My husband and I happened to stumble upon the Mohegan Diner...and, we were pleasantly surprised. It seemed unassuming but it exceeded our expectations in every way. Imagine the best waitress you ever had (warm, helpful, and attentive)--that was Donna, terrific food (we both had the lunch special lentil soup and half a ruben), and we split tiramisu. The owner even came by and gave us some tips on which dessert to order (his wife makes them all). The food was amazing. We will definitely go back next time we are up that way. read more

I love this Diner food is always good. The service is great plus the owners make you feel like family. They remember our names and its just a nice place to eat . The bathrooms are very clean . The diner is clean just love this diner read more

Service was food. Husband ordered an hamburger. It came plain- no lettuce or tomato. Wasn't offered a pickle or coleslaw to go with it. Servers should bring the food as requested. read more

HORRIBLE customer service from the waitress being rude and unpleasant to the woman at the front desk (Short dark hair) being beyond rude. Unfortunate to say but very disappointing!!! read more

The food is always great! The wait staff is amazing! It's our good too place when we visit our daughter in Yorktown Heights, NY!!

Just had the tiramisu cake for desert and it was the best that I have ever tasted. The baker was on vacation and returned this week, we had the strawberry cheesecake yesterday which was also to die for. read more

Great, classic diner! Exactly what you're looking for in a diner. Great family restaurant!

The food was at or below mediocre--the tuna in the wrap was good, the side of "turkey sausage" looked more like kielbasa that may have been cut up to make it look like there was more on the plate. It was warm when it was brought out and down to room temperature about half way through the meal. Now, for the "nickeling and diming"! There was an extra charge for "lettuce and tomato," and avocado, and to substitute egg whites for whole eggs, and to use a credit card. While I do not have an issue, in general, with the idea of charging extra for "extras." For the amount they charged for the lettuce and tomato, and the avocado, they could have purchased a whole head of lettuce, a whole tomato, and a whole avocado. If you need to or want to raise your prices, raise them. Please do not "nickel and dime" us. Credit cards are as convenient for vendors as they are for customers. If you do not want to pay the credit card fees, do not take credit cards. I would expect an immediate and precipitous drop in your revenue, more than what you would be paying in credit card fees. A lunch consisting of diner fare for four adults and a child cost over $100. If I had known this sooner, I would have went to one of the other "finer" restaurants in the area. I hope that this enables others to make more informed dining choices. read more

French toast was burnt on one side, no sign that any egg was used just slice of brioche thrown on a grill where onions and peppers were cooked. the French toast tasted like onions!!! steer clear of this diner, they can't make something as basic as French toast. read more

Prices here have gone comically high. They're charging high end restaurant prices for basic diner food. I understand inflation caused some price increases to cover costs, but this is pure price gouging. This used to be my favorite diner in the area, and this review brings me no joy, but their prices are wildly overpriced. Sadly I won't be eating here till they fix their overpriced menu. read more

I've been going to this diner since I'm a kid and I've always loved it every time I've gone! Some of my favs are the southwest pancake wrap, chicken fingers, and the Mohegan wrap! Their ranch is the BEST. read more

Mohegan Diner - a grilled cheese and bacon sandwich - Diners Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

See all

Went here yesterday in between a sad event with my family. We called ahead, as we were a party of 20, and we were accommodated right away. We sat in 2 separate tables, but that was okay. Restaurant was clean, and overall not that crowded. Our Server was awesome, and accommodated us promptly with drinks. Some of us ordered alcohol, some of us ordered sodas like i ordered a root beer, and most of us were fine with just water. Now, a little bit of a mess up was that i finished my root beer, but instead of asking if i wanted a root beer, they just refilled it with water. it is fine tho, as water is the best thing for your body anyways. I ordered the short stack of pancakes, which was big, and i didn't even finish, but it was good. The other portions of everything else was also somewhat big, which is good. overall enjoyed this place. only con is that the food was a bit pricey. read more

Picture this: It's 3 AM in New York, you and your boyfriend just saw a movie of questionable quality starring Dennis Quaid (it shall remain nameless, but it involves a house and a lawn mower), and you're craving ice cream. Everywhere is closed, but this craving is REAL. What's a girl to do? Enter Mohegan Diner, to the rescue for all of our late night ice cream binges! I cannot speak with authority on anything at Mohegan other than the fantastic and huge banana split, which comes to the table in all its rustic 1950s soda shop charm, complete with three massively heaping scoops of chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry ice cream, piles of whipped cream, cherries, bananas, and chocolate sauce. All this for the low, low price of $7.95?! It's a miracle! Coupled with the fun and sassy service you know and love from a proper New York diner plus clean booths and no one who gives you any issues with just ordering ice cream at 3:30 AM, and you have a recipe that keeps us coming back for more. So the next time the wee hours roll around and you're looking for a late night snack without breaking the bank... Mohegan Diner is the place to go! read more

The Mohegan Diner is the definition of a sweet diner in a Big 'small town'. The food is always delicious, but what keeps me and everyone I know coming back is their staff. The waitstaff, the management and even the bidders are all so sincere, fun and are just plain happy to be there! Full of laughs always! Thank you- Mohegan Diner for being such a staple of our community that is near and dear to all of our hearts :) read more

Every time I come here I leave thinking why why WHY did I come back? The staff is always friendly - that's the only thing keeping them from getting 1 star. Our waitress was very playful with y 18 month old which gets her brownie points. The food has really gone downhill from years ago. I ordered a fried egg n cheese on a roll ... It came out cooked well done with a firm yolk... Yuck! I asked my server to bring it back as have them make a new egg with a runny yolk... When it came out it was thick and gross. The bun tasted stale too... I should have just stuck to a deli for my favorite breakfast sandwich. Oh well... Hopefully I won't be back too soon read more

Food was good, place is clean ...I would definitely come back . I had the quesadilla and my husband ordered ordered a Cesar wrap and got a Cesar salad , lol Close enough , lol Then for desert we got the strawberry cheesecake. All good and the service was excellent . Not too crowded so we didn't wait at all to be seated and served . read more

All food is so good I've gone back so many time I think I've eaten everything on the menu the food is so good and it comes quick they are open late so it's good for when you have the munchies the staff is funny and kind the only thing I have to complain about i that I never take enough cookies after I leave 10/10 would recommend :) read more

Super friendly family place. Great diner food. Fun ambiance. Lots of locals who know the by name is always a great sign

I loved the food ! It was great, tasty, and super comforting atmosphere! The owner Maria is such a sweetheart! Deff recommend. Not expensive at all. read more

Waited awhile for the food but had the French onion soup which was really good! The breakfast crepes are packed with nutella, a good or bad thing depending who you are. Husbands hungry man breakfast was underwhelming according to him, one sausage was not up to his standards as most diners give at least two for a hungry man. Our waiter was nice and checked up on us. Very average dinner with great French onion soup. Oh and please don't judge me that I had French onion soup with my crepes. read more

See all

I have been eating at this diner since 1987. I ordered steak and eggs today and the steak was stringy and full of sinew. I called it to the managers attention quietly, and I told him that I wanted to point this out to him as a friend, but that his quality has obviously dropped. I said I wanted him to know that it's recognized, that it has dropped and I didn't want him to harm his business by focusing on profits. He childishly told me to not order the steak next time I came, and I'm here to tell you that there will not be a next time . I am way beyond disappointed. read more

This review is breakfast only (pic uploaded). Based on service, cleanliness and price, I prefer Mohegan Diner over New City Diner, its nearest rival in Cortlandt Manor. Free Wi-fi. Tip: request a booth by a window if you want to read. Unusually dark for a diner. Location Alert: Yelp's Google map on the side is incorrect. But if you bring up a Google map, then location is correct. Yes, Mohegan Diner is on Route 6, but closer to Lexington Avenue than shown as on the Yelp map. Funny. Most diners sell advertising for their paper placemats...Mohegan Diner sells advertising on their coffee mugs (pic uploaded) read more

Mohegan Diner - Breakfast for about $8 including coffee. - Diners Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

See all

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was that it smells like the cafeteria at sleep away camp. Not a bad thing, just triggered an unexpected memory. They have a great diner menu. Parking gets a bit tight sometimes. Service was pleasant and prompt. I had breakfast on a Friday. The place was pretty dark and not a lot of customers. I expect they do more lunch and dinner business. I love that they serve Pepsi products. The fruit salad I got with my egg white omelette was surprisingly fresh cut fruit. Good diner. read more

Yet another diner that charges prices that makes you wonder why you didnt go to restaurant. Services was fine, food was fine but the prices are way too much for a diner. read more

Breakfast review: Pancakes are good (not Patio great) and omelettes are fresh and well cooked. Service is prompt and friendly this day, but the diner is sparsely populated on the day after Thanksgiving. Asked to change seating after being directed to the booth closest to the cashier and bus stand, which was silly given the emptiness. Asked for a window booth, which greatly "lightened" the meal. Not sure what the hostess was thinking. Free wi-fi was nice! The men's room would benefit from some air freshening (it is clean). Prefer Pastels or the Patio II in Peekskill read more

Just, no. They don't care. The corned beef for my Reuben was grey. And how do you mess up a black and white cookie??? Just, no.

Walked in on a rainy Monday - mid morning, for brunch with a friend. Not crowded at all, lots of booths opened. The waiter appeared annoyed, unfriendly and pointed to a corner and told us to sit there. He arrived at our table with menus, throwing them on the table, again annoyed and unfriendly, walking away quickly. Upon ordering our food, the waiter arrived with the wrong order. When we explained there was a mistake, he tried to be adamant that he did not make a mistake (I ordered scrambled egg whites, he forgot to request egg whites only). This diner is unfriendly from beginning to end....staff appear annoyed to be serving people. The locals nearby know that this diner is not known for customer service....its the last resort when feeling hungry and desperate. read more

Disgusting food here. Took forever to get the food, my friend didn't even get her food half a hour after i got mine. It took someone at our table a hour just to get a toasted bagel with cream cheese on the side. The prices are outrageous for disgusting food. read more

A great diner for burgers and fries , eggplant and chicken Parmesan , great onion rings and quick service , the owner is always friendly , easy parking and it's very reasonable prices , great value for your money ! read more

Cannot say have had many positive experiences going here. The service is good-great and they don't rush you to leave your table. Those are the positives. On the negative aspect, have had over cooked dark brown pancakes. Thought they were using whole wheat! Lol Had undercooked sausages. Needless to say, an uneaten breakfast. Takeout wings were merged into the blue cheese making it runny:( I only go there now to order "something safe" such as burger & fries/bowl soup. I now go out of my way to patronize other diners instead. Sorry Mohegan Diner!! read more

I came here with my boyfriend & his parents for lunch and I have to say that the experience & food was underwhelming. The waiter was inattentive as it clearly looked like they were understaffed & didn't really come and ask if we needed anything, so when we did we had to flag another worker there for help. I ordered the Mexicana omelette topped with chili (which I did not like) that came with potatoes and toast. The potatoes were incredibly under seasoned and the omelette was just ok. The only thing I really liked were the crispy fries that came with the souvlaki platter my boyfriend ordered. When I go to a diner I don't expect to be blown away by the food, but I was expecting a better dining experience here, which I unfortunately did not get. read more

Honestly, I only have one thing to say. I will never again give this business a dollar because of the front desk clerk. Now that I have experienced this diner's service, I can understand why this restaurant has such a poor rating. I've never been more horrified by the poor service I just got. Save your money here and go to Mcdonald's down the street for better tasting food and better service. read more

I ordered a breakfast wrap with home fries. I am in a sling after surgery and I had my friend go inside the diner to pick up the meal for me. The lady behind the counter and other staff had some of the worst customer service I've ever seen as they yelled at my friend asking her for what the order she had placed. they said they never went by names and that the grill turns off at 10 PM (keep in mind the advertised 24 hour service). After arguing for five minutes with the front desk lady, my friend came to get me as she was visibly upset. I left the diner with her and will never step foot or spend a dime in this diner ever again 0/10 please go to another diner. read more

Stopped for a bite to eat during a day trip to NY. Walking in the door the decor/ atmosphere gives off 70s vibes, I loved it. So I had the corned beef hash platter with lightly buttered rye toast. Food/ portions/ price/ service = good. read more

Mohegan Diner - Diners Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

See all

How can you possibly screw up soup?? It's SOUP. Had the French onion last night at about 2am (hahah yeahhhhh it was a beer evening) and I swear, it was like a liquid salt lick. I love salty but this actually hurt to consume. So friggin bad!! I would have been better off to eat a ball of playdoh. I'm putting my foot down, and NEVER coming here again, no matter what. read more

The food tasted like freezer burn I can think of a lot better places to eat right around there I'm wondering how they stay in business They really don't deserve to read more

Went to the diner about a month ago. there was a fellow there with a beard without a mask. He worked there. Then a woman came in with two teen aged girls and they were all over the place with no masks. When I mentioned the lack of mask wearing to our server she replied that the woman was his wife. Who cares of that was his wife and possibly his kids. rules are rules Haven't been back since and won't be going back. Their lack of respect for the rules and their customers was shocking. read more

the problem I have with this diner is the portions with the home fries at breakfast.PLEASE give your patrons a little more than just a small scoop after all we are paying a premium price to eat breakfast there and potatoes relatively cheap. read more

I've been to this diner plenty of time before COVID and it was "ok", I went this afternoon to get lunch on the way home from a long trip. I was happy to see them following the new pandemic rules. Prices have gone up and for a bacon cheeseburger it's $15? No pickle, no slaw. I can go to the Carriage House and have a better burger for $15. The burger tasted ok, except the bacon was chewy and made it hard to cut and bite. I liked the fries, not soggy and not too well done. I would probably eat here again but wouldn't go out of my way to seek them out. read more

I love the Mohegan Diner. I've been to countless diners, but this one is by far the best one in my experience. The food is great! They have the yummiest French fries ever (they are more like potato wedges). I've tried countless things on the menu and I have to say they were all pretty good for a diner. I would say their strong point is breakfast foods like omelettes, pancakes and waffles. The best part is if you want fruit with your food, its fresh. If you want some strawberries with your pancakes, you get fresh strawberries, not the fake strawberry syrup goop. They put IHOP to shame. The service is amazingly quick which is awesome. The staff is very nice and helpful- they check up on you often and make sure everything is good and check to see if you need anything else. They are open 24 hours so if you want 2 a.m. pancakes, you are in luck! This diner is also quite big, I've never had to wait for a table. They are most popular Sunday morning for breakfast/brunch so there may be a wait then but probably not a long one. read more