Cancel

Open app

Search

Melt in Your Mouth

5.0 (1 review)

Order Melt in Your Mouth Delivery

Melt in Your Mouth Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Melt in Your Mouth

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Custom Cakes 335 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Fancypants Baking - Crispy Fancypants Chocolate Chip cookies stacked with falling chocolate chips, made with real butter and premium ingredients.

Fancypants Baking

4.4(13 reviews)
0.4 mi
•$$$$

A friend mailed us cookies from Fancy Pants around Halloween. My husband, who is not normally a fan…read moreof sweets, went nuts for them. I knew I had to get him more for Chanukah. I wanted a mix of the various Chanukah cookies, one for each of the eight nights. (Cue Adam Sandler.) When the website did not have exactly what I wanted, I emailed customer service. They were incredibly responsive and helpful. I ended up getting exactly what I wanted, shipped exactly when I needed it. The cookies were fresh and packed so well you would have thought they were Ming vases! My husband was thrilled with his treats and I admit, I ordered a few extra to enjoy myself. The price is high, as is the quality. However, due to the prices, Fancy Pants cookies will probably be a 'sometimes food' (credit to Cookie Monster). Worth the occasional indulgence - and so nice to encounter such responsive and friendly customer service!

discovered this place from the Too Good to Go app. cookies were fine. I got the chocolate chip,…read moresugar and frosted sugar. I like the fact that they are soft but overall not that memorable. the most memorable part is actually finding the place. google maps leads you to the front of a heavy equipment company where you see a bunch of bulldozers outside. the location itself is off to the side. I made the edits on google maps and has been accepted so it should be bringing you to the correct location. service was quick and painless so couldn't ask for more

Photos
Fancypants Baking - Fancypants Salted Caramel crispy cookies in mini snack packs with sweet caramel and sea salt, perfect for on-the-go snacking and sharing.

Fancypants Salted Caramel crispy cookies in mini snack packs with sweet caramel and sea salt, perfect for on-the-go snacking and sharing.

Fancypants Baking - Fancypants Baking Co. peacock toasting marshmallow

Fancypants Baking Co. peacock toasting marshmallow

Fancypants Baking - Fancypants Baking Co crispy gourmet cookies assortment with Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel, Gluten-Free, and more in signature red packaging

See all

Fancypants Baking Co crispy gourmet cookies assortment with Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel, Gluten-Free, and more in signature red packaging

Ever So Humble Pie Company

Ever So Humble Pie Company

4.6(60 reviews)
2.3 mi
•$$

There are two farm stands in my area that sell these pies. The best pies in the world. I love your…read moreJumble Berry. They are certainly outrageous and homemade. I do not hesitate serving them for holidays over a bakery. If you were closer I would try your donuts. Do you make apple cider donuts? Don't go away. I eat no other pies but yours.

I recently stopped into Ever So Humble Pie Company with Easter in mind, and it quickly turned into…read moreone of those visits where you leave with far more than you planned--in the best way. The shop is set in a funky old New England mill space that perfectly matches what they do: warm, a little rustic, and full of charm. It feels authentic right away, like everything coming out of the kitchen is made with care and intention. The pies are the main event, and they absolutely deliver. I went in specifically for a large blueberry pie to serve at our Easter brunch, and I'm absolutely confident it won't disappoint. Of course, I couldn't stop there--I also picked up a few of the personal 5" pies to stash in the freezer, which feels like a very smart decision for future dessert emergencies The ready-to-eat baked goods are just as worth your attention, but you have to time it right--they sell out fast. I managed to grab a lemon raspberry scone for the drive home, and I think it's my favorite scone now. Perfectly balanced, not too sweet, and exactly what you want from a great scone. Between the quality, the setting, and the variety, this is the kind of place that works just as well for a holiday centerpiece as it does for a spontaneous stop. I'm glad it's not closer to home though--it would be very hard to achieve my desired weight goals it if were. Just be sure to go early if you want the best selection of ready to eat goods.

Photos
Ever So Humble Pie Company
Ever So Humble Pie Company - Apple pie, blueberryand cranberry breads

Apple pie, blueberryand cranberry breads

Ever So Humble Pie Company

See all

Guarino Pastry Shop - cookies galore

Guarino Pastry Shop

4.1(109 reviews)
3.9 mi
•$$

Needing to get some cookies for a family party, I stopped in here with my father and got a few…read moreboxes of cookies. A long standing, family owned Italian Bakery has been a part of many family parties throughout my life, and I'm glad to see they're still surviving. They offer a great variety of cookies, as well as other baked goods like breads, cakes, pies and more. Many of the cookies are sold by the pound, so my father got a couple of mixed boxes for our family reunion, getting a good mix of styles and flavors. The staff was very friendly, and patient as we filled the box. They took care to put heavier items on the bottom, as to not ruin the softer items, and were happy to make suggestions and recommendations. The selection went over really well at the party, and in the end we were left with just crumbs. Looking forward to the next opportunity I get to enjoy some tasty treats from Guarino's

Really nice bakery for cookies, cakes and breads. Old school place with nice employees and sweets…read moreand breads that are legit. We had the ricotta cheesecake which was insanely good. Perfectly light and delicious with ample ricotta and lightly dusted with powdered sugar. Cinnamon loaf was similarly delicious. Italian breads (square shaped) are delicious, great slices and buttered or cut into chunks for a hearty sandwich. Solid spot to score delicious baked goods and breads.

Photos
Guarino Pastry Shop - Went in for a couple of danishes and came out with 2 variety boxes filled with deliciousness!!

Went in for a couple of danishes and came out with 2 variety boxes filled with deliciousness!!

Guarino Pastry Shop - Pies and breads

Pies and breads

Guarino Pastry Shop

See all

Melt in Your Mouth - customcakes - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...