Pizza was cooked perfectly, crust was homemade and flaky. Toppings were generous and evenly distributed and the cheese was cooked to a perfect golden brown. Staff was friendly, service was incredibly fast , the pizza was served only 10 minutes after being seated. Clean establishment and reasonable prices, highly recommend! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Chicken bacon ranch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cloverdale, Indiana

Probably the worst service I've had in years. Only two waitresses on a Friday night who were expected to take care of everyone from seating, drinks, cleaning, paying-- everything. Even though they were both trying their best, our server was lacking in many areas. When ordering our chicken Alfredo pizza the response we got was "we don't have Alfredo anymore" but no suggestions were made. After evaluating the menu we asked if a garlic Parmesan base could be substituted. "People do that all the time!" Pizza was pretty decent, but hard to finish without refills. Probably won't be back at this location anytime soon. read more

Great service. Good pizza. Handled a large group. We had a couple drinks and took our pizza to go.

Our local Chicago Pizza is AWESOME!!! Quality food for quality pricing and the BEST people serving you! Establishment is very clean and welcoming! This stop is a must for all. It does out-shine any other Chicago Pizza's I have ever been to by far! FIVE STAR FOR SURE! read more

Did not see away to order on line so had to do an actual old school phone call. Very friendly Young lady answered the phone and took my order. Order didn't take long at all. They have a drive up window for order pick up. Love it!! Employee at the window was wearing a mask. Pizza very cheesy. Something had a bit of a Smokey flavor it may have been the sausage. Good topping coverage. The breadsticks were fluffy and good. They could have been better with garlic butter or if they had some salt on them. But they were still good. Great choice for pizza in the area. They aren't the cheapest choice in town. Two pizzas two orders of breadsticks right at 50$ read more

See all

We stopped at Chicago's in Cloverdale and were seriously impressed. The food was SO good, way better than we expected for a random stop. Everything we had was hot, fresh, and super tasty. Kenzi, our server. She was amazing, super friendly, on top of everything, and just made the whole experience even better. read more

Our deep dish was delicious!! And the kids loved their pizza also. Great find. Thank you from California.

Was driving through and had dog in the car. Asked how long and was told 15-20 min to get traditional pizza. Was very busy and they were short staffed. The people working there were so nice and were hustling! Very pleased with pizza and salad. Awesome customer service and people so friendly!! read more

Their Food is always fresh - love their pepperoni stuffed breadsticks & regular breadsticks. Delicious! definitely recommended!

It was good but I wish they would start putting the sauce on top again. It is an amazing memory from childhood but when I asked them to do it at the Cloverdale location they refused stating that if they were to do that the cheese wouldn't melt. Now I'm not the most pizza savvy but it stands to reason if that is a known issue one could cook it a little longer. Missing the old days David Finchum read more

The service was a little too good as the waitress came by every 5 minutes to make sure everything was OK. Yeah I know but it can get annoying. But anyway the reason for one less star was the garlic cheese bread was rather tasteless. How do you make garlic tasteless? But the pizza (I had the thin crust) was really good. read more

The most awesome deep dish pizza we have had in a long time!!! No pizza like this back in Georgia.

Icy cold bee, crispy crust pizza and delicious garlic bread. What more could a girl want?! read more

See all

Solid. Deep dish is really good and by far the best pizza around. We recently had one of the highest rated pizzas from a restaurant in Brooklyn a month ago... and Chicago's deep dish is better. Price could be lower but it's reasonable considering how much better it is than the fast food pizza places out here. read more

Review from a local. The food here is fine. It's the service that needs improvement. Over the last few years I've dined here occasionally and I cannot say that I've had a server here who seemed genuinely happy to work here. Here is what happened on my most recent visit. I was sat at a table that was apparently supposed to be clean. I had to move the my plate and wrapped silverware off the table because it was sitting in the former patrons dried pizza sauce and crumbs. I was told Ashley would be right over to take my order. Meanwhile, I waited looking at a dirty table, wishing I had a menu to look at. Another group came in and sat at the booth next to me. They were also told Ashley would be right over to take their order. A few minutes later Ashley did come over. Except Ashley began taking the order of the patrons who came in after me. I got up and left and came across the street to the fantastic Mexican restaurant I eat at weekly and the service and food was spectacular as usual. read more

Ordered a supreme pizza and it was poor at best. There were very little of each ingredient smothered with cheese. It was disappointing

Stopped in for some 'za and it was ok. We tried the traditional but thought it could have had more flavor. Ironically, the salad bar was the star of the show. Everything was fresh and there were quite a few options. Service was very good. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Very nice dining room. - Pizza Near Me - Cloverdale, Indiana

I pulled off of route 70, on my way home and decided to try this place because I've never known any one from the area (and i have lived here 28 years) who favors it. No one considers it their go to Pizza. I wondered why. Here's why: disconnected management. Directionless wait staff. No recommendation for what to try. No enthusiasm for the product., it was as if having a pizza at 4 PM were a puzzle to everybody who worked there. The pizza that came out, while buried in a senseless blizzard of cheese, was the wrong one. I asked them to put it in a to-go box, watched as the owner manager rolled her eyes. I paid, tipped and left without so much as a sorry. Good soft drinks though. Just like the ones from a machine at a motel you were forced to move into. Try the pizza at Bridges in Greencastle instead or Anthony's in Groveland for the best of the local pizzaverse. read more

Ah this place brings back so many memories of my teenage years. I remember always thinking they were delicious, but never really grasping how cool it was to have a tasty local pizza place right in our backyard. I always thought; I like them, but I think I will just go to Greencastle and get Pizza Hut or Papa Johns instead. It was only in my later years, did I come back and eat here more often when I visited. Those chain places get old pretty fast. The pizza here is always really good and the service is always great. I wouldn't really call this a Chicago style pizza per say. I would just label it a tasty pie to all of my friends. The pizza is always cheesy and yummy, the sauce is zest, and the toppings taste pretty fresh. I've been around the block when it comes to pizza, so I wouldn't really call it pricey per say, but just be prepped to buy a whole pie. read more

Amazing pizza! Best I have had in a very long time. Skyline was to die for delicious!!

The customer service is awful The manager LOTZ as she spelled it out to us was rude. All we wanted was to know why we ordered pepperoni pizzas (2) and we got cheese. I live to far away to drive back and she was absolutely awful. read more

Always good pizza, bring back your old business hours and lunch buffet. Have to wait until 3:00 to place an order. It was the only good place to eat in this town. read more

Hadn't been in a really long time, it's a small drive for us. We happened to be playing a football game against their local school. Stopped there for dinner and everything was great. read more

Not too shabby for pizza in Cloverdale. We were craving some pizza and had never been here. We ordered the deep dish. It's not super deep, deep dish pizza (more like a thick hand toss) but it was yummy none the less. We ordered ground beef as a topping and had no complaints. Prices are average for pizza, pretty affordable for the amount of food. The breadsticks look amazing. I regretted not ordering them, but had to save room for pizza. The noise level is higher here. It's all open dining room with tables and metal chairs that drag loudly on the floor and you sit fairly close to people, so certainly not a quiet, romantic, have a private conversation sort of place. Everything was clean and staff were friendly. read more

Delicious! This is not true Chicago deep dish pizza--so as long as you know that up front you will not be disappointed. The breadsticks were very good but the sticks themselves are plain no garlic butter or parm on them. The deep dish pizza is somewhat similar to pizza hut pan but the crust is superior. The best thing is that you can tell the cheese is of premium quality and it goes over the crust! You know how you always have those dry ends of crust? Not here cheese over it! Every bite is delicious. A large 1 topping was $15 and a great price for the amount and quality. Also the dipping pizza sauce was really good. Very flavorful. Sad there aren't any north of Indy where I am from! read more

Chicago's Pizza - Deep dish pizza cheese and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Cloverdale, Indiana

I've now ordered from Chicago's pizza three times. Two times we ate in, once was takeout. My advice to you, is to order take out, no matter what time of day or day of the week it is. The food is 5 star! So good. But the service is not. Both times we ate in, they didn't bring me my salad but still charged me for it when I reminded them... AFTER we got the pizza. Zilch on refills, and I saw several people getting up to get their own. The breadsticks came out about (literally) thirty seconds before the pizza and they were cold. When we brought up why we didn't get our salad or breadsticks, the waitress (who I'm pretty sure is the manager because she marches around bitching about other employees loud enough for customers to hear) said that she thought someone else had already brought them to us. I'd never leave a review like this based on a busy Friday or Saturday night. We ate there on a slow Tuesday, and on a busy Friday. The service was the same both times. Just do yourself a favor and order takeout read more

Not my first time here, but it's definitely gone downhill. Stopped in for the lunch buffet.. Walked in just after Noon, so I assumed the buffet would be ready for some kind of lunch crowd. I was wrong. The salad bar was full, but the lettuce was the shredded type you would put on a sandwich. Not bad, but not what I would expect. Overall the salad bar was nice with a good selection of toppings. The pizza buffet had 4 slices, not pizzas, slices. They also looked like they had been there for a bit. Over the time I ate, there was no more than 2 pizzas out at a time. The fresh pizza was pretty good. The breadsticks are pretty good along with the cheese sauce. That being said, they must be fully cooked to be good. The first batch when I got there was fine. The second batch came out while I was waiting for fresh pizza and still had raw dough in the middle. I explained this to the staff who was pulling another batch out of the oven. At this point you would assume they would remove the older (not cooked) breadsticks. Wrong, they dumped them right on top. So I grab a new one, open it up.. Raw dough again.. Seriously.. I jut told you that they weren't cooked through, and you didn't bother to maybe check the next batch?? Overall I enjoy Chicago's Pizza, but this will probably be my last trip to this location. I can tell by the scarce lunch crowd that others have given up too.. Gave two stars (being generous) because the pizza was good and salad bar was nice, but the breadsticks and lack of selection defeat the purpose of the pizza buffet. Spending half your lunch break waiting on a new pizza is ridiculous. The location could also use a full remodel to look like other locations and not feel so dirty. read more

Staff was really friendly. Food was excellent, and ready when they said it would be. Not overpriced at all.

Chicago's pan pizza is best anywhere! It takes a few minutes but it's worth the wait. Their breadsticks are awesome as well. Great service friendly staff I'll be back. read more

Rude and disrespectful. Beware if you go inside to be seated during a busy timeframe... staff will let you know they are busy and you will have to wait add your name to any wait list. So the place next door is highly recommended if you are looking for a good place to eat. read more

Stopped in on a Saturday evening with 5 hungry kids. The ticket got "lost", they dropped it on the floor. We waited there for an hour, no food. Granted, they were fairly busy but the waitress walked by our table 15 times and didn't notice we still hadn't received our order. I would like to say the pizza was great but after an hour and 15 minutes, we left. The breadsticks were good. The waitress was understanding when I expressed my frustration. read more

We ordered the Skyline. It was delicious! We also got the salad bar. There was a pasta salad on it made with poppy seed dressing. We all were impressed with that salad. Our server, Lindsey, was very nice and helpful. Nice experience all around. read more

After reading reviews we thought we would try it. New York style pizza it wasn't. Salad bar really wasn't that good either. Not much to choose from. Not a bad place but I've had better. read more

If you're looking for Chicago style pizza, go elsewhere because this isn't it. That being said, the pizza was good. We had the buffet which had salad and breadsticks as well. The breadsticks are really good and they had individual cups of cheese and marinara. Salad bar was good as well. Service was decent and would definitely try again if in the area. read more

Good pizza, good salad bar, new bathrooms, clean, friendly staff. Best place if you are driving along 70 and find yourself needing to eat in Cloverdale. read more

The pizza was fantastic we had the skyline deep dish and it was absolutely fa nominal it had plenty of flavor and had plenty of toppings the service was fantastic the Waitress Madi was fantastic she not only did her job well she did it with a smile she checked up on us every so often not to much but not too less the service was fantastic. It was a great place to eat and I recommend it to anyone who is a fan of great pizza for a good price. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Deep dish skyline - Pizza Near Me - Cloverdale, Indiana

I heard multiple people tell me that this is the best pizza in the area and I had to come check it out for myself. I pulled off of Route 70 and Chicago's was conveniently located within a half a mile from the highway. When I entered the restaurant, I noticed how clean and up to code this establishment is. I was greeted by a very friendly and accommodating staff. My waitress recommended that I try the 'Skyline' pizza. What a great recommendation this was. The pizza came out buried in a blizzard of ooey-gooey deliciousness. Perfect amount of toppings and cheese to compliment the crispy and flavorful homemade crust. Additionally, my soft drink was ice cold and never dropped below half-full, as my waitress was determined to make my experience the best it could be. I recommend this pizza/restaurant to anyone who is looking for excellent eats and excellent service. Chicago's definitely lives up to the hype and I will be back! read more

Their pizza is so good! It's not deepdish with the tall crust to fill in with toppings, but they still manage to fit everything on there anyway! Another reviewer said to ask them to go easy on the cheese...but that's the best part! They also have really, really cold beer. I was really surprised at the quality of the meal for a small town place such as this. read more

Great service and great food. Beer is super frosty mugs...can't beat it! Whenever in the area, we're from Cali, we'll be back!

Chicago's Pizza is a three to four star restaurant and a solid stop for pizza between St. Louis and Indianapolis. The food and atmosphere are better than the outside facade would indicate. The decor feels like a 1970's pizzeria with walls adorned almost totally in wood paneling. I would say, there is a good chance, the building was previously a Rax at some point in it's lifetime. They have pepsi products and the mountain dew was delicious. I didn't partake in the salad bar, but it appeared to be better stocked than your typical pizzeria salad bar. Breadsticks were good and the pizza was okay, not amazing, but good enough for a small chain store that is basically in the middle of nowhere. Also the service was excellent. Our server was helpful, personable, efficient, and made our experience as pleasant as possible. If you are in the area, I would check it out. If it's not conveniently located along the way wherever you are going, I probably wouldn't make a special trip to go here. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Salad bar and seating. - Pizza Near Me - Cloverdale, Indiana

See all