizza delivery, my family was happy to see Anthony's come to the neighborhood. They are set up and operate very much like a Luca pizza, where they have there ovens ready all day so they can throw in a slice on demand. Although I believe the food tastes better than a Luca. They have a full menu of fresh pizzas, pastas, salads and appetizers. The restaurant is very clean and the staff are very friendly. The owner is very personable. The prices are reasonable and they often offer coupons in the mail. My family has eaten at Anthony's, dine-in, carry-out and delivery, numerous times since they opened. My personal favorite, as well as the favorite of several of my friend's, is just the cheese pizza. People also rave about their stromboli (or meat stuffed pocket pizza, can't remember the name). We have always gotten quick service. And quick delivery when we choose that option. In the summers, when it's boating season, drivers are happy to meat you at the Heritage Lake marina so you don't even have to leave your boat for a meal. This has come in very handy when we are out with friends and we all pitch in and get several pizzas on a hot summer night. The only reason I chose to give 4 stars instead of 4 is because I have a special diet and have received the wrong order a few times. For example, pepperoni instead of plain breadsticks. Not good when you have vegetarians in the house. And cheese sent instead of marinara with the breadsticks. These details really are important. However, Anthony's does have great food and they do a great job. It's been almost a year since they have had the run of mixed up items on our orders. I definitely recommend. read more

Fast, polite service. Very tasty food. This is our new go to pizza place. They deliver and have a good variety, including pizza, calzones, subs, salad, pasta, and beer. The restaurant was clean as well. read more

Stopped in with a friend last night after a business call. Pluses- fast friendly staff, the place is clean as a pin. Quick service. Negatives- you can't pick your toppings on slices. 3 pices + 2 drinks $15. And the sauce has a spice that hurts my stomach. But as I've stated before, pizza is a local thing and it's what you grew up liking when you were young. But for me it's A-OK. read more

Kind of like what you'd get in a mall. The toppings are good and so are the portions but the crust needs work

Pizza great!! The guy fixed us a pizza just 10 minutes before closing time!! He was actually nice even when we ordered last minute!

CLUELESS!!! I asked if they had any specials...she said they had an 18" 2-topping and 2 orders of breadsticks for twenty something dollars...I said GREAT I'll take that, give me that I want pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms on half and just cheese on the other half...she said both halves have to be the same...I said "then you don't get my business"...she said "that's fine"...they didn't get my business!!! read more

I grew up in New York, and since moving out here in 2002, I had missed the New York pizza I grew up with. When I moved to Coatesville and discovered Anthony's, I was so excited to taste what I had been missing. Anthony's has real NY pizza, and even if you aren't in Coatesville, it's worth the drive. (I think they have another location, too.) Plus, they deliver! The staff is always friendly and quick to offer the current deals. Best pizza I have found in Indiana, hands down. read more