Good pizza, fair wings, very busy, inattentive staff. After a very long day of birdwatching, we stopped in at Kersey Pizza and ordered a pizza and some wings. No, you can't get thin crust. No, we can't make the pizza well-done. No, you can't have the sauce for the wings on the side. We got our number and sat down 20 feet from the counter. Oh, well... The people who came in after us got their food and finished, then asked us what we had ordered, since it must have been something special to take so long. I went up to the counter to check. "Your carry-out order has been ready since 10 minutes after you called." "We didn't call - you took our order yourself, a half-hour ago, and we've been sitting right there ever since." Anyway, the pizza, at least, was tasty. read more

Would not recommend, slow service, poor attitude. Not sure what happened this used to be a great place 4 kids behind the counter no ambition more of a joke to them than running a business. Will not be back. read more

Not your typical pizza joint. I was kind of surprised when I walked through the door. Big open room with concrete flooring. There's a pool table, air hockey table, some pinball machines and kind of a skee ball machine that ate my .50 with no opportunity to play! It all looked a little run down. Kitchen is almost completely open to dining area, which isn't a bad thing just trying to give a visual of the place. I ordered a couple pizzas to go and the gal behind the counter was basically there just existing. No greeting. I was the one to greet her and ask how she was doing. Food was okay, nothing to write home about. I ordered a cheese pizza, pizza deluxe with pepperoni and sausage and a Philly cheese steak. While it was good it definitely wasn't worth $60!!! I really hate how they set up pay machines to ask for a tip! I wasn't really paying attention and hit the stupid 15%! On take out??!! Never! This place is a little out of my way but I've been wanting to try it. Wasn't impressed so doubtful I'll be back. read more

See all

Where do I start? From the moment we walked in, we were greeted by friendly staff in a clean environment. We placedour order, which was a couple of specialty pizzas, and they were ready quicker than we thought. They were cooked to our liking, cheese was melted perfectly and every ingredient was great. Great pizza! We'll be back. read more

We have always had very good experience with Kersey Pizza. Today Brenda took the order for two calzones ( pizza pocket ). She informed me that it will take a while since there area couple of orders before me. She did not give me number with stand. When asked she said she will call out my name. We noticed that those who came after us were served pizza. We waited for 45 minutes and finally Brenda brings out two calzones in two separate boxes. When I told her that we are dining here and she replied that I did not inform her earlier. I reminded her that she did not ask and did not give me a number stand even though I had reminded her for one. Well. Grumbling she brought the calzones on serving plates. The calzones were baked very well but there was hardly any sign of mozzarella cheese. Also, it was loaded with jalapeno; we could hardly see any other toppings other than sausage. I informed Alicia ( part owner ) about these discrepancies and she made excuses for the staff but also said that she will have a talk with them. Alicia, honestly I think you have not trained your employees. From where we were sitting, we could see that the employee was struggling with the preparation of calzones. read more

Road trip to Kersey, CO for a class and look what I found for lunch. At first glance it looked like a type of storage area and then I saw a sign that said pizza. Yep, here I go. As I walked in on the right side was a large kitchen area with employees hussling and this is where you order. Straight ahead was an open area concept for dining. The open area reminds me of a type of rented hall like B-I-N-G-O. I'm standing at the counter and an employee asked if he could help me. I told him it was the first time here and he showed me the menu and offered a few suggestions. One thing caught my attention for sure. He said you can order cream cheese on any pizza. I was like "shut the front door, what?" I guess its a real thing now. He said most peeps just have the cream cheese added to the top of the pizza like a topping. I added the cream cheese in place of the red sauce and then added shredded cheese and pepponi on top. He was like oh okay, cool. I was so excited to see and taste this original pizza I created. But, I'm still waiting and waiting. They were busy and I understand, then I see the pizza coming out. It looked so fresh, appealing and ready to indulge. The pizza was not disappointing at all. WOW! I absolutely the cream cheese on this pizza. So flavorable and inviting. It was a perfectly shaped, cooked pizza. Thank you for recommending this topping. I know why they are busy now. Great food . They also offer gluten free crust for pizza which was amazing as well. I definitely recommend this pizzeria and try the cream cheese as a topping or sauce. Thank you for a memorable lunch experience. read more

See all

I really enjoy their single slice pizzas, sometimes they're consistent on how they make it sometimes they're not but I'm never disappointed. And now they've added Cannoli Cake and Lava Cake that is so amazing, a great choice if you want something different. read more

I was recommended to try this place by my husband, who is a truck driver. During a trip I joined him on, we decided to give it a try, and I'm glad we did. The food was fantastic! We ordered a pepperoni pizza, a white slice pizza, and a chicken bacon and cream cheese dish, and everything was delicious. We'll definitely be stopping by again when we're in the area. I highly recommend giving it a try! read more

See all

Food was ok. Service though was horrible. Hope the management fixes this soon, used to be a good place to go to. Not anymore.

This place used to be a hidden gem but the last 2 times we ordered pizza here it's mediocre at best. Plus employees are so high I'm surprised I got my order. read more

passimg through we decided to try this place. waited over 30 minutes then had to go ask where our order was. The gentleman said sorry we forgot it would only take 5 minute. so we said ok. They offered us free chips or ice cream or more soda. we said no thanks. finally got our food 13 minutes later and after 1 bite, it was cold. (philly steak sandwiches) the young lady said sorry we microwave them and it don't always heat up. We got a refund and left. We should have gotten pizza! read more

The pizza is good but the customer service is AWFUL! They are so rude! I think I'm done after this go around.

When I call ahead, pizza take and bake is ready and I am on my way. If I am short on time, these young people will bake the pizza and box it upready to go. When I dine in, there is always some fun happening! Good tasting pizza and great salad! Ice cream shakes and we are happy! read more

Great bang for your buck. Largely consistently good. Because of its proximity to Greeley, they get a whole star for consistency alone. A bit pedestrian, but good at a minimum, prices are good, and so are portions. That said, if you like chicken, bacon, and ranch AT ALL, get the chicken Calzone, it is much better than the sum of its parts and COMPLETELY worth a drive from Greeley. read more

Good pizza plus friendly folks . I have been in twice. And definitely will go back for a third time. I would recommend this place to anyone who wants good pizza n great customer service. read more

This is the best pizza in Colorado HANDS DOWN. I've been a resident my whole life and even though it

Just moved to the area and this place was recommended. Very disappointing. Ordered to go and got back to hotel and pizza was supposed to be deluxe and it was just pepperoni. Called and talked to Manger and she just brushed me off. So sad service means nothing anymore. read more

Kersey Pizza - Not a deluxe pizza.... #noveggies #epicfail #mgrdontcare - Pizza Near Me - Kersey, Colorado

Stopped in cuz I've heard so many good things about it. Ordered a meatball sub and the meatballs were stone cold!! Had them microwave it to heat it up. At least the cheese was melted. Certainly nothing special. Thought I'd bring my family here but probably not now. Maybe the pizza is better. First impressions do count! read more

The pizza is a family fav, and the large feeds 2 adults and 2 kids with leftovers. The subs are great also. Fresh ingredients and good tasting sauce. The salads are what you would expect from a small pizzeria, nothing to brag about but their ranch and blue cheese dressing are homemade and amazing. read more

Super expensive for awful quality and teenagers who ignore you when you come in. I've been in this town for 9 yrs and over the years the quality has gone down and the prices up. I don't mind paying more but at least give me a pizza without freezer burnt meat or have better customer service. The teenagers are rude ans can't be bothered read more

We love this place. It's great pizza and a awesome place to take the family to eat. The kids love the video games

Today, I ordered and waited at least 20 min maybe 30 min with no food. During this time the employees were coming out saying hi to friends and hugging them. I finally asked where my food as I been waiting and they had to find the order. The paper with the order was on the ground so it was lost. They wanted me wait again for food but i could not any more. I asked for my money back but they would not give me my tip back which I think is competently wrong. They should have given me my money back and a comp meal or at least all my money back. Personally if i paid on a credit card, I would have dispute the entire charge. read more

I was in Kersey for a my daughter's horse show this past weekend and decided to take them to lunch. Kersey, being a small town does not have much to offer in the way of variety, but we did come across the pizza place in town. Kersey Pizza isn't just a pizza place, they also make several subs. In fact, I'd venture to say the subs are better than the pizza. The pizza itself was pretty bland and the crust reminded me of cardboard, with very little flavor. we ordered the Hawaiian BBQ Chicken pizza, which may have been our mistake as the chicken tasted very processed. Service here was about as good as you would expect from a pizza place. The staff was very friendly and answered any questions we had. The friendly staff even brought our order to our table once it was ready. read more

The food is pretty good here. I like the Philly cheesesteak sandwich with jalapenos or the nachos. The pizza is also good too. The crust is nice and soft and they don't go overboard with the cheese. The dining room is always very clean and the service is good. We live close by, so I like to get carry-out orders. The dining room is awfully crowded on the weekends. I like that there is a pool table and old arcade style video games that I remember playing as a kid. That bit of nostalgia adds to the funkiness and small town feel of the place. Also good for large groups and kids. read more

Great pizza. Great people. Milkshakes are epic. Thanks guys!!! If you're driving thru Kersey or working in the area, it is definitely worth the stop. read more

This pizza was blah. There wasn't much flavor but it was edible. Decent, not my favorite. The thing that ticked me off though was when I went to go pick up my order, there was about 6 high school aged kids behind the counter all looking at one of the girls telling a story... as I STOOD and WAITED behind the counter (where they all saw me, mind you) for 2 minutes. TWO MINUTES! Won't be returning, obviously business is not important to the employees. read more

As native to Colorado, there are couple brands I have been loyal to. Recently I discovered Kersey pizza and flavor wise, I will have to deem this place as the best place in the state. I have tried the house, chicken bacon, and bacon cheeseburger; all of which have been filled with toppings and flavor. read more

Kersey Pizza - Chicken bacon with cream cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Kersey, Colorado

Best GF pizza anywhere -- including, believe it or not, the East Coast!

A guy probably in his late 20s was helping me and was rude. Food is okay but pizza is extremely greasy. Don't recommend

My husband craves their Philly Cheesteak and I always get a calzone. We always stop when we head to Pawnee National Grasslands before a hike. read more

Pizza is ok. Honestly the only reason I continue to eat here is because I work in the oil and gas industry and there really isn't anywhere else, and most of the time someone else went there and offered me a slice. I have only gone there one time and ordered a calzone and I watched the girls in the kitchen take the calzone out of the oven and stick it in the microwave. Ruined. It was now soggy and gross. If not for other people in my industry buying the pizza and offering me a slice I would never eat here. Please please learn how to cook good pizza. And stop leaving it to young girls more interested in the cell phone than the service and food they are serving. read more

The young girl that took our order was absolutely rude about everything. The staff was very uninviting except got one young gentleman that was going around making sure everyone was ok. The rest of the staff was rude, had poor appearance and were standing around doing nothing as the young gentleman was cleaning. Great food but poor staff which made the entire experience really awful. read more

I love your pizza and I love that your twist cones are 1.72. Never change!!!!

We ordered for dine in and they gave it to us in to go boxes and we never got our nachos

Great pizza, great prices. We order from here in bulk (10-20 pizzas at a time) and they have never let us down.

The service is lacking and its an open kitchen with nothing but giggling teenage girls, no sense of urgency. I don't know if its perhaps different during the day. Food is pretty good though not great. Lots of cool games to play though. read more

Poor service. The 5 young girls were more concerned about their social life. 6 tables still full of customers dishes and food. Water on the floor, and young kids running all around screaming and playing sword fights with the pool cues. Pizza was OK. That's about all that was ok read more

All the pizza here is good, but the best by far is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, cant get enough! I have never actually sat down inside to eat, always just call in orders and pick up. And the staff have always been polite and fast. read more

We discovered Kersey Pizza about 4 years ago.........We live in Fort Morgan and have driven the 45 minutes it takes to get there one way just to get the pizza. For some reason my husband could not remember the name Kersy Pizza so in our family its Gernsy Pizza. Either way we enjoy it a lot and even have it in my phone so when I'm on the road I can call ahead stop in and take a pizza home with me. read more

Amazing pizza can't say enuff good about this place....the people that work there had such a great aditude mad you feel right at home...