It's obvious my plantain was not fresh, tasted dry, and hard to cut into and I was looking at other people plates and there's look way fresher read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Old fried plantain - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Always a good experience. Food is excellent and service is quick. Lots of options for food and drink. Ample parking. Always clean and a steady flow of customers. They also have their menu in Spanish and English for those who need. read more

See all

I love this place. They have some of the best columbian food. I used to come here when this location was first opened. They have an extension on the small little restaurant that they started out with. The service is ok. They got mine and my aunts order mixed up, but they fixed it pretty quick. Have visited every time I come to visit now. read more

See all

Service horrible can't understand us, the food wait long, then barley warm, french fries not hot, rotisserie chicken bland and nasty, no taste at all, the server never came back, the sodas had to constantly be exchanged and still flat like water and syrup, never came back to ask if anything was alright. Just horrible a "ZERO" I will never waste my TIME NOR MONEY!!!! DO NOT PATRONIZE!!!!!!! read more

Yesterday, Wednesday, November 19th of this year, I visited the Mi Tierrita restaurant in Patchogue, NY, and I'm going to tell you about my bad and bitter experience at this restaurant. I ordered chicken consommé and my friend ordered beef sancocho. Excuse me, but the food was so poorly cooked that it tasted awful. The sancocho tasted like pure grease, and the chicken consommé was even worse. And to top it all off, the waitress gave us terrible service. We were served by the worst waitress in the restaurant. I was starving, and the service was terrible! I was sorry to pay for that meal; I felt like I'd wasted my money. I went home hungry and very disappointed. I would never recommend this restaurant read more

This restaurant is kept clean and neat on the inside. The service is pleasant and quick. The food is amazing, always fresh and plentiful! I love their consommé, as well as the grilled mixed platter! read more

La comida es deliciosa!! Amo ir con mi familia, existe gran variedad de platos y opciones para todos. El servicio siempre ha sido rápido aunque siempre esta lleno la Asignación de mesa es rápida. La decoración trae muchos recuerdos de colombia uno de mis restaurantes favoritos en long island. A veces hay música en vivo o ponen muy buena música lo que hace el ambiente agradable y feliz .. como en casa! read more

Can't believe I just made my first visit to Mi Tierrita Restaurant just a few weeks ago. As I scrolled through fellow Yelpers' reviews, I was surprised to read about the hit or miss experiences they've had at this place. My husband grew up a local to town and this was a spot he frequented while still living in the area. I'm thrilled that we came on a 'good' day as everything from the food to service was fantastic. My husband and I came in on a weekday for dinner. To my surprise, they had many customers at the time we came in and maintained a steady flow of take out and dine in patrons while we enjoyed our meal. We were promptly greeted and brought to a seat, then quickly approached by a friendly waitress to take our initial drink orders and answer any initial questions. Her attentiveness to our table and speed with our requests were remarkable. The great service we received elevated the amazing food we ordered. Our order consisted of - Chicken Empanadas - Beef Empanadas - Typical Platter All the food we had was OUTSTANDING and authentic. Empanadas were stuffed with flavorful, tender meat. The Typical Platter was large in quantity and was loaded with all components listed on the menu. Every item on the platter worked perfectly with each other and though everything was tasty, the most memorable were the steak, pork skin (yum!), and sweet plantains (definitely the right thing for this sweet and savory palette of mine). A great sample of what I'm sure is some of their best items. The food was definitely priced correctly to the taste, quality, and quantity. Based on my experience, Mi Tierrita Restaurant made a memorable first impression. Looking forward to future visits to try more from their menu. read more

See all

Good food and great service! We were having an impromptu get-together at the house and we didn't want the regular go-to like pizza or burgers. My big brother recommended this place as one of his favorites, and it's now one of mine! We ordered the Salmon dinner, which came with Cassava, and a soft, delicious cream sauce. It also came with rice and beans which were very flavorful. We also ordered the grilled chicken dinner and breaded fried chicken dinner, which came with fries and rice with beans. The beef empanadas were amazing, so were their version of fried sweet plantains. The Arepas were good, fresh, and cheesy. We also ordered an extra white rice which had tons of flavor. Overall, the experience went beyond my expectations. I'll be recommending this place to friends and family, and I will make sure I stop in every time I'm in town!! read more

Mi Tierrita 3/5 I've had a lot of Colombian cuisine and this was pretty average. Nothing was out of the ordinary and dishes were overall lacking flavor. Service from certain servers were horrible, other servers were much more attentive. Food and service fluctuate too drastically for me to give this restaurant any more than a 3 our of 5. Dishes ordered: Bandeja Campensina (Ground beef, pork skin, egg, corn cake, sweet plantain, avocado, rice and beans) Pechuga De Pollo Empanizada (Breaded chicken breast, french fries, rice and beans) Guisado De Cola y Costilla de Res (Sautéed oxtails and ribs, casava, potato, rice and beans) Arepa Blanca con Queso and chorizo (Corn Cake w/ Shredded Cheese and Sausage) Mondongo Grande (Soup of the day) Bandeja Campensina: 3.5/5 This dish is very fulfilling and will definitely hold your hunger down for a while. Rice lacked flavor and the Chicharon was very hard, a bit over cooked. The sweet plantain is a great change of flavor for the savory based plate. The ground meat was good and complimented the beans well. Just lacked a bit of flavor but overall good dish. Pechuga De Pollo Empanizada: 5/5 Chicken was fried perfectly and the breading had a delicious crunch. The chicken stayed juicy and can never go wrong with some French fries on the side. Guisado De Cola y Costilla de Res: 2.5/5 I do understand the meats in this dish are expensive so that definitely reflected the portion size but I wish I got a heads up. The meat the potato and the Yuka all lacked flavor. Even the orange sauce on the plate could save the lack of flavor. Meats like oxtail usually are soft tender and fall of the bone, here it was a bit rougher than I would have liked and had a lot more fat than meat. Sadly the best part of this dish was the rice and beans on the side. Arepa Blanca con Queso and Chorizo: 4/5 Arepa was cooked to perfection and the cheese was broiled on top and left a nice golden crust. The chorizo was cooked and tasted very fresh. Combining all three flavors created a party in your mouth was really good. Arepa felt like it was a couple days old but still was a very good dish. Mondongo Grande: 5/5 Was a delicious soup and was very tasteful. They were very generous with the meat and was the best dish by far. If I were to come back it's for this soup right here, a Colombian classic and it's absolutely amazing here. The rice and beans are an awesome side with this dish and the flavor was spot on. I will continue my search for the best Colombian food in the Suffolk area but this is a nice place if ur in the mood and ur in the area. I might come for certain dishes but the inconsistency in their service was a good turn off. 3/5 the soup and the chicken is the only reason I might come back. read more

See all

Being objective about this place. The location and the decor and overall cleanliness is pretty good. The great part of the review stops there. Of the plates that we got, the main plates were mostly bland and the aji was borderline acidic. It was the empanadas that were inedible. One of the four empanadas was as hard as a rock and was sent back, didn't feel like breaking any teeth. The second of four empanadas didn't have any chicken and here is the kicker, the waiter tried to convince me that the chicken had been pureed to the point that it was even textured to the flour used. Rigghhht...and I have a bridge in NY to sell you. Lastly, when dishes are sent back, a customer usually doesn't have to pay, but not here, full price and not even an apology. First and Last time we go there. We are Colombians and know Colombian food. read more

Ordered lunch to go about a week ago. Food is great honestly, but customer service has to be better. I don't live near here, and when I realized my side of beans were missing, I called to ask for a partial refund. The lady who answered said they "don't do refunds", and proceeded to say it was my fault because I left when she went to get the beans. However, she told me have a great day, never said to wait for anything else. Poor communication, poor service. Food isn't enough if you can't properly serve your customers. read more

My boyfriend first introduced me to this restaurant. This restaurants plates are huge and loaded with delicious food. The plate we get comes with steak, an egg, avocado, rice,beans & chicharrón. Service is quick and nice and it's a family friendly environment read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Typical Platter - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

If I could leave zero stars I would. This was our second time giving them a chance because the first time was not good. Never brought the appetizer, got the order wrong twice and refused to fix it. Charged us for the appetizer and never brought it but the chef said they sent it out. There wasn't even a plate for it in the table! Manager was no help didn't even apologize. Second waitress was rude trying to help and then laughed at us for complaining. Will never go back there again. read more

This place is is horrible. Brentwood is ok but this place is not worth it not even for the food. From the person in charge to the waiters. Everyone seems like they are having the worst day of their lives every day. Very rude, yell and fight with customers and with each other in front of customers. Even over the phone very rude. El servicio es horrible, el de Brentwood es bueno pero el de Patchogue es Súper mal. Pelean entre ellos afrente de los clientes y le gritan a los clientes hasta el teléfono te gritan haces una pregunta y te insultan. De la Mesera ala encargarda. NUNCA mas read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Picada ordered but found a hair - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

... very friendly staff ... my favorites are the Tripe Soup and Ceviche ... Chicken dishes are very good ... great beer, drinks and desserts... read more

Love this place! From the friendly waitstaff to the delicious food, to the welcoming atmosphere, Mi Tierrita is a winner! Empanadas are great, and if you ask, they'll prepare a special Arepa con queso blanco for you. Chicharon and parillada are wonderful. Looking for authentic Colombian fare... Try this place. read more

Do not waste your time or money. Empanadas and the rest of the food are horrific. This use to be a good restaurant they have completely let go. read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

I only got takeout but everything was very good. I definitely will go back to eat in the restaurant

#1 COLOMBIAN SPOT ON THE ISLAND You cannot beat the portions and prices. And don't even get me started on the food, FANTASTIC. I would give 10 stars if I could. I recommend this spot to everyone I know and I get the same reaction every time, delicious. If you don't speak spanish like myself, pretty much every sever is bilingual which is great. read more

See all

Food is excellent, fresh & authentic! Love this place!! Been coming here for several years & never disappointed!! read more

Zero estrellas. Why: I bought two chicken soups and a full chicken platter to go. They would NOT give any limes or sell them to me unless I bought an alcoholic beverage. Weird. Big disappointment when that's what I was expecting with a soup. --No me quisieron dar ni un limón para las sopas de pollo que compre. Ni aún diciendo que los compro. Me hicieron gestos bien odiosos y al principio dijeron que no habían limones. Des pues que solo me los dan si se compra bebidas alcohólicas. Que bárbaros!! read more

food is alright my chicken came raw and the waiters are so bad they don't deserve no tip

This place never disappoints! Always good food, large portions, great place and affordable family restaurant!

I love everything about this place ! From the sangria to the apps the rice is one of the tastiest I've ever had so buttery. The chicharron is the best anywhere . The empanadas delish . Prices are incredible. I could go here once a week. The chicken soup is fresh homemade chicken on the bone and the broth I could drink all day ! The salmon soup has huge chucks of salmon , and if you order the salmon dinner it's so worth it def for two ppl to share. We always over order .. But nothing goes to waste. Portions are a great size. The corn cake with cheese on top omg so good severed with this lil pepper sauce on the side . read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

My first visit to this bustling restaurant. And I know why it is so busy, the food. We started with the house sangria, so delicious. A big glass, only 6.95 and so worth it. Tried the empanadas, delicious. I could easily have. Devoured more, tender been in side delicious golden friend dough. As the was our first visit we tried two players, both came with the best beans I have ever experienced. I could go back and just eat beans, and this coming from someone who normally does not enjoy beans in any form is a real compliment. Loved the fried plantain. The grilled steak and pork was awesome as was the rotisserie check. Next time you are out skip the Mexican food and head for Columbia! read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Siempre la mejor comida! Me encanta este restaurante, siempre dan buen servicio y la comida siempre está deliciosa. 10/10

I used to love getting food here. The prices went so high up even before pandemic. Portions used to be nice and big. I cannot believe 3 large sancochos (that come with a small portion of rice and beans and one order of 5 slices of maduros totaled 48.99 as take out. The taste is there however for that price I should just made it myself. 3 stars for disappointment because I recall how it used to be. read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Latest menu. Prices are way up now. - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

This is bad so many times I order pechugas empanizaras and EVERY TIME they are nasty uncooked inside !! No matter how much I ask please to get it right .. and they can't !! It used to be a good portion of chicken inside . Now it's 1/8 of meet and 1/2 " of bread .. come on ? All that money for rice and beans ?? read more

Terrible customer service, on top of that, I order rosterier chicken and it was half way cook all pink inside . NEVER coming back here.

I initially called to ask about a specific kind of soup. The person who answered the phone could not speak any English. As hard as I tried, she wasn't understanding me! I then told her I needed someone who spoke English! I had to wait on the phone for almost 15 minutes before someone (I think a waitress), got on the phone. I placed the order with her. After picking up the order, my husband said the soup was bad (old and tasted funny ), so he had to throw it out! I won't be ordering from them again UNLESS I stop in purposely and only order the 3 empanadas and rice and beans. It's the only food I believe will be good. My husband is from another country and works with the public daily AND his English isn't perfect but he can understand and responds to customers appropriately, so my complaint has nothing to do with the fact that most of the workers weren't born in this country. However, if you want to serve Spanish speaking people only, you should let English speakers know that! Furthermore without having someone who can speak English enough to answer simple questions and take orders, they will lose many English speaking customers! read more

Absolutely Love Mi TIERRITA...The Food is Always Delicious & they make the most scrumptious roasted chicken! Pinto Beans, Salad Fresh & Chicken Soup to die for! Everything on Menu is a Must Try more than Once! We come @ least once a month read more

See all

Service is terrible people don't want to serve and rude and had faces the whole time while we were polite and nothing but happy for my cousin's graduation and they ruined the mood and the food was okay read more

The food is very good but the service was horrible.. Since I only speak a little spanish I ordered in English but she insisted responding only in spanish. I made many attempts to get my waitress to come by so I can get a drink but she would make eye contact with me and look away. NOT once did she come over to see how I was doing. Not to mention I was the only person I there eating at the time. I had to get up at the very end and ask another waitress for the bill. As I was walking out I passed my waitress and she made a point to ignore my "thank you". I don't know why I received such a nasty attitude and poor service. Can it be that I'm not spanish? I'd like to think that's not the case but considering when I couldn't understand one of her questions she sighed then rolled her eyes and repeated it slowly like she was talking to a little kid.. If I could vote food alone it would be 5.. service 1.. Edited: wow just read comments and it seems that the service is horrible is a regular occurrence. If you don't speak fluent spanish expect to be looked at like your not in the USA. read more

Ordered fried shrimp which normally comes with rice, a beet, lettuce, tomato and the shrimp. Picked up my order and the plate had only shrimp and some lettuce. A week later ordered the same thing and told the lady that they didn't included everything last time so please make sure they do this time. Picked up the order, and shrimp came with just rice. Nothing more. I'm annoyed and angry that I pay full price but didn't receive my full order. The food is delicious and this is something they can fix. Please fix it, pretty soon I'm goin to stop ordering. It's not cheap and not fair to be paying full price if the order isn't complete. read more

Where do I even start? This place is the best!!! I have been here before. Mi Tierrita is guaranteed to fill your belly with freshly cooked food. They have an ample sized parking lot. It was early so we were seated quickly. Service was great. Oh to start we ordered a pitcher of homemade sangria. Delicious!!! It's a cool fall evening on Long Island. My friend invited me to dinner. As I was driving there I was thinking about what I wanted to order. I knew that I didn't want to leave uncomfortably full, as I have in the past. So when she ordered a bowl of chicken soup, I thought that sounded perfect. So I ordered a bowl of Mondongo. It is a delicious soup with (get ready for it) tripe. I love this soup. It was delicious!!! Little did I know that it came with rice and beans. We got a side order of tostones (plantains) and a side order of maduros (sweet plaintains). For dessert we ordered the caramel flan (a custard), I didn't care for it. But it's personal preference. Of course I will be back here... I highly recommend eating here!!! read more

See all

My fiancee told me we needed to try this spot after she went there with her bosses. The service was a little slow, but it was a Friday night at dinner and was packed. The portions are huge, I ate for 2 more days with what I ordered, and the prices were reasonable. I will be adding this restaurant to my rotation. read more

Mi Tierrita Restaurant - Pork rib meal with 1/4 chicken and chorizo. - Latin American Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Didn't feel particularly welcomed here. Food was okay. Ordered red wine that must have been stored near machinery since it was warmer than room temp when it was served. Date's sangria was spot on though. read more

Food is hit or miss. It used to be much better. Downgraded their quality of meat in my opinion. Service is slow and prices are high. We still go sometimes. It's kind of like Russian roulette though. read more

We decided to go with the whole family for dinner. It looked promising because the place was packed with people waiting to be seated and dining area was crowded. Food coming out looked very good. Staff were attending us and food came out fairly quickly. And that's about it. The food was meh. Rotisserie chicken had no flavor, the food came out drenched in grease. The only good thing on the table was the rice and beans. Tried it, ate, never going back. read more