Loved this place. It was like going back in time. Employees were so nice and seemed so happy to be there. Food was great! Had the Pizza Omelet which I had never even heard of before. Spoke to the cashier. It was great to hear about the history of the diner read more

Wonderful place. Food is amazing. Best Breakfast place I have found yet in the region! Try the omelets with the spicy sausage and tomatoes! Ask for a side of corned beef hash extra crispy! Ask about their freshly baked bread too! read more

See all

Excellent service and good food. Nice place to visit old mementos from Fairmont State

Service was quick and the portion of the food was good. We took leftovers back to the hotel room. The waitress was very attentive to our needs. The cashier was polite and friendly. If I am back in the area this place will be on my list for another breakfast. read more

Excellent food, service, and location! Homey atmosphere! Their breakfast is fantastic! Try their omelettes!

Best breakfast in Fairmont. Homemade toast on sandwich is always good. Demus Italian sausage, mozzarella cheese and fried hot Hungarian wax peppers. Just the right amount of heat and flavor. The waitress was so cheery and helpful. They were busy but the room was quiet and comfortable. read more

McAteer's - Home made bread toasted with hot Demus sausage and fried hot peppers and melted mozzarella cheese. - Diners Near Me - Fairmont, West Virginia

Is a great experience. Service & food terrified. They really aim to please the customer. Wish I could go eat there more often. Very clean & welcoming. read more

McAteer's - Happy day with family & sunshine - Diners Near Me - Fairmont, West Virginia

See all

Had breakfast here on Sunday morning before heading out of town. It was busy, but they had just enough space for us to grab a table. Coffee was served from eclectic mugs, friendly staff, and a hometown, diner kinda feel were pretty much what I would expect in Fairmont. I ordered the breakfast burrito and my bf ordered a combo plate with bacon, eggs, toast and a side of french toast. Coffee tasted like diner coffee... or like coffee from grandma's house -- like it was made with a fine aged coffee pot with folgers. The sausage in my burrito was tasty, but overall, there were too many potatoes which made it dry (even with salsa and sour cream) and it could have used more eggs and cheese instead. bf didn't have anything to complain about, but then again his was pretty basic. Overall, it was a bit underseasoned, so I'd likely go for something basic next time I'm in search of breakfast in the friendly city. read more

McAteer's - Diners Near Me - Fairmont, West Virginia

Best food in town! We live the entire staff. Eat there any chance we get. Large menu. Best tea in town.

My favorite grilled chicken salad around.... It's loaded with veggies, fresh lettuce, cheese, grilled chicken and waffle fries if you'd like...... So good and filling! read more

Amazing place my dad works here he is the best cook everyone knows here at mcateers amazing restaurant and food so nice

Great service. They're always busy so be prepared to wait for a table. Coffee is the best in town. Newly painted with new tile floors. But the food is still the same......GOOD!!!!! read more

Been here twice and both times were absolutely great! We love their breakfast food a ton. Very friendly service and comfortable sit-in dining. We love the historical things hanging on the walls. read more

Recently, I've been from place to place looking for a good breakfast spot, and this is the only place that passes my test. A few days ago I stopped in here and found the hands down best breakfast that you can find anywhere. I don't know what it is that they do, but their food is magic. The western style omelet was perfect. The meat and vegetables didn't water down the eggs. It was the perfect sponge texture. Generally I only eat breakfast on my days off of work and this is my new regular spot in the coming weeks. read more

McAteer's - Diners Near Me - Fairmont, West Virginia

Food was decent. Service was slow but good. Cool place. I probably would look elsewhere next time.

Amazing food every time. Coffee is a little weak and watery for my taste but other than that I love everything else about the food

Great and simple breakfast! Nothing fancy, but the food is good and the atmosphere is inviting. read more

McAteer's - Menu - Diners Near Me - Fairmont, West Virginia

See all

So less than impressed. Eggs were overdone, pancakes were doughy. Hashbrowns were a pile of grease. We had to wave someone down to refill our coffee. This was just really bad. read more

So I have been hearing nothing but good reviews about this place from personal friends, so I decided to give it a try today for breakfast. K ordered the chili and homemade white bread while I had an order of hotcakes and an order of homemade white bread. The chili was appetizing, plentiful, hot, but overly spicy. The bread complimented it well for dipping. I had the hotcakes, 3 full sized plate pancakes, which were huge. I didn't get butter delivered to he table so I just had them with syrup. They were extremely filling, and I could only eat half the plate.. (Which is unlike me!). Service was slow for a slow morning, parking was sparse, the prices seemed a little high for what we were actually getting. I wasn't amazed by anything at this place, so I don't think I'll be rushing back anytime soon, but I might drop in again. read more

We stopped by on our way to Morgantown and it was great.. had breakfast and wanted to stop in for lunch but didn't have time... My hats off to the cook! read more

See all

My favorite place in Fairmont. When you walk into McAteer's you are treated like family. Even though I now live in nyc, I will keep visiting McAteer's every time I com back to iFairmont. read more

This is such a great diner! Great service. Great portion for the price. Mom & pop atmosphere. Fresh food. Breakfast - warm syrup - you can't go wrong. Plus prices for breakfast all include the cup of coffee! read more

The breakfast food is great. Fairmont never needs an Eat n Park or Denny's as long as McAteer's is around. And they are not very expensive. Just make sure you remember to bring cash. read more

It's a good "Down Home " Feeling place to meet and eat. Service is good and the food is great. Kudos to Tim Mc. especially on St Patricks' Day. Yum.. Tony Sirianni read more

Very authentic "down home"; very friendly staff. Family-run. A real "find", for us non-McDonald's type diners. Loads of local memorabilia on the walls and all around. We ate at the counter and lingered. The night before, we'd "dined" in Grafton with the Colonel (yeah, food is 'that' bad, in Grafton). We'll go out of our way to eat at McAteer's again, you bet. read more

Definitely the best place in Fairmont to plan for a small breakfast with a large group or just for two. This place has an amazing, "Fairmontian" atmosphere that will really make you appreciate the city and the history. The food is amazing, as I have visited many times and have ordered plenty of different things. I love the hotcakes, the breakfast burrito, and the egg salad sandwich. Service is very quick, and the staff are very friendly and welcoming. The only downfall is being able to accept cash or check, but that can't stop me from leaving a 5 star review. You should definitely check in if you're in the city and need a place to eat for breakfast or lunch! read more

Visited here for breakfast after moving into town. Great little diner. The hot sausage is great and the homemade toast is worth the extra charge! If it's a busy time, seating is limited. They only accept cash, so come prepared! read more

Outstanding! Service was quick and very friendly! Food was excellent! Perfect diner experience! Love all the vintage sports related pics, banners and clothing! A must stop in Farirmont! read more

So my friend and I were very hungover after a night out and needed breakfast. We go to WVU so we drove to 3 different places in Morgantown and all were closed or not serving breakfast. We drove 30 min to Fairmont for Poky Dot cause we heard it had good food, and they were closed too. So we last minute decided to go to McAteers. I think the universe directed us here. The food was fantastic and so was the coffee. But the service was the best of the whole experience! Our waitress was so nice and all the people in the restaurant were kind with smiles on their faces. Overall, this place is just fantastic. read more

Great service with even better food! I've enjoyed every meal I've ever eaten here, and have made it a go to place every week.

It is the greatest food. Very good pricing as well. I would recommend checking them out especially if you like good home cooked food. You will not be disappointed. I have had breakfast several times and it was so perfect. Not a large place but it has plenty of seating and the staff is wonderful. I owned my own restaurant of similar size and type in the past and I appreciate great food and friendly service. The waiters and waitresses go above and beyond to see that you have all you need and want and make your dining experience great. read more

The food is fantastic!! The service is great! I love the "mom and pop" type atmosphere. It is certainly a one of a kind restaurant.

Definitely one of my favorite places in town to eat. My girlfriend and I stop in after we get off of work quite often and the service is some of the best we've experienced at a restaurant. Great food, polite and timely staff. read more

I love this place. When I walked in the front door, the smell immediately reminding me of my grandmother's kitchen. The service is generally very good, but due to the demand they can become quite overwhelmed during the busiest hours. There are a lot of items related to Fairmont nostalgia across the restaurant. I highly recommend this diner. read more