Mombar is not the same as it used to be, and I'm not sure if it's because the chef is going senile or if he's skimping on spices and salt or just being racist toward us Asians by making the food more bland (which is kind of silly, but I'm trying to think of reasons for why the quality has declined). I used to trek here from Columbia University with my then-boyfriend between 2008-2010 all the time-- for holidays, for special occasions, for birthdays, everything. I took my NYC dental school friends here on a Friday night (5/16/2014) in the pouring rain and tried to rehash those bygone days of made-to-order Egyptian gastronomic grandeur, but it fell wayyy way short of my (and their) expectations. I felt so bad talking Mombar up to my friends and then having us trek out from NYC and even New Jersey just to be completely, utterly disappointed. I'm not complaining that the food took hours to come out-- if the food had been as good as it used to be, that's forgiveable since I am patient and will wait for great food. I don't think the issue is that there were too many diners, either, as the tables were barely filled when our party of four arrived and ordered. No, the issue at the core is the huge decline in quality.
Let's start with the complimentary za'atar and phyllo. Comparing it to 4 years ago, the za'atar was missing something. Salt? Umami? Magical egyptian herb? I don't know, but it didn't wow me like it used to. First warning sign.
Next, we ordered 2 appetizers for the table-- grilled red and golden beets, and the quail with quail eggs. The grilled beets were just OK, but the quail was not flavorful (again, missing salt?!) and worst of all, it was really dry. This was not how the quail used to be cooked.
For our entrees, I spoke lovingly to my friends about how the glazed molasses duck was DA BOMB from my memories years ago. It used to be so good and flavorful, with amazing crispy skin, tender meat, and just enough fatty bits to please this Asian foodie used to fattier cuts of pork and whatnot. It also used to be bursting with so much flavor that my dinner companion and I used to eat it for my meal, then order another one for take-out to enjoy it for lunch the next day at home. This was probably the most upsetting part. On my recommendation 2 of my friends ordered the same entree-- but I, knowing that I used to substitute the spinach that normally accompanies this entree for these amazing roasted mixed vegetables with the most fantastic blend of spices and sumac-- decided to again substitute the spinach for these "mixed vegetables" in the same manner as I used to request 4 years ago. And what I got in return was simply unacceptable. The 3 duck entrees that were served were dry, tasteless (again, why no salt?? Why no spices?? I come to this establishment to experience the fantastic flavors that Egyptian and middle eastern cuisine is famous for!), and even the duck did not seem to be of the same quality as in the past. I have no doubt that the duck was still glazed in molasses, but it did not have the proper blend of salty, sweet, and umami that the chef used to master. I'm sorry to say, but, I could have ordered better roasted duck at a Chinese supermarket for $5 and I paid $19 for this entree. I barely finished half my entree because it was simply inedibly dry and flavorless. The biggest shock, however, came in the form of the "mixed vegetables" that I substituted for the spinach. These mixed vegetables literally came out in a watery, flavorless mess that consisted of frozen carrots, corn, and peas. What?!? To add insult to injury, when the chef came out from behind his kitchen to ask us how the food was (just as he used to) I had to tell him the truth by telling him that the food is not as good as I remember and inquired why the mixed vegetables in particular were reheated frozen vegetables and not the wonderful grilled veggies with sumac that he used to do (Please see my photo of the lamb chops under "Tian H" from 2009 to see a pic of these grilled veggies to get a better idea of what they used to be like), and he gave me the lame answer of: "Oh, the sumac roasted vegetables? I cannot serve those vegetables with that dish, it is not appropriate." Oh, is that right? I guess it was appropriate 4 years ago, but not anymore? Well, maybe the chef or the waiter should have said so when I asked them to please substitute the spinach side for the mixed vegetable side that I specifically said was what I used to request in years past. What??
In closing, before I get too upset or bitter about this complete and utter letdown on 5/16/14, I cannot recommend Mombar to any person who might be thinking of revisiting this establishment because they have had great memories from years ago. Even if you are thinking of trying this establishment for the first time, there are so many other great Egyptian and Middle Eastern restaurants in Astoria that there is no reason to waste your time. read more