Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    May St. Cafe's

    5.0 (1 review)

    May St. Cafe's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - May St. Cafe's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Latin American 1,183 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Amaru - Bolivian Pork Roast entree and wine

    Amaru

    4.7(486 reviews)
    4.1 mi•Wicker Park, West Town
    •$$$

    I can't believe it took me this long to try Amaru. I fully regret waiting this long to try it…read morebecause it was so so good. We were able to snag a Rez day of. The service was great, everyone was so helpful and nice. We started a the piononos, the server told us the coconut fried rice was really good paired with the piononos and she nailed it. They're perfect together. So much flavor. Very tasty. I had a NA piña colada that came in a fun flamingo glass. The papa bravas were so good as well. The Cuban oxtail is a pasta fish w oxtail inside. Very rich and delicious. Husband ordered the bone in rib eye, which took a bit too long to come out so we were stuffed by the time it came out. It was cooked really nicely though and was nice to take home to eat at another time. The inside is small and cozy. We will mos def be back! There's pay to park street parking outside.

    Dined here with the hubby during Valentine's Day weekend. They had a special Valentine's menu…read morecurated for guests to order from. I was so excited for this meal cause Amaru has been on my list for so long! Piononos: They had me at chorizo stuffed plantains. A nice latin twist from the usual bacon wrapped dates. Highly recommend! Pulpo gallego: I don't think I've ever had octopus with beans before but it surprisingly paired very well together. Love me a nice charred octopus and this one was delish. Cuban oxtail: I still dream about this unique pasta dish!!! Great flavor. Wish there were more agnolotti because I had a lot of oxtail meat leftover by the end of the meal. Lomo steak: Such a pretty delicious dish! 5/5 stars all around! Highly recommend to share. Guava cheescake: I LOVE anything guava. The cut and presentation of the dessert gets a 5/5 for me. The slice was as long as the plate! Great way to end the meal. Overall, everything was great - the service, food, vibes, etc. I would love to dine here again :)

    Photos
    Amaru - Interior

    Interior

    Amaru - Shrimp Entree

    Shrimp Entree

    Amaru - Pina Colada and ?

    See all

    Pina Colada and ?

    Cariño - Horchata chai

    Cariño

    4.9(43 reviews)
    7.9 mi•Uptown

    Good value compared to other Michelin star menus. Nice portion size, leaving full but not…read moreexploding. Excellent cocktails. Intimate setting with just 7 seats at the chef's counter and 12 in the dining area. 9/13 dishes were great. There's no "smoke and mirrors" at the chef's counter. For an additional $20, we received two extra courses and an intimate look at a high-functioning, high-pressure kitchen. Chef Norman Fenton's exacting expectations are on full display. It's a masterclass in attention to detail, though the transparency comes with a side of tension. I loved the honesty of the experience, but if your goal is a serene conversation over dinner, the main dining room is the play. 5/5 Would be sad to never have again (1) * Chamoyada: Palate cleansers are always refreshing, but this was next level. Fruity and fresh heaven. 4.5/5 Great (8) * Chips and Salsa: Impressive to finish like a true salsa and chip. My wife loved * Chicharron: Rich corn and cheese dip. * Aguachile: Stunning visually. Lovely chile broth. * Quesadilla: Truffle uses well to round the dish. Super rich with black garlic. * Lamb: Super rich glaze. Great accompaniments from the beets and sauces. * Pineapple dessert * Horchata chai: Banana pieces were incredible. Good sweetness level. * Finishing bites: Nice 33% and 66% chocolate. Fun little bites. 3/5: OK (3) * Ravioli: Ravioli inside was rich, but overly so. Nice corn sauce but there was a corn component on the outside of the dish that had an unpleasant chewy flavor. * Tacos Dorados/Bluefin Tuna/Toasta: Love the idea of taco flight, and a great mix of textures. But none of the taco flavors hit for me. * Black Cod: Great components, but a sum that added up to less not more. Ultracrispy kale, but it tasted far better on its on. Nice green sauce and cod. Chayote texture felt out of place for me. 2/5 Not good (1) * Michelada: The Modelo beer foam dominated what I'm sure was lovely oyster.

    Let me start by saying that curated Chef experiences are new to me and realistically outside of my…read morecomfort zone. I've never been a fan of someone else telling me what and how to eat. Wow... what a great experience. From the first course, a zesty oyster to dessert the experience was not what I expected and in a good way. I won't do the Chef a disservice by trying to describe what we were provided but know this the Taco Omakase is well worth the trip. Seriously, if you can make it in you need to do so It is well worth the effort.

    Photos
    Cariño - Frida greets you inside.

    Frida greets you inside.

    Cariño - Tacos

    Tacos

    Cariño - Old fashioned

    See all

    Old fashioned

    Carnivale Chicago

    Carnivale Chicago

    3.9(2.7k reviews)
    2.4 mi•West Loop, Near West Side
    •$$$

    Carinvale is such a fun and lively restaurant in Chicago's West Loop! This spot was recommended by…read morethe hotel I was staying at, and the decor alone makes it worth it. The space is incredibly cool, colorful, and full of personality. Our waiter was friendly, attentive, and really made the experience enjoyable. The food was okay overall, but the pecan banana butter cake was definitely a highlight. They also provided a side of free cotton candy. How fun! There's a parking lot directly across the street, just a few steps from the restaurant, and they also offer valet. The valet was actually cheaper than self parking but I went on a week day so you may want to compare pricing before you park.

    Such a coolly decorated place!…read more Had a work dinner event and happy hour place and was blown away when I walked in. The design is very in your face, with bright colors and large fixtures. Super cool. Staff was amazing, both the bartenders and servers. Very attentive and out of their way to accommodate. We had a coursed dinner. Apps were good. Shrimp ceviche was not my fav, but the smoked mushroom croquettes were flavorful and good. Carnivale Salad was great with little cheese bites and great dressing. I got the filet. Didn't ask for temp, but the crust was flavorful. Not a cake person, but the chocolate dulce de leche cake was one of my favorite things. Would come back for a drink, salad and dessert.

    Photos
    Carnivale Chicago - Rumba Bar

    Rumba Bar

    Carnivale Chicago
    Carnivale Chicago - Ropa vieja - a must!

    See all

    Ropa vieja - a must!

    Pilsen Yards - Beef barbacoa

    Pilsen Yards

    4.1(356 reviews)
    0.3 mi•Pilsen
    •$$

    Excellent! Everything was A+. Service was attentive…read more Their recommendations were spot on. The food was fresh and oh! So tasty! I'll be. Dreaming about the grilled sashito peppers for months! I simply can't wait to get back and try more of the menu!

    After attending Fiesta del Sol 2026 in Pilsen on a gorgeous Saturday, a close friend and myself…read morefound ourselves at Pilsen Yards for early dinner at about 6P based on a recommendation. The front door host was SUPER engaging and made us feel immediately welcome. The restaurant is trendy with a very hip vibe and the requisite interior decor to match. We were ushered by our waitress through a very nice indoor dining room to an outdoor dining area table for two. I noticed the outdoor dining also incorporated large sections suitable for big parties. Service here is very very attentive, starting with the fact that, I asked for a different type of chair finding the metal ones to be slightly confining. Our waitress, Caoimhe, was so hospitable in bringing a much more comfortable chair immediately. We ordered some alcohol drinks, a Pisco Punch and a beer. The Pisco was something new for myself and I found it refreshing. For light dinner, we ordered items to share. We both really liked the Piña Colada Ceviche. It was so delicious...the tuna pairing well with pineapple, jalapeño, coconut, cilantro and served with taro chips. Would definitely get it again! We also ordered three tacos. One al pastor, one shrimp and one barbacoa...with our favorites being the first two in that order. The barbacoa was dead last. Although it was tasty, I felt it needed a sauce to bring up what I felt was lacking in moisture. The corn tortillas of all the tacos were fine. We also asked for a side of rice and beans. Apparently they don't do refried beans so our waitress Caoimhe, suggested their black rice. Honestly, it was just ok and we found that a little salt & pepper made it a little better. I'd suggest the chef try cooking the black rice in a rich chicken stock. Should I return, I'd like to try the adobo glazed shrimp or the fire roasted salmon...they sound interesting. All in all, Pilsen Yards left me with a good impression of a new type of Mexican restaurant. The menu is definitely curated with the mindset of "less is more". This isn't your little neighborhood taqueria or old school Mexican restaurant with fifty different food options, refried beans and rice or chiles rellenos. What actually made the experience memorable...was the good service of the staff and if you're really "nice", the amicably amazing host may invite you to peek into their VIP "Alderman Room". Pilsen Yards is definitely worth a visit.

    Photos
    Pilsen Yards - Lounge area, open to the patio

    Lounge area, open to the patio

    Pilsen Yards - Chilaquiles

    Chilaquiles

    Pilsen Yards - Select Spritz (secret menu) and champagne  of beers

    See all

    Select Spritz (secret menu) and champagne of beers

    La Parrilla - Arepas

    La Parrilla

    3.9(25 reviews)
    9.5 mi•Edgewater

    Flavorful Food, Attentive Service, Great Value!…read more We walked in Sunday evening and took over the large table in front. We adopted our server, everyone ordered something different, and we shared. Our server brought a variety of sauces which took the flavorful meat to new heights. We shared the Picada a La Parrilla. It's enough for 2-4 People and hits the Meat Highlights. I think the Plantains, sausage and chicken were my favorite. My friend's favorite was the pork ( large chunks of pork belly ). We left with a box of leftovers too! The bar program is incredible! We all loved our unique hand crafted drinks. We can't wait to come back!

    This was one of those places we kept passing, with a "I wonder how that place is . . . " until the…read moreday we went "Let's try it!" JUST GREAT! We popped in for a couple of apps and drinks. The spicy margarita was top notch - very tasty. All the cocktails were! The food - Latin restaurants worth their salt are typically great at grilled meat, and this place is no exception. So . . . TOSTONES! And WOW were they tasty. I particularly liked the sauces that went along with them - a spicy hot sauce, chimichurri and another salsa (?). No matter, they were all tangy and delicious. Empanadas - something I always love. These were great. We got a few apps, and that was enough food for two for a light dinner. The staff was really friendly, adorable and welcoming. The people who work here are just fantastic, really adds to the experience. Ambiance is great - a nice bar area, which is where I always like to sit. A larger room for parties, and a smallish dining room. Recommended!

    Photos
    La Parrilla - Vibe

    Vibe

    La Parrilla - Salsa Chimichurri / Chimichurri Sauce

    Salsa Chimichurri / Chimichurri Sauce

    La Parrilla

    See all

    Tango Sur - Sweet beef Empanada with chimichurri

    Tango Sur

    4.0(2.8k reviews)
    6.8 mi•Lakeview
    •$$$

    We had a pleasant dinner on a Sunday evening out on the patio. Luckily it's covered so the little…read morebit of rain we had did not bother us. They had a very nice bread server with four individual oval French loaves with very tasty butter. We tried the provoleta with peppers because we like that a lot in Argentina, but this was nothing like it and I guess that was to be expected. There they have a bunch of drier version of provolone and they grill it directly on the grill grates and it doesn't really melt too much. This tasted like standard provolone cheese and it was melted in a bowl. It was tasty, and unfortunately they probably can't get the Argentinian version of the cheese they would need to do it correctly. Our friends got the beef brochette with asparagus and the outside skirt steak and both were fabulous. Well seasoned and grilled and tender. My husband and I got the 2 pound stuffed fillet! It supposedly had ham in the filling but I couldn't taste it or see it anywhere. Unfortunately it had a really strongly flavored sauce along with the portobello mushrooms. We expected something with fewer herbs, which kind of overpowered the beef. It's a shame because the way they described it on the menu is not what came out. It wasn't bad. It just wasn't what we were expecting and unfortunately, the beef flavor was hard to discern because of all of the herbs in the dark brown sauce. We brought our own wine and they didn't even have a corkage fee, which was amazing! We saw other plates go by with copious amounts of tomatoes and onions on salads and the filet mignon platter, it seemed like it was three or four pieces of fillet it had to be nearly a pound for one serving. The prices are pretty steep for the beef and they do charge $10 for sharing, however it might be worth just getting one of the larger plates and spending the 10 bucks to share as opposed to getting an entrée each and taking home lots of food which we did.

    We love a BYOB with no corkage fee. Also, warm table bread!! Pretty easy to call in and get a res…read morefor a Sunday night. The warm table bread and butter was pretty good so it was an effort to keep from eating too much and ruining our appetite. We split a chicken empanada to start which was really good, especially with the chimichurri sauce. For mains, we split the parillada para dos - a large meat platter meant for two. It was came with a little house salad and was a super good deal with all the meat they gave you (we ended up with lunch the next day, too!) The best part of the dish was the short ribs. Super soft and sort of fatty tasting, but not in a gross way, in a really yummy way. We also really liked the chorizo sausage. The flap tastes good, but was a little tougher than the other meat. The beef sweetbread and blood sausage were different, a little bit of an odd texture, but still good.

    Photos
    Tango Sur - Dining area

    Dining area

    Tango Sur - Empanadas

    Empanadas

    Tango Sur - Meat sweats. Delicious.

    See all

    Meat sweats. Delicious.

    May St. Cafe's - latin - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...