Better preparation. Ordered an Italian sub and mozzarella sticks, sub was fine since it was all uncooked but still lazy construction and falling apart. Mozzarella sticks were over fried so the exterior was burnt. Charged $0.75 for 2/3 of a small tub of marinara sauce, asked for extra which was ignored. In general just generic and uninspired, probably complacent with the orders they are receiving so aren't worried about customer satisfaction. read more

This has always been my favorite local pizza place... but lately it has been really disappointing. :( we have ordered from here for years and had no problems but the last 5 or 6 times we have ordered everything has been burnt or over cooked. From sandwiches to pizza to fries... I hope they can fix what's going on because the food usually is so good! read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - Burnt hard crust - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

See all

roast beef sandwhich came with normal bbq sauce and not the James River version I expected. the steak and cheese had an over powering cheddar and not American cheese and the steak was shredded beyond belief and I was served refried burnt fries. Absolutelygross meal. I will never be back read more

Mickey's is my go-to for pizza in Hudson, NH. When they were closed for repairs, the husband and I tried every Hudson-area pizza joint and couldn't find a decent replacement. read more

Not a lot of meat on the roast beef sub. Barely any. Picky kid wouldnt even touch the chicken sandwich. Was made right. Pickles were supposed to be on side. read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - Roast Beef sub - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

See all

Not impressed at all, ordered a pepperoni vodka scillian pizza and chicken pesto pizza. $66.00, both pizzas definitely over cooked, called, no customer service didn't care. Buyer beware order elsewhere! read more

See all

We ordered pickup the other week (hot honey pepperoni pizza) and no one was really a fan. To several of the people I ate with the cheese didn't taste right. Would not recommend. read more

Why is it SO hard to find good pizza in this state?? I mean, don't get me wrong. I'm not suggesting that all NH pizza blows. To the contrary. MOST of the pizza around here is mediocre to pretty dang okay. Aaaand I guess that's sorta the problem so far. Perhaps my kid brain remembers food differently from back in the day. These days, I tend to approach menus at a more cynical perspective. I dunno why, I just....tend to be that way on account of things that have to physically enter my body to sustain life as I know it. So, the best way I can describe this so-called NY style pizza is: brick oven. That's not even a knock on them, btw. But true NY style is a very specific style....and this ain't it. If you know, then you know. Irregardless, this pizza would actually be pretty damn good, if not for the harder-than-tree bark crust. That's right. They manage to screw up the one thing you shouldn't screw up on pizza: the base. To be clear, the "main" part of the pizza is decent. Like...6 out of 10 decent. But the crust is virtually unchewable. That kinda takes me out of the moment. Dunno about you. But I don't like not finishing my pizza. We also tried the wings, which were okay enough. The sauce was somehow both overwhelmingly spicy whilst underwhelming in potency. What I mean by the latter is that it was thinner than chicken broth. So, you had this weird situation where the buffalo sauce was seemingly trying to escape from the wings. The container it came in likely had more flavor on it than the wings did. What a let down. I realize that 3 stars isn't technically bad. But anytime I see the initials "NY" in the title of a pizza parlor, I don't wanna just like the pizza. I wanna love it. Props to them for offering both delivery and pickup service directly from their site though. I can adequately say Mickey's NY Pizza is worth 3 brick oven pizzas with crust harder than granite out of 5. read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - Pepperoni pizza with mozzarella and buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

Food is overhyped on social media, Subs are skimp. Spent 50 bucks on 3 little measly subs... Steak bomb didn't have extra cheese chicken parm was chicken fingers and not a cutlet, very disappointed read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - Completely overhyped! Subs are skimp and overpriced... Spent 50 bucks on 3 little tiny measly subs. Very disappointed - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

Their pizza is terrible burnt top and bottom and awful taste, we had one bite after scraping the burnt doe off and it ended up in the garbage. The rest was put into a Tupperware container and in the fridge, called, told them I was bringing it back in the mean time my wife got sick from that disgusting bite and was sick for a few days so I didn't make back to the place for a couple of days and when I did they said I'll get my refund with in 4 days back on my CC well that never happened I called and the girl on the phone told me I waited too long (what did they want to resell it) and she hung up on me! I'm 70 yo on a tight budget and $25 was wasted on this garbage I recommend don't eat anything from this disgusting place. I'm for all small business but not here! This is link to a post I posted explaining more. https://yelp.to/WX83sZ8sok read more

Shocked at these reviews. Pizza was fantastic. I'm from NY. Actually I think north jersey pizza is the best. This pizza was equal to those ny/nj pizzas. Thin and crisp with great flavor. Service was super friendly. Thanks guys!! See you soon read more

Missing item from delivery and didn't offer to make it and send it.. only offered a credit or refund.

Oh wow, surprised this place reopened... they used to refuse to refund customers for delivery orders that never get delivered. They have this funny system where they hand their deliveries off to a third party and then refuse to take responsibility for whatever happens to it after that. But they'll keep your money read more

This place sucks to order from Orders for delivery don't get delivered. Whether you use the online system or call it in they consistently can't get it done. 3 times we have tried to order delivery and been waiting and hour and half or more. When you call to find out what's going on. The online order didn't go through Or the door dash driver never showed Or you ordered from door dash so you have to cancel through them even if you didn't. All set with this place No more. read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - Replacement dinner 2.5 hours later - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

Got dinner delivered the other night. A pizza and grilled chicken kabobs. 57.00 plus tip. Was not worth 10.00. The food was terrible, delivery took almost an hour( at 4 in the afternoon) this place is terrible! Will never go back! read more

Food is great! People are nice! Order early, as they can get so busy that they can't even handle "eat in" orders within 2 hours of closing. read more

Over the last two years, the quality of product and the ingredients being used I don't know if they're cutting corners trying to save money but it shows. They are officially on our do not call for delivery list since this last time ordering pizza. read more

On 11/25/24, I paid $27 for a hot honey pizza so burnt that it was inedible!! Lesson learned

Received a delivery from DoorDash and the food was all overcooked. The plain pizza was disgusting it was so overcooked. We also ordered two other pizzas and it was like eating cardboard. I called to let the store know about this and to give them a chance to fix this $100 mess. They didn't seem to care. She told me if we hadn't touched the pizza we could have driven them back to the store. WHAT?!?? We paid over $13.xx in fees and I should drive back to get rid of their slop? read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

I've had ordering issues here but that's only because I order so much from Mickeys since they opened. It's a family business and I support family businesses. And thank God it's not one of those wood fired franchises. I'd take Mickey's over all those faux gourmet pizza joints anytime. They also support customers who are down on their luck. But there is no question they have the best tasting pizza in this part of New Hampshire. Their sides and salads are great and the wings and roast beef sandwich are fantastic. Subs are huge. Oh yea....free parking. read more

Ordered 2 types of pizza. If you like your Sicilian pizza dough over proved and overcooked then this is the place for you. Our regular pizza was precooked, then reheated with the toppings sautéed and put on after. Both were over done, chewy Very disappointed. Don't let the name fool you. Not like any NY pizza I have ever had; will never have it again. read more

Great Pizza Great Wings Great steak subs! Crispy fries! Nice people willing to help! Nice to eat outside in warm weather! read more

This is an unassuming little shop on the roadside of a main drag through town. I'm from New York. Pizza is not New York pizza unless the sauce is flavorful and the cheese is threatening to drip off. That is not this. This pizza is at least NY-style, which makes it more appealing than Greek style or delivery chain style. But that's about it. We got a plain cheese pizza. The pizza was overcooked. People around here seem to like their pizza crust well-done, but that's not how we do it in NY and I don't care for it. The sauce and cheese didn't have much flavor, so all I could really taste were the burnt parts of the crust. My son's favorite food is pizza from NY, and after taking a bite he opted to skip dinner. I did at least eat mine. I'm sure there are palates around here that this pizza would appeal to, and some people seem to like the sandwiches, which we didn't try, but for me it wasn't great and I think the place should be called something else. read more

We have never been disappointed with our order from Mickey's NY Pizza. Ordering is easy and you can select the time you want delivery. We highly recommend them. read more

Not sure why all the bad reviews? I used to go to Hudson House of Pizza for a long time and they changed not for the better... I decided using my GrubHub I would indeed try Mickey's out, got a Large Cheese pizza and a Chicken Kabob Wrap. It was delicious! Sunday, we were cleaning still from New Years and didn't want to cook and make more dishes so I ordered a Beef Tip Salad, and a Pepper Steak sub, large fries. Sub was fantastic and the Salad had literally an entire steak practically cut up and well seasoned, the wrap that came with it made for a great Beef Tip Wrap. I have only ordered from mickey's twice and both times the food was fantastic and the prices were decent. I will order from here again, keep up the quality Mickeys. From a New Customer! read more

Creative and delicious pizzas, I'm a big fan of the baked potato pizza. Nashville hot chicken loaded fry situation is BOMB and reheats well.

So I don't know what some of the others are talking about. So I had the Sicilian pizza with extra cheese and I didn't realize it had some type of honey sauce on it but DAMN was it good! Perfectly cooked and so much flavor it was ridiculous! Then we had a large pep, bacon and sausage and here again cooked best and very good! My first time going here, I delayed for some time as a result of other ratings but I wanted something different sands they delivered on this visit! We will be back! read more

Loaded baked potato was very good and not a long wait at all always love Mickeys pizza read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - Loaded baked potato pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

Ordered 2 pizzas via Door Dash for employee appreciation at a local business after seeing ads on social media. One pizza was burnt on the bottom so I called - to make a long story short- I spoke with the owner who told me he already paid Door Dash 30% for the order and although he does delivery direct from his restaurant, he was unwilling to send me another. As a consumer, what Mickey pays a 3rd party is of no concern to me and perhaps do not partner with Door Dash in the future. He then swore at me stating the pizza wasn't burnt and that I could post pictures and reviews across America and to never order from Mickeys Pizza again and then hung up on me. Mickey can benefit from customer service training since this picture says it all. Mickey- this review is for you and your request to post across America. Good luck with all your paid advertising. BTW- Being from NY- your non burned pizza was 2 out 10 in comparison to NY pies. read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - two slices of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

Go in for a couple slices, they've been open for 10 minutes. I asked how long before slices are out, she says about 10 minutes, I said all right so I went back out in my truck and waited 15 minutes. I come back in and the girls on the phone talking personal stuff, then she proceeds to start making pizzas with the phone to her ear on her shoulder after another five minutes she comes over and asked me what was I looking for for slices and I told her whatever is coming out. She told me that she thought I had left so she didn't bother making any pizzas. The two other gentleman behind the counter walked by her several times while she was just talking on the phone and I was standing there nothing said to her. Jumped back in the truck and went to Kendall pond where they appreciate a customer. read more

When they first opened the food was good but the last three times have been there they've messed up my order fully they did agree to remake it if I brought the food back, two are those three times it was messed up a second time, they made it and was remade again in the store, the cooks don't pay attention to the slips I can't tell you how many times my orders have been messed up, it's astronomical, the food is gone downhill like they don't care even when they cook it, I will not be going back again, I'm tired of messed up orders read more

I don't believe a pizza that costs $17.99 should look like this. White sauce Ricotta cheese Artichoke read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

I will tell you their pizza is great and food overall is very good. No masks for anyone inside and that is great as well. I'm an anti masker but please wear gloves. The girl making the pizza had gloves but the kid handling the food putting it in the containers had no gloves touching his phone then handling the food straight into the container. Seems like supervision might be lacking here. Pizza can be overcooked so make sure you ask for it less well done, or it'll be like a rock. That last time it was not great, but when cooked right it is great. read more

Plenty of room here for your pizza party! I love this place and love pizza any day of the week. This will be my new "go-to" for good pizza. I feel sorry for those who don't know the difference between really good pizza and the rest of inedible stuff! Fun, friendly, casual and delicious! read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - menu for mickey's pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

This place was horrible !!im a traveling foodie with thousands of followers on my other sites and these people actually sent this Pizza out the door looking like this... TONY WAS MORE THEN HAPPY KEEPING MY MONEY AND SENDING THIS OUT THIER DOOR ! Took me 3 times on hold to get a "manager" and the Manager or owner whatever TONY is .. was himself condescending speaking ignorant with the "how can I help you "when he knew after me being on hold for three times that there was an issue!! And I gave it right back to him at which point he hung up I let him know I am calling the BOH based on the condition of the pizza their place needs a good cleaning I'd say also let him know I will be showing this all over all social media PLATFORMS and he says GO Ahead SO HERE YA GO TONY ...and the comments I received From viewers of my post confirm his nasty attitude and poor BUSINESS ETHIC.. penny wise dollar foolish.. attach is only 1 of many many comments left on my other pages ... WHO CAN WITH PRIDE SELL SOMETHING LIKE THIS ?? I have seen other reviews all their food seems over cooked and Burnt .. BEWARE OF THIS PLACE !! read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - Just one comment of many see my page for a full report and every comment there are 100s - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

See all

So, it's a Wednesday (nonholiday, nonsports-day, etc.)... I ordered an hour and a half ago...just one pizza...still waiting. We called and they said the driver left a while ago... no resolution... read more

Ok 4th time ordering the meat ball marinara pizza, second time saying over the phone make sure you've included all ingredients. Still have not delivered. Person on the phone listed ingredients and still left out two that are listed on the menu. Got. The pizza. Missing garlic, Parmesan, basil and ricotta. I'm done with mickeys read more

Mickeys NY Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Hudson, New Hampshire

Mickeys NY pizza should be renamed Mickeys NH pizza. As a New York transplant, I can certainly say that there is no part of New York in this pizza. Obviously New York has the best pizza and this does not even begin to compare. Personally, I'd like to slap Mickey across the face with the cheese slice that I just received. I'm sure this is a business of wonderful people but I'd either consider changing the name or heading to New York for a lesson in pizza making. read more

Their subs are very good - and large. Boars Head meats and fresh vegetables. I always get the Italian.

I used to love Mickey's. Last 2 times my pizza has been Luke- warm. I live a 1/2 mile away! One was the wrong order. I called and the manager tried to explain how they cook their pizza. Then asked me why we ate the pizza... We were hungry. I ordered it an hour ahead of time and it was still late. They took no responsibility. So disappointing. read more