This was our first time visiting Overpass Pizza and we were so surprised! It's in an unassuming little building - off the beaten path. When we arrived we were seated right away but it was buzzing with locals and pick ups (good sign, right?!) We really enjoyed looking at all of the local memorabilia on the walls and our service was EXCELLENT! The woman that served our table was very friendly, upbeat, and knew exactly how to take care of her guests. Our food came out very quickly and we enjoyed all of it. We had the 12" thin crust pepperoni pizza and some garlic bread. Next time we'd like to try either the deep dish or some of the house special pizzas. I was pretty shocked to see that our total was over $45 for the 12" pizza, bread, and two drinks with tip. But really everything else made it worth it. And we got a slice of the most delicious almond cake on the way out for free - score! read more

Overpass Pizza - 12" thin crust pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covington, Indiana

See all

7/5 stars...yes, it's that good!! Dad was visiting in Lafayette, and wanted to try something new. Found this gem, listed as one of the best pizza places in Indiana, and I was NOT let down. Pros - Service- Our two waitresses who were working and helping all the tables were amazing! Friendly, joking, amazing. - Food- I order a personal meat (thin crust), app of breadsticks, and my Dad got the pepperoni pizza sandwich. All were amazing! Hot, fresh, tons of toppings, and very affordable. - Atmosphere- The atmosphere was great. Fun and had a few funny signs (see below). While this place is small, it is friendly, good, and we'll worth checking out, no matter where you are! Cons None read more

See all

So happy they are in diving distance from us because the pizza is amazing. Love the crust, great flavors! Definitely a must try!

My first time eating here, it was a good experience. We got 14" half sausage, half sausage & pepperoni thin crust pizza. We also got breadsticks and pan sauce and garlic sauce. Me and hubby enjoyed it. I personally am not a fan of thin crust or Chicago style pizza. So next time I think I'll order one of the subs/sandwiches. We also got there 40 minutes before close, ordered after getting our drinks, got our order pretty quickly and ate and still left 3 minutes before close. The server and staff was pretty nice, they didn't have an attitude about us getting there kinda late, so we appreciated it. read more

Overpass Pizza - Breadsticks, pan sauce, garlic sauce - Pizza Near Me - Covington, Indiana

See all

Amazing pizza and service. Everyone that comes through the door is treated like a friend. This place is a local gem.

Let's start with the food. I have been eating pizza my whole life. I have wanted to come here for years. I regret not. This is the best pizza I have had in a long time. The bread sticks were delicious. The pizza sauce was fresh. The dough was fresh. The cheese was real. They have fresh ground red pepper. I have been wanting that for years. They even sell red pepper grinders. The service was great. Very Good hard working People. Give them your business. I deeply regret not coming sooner. read more

food was amazing, almost as amazing as the waitress! someone slide her my ig for real nonetheless the service and friendliness of the entire place was amazing and if i'm ever back in Indiana I'll definitely be stopping by again! read more

Overpass Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covington, Indiana

EXCELLENT!!! Wasn't expecting much when we pulled up and even after walking in, but the pizza was very good as were the calzones!

I was very happy to find this little piece of Italy in the mid west. Great food very busy like all good places they are short staffed but good thing come to those who wait read more

Pro tip-they have thin and thick crust. If you like thick get the thin crust sauce. They have different sauces. Thick crust sauce is sweet. Place is small and usually packed and smoky. Decent beer selection read more

While the pizza is great, I am in love with their sandwiches. The Stromboli and the Quigley are the best. Rates as one of the best pizzerias in the state. We live two-three hours away, we have friends in the area, we visit at least once a month, and we always stop when we are traveling through on I-74. read more

This place has really good food, but the waiting time is ridiculous. We have been waiting for over 45 minutes for one thin crust pizza. Plus, our waitress looked sort of intoxicated. I'm not going to jump the gun and say she was but she looked like something was up. read more

Their pizza sauce is amazing. If you get the deep dish order it with extra sauce, so it doesn't seem dry. Generous toppings and friendly employees. Do yourself a favor and order their wings. The chicken wings are even better than their pizza. read more

A must stop along the I-74 corridor! Growing up in IL one becomes distinctly aware of the nuances and variations of pizza along the crust spectrum (from a Monical's ultra-thin to a Chicago-style deep-dish). Friends described Overpass as the Indiana version of Monical's, referring to the thin crust, family salad and "red dressing". Overpass however deserves its own merit. The ultra-thin crust pizza with toppings edge to edge has a hint more seasoning than one gets across the state line, making it noteworthy and different. In fact, you forget all about the allure of red dressing as you impatiently grab another deicious square. Dining in you can enjoy the unique qualities of Hoosier rustic decor along with a cold beverage or if your blessed enough to be staying local have their friendly delivery staff bring every bit of the deliciousness to your door. read more

Really awesome bbq chicken pizza, especially if you add on their homemade blue cheese dressing (the bbq sauce is homemade too). There are two options for crust style - thin crust or Chicago pan. We went for the thin crust based on all the rave reviews and even though we don't normally like that style, I have to say it was really good! We did see a table get the other type of crust and that looked great too. Be sure to hit the ATM before you stop here though. It's cash only. read more

Overpass Pizza - Happy harvest menu and cash register area. Love the old timey feel! - Pizza Near Me - Covington, Indiana

What??! Was totally blown away by this place. Pulled over looking for a quick meal, and got even more. In and out in 25 minutes, the pizza was great and the service was as well. They also sell Brown County wine, so I ordered a glass of my favorite, the blackberry wine. So sweet, so good. WILL BE BACK! read more

Don't let the outside fool you! Overpass has amazing pizza! Their thin-crust pizza is the best. Also, you MUST try their french dressing when you go. It is so good I even dip my pizza in it! Also, they have wine and other things from a couple different wineries. I love that I can get Brown County wine there. If you are in and need cooled off, ask for a wine slushy. You won't regret it! read more

This was one of my favorite places growing up. Being from a small town, there weren't many places to pick from but this was always my first choice. The outside looks rough, but on the inside it is cozy and feels like home. Whenever we come back to visit, we try and make a stop here. Their salad is great, and I love their ranch & french dressings here. I'm partial to thin crust pizza, so that is what I would pick, but their deep dish pizza is good too. For years they only took cash or check, but they are now taking cards as well! read more

The best pizza anywhere. I have been here many times and it's always wonderful. It's in a tiny building that is often full because the locals know it's the best. Great service and the best pizza. Give it a try. read more

Covington's best pizza, no contest. One of the best in the area. Great crust, flavorful sauce and toppings, and delicious sides and salads. Hard to get a spot to eat at inside, but if you carry out it's just as delicious at home. read more

By FAR the BEST pizza in the area. Overpass has excelled where Monical's has made missteps. I love Monical's, but since the corporate nerd pencil pushers made Monical's REDUCE the amount of ingredients (less cheese, cheaper sausage, etc.), Overpass has taken the lead by pursuing the better, independent, old fashioned approach with lower prices and MORE ingredients. Monical's is a close second but Overpass is #1. Moreover, Overpass is in the top two BEST pizzas I've ever eaten and I've had pizza all over the map. read more

Favorite local pizza place! Their thin crust is amazing but I'm a sucker for the thick crust. They don't skimp on toppings and the food is always hot and fresh. If you're dining in, enjoy the awesome staff, a cold beer ( or specialty soda) and fun, kitschy atmosphere. If you're already in your PJs have one of their friendly drivers deliver it. Our little community is lucky to have this iconic restaurant! read more

I liked the curb appeal and the inside, somewhat. But to get to the restroom, you gotta walk through the kitchen. And everything appeared dirty and filthy. The pizza was ok, and salad was just fresh lettuce with cheese. Not too impressive. Good service, but would not go back. read more

Very good home cooked pizza garlic bread is outstanding this was our first visit and will definitely be back!!!

Should be on you buck list of food experiences... When it comes to pizza joints, they are a dime a dozen it seems like anymore; but this place is the Creme De Le Creme...don't be fooled by location, the rustic old building or the size; this place is a sleeper.... it's Awesome, with a side of Awesome.... great staff; very prompt and polite; hometown treatment to all even if it's your first time there and not from area; have had everything on menu over the last few years from the lunch specials to the pizza and sandwiches on menu... and can honestly say everything has been the best; When working in area eat lunch there as often as possible and my crew always is happy to take lunch on days if we go here.. then wife and kids find out I went there for lunch and at end of day before leaving area to head home, I have to go back to order take out to take home for family and then I get to have for dinner which still is great because it like going to a doubler hitter for the World Series of pizza joints.... worth the drive and never a disappointment....Highly recommend to all.... read more

Warning: Cash only. Super good and fast. We has three different thin crust pizzas. Lots of people going through. Near freeway for easy on/easy off. Dirt parking lot and beatuo deco, but that's all part of it. read more

Best pizza for many, many miles. Always tasty, plenty of toppings, and you never leave hungry. Great family place. They have a few draft beer as well as bottles. Small place, sometimes ya gotta take it home. read more

My sister lives in Champaign. I'm in Indianapolis. We were looking for a place in between to meet up for dinner. Was pleasantly surprised by Overpass Pizza. It's a 'hole in the wall' joint, but has a warm atmosphere and pretty good food. read more

Surprisingly tasty pizzeria in a surprisingly nifty old building. Cracker thin crust with burnt cheese stuck the bottom. Perfect. Try the pepperoni with Rail Splitter IPA. read more

Overpass Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covington, Indiana

Charming atmosphere and superb pizza. Look out, Monicals pizza. You have serious competition!!

Great service. Staff was polite and courteous. Pizza was hot and wonderful. We will be back.

Me and my best friend where on our way home from Chicago and where craving some pizza! This hole in the wall really surprised us. The Pop isn't all that good but we got some garlic bread as an appetizer and it was really good. We got a Chicago style pizza and it was really good!!!! I would suggest it if you are driving through the area! Customer service was decent, pizza took a little longer than we had hopped was worth the wait! read more

Normally a decent place for a slice if you're in town. However, dont call for delivery on Friday nights. Placed my order literally at 5:38 pm, food arrived at 7:37. Very dissatisfied at this point. On a high note, Clay, the delivery driver is a righteous (cool) dude! read more

Pizza was great and the waitress was phenomenal (minus being a cubs fan).

We got a Chicago style with breadsticks. The pizza was great. The sauce is a bit sweet, which is a good thing IMO. They certainly separate themselves from the crowd with their delicious and unique taste. Highly recommend them!! read more

Very good thin crust pizza, friendly employees and easy going atmosphere. Excellent road trip stop! The blue cheese dressing is for real.

We prefer to drive from Danville to eat pizza here! It's the best! We do wish they would get a bigger place as it can get really crowded inside and you feel rushed. read more

This place is great! I am giving it four stars based on two not so great experiences. First off...again, this place is great. The pizza, wings, breadsticks and salad are all great. It is reasonably priced and worth it. It is a little place so seating can be a little crowded, but oh well. Now, for the two not so great experiences. 1. We drive to and from KY on a regular basis and try to time it so we can stop here on our way home. We knew we would be running late so we called ahead with our order. Told them what we wanted and how far out we were. We told them we would like our pizza ready when we got there, because it was going to be cutting it close. When we arrived, the pizza wasn't even in the oven yet. Not super happy about that. 2. We drove an hour to eat here for my sister's birthday. When you google the restaurant, the hours show up. We planned on meeting at 1 IL time because according to google, the place would be open. After our hour drive and my sisters 45 minute drive, we showed up to a closed restaurant. We ended up having Monicals instead. Definitely not the same! Make sure you call for hours before driving there. Overall it is a great place!! read more