Finally got to stop by this local ice cream shop. It was nice not having to track down the truck this time. The store itself is simple, with no seating inside. There's a small merchandise area where they sell hoodies, T-shirts, and even a toy ice cream truck. I noticed they had a large selection of ice cream and really appreciated the assortment of cones available. The prices were a little higher than I expected, but the customer service was good. They also offer a BOGO sundae special on Tuesdays, which I definitely plan to take advantage of in the future. For such a nostalgic company, though, I do wish they had some seating so people could sit, talk, and enjoy their ice cream with family and friends. Overall, it's a fun stop for a sweet treat, but adding a small seating area would really make the experience feel more complete. read more

See all

Here's the Scoop! We all remember the Siftee ice cream truck coming down our block or at the park. Well now you can go to the store. It's located on Carlton Avenue in Islip. Oh boy the choices are delicious and so, so good. I ordered a waffle bowl with soft serve vanilla, nuts, black cherries and whipped cream topping. Yum, yum, yum!!! So happy I don't have to wait until summer to listen for the truck. Definitely check them out. Fast service and reasonable prices. read more

See all

Came for a late night sweet treat to celebrate my moms birthday! I was surprised how small the selection of ice cream is considering this is an ice cream shop. I went with the ice cream burger which comes with 4 kinds of ice cream so I did Cookie Monster, biscoff cheesecake, chunky monkey and I forget the last flavor but it's sandwiched between two waffle cone 'pattys' dipped in chocolate with sprinkles-it was huge and very tasty! My mom went with the ice cream nachos which was waffle cone 'chips' ice cream and she chose peanut butter sauce. This was just ok-the pb sauce tasted like skippy pb-it does not compare to Ralph's peanut butter sauce at all. There's no seating so we took it to go but the prices seemed ok for what we got. read more

Mister Softee Store - Ice cream nachos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

My husband and I couldn't believe our eyes when we stumbled upon this Mister Softee store in East Islip. We stopped in on an a weekday evening after dinner and they were busy. There were a good amount of staff and they were working quickly and efficiently to keep wait times low. They had different things to choose from including soft serve, ice cream, sundaes, and more. Their ice cream flavors were enticing to try since there was a nice variety, but my hubby and I went with a classic Mister Softee soft serve: a chocolate one for him and a vanilla dipped in cherry for me. We also couldn't resist and ended up getting a Mjster Softee truck coin bank! Of course our treats were delicious, service was friendly, and the vibe of being in an actual Mister Softee store could not be beat. A positive experience overall. We would definitely return in the future and can't wait to try some of their ice cream flavors next time. read more

See all

My wife convinced me to get it I knew was a bad idea. I ordered the ice cream sandwich. Six scoops of ice cream or four big scoops of ice cream in between two waffles. After you choose your ice cream, they dip it into one of three sauces a chocolate sauce, a cherry sauce or a blue raspberry sauce and then they dip it in sprinkles. It is definitely big enough to share between two or more people in my opinion and I wish I didn't eat all six scoops of ice cream and two waffles but I did because I paid $10 for an ice cream burger. I'll only get it again if I share, but I definitely did not regret my decision. It's super unique and really fun experience to have. Our group left so full as we all chowed down on our ice cream burgers. read more

See all

The Mr. Softee Ice Cream Store is situated at the end of a modest strip center East Islip. Although the store is relatively small, it provides all the excellent selections of Mr. Softee and more. The waffle cones and soft serve ice cream are exceptionally tasty. It is highly recommended to try them. Parking may be somewhat limited, but patience is advised. This establishment is the Mister Softee Ice Cream Truck in a Store. This was the inaugural store on Long Island that opened this year. read more

See all

I'll start with the good, then roll into the bad and ugly haha. Cause there's a fair share of all. The good - the place is new, bright, clean. The staff is very friendly and helpful. The selection is solid, and the ice cream is delicious and par for what you expect from a Mister Softee truck. We got 2 large soft serve cups and 2 waffle bowls - dips and sprinkles or crunchies. Now let's get to the bad. First, it's new and a hot spot to try so the place is always packed. Wait isn't that bad, their through put is decent. But expect a wait. Parking is also horrible. It was already bad in this strip mall, and is ten times worse now that Softee has moved in. A child has already been hit there by a truck backing out - so please be careful. But the real kicker for why I probably won't be back... the price is insane. Four bowls was $32, before a tip. They nickel and dime you for any toppings - none are included. And I didn't see those topping prices advertised in their signage. The language read more like "add any topping". There should've been a prominent display of the upcharge. And what's worse - the price they display on their signage doesn't match what they charge you, which makes me think they're displaying cash prices instead of the highest price - a no no that's illegal in NYS. So yeah, glad I tried it. But I won't be back anytime soon. read more

Mister Softee Store - Soft serve dip with crunchies in waffle bowl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Islip, New York

Mr. Softy! They had me at waffle ice cream. Messy but worth it. The parking situation could be stressful, so just be prepared for that. Will definitely be back! The line was out the door, but it moved fast. read more

Mister Softee Store - Bubble waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Islip, New York

We were very excited for this location. My husband tried the ice cream burger. It was pretty good. My ice cream was made with Reese's pieces instead of cups, so I was unable to try it. Very clean inside. Parking is easy getting in but a little annoying getting out. read more

Yum, yum, and more yum. I got the cherry dip cone upside down in a cup which was suggested to me by the lady working and she was so right. The soft serve was so good, I ate it all up!! read more

Mister Softee Store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Islip, New York

The staff is always very nice. I usually get the bubble waffle which is delicious. Today I tried dubai sundae which was very good as well. My kids like the cookie monster ice cream read more

Mister Softee Store - Dubai sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Islip, New York

The way I RAN to the new Mister Softee Store omg! It's the first store on Long Island if it's kind and an hour outside of NYC. They just opened on March 1. I was lucky the line wasn't super long today but I can only imagine what it will be like in the summer! Everything was clean and new. Workers were quick and friendly. Had to get myself a classic soft serve with sprinkles. Reminds me of my childhood days running after the ice cream truck - only now you don't have to! Also saw some delicious banana splits and milkshakes. Enjoy! read more

See all

What's not to like about Mr. Softee? This is childhood nostalgia in a cup (or cone) but with a storefront that stays open late enough to fuel your late night cravings. The Choco Taco? Ohhh ... MASSIVE, peanut-crusted, and worth every single bite. If you don't order one, we can't be friends. They've got all sorts of specialty options, but why fix what isn't broken? Line looks scary sometimes but it moves quick don't worry. This place isn't trying to be bougie gelato or artisanal rolled ice cream it's Mr. Softee. Classic, messy, and exactly what your inner kid signed is looking for. read more

Mister Softee is hands down my favorite ice cream truck, and I was SO excited to go to their physical store in Long Island, but the experience was not all it was made out to be. First of all, there was barely any parking or space to even eat the ice cream - so I saw everyone just eating their ice cream on top of their cars. Secondly, the store was so tiny and I felt so cramped inside the store. There were only two soft serve flavors and a bunch of other regular ice cream flavors. I got the chocolate with oreo and it was SOO expensive. On the screen it said it was $5ish, but the total came out to $6+!!! It was SOO much more expensive than normal Mister Softee ice cream trucks. Not to mention, the oreos came in GIANT chunks, so you have to finish the actual oreo pieces before you get to the ice cream. Which isn't intuitive at all because the ice cream melts fast... so it was an awful experience. I wish the oreos were dust powder instead of chunks, or at least put the oreos on the side ??? I wish the employees had the decency to tell me that the oreos came in giant chunks...so I would know how to plan ahead of time. I do not recommend that experience because the ice cream got all over my hands due to me not being able to actually eat the ice cream due to the giant oreo chunks. Anyway, not a great experience and it was also too expensive and overpriced. Would not come back. read more

Mister Softee Store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

I stopped by the Mister Softee store in East Islip for the first time, and it completely exceeded expectations. As someone who grew up spotting Mister Softee trucks, walking into a full storefront version felt both nostalgic and exciting. I ordered the Ice Cream Burger, which was a fun and creative twist--soft serve sandwiched between two warm, donut-style buns. It was sweet, messy, and absolutely delicious. I also tried the Dubai Chocolate Sundae, which was rich, layered, and indulgent, with just the right mix of chocolate toppings and texture. The shop itself is bright, clean, and well-organized, with a wide variety of soft serve, sundaes, scooped flavors, and seasonal specials. Staff were friendly, helpful, and patient despite a steady flow of customers. This location takes everything people love about Mister Softee and elevates it with creativity and quality. A must-visit for any dessert lover on Long Island! read more

I live a couple of minutes away so figured I'd stop in with my husband. For starters: the line is long! It's always long, we drive by all the time and it's always out the door but we decided to bite the bullet and go in. Parking is atrocious so we just parked on the side street which is literally equivalent to parking at the far end of the lot but I've got to say, despite the long line, wait time was better than I expected. Pros: I mean... Mister Softee has a brick and mortar store how cool is that. Cons: garbage outside was full and people kept putting stuff in so it ends up just falling on the floor right in front of the store. One of the TV's isn't on? Wondering if there was menu related stuff on there. I kept seeing people walk out with such cool concoctions but from the three monitors that did work I just saw basic stuff (pricing of diff size cups, types of toppings, shakes, banana boats). There was a dry erase board that mentioned a Dubai chocolate sundae I got a hot fudge sundae. I could've went to carvel or friendly's 5 minutes away for the same thing to be honest. I do want to go back and try something a little more basic than a hot fudge sundae so.. we'll see! Dubai Chocolate sundae is calling my name. read more

9 bucks for a watered down half full milkshake. Nope. Ill stick to the trucks. The staff is wonderful honestly. Just way overpriced for what you receive and the parking lot is a nightmare. read more

I purchased two "small" soft serve in a cup which measures 3" in height (minus 1/4" recess on bottom) by 2.5" wide with a plastic lid confining the soft serve to three inches. It did not even fill the perimeter of the cup. The cost......$11‼ read more

Mister Softee Store - Cup with measurement reference. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Islip, New York

Classic Mr Softee when ever you want place gets crowded but worth it. Service is quick maybe should put a few tables out front.

Ice cream selection inconsistent, they had 2 amazing flavors for soft serve, strawberry and the banana, and those in a milkshake were amazing. I don't understand why you remove two classic flavors that were awesome and now after 3 times being there the lack of consistency is obvious. People open stores with good starts and fail because they can't deliver consistently. Soft serve is your bread and butter and you mess that up. read more

Friendliest people!! So helpful. Great prices. Good treats . Fast on the ball. Prices for kids1.50

Service was trash, young boy who worked there served me a sundae with toppings and ice cream pouring over the sides. Didn't care to clean it up to pass it to me. Then proceeded to give me a cap that was too big for the cup that he passed to me for myself to put it on...after he seen I had ice cream and toppings all over my hand. Nothing like the old ice cream shop Pam's... disappointed. read more

Such great service and the ice cream was delicious! So light and the strawberry topping tasted like fresh strawberries! A small ice cream shop with amazing ice cream that is to go. read more

Don't go here they have a Cybertruck. Your money goes straight to paying Elon Musk. They also park the cubertruck to take up extra spots. Bad parking and bad vibes here , beware read more

Went there today and we were so excited and wanted to wait for a good time when it wasn't as crowded. Thankfully we were the only ones in there initially in the early afternoon. In my opinion only.... The quality and taste of the ice cream was good. Pricey but not horrible bcz it is Mister Softee, and we don't mind paying the price for it. However, so disappointing to see that the place was a complete mess when there were 4 teens behind the counter laughing and carrying on when they clearly should have been cleaning up when it was quiet. Melted Ice cream and toppings allllll over the floors, all over every counter, the register , etc. Don't know if the owner was on site but wanted to comment bcz it is a great addition to the neighborhood and want it to succeed. But it was a big turnoff to see it so " unkempt " we will say. Will try one more time, hopefully just an off day! The ice cream was good. read more

Best place ever! Ice cream is to good! Service is amazing too! Clean and nice location.

Always loved Mister Softee truck in my neighborhood growing up, the store brought back many of those memories. Would have given 5 * but the store was a little messy and no seating read more

Location is horrible! Needs seats to enjoy your melting delicious cone. Staff needs to be a wee bit friendly.

Went there tonight with my wife and son. Line was 45 minutes but we thought it would be worth it. We never found out because after placing our order for one bubble waffle twist ice cream and paid for it, we were asked to proceed to the front of the store. Told it would be 5 minutes. Well after 15 minutes and noticing customers who were behind us were getting there bubble waffle cones I reminded the worker who took my order. He said we were next up. Two more bubble waffle ice creams came out to more customers who were behind us in line. So then I told the owner about it, he basically nodded at me and walked towards the back of the store...he looked useless but happy his store is taking in $$$ for him. So after almost 65 minutes in total I asked for my money back and we left to Cold Stone Creamery. MUCH better service and establishment. I see this place doing well at first but the novelty will wear off and if customers keep getting treated like we did, sales will decline. From now on I will support our local Mr. Softee driver. read more

Had been very much looking forward to going here and the hype is not worth it. Yes, it is clean and line moves quickly but this is a very small storefront. Went at 6:30 p.m. on Sunday and wanted four waffle bowls-was told they ran out from the young woman behind the counter. Overheard another patron actually told by his counter person if he wanted he would make him one--which was annoying as my server never offered the same. They also had no cookie dough topping left in stock (not the biggest deal breaker as this could happen in other places). The price however is outrageous! 3 medium soft serve cups (and the size of the medium is quite small) plus one hard scoop cup, each having one topping came to $27.43. Better off going to Carvel for soft serve or buying off your local Mister Softee truck. Will not be back due to customer service and pricing. Even more bizarre is the receipt states it is from Atlantic Avenue, Amagansett, NY when we were at the EAST ISLIP store. read more

amazing service very nice environment inside. the taste of the ice cream really makes it special