Friendly young counterman. Lunch special just the right price. Close to NY pizza (from this New…read moreYorker). Glad they added a west Greeley location. Garden City was out of the way for us. Brighter, newer setting.

Terrible service. I ordered a pizza online, came in to pick up my order and the cashier wouldn't…read moreeven look at me. He would only make eye contact with the person I had walked in with, I reached out to take my pizza and they make a detour around the counter to hand it off to the guy I had walked in with. Not me - the person whose name was actually on the order and who paid for the food. Blatantly sexist assholes working the counter that night.

The pizza was so very good as well as the fried ravioli. It was fun reading about the history of…read morethis place. I would eat there again if I ever make it back to Greeley.

Absolutely love this place! One of the best pizzas you will get in Greeley. It's a little pricey,…read morebut then isn't everything nowadays.

This place was top tier! My family was looking for a good Italian restaurant while we were in…read more Greeley since we didn't know where to go. This one popped up on the top of the maps When we came, we got a salad and it was the perfect size! The homemade pasta is delicious and my husband had a pizza. The crust was amazing! To end our meal we ordered a cookie and it was a large cookie with ice cream. I would highly recommend this place!

Flavor of the food was really lacking, I had been hearing so much about this place and we finally…read morehad the opportunity to go there for our grandsons birthday.i was so disappointed by the Alfredo pasta having very little flavor the wife had chicken that she said was so rubbery in texture , we don't plan to go back and went with friends to a different restaurant this past Friday rather than meet them at santeramos

Stopped in to the Greeley location to order a few pizzas to take home…read more We were looking at the posted menu board and one of the items listed (a pizza) was way cheaper than the others so we asked if that was accurate and the guy had a snarky, rude tone and said give me a break - isn't it obvious that is an error! Actually no, I would expect the business to have the correct menu and prices displayed and that they would correct it if there was an error. So condescending and rude! If this was the only pizza place available, I'd never have pizza again because I don't like being treated poorly when I'm spending my hard earned money.

I like the pizza, but let me tell you our delivery tale:…read more We selected contactless delivery, an option on the website. I know some people are probably like, "Ugh, you're too good to chat with a delivery driver," and I'm like, "Look, I tip at least 25% on a delivery, which is a hefty sum at this place, so I think the driver is probably just fine." Anyway, we make the selection, and the dude shows up at the door and keeps knocking. He knocks, knocks again, and we figure, "Okay, there must be some issue." When we answer, homeboy says, "I know you selected contactless delivery, but I wanted to talk to you and see if you read your Bible." The dude was using pizza as a Trojan Horse to proselytize. Not cool. If someone knocks on the door, and I'm not expecting, say, a delicious pizza, and I see they're standing on the porch with a Bible, I can choose to just leave the door closed, or I can choose to open the door and politely say No Thanks. It's kind of annoying under the best of circumstances because I know where you all are, okay? When I'm interested in religion, I think I know where to find you. Still in those big buildings with the huge crosses on the front? Cool. But when it's the pizza guy, it's much worse. Because I paid this dude to come over and ask me about my reading habits. But, hey, let's do this properly and quote Pete's Top Bible Verses Relevant to this Situation Where a Deceitful Guy Pulled a Fast One In Order to Preach: Psalms 101:7: No one who practices deceit will dwell in my house; no one who speaks falsely will stand in my presence. Proverbs 29:11 ESV / 102: A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back. Proverbs 25:17 ESV / 32: Let your foot be seldom in your neighbor's house, lest he have his fill of you and hate you. Kaisarion: It's the truth of candor shone through the prism of deceit It's the continence of bishops with their choirboys en-suite It's the tongue soiled in adulation that licks to no avail It's the noise of the righteous dogma that hides the handmaid's tail Oh, wait, sorry, that's a Ghost song about how Catholic priests were treating their choir boys. Whoops! Tell you what, Marco's: We'll buy our pizza elsewhere, but if you'd like to have us back as customers, I'll send you a book that I LIKE, you can read it, write me a report, and then we can resume our previous relationship where we just exchange money for pizza, no reading required.

When I went to pick up my food at Pizza Street it was very unprofessional. I walked in and could…read morehear a guy screaming profanities. When I got around the corner and was able to see the counter there was an older guy screaming at this kid (his employee) while another kid was standing there as well. When the second kid saw me he was trying to motion to the old guy to quiet down that there was a customer present. There are only a handful of reasons you would ever have to yell at a kid like this, and there is absolutely NO excuse for spewing profanities like he was. If you need to talk to an employee do it in a calm and professional manner. The food was okay and extremely high priced. Don't think we will return. Never want to see that lunatic again.

ordered a sandwich, $6.99 for two sides. one tiny piece of ham, one even smaller piece of cheese…read more. barley half the size if the bread. Asked for ranch and for two marinara. which I could leave a photo but don't see the option.

The pizza here is fantastic! This is such a cool little spot, the games always on, the beers always…read morecold, and the service is friendly. They make some great cocktails too. Please support this place and let's keep em open, the recent construction in the area has made parking tough and it would mean the world to those that work there to keep this place alive and thriving.

This was once a place I regularly recommended, which makes its recent decline particularly…read moredisappointing. While the specials remain one of the few bright spots, the broader experience is less than impressive. The kitchen was notably slow, the pizza arrived with a burnt bottom crust, and service is inconsistent. Most concerning is management's response to a routine question regarding a service charge... rather than addressing it professionally, the matter was handled with unnecessary hostility and followed by an inappropriate private message. A restaurant's leadership sets the tone for the entire operation, and based on recent experiences, that tone appears to be contributing to the establishment's downward trajectory. I hope they are able to make meaningful changes. Update: After posting this review, the owner texted me: 'Don't EVER come here again. You are not allowed and police will be called. Have the day you deserve.' Screenshots retained. Readers can draw their own conclusions regarding professionalism

I wanted to like this place, but the overall experience fell short…read more Food-wise, it's just okay. I ordered a cheese slice, and it wasn't anything memorable. The flavor was very bland-- mostly just tomato sauce and cheese without much depth-- and the crust was overly doughy, almost undercooked. The bigger issue was the service and overall operation. They're listed as opening at 11 AM, but when I arrived with another customer, the doors didn't even open until 11:10 AM. Even then, they clearly weren't ready to be open. There were no slices available, and it didn't feel like they were anywhere close to being prepared for customers. The atmosphere didn't help either. The interaction felt somewhat rude and dismissive, with a lot of excuses instead of solutions. There is a sign stating "no public restrooms," which I initially didn't realize also applied to paying customers. During my visit, two different people came in asking to use the restroom-- want to use it in another just to wash their hands-- and both were returned away. After the second request, the employee put "out of order" signs on both of the restroom doors, which felt misleading. Overall, the experience felt disorganized and underwhelming. The food is mediocre, and the service doesn't make up for it.

Got the mushroom cheesesteak. They offer the traditional cheesewhiz as an option and the place…read moreseems to be popular with locals so I wanted to try it. The beef has more of a carne asada seasoning than a traditional Philly but they load this sandwich up and the value is absolutely banging. Asthetic is bad, no working bathrooms and very run down, but the food for price elevated this from 3.5 stars to 4.

Went here last night and ordered a small Caesar Salad and the lettuce was so full of rust I…read morecouldn't eat it. The pizza is always good even though ( I have said it a million times) the crust needs some salt or something. The service was impeccable but they just need to work out a couple of kinks to get more stars out of me

This place was super good couple years ago, I don't know if change the owner oh what but food is…read morenot the same I always order at carroli and was delicious I was driving from Denver only for eat at this place now I have too find another place because service is horrible people is not nice and the cooking people is not doing the job I feel so sad cuz I was loving this place.

I love their sauce but how is this ok!? Boneless hot wings. More like burnt chicken piecesread more

We asked if they could come deliver and they said they were out of distance we were going to ask if…read morewe could pick it up but they hung up and they never answered our calls afterwards.

The reuben sandwich was just like the picture showed online. It was delicious and we enjoyed our…read moretime there. Will go back.

Us two and another couple at the bar plus one couple on the floor. We ordered a baked appetizer and…read moredrinks. Wife had wine, I had a shot of Crown and water. The food order was late poorly baked and flavorless. One bartender and one server/baker. 28 minutes later we got the food. The bill was the problem and we should have sent the food back to get a little crisper. Mush food, medium wine cost but the SHOT was charged at $ 8. 25, whaaaat? Go there once but drink water and wine the Alcohol must be mixed with gold. Need employees that care for their employment.