Our second time here and this place does not disappoint. From the moment you walk in you're greeted kindly by everyone and sat in a beautiful dining room with cozy vibes. Every employee who helps from the people who fill your water glass to the bus boys clearing plates are exceptional. Our server Francis was absolutely outstanding. He was attentive, always checking on us, making sure our drinks were full, apps were plentiful, and food came out perfect and delicious. We had mentioned it was my birthday in passing and were surprised with a delicious dessert and tequila shots to top off our already full bellies. Between the mouthwatering dessert, fresh table-side guacamole, flavorful enchiladas, and delicious margaritas - we left bursting at the seems and blown away by the service. Thank you to Francis and the team here at Don Quijote for the best dinner experience we've had in quite some time. read more

Don Quijote - Watermelon margarita - Mexican Near Me - Patchogue, New York

My fiancé and I came here for dinner. We went around the start of prime dinner time, but we were seated promptly. Chips and salsa came out shortly after we sat down. The salsa had good flavor. To drink I had a blueberry margarita and my fiancé had a watermelon margarita. Both were great and not overly sweet. For an appetizer we shared the chori- fondue. The menu stated it was served with a side of tortillas, which we didn't get. Not a big deal..we dipped the chips into the fondue instead. For my entree I had the Baja shrimp tacos. They started off with good flavor but then in my first taco one shrimp still had the shell on it. I know that sometimes the shell is left on for flavor purposes, but not in tacos that one is bitting into. I then saw the shell was on another shrimp in my third taco. This was definitely a poor oversight and poor attention to detail as it wasn't on every shrimp. Eater beware. My fiancé had arroz con pollo which he enjoyed. The serving was quite large and he has atleast another two meals for later. Service was alright, but our server never came back to check on us. Overall, I'd say it was just okay and average. read more

See all

First time here and it did not disappoint! We were lucky enough to get a nice day for cinco de mayo so we arrived for lunch and ate outside. It was super quiet which was nice. Chips were swiftly brought out to our table as was our main dishes: cheese quesadilla, skirt steak and a burrito. Everything was absolutely delicious. The marinade on my steak was perfect and was cooked perfectly. We ordered chocolate fudge cake to top it off. Highly recommend! read more

Don Quijote - Mexican Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Very nice outdoor space, great service and outstanding food Nd drinks. This restaurant is very accessible. I highly recommend. read more

Don Quijote - Top shelf Margs - Mexican Near Me - Patchogue, New York

I should have written this review sooner. My wife and I are regulars here . We have been seated at the tables but prefer the bar. This is a festive establishment with great food, drinks and atmosphere. You are greeted with chips and salsa. Delicious homemade chips and authentic Mexican salsa. Not typical Tostitos salsa . The bartenders are friendly and accommodating , shout out to Maria! The BEST margaritas EVER. We have eaten virtually the entire menu. Tacos are delicious and authentic. We have enjoyed both hard and soft shell. Awesome seasoning, not to salty as compared to typical "Mexican" restaurant's Pollo poblano is awesome. Delicious authentic Mole sauce. Tonight we had the Enchiladas trio. 1 each chicken, beef and cheese. Delicious. Hot flavorful and fresh. We also had the tortilla soup with chicken. Probably my favorite dish. Loaded with chicken, cheese, chips. It's warm and flavorful especially in February! Although we enjoy it all year round. Skip the "dirty taco " chain restaurants and head here for the real thing. read more

Don Quijote - Enchiladas Trio - Mexican Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Great customer service food was good. They topped your meal off with a shot of tequila. If you want want, I passed but evey single person from the weight staff to the cedar to the guys who cleaned up your table. Wonderful experience it was fantastic! read more

Had a great time for their cinco de mayo event. Our waitress Colette was super attentive and having her around made the evening that much more special. This time I had the chicken enchiladas with the salsa verde. It came out piping hot and delicious! Their mango margarita was good too! We forgot to make a reservation so we waited at the bar until a table became available. read more

See all

Upon opening, I came to this Mexican spot to grab lunch with my family. The restaurant was currently empty so it felt like we were the first guest. I requested seating outside and was happy to choose a seating of my choice. The outdoor seating is very nice with umbrellas for shade. The indoor seating is nice as well but it was a lovely day to enjoy some air. The staff was very pleasant and we had very fast service. I ordered the chicken and rice (which I have never ordered at a restaurant before) while my family ordered the Churrasco. We were served chips and salsa for the table which was very delicious. The chicken and rice had a mix of many flavors. I didn't notice this dish came with sausage so I did put them to the side after trying one (not a huge fan of sausage). Additionally, The churrasco was cooked in a way I had never seen before. My family stated it was okay and not bad. The churrasco came with beans, rice and sweet plantain. I will definitely come back to this place. It was pretty quiet, great wait staff and fast service. Oh, lastly the drinks were delicious if you are a drinker. We got the mojito and the smoky sandia. read more

See all

Best enchiladas in NY! Same recipes since the 90s. I always come back just for this. The menu is expansive with many types of Latin food as well. Not just Mexican. read more

Don Quijote - Enchilada trio. Beef, cheese, and chicken with rice and beans. - Mexican Near Me - Patchogue, New York

The only restaurant besides Taco Bell that uses jar salsa. The queso was also microwaved from a jar. Inedible. Crazy expensive prices for this type of food. There are plenty of other great options on Long Island. Service was very good but even they were shoulder shrugged over what was being brought to the table. read more

This is so much fun on a Saturday night. Ernesto plays the guitar and sings. your table can join in on a song and play the tambourine along for a fun and memorable evening. Fajitas and tacos are excellent. Table side guacamole is a treat! Pitchers of margaritas are always a good time. Wait staff are friendly, consistent and professional. they are happy to accommodate special requests and substitutions on the menu. read more

Visiting from out of town and we're referred from locals. Location is set back but easy to find. They have a beautiful outdoor seating area to eat and inside is very cozy and warm feeling. We were greeted with swarm hello. The staff were all very helpful. We started with peach margaritas that were amazing and complimentary chips and salsa that were so good. I ordered shrimp in garlic sauce, my hubby ordered pulled pork chimichanga. Both come with rice and beans. Everything was so fresh, tasty and seasoned to perfection. Definitely a great Mexican restaurant to eat at. read more

See all

First time going to Don Quijote and it wont be the last. Very nice looking restaurant. Our server was great and very attentive. Margaritas were really good. We had the Flautas and Calamari for appetizers and they were great. I had the pescado dulcinea for dinner and it was amazing. Generous size portion of fish. My wife had the carne asada. When served it came out with 2 slim pieces of steak and some plantains. Looked just somewhat bare, but in looking at the menu after, you can order onions and mushrooms but you are charged extra for them. To make it more of an appealing dish they should serve it with that. She said it tasted good which at the end of the day is what matters most. Desserts were very good as well. Highly recommend. read more

The food is good and the portions are surprisingly large . I stopped by one night after working late and picked up what I thought would be two meals . It was enough for 4 people IMO . My family loved it . read more

We have eaten at Don Quixote in Miller Place. Excellent food. Great atmosphere. Mariachi singers. What more would you need?!

Not sure if it was because my family is white but the waiter asked how many was in our party we said 3, 2 adults and an infant and then instead of seating us changed his mind and told us they wouldn't serve us since they were closing. It was an hour and 10 minutes before closing. The 2 hispanic gentlemen's who were sitting at the bar eaten were shaking their heads that they weren't closed and then said they closed at 10, It was 8:45. I definitely wont be returning and my husband will definitely share his experience around patchogue as he does the commercial business route. read more

I'm sure this place does some food items better than others... but the Carne Asada and Pollo con Camarones were respectfully not good. $30 for Carne Asada and it was 2 thin strips of cheap meat, not seasoned and just meh. The Pollo con Camarones had no flavor... chicken unseasoned and the sauce tasted like nothing. Service was awesome, and like I said I'm sure they do some things better than others (the place was slam packed). But these items should immediately be taken off the menu. Worth giving a shot and trying a different dish to compare read more

the food was really good but then me and my girlfriend had a terrible stomach ache and diarrhea after .....kind of worth it i guess

The waiters at Don Quijote were so attentive, and the food was tremendously yummy! Would highly recommend to anyone looking for authentic cuisine and an awesome time! read more

This spot was really nice. Server was on point and his recommendations were on point. I had the Mexican torta and it was great. My wife has the Baja salad with mahi mahi and it was delicious. The coconut margarita was great. I would definitely comeback again. read more

Was very hesitant to come to this place due to some reviews. Well let me say I don't know what is wrong with some people!! The staff were amazing!! The food was fantastic so flavorful!! Drinks are darn good!! We live two blocks away and will be back again and again!!! read more

We were very happy with our experience and meal! The chips and salsa brought to the table right away we're perfect! We ordered the mofungo appetizer without bacon and it was delicious, especially the sauce that's included! I could've taken a straw to it!! I decided on a skinny margarita and it was really light and refreshing. At $13 a drink, I was good with one! Only downside was we waited about 35 min from our appetizer until our meal. Our waiter was nice and apologized for the delay. We weren't in a huge rush so it was tolerable. They had a lot of big parties, so I could understand the wait. Our entrees were really good and generously portioned. My hubby got the pollo ala plancha which he commented was very tender and flavorful. It came with a small portion of white rice and beans. I got a make your own combination plate and chose a beef taco, chicken burrito and chicken enchilada. It came with refried beans, yellow rice and lettuce and tomato. It was SO good and so much food that I took a lot of it home. We were stuffed from our meal that we couldn't fit any dessert in. We will be back again though!! read more

See all

Very good. Came here on a whim... service was good, food was excellent. Loads of gluten free options for my husband. I had the sizzling fajitas sanchos which is steak, chicken and shrimp. Seasoning on meats was different from other Mexican restaurants, chipotle ted sauce with bacon... My husband had the shrimp and fish enchiladas... he enjoyed it as well... read more

See all

I used to know everything, but as I grow older and wiser, as this world changes I find myself at a crossroads of things I just don't understand. One of those things is how Don Quijote could have less than a 4star average here on Yelp; I get it, they are expensive, but I have been here a few times with a plethora of people ordering many many many items off this rather large menu and the food is nothing short of just plain great. My biggest upset in fact, was tonight when my extremely nice and rather cute waitress put down my extremely delicious Ropa Vieja (not much to complain about) which traditionally is shredded beef but to me seemed like pork. Hey, eff me right? The Mofongo was delicious and the typical platter of chorizo, plantain, rice n beans, flank steak (substituted with skirt) and egg was stupid good. The perfectly medium rare steak alone was worth the $20 and then throwing a perfect runny egg over a delicious chorizo... what's there to complain about? Dreams are made in enchiladas Suizas and it earns its spot on the Don Quijote menu for sure. The Ceviche isn't the style I normally make or go for but it's still bomb af. Happy hour is home to $4 beers and $7 margs, the staff has always been nice and the kitchen has always been accommodating; the place is nice and decorated for the holidays. I see no problem living beyond my means sometimes and I have no problem forking over a little extra at Don Quijotes, it's well worth it for the flavor they pack into everything from the Salsa to the Entrees. I think the disappointment people feel with this place is the disappointments in their own boring selves, when you suck you usually don't enjoy much of anything and always find something silly to complain about. (Ie. I just read two big criticisms of the free chips n salsa, yet I thought it was just fine ...and free) Check it out for yourself, it sure hit the spot with our party tonight. read more

I have been frequenting this restaurant for many years, even prior was it was under Messon Ole. The food and service are impeccable. I love when I'm dining they have a wonderful and sweet man play guitar and sing and take some requests. A few of the servers know us and know our preferences. I consider this my favorite restaurant. read more

soooo yummy, authentic, cute inside - nice and cozy. nice romantic ambiance for a date. excellent service. they gave us a shot of tequila on the house after our meal. it wasn't packed which i loved, feels intimate and private. maybe 3 couples in one room w space in between. the enchiladas were great and everything had so much flavor as expected. drinks very well made and strong, amazing bartender. reminds me of a few restaurants back home in new mexico. absolutely love thank you! read more

Don't come here with a sore throat. 12/10. Best appetizers, best margaritas, and the best tacos! I love the vibe fr fr

Good service but the food leaves a lot to be desired. The chips were good but the salsa was like nothing I've never had. It was more like watered down Pace with a few diced vegetables tossed in. No flavor at all! Quite a disappointment. I ordered the Steak Milanese with rice, beans and maduros. While it wasn't bad it wasn't anything special. The rice and beans were the best part of the meal. My wife ordered veggie fajitas but they were so laden with palm oil that she couldn't finish her meal. Definitely wouldn't choose it in the future. read more

I'm gluten intolerant and have tried several other local Mexican restaurants that had gluten free items but I would always wind up with some kind of reaction. None of those menus have bespoke gluten free either. It was always something that I'd have to request, and hope they knew what I was talking about, or just gamble with what might be tolerable based on the ingredients. That is not the case with Don Quijote! I was glad to see them appear in a GF search and that the menu had items marked as such or came as an option. Added to that was the flavor didn't suffer, although I suspect the pulled chicken that isn't GF might come with a little more seasoning, it was delicious in my enchiladas. My wife also got the chicken fajitas and she loved them. It was a little expensive and the portions are huge, which is why I'm not giving a 5th star. read more

The food was delicious and the service was amazing, the server and bartender were so friendly and nice. And the food was better than Maria's. read more

The food is amazing. The drinks as well. My favorite is the scorpion bowl. I always share one with my husband. If this is the kind of food you like this is the place for you. Once you're inside it's not too bright and not to dark. It's the perfect lighting. This piece is .3 miles away. So a lot of the time we will walk up there so we can drink and walk home. It never matters anything can happen. The service was also very good. Highly recommended!!! A++++ read more

We went to Don Quixote in Patchogue last night and as usual it did not disappoint!!! The food was delicious and ther service was excellent!!! So fresh and the atmosphere is cozy and warm. We ate inside but pledged to eat outside next time because their outdoor section was beautiful! read more

Don Quijote - Combination of Chili Relleno, Guacamole Tostado and Cheese Burtrito Enchilada - Mexican Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

I debated on leaving a review, but my last experience warrants it, especially with COVID. We had a reservation at 8pm on a weekday. The restaurant was PACKED, every table was filled. As we waited to be seated, I noticed that the entire bar area was open, with people standing shoulder to shoulder, some wearing masks, most without. Even the family waiting across the tiny hallway was not wearing masks, which made us a little uncomfortable. We were seated outside, which was nice, and a little more quiet. The food was good, as were our drinks. The service was okay, it wasn't amazing, but it wasn't bad. I'm not the COVID police, but at the same time, this was pushing the limit on everything. It made my husband and I uncomfortable, and we would've left if not offered an outdoor table, with a little more privacy. I just think people need to be aware of this experience, especially if COVID is a concern. read more

One of my favorite Mexican restaurants. Food is consistently good at reasonable prices. Service is always great

EXPENSIVE for the dinner I received ($20 for a Burrito which only comes with a house salad is crazy to me!!), Service was decent, liked the atmosphere & decor. So the location of this restaurant is great! Right on Montauk Hwy! Parking wasn't terrible but I also went before prime time. I could see the parking lot filling up and having to street park or park elsewhere when it gets super crowded. Was able to make a reservation but because I came so early the restaurant was still almost empty so I didn't need one. Liked the decor and music playing. Tables are tight, especially if you have long legs like I do!! Service was good. Our waiter was definitely friendly. The drinks I ordered were very strong but had a nice taste. I do have a bone to pick about something though...I requested some extra chipotle sauce for my burrito, can you believe they actually charged me $2 for it...after I already spent $20 on the burrito which ONLY came with a salad, no sides! Kind of crazy if you ask me! No prices on the bar menu! My House Margarita was $10.95 which I thought was reasonable. I enjoyed it so much I ordered 2! No free refills on sodas- each soda was $2.50 Food- Good but nothing that overly impressed me. The menu prices are quite high especially compared to the competitors in the area. I didn't mind paying this one time because I wanted to try the restaurant out, but I don't think I received a good deal for the food I was served. There were an extensive amount of menu items to choose from which is a plus for some people and a minus for others. I will be reviewing what I tried at my table! All entrees come with house salad -I did enjoy the dressing Complimentary Chips & Salsa: pretty good, felt that the chips lacked salt but the salsa had a nice taste Alitas De Pollo App: Crispy Fried Chicken Wings: thought the chicken was fried well, liked dunking my wings into the chipotle sauce & sour cream. This was my favorite menu item I tried. 4.5 out of 5 stars Burrito Santa Fe: $19.95 for a salad & burrito is a steep price! Asked for extra chipotle sauce and was charged $2, so a total of $22 for a burrito-yikes! The burrito was disappointing. Very large portion but there was sooooo much rice, almost the entire burrito consisted of rice & beans! I ordered mine with steak and the amount of steak I received was actually PITIFUL. I really did enjoy the chipotle sauce on top, the sauce had a very nice taste to it. 3 out of 5 stars Burrito Ranchero: Picked beef and also comes with bacon. I felt that there was an overwhelmingly large amount of bacon along with rice inside the burrito. There was definitely more meat inside compared to the santa fe burrito but I still wasn't impressed. 2 out of 5 stars Overall I'm glad I was able to cross this restaurant off my list but I most likely won't return. read more

See all

I was excited to try this new restaurant! WORST service ever. When I got my food it tasted like complete dish soap!!! Do not recommend this restaurant to anyone. Besitos is 10x better if you're looking for great Mexican food! read more

Went here on date night with another couple. GET the pitcher of Margaritas! They were delicious! I could not give 5 stars even with the free tequila shot they gave everyone as our waiter had to be constantly summoned over for water refills, to order, another pitch of sangria and our bill. Trying not to call the waiter over to the table like a dog, we spent too much time trying to attract his attention. We ordered the Valencia Paella. We have ordered this before and is a favorite. The crunchy rice is the best part on the bottom of the pan. I ordered the mixed fajitas which were huge and included bacon. Unusual but who doesn't love bacon?! Love this place but not the service, so go with knowing the food is delish but the service is spotty. read more

Most amazing time last night celebrating our dear friend Cliff's Birthday. Great laughs and conversion with friends. Staff had a big role in making it a great night! We basically had the whole bar area. Sampler platters, wings and cocktails were amazing. Not to mention the endless chips and salsa. It was perfect. Thank you so much!!!! read more

See all

I was first drawn to this spot for the beautiful outside seating arrangement. Quality of food is good and portion sizes are even better but I feel like my burrito could have had more flavor. Was mainly rice & beans and not much steak but still good and filling! Not the fastest service but nice servers and a nice place to meet with friends and have a drink & dinner read more

Don Quijote - Don Quijote Burrito - Mexican Near Me - Patchogue, New York

This restaurant is kinda hidden away (hence its name), but well worth the effort to s-l-o'w down & find it. The menu is authentic yet creative and the food is bursting with flavor and simply delicious. The waitress was very friendly and helpful and I ordered the pre fixed based off my waitress' suggestion. Excellent suggestion! It tasted as good as it looks in the photo. Even better. Bar area drive, well lit with atmosphere. Bus persons were A+ attentive. I could communicate with everyone and they played both English and Spanish holidays music. Cocktails are worth the charge, nachos are delightful, appetizers are plentiful. Glad I came here. On main rd but youill never see it if ur driving too fast read more

See all