Maxim's Bakery was one of the contestants in my ongoing BBQ Pork Bun Off competition. The review is entirely about their BBQ pork buns, which is the one standard by which I hold all of my Chinatown bakeries accountable. I used 5 criteria, each with a possible 10 points, for a total possible score of 50 points.
Other things to note about Maxim's before the bun-off: they also sell lottery tickets here and there's a giant room in the back with tables for eating your purchases, if you care to hang around a dingy little lotto-bakery...
BBQ Pork Bun Off Results
Surface: 3 out of 10
The top is sticky, but not so sticky that my fingers feel sticky after touching it. Everywhere except the center of the bottom feels tough and crusty, with crumbs able to fall off when touching the edges.
Dough: 2 out of 10
The dough outside of the filling has the consistency of packing material with a faint taste and odor of yeast. I can vaguely tell that this is a baked good due to that, but aside from that, there is no flavor to help the dry and crumby dough.
The BBQ sauce: 7 out of 10
The sauce itself has a good flavor to it. Not a whole lot of spice, but enough of a sweetness that it goes well with the pork and is smooth enough to fight some of the issues with the surrounding dough, though it has caused some structural integrity problems with the center-bottom of the bun, making it very soft and almost mushy.
The pork: 6 out of 10
The major damage to the score on this facet was that there were basically 3 monstrous pieces of pork and then a few slivers and chunks elsewhere. They were tender enough that biting into a huge chunk caused it to split cleanly, avoiding the "string of meat falling from the bun and hanging from your lips" moment that I've admittedly experienced in the past during my many years of BBQ-pork-bunnery. No gristle, but some extended chewing on those larger bits of meat.
Overall presentation: 2 out of 10
The buns were maybe 75% dough, and with dough like that it was not a lot of enjoyment to be had. One thing that struck me was the piece of green onion stuck to the bottom of my test sample - which could only have come from cross-contamination on the shelf or on the utensils used to extract my bun and place it in the paper bag, which developed some spottage sometime during the trip home. The overall experience was negative, aside from the sauce that I enjoyed and found to be quite little of in the grand scheme of things.
Total Score: 20 points of 50 (40%)
The complete/ongoing results of the BBQ Pork Bun Off can be found on my blog. http://aaronbsam.blogspot.com read more