We had our daughters 13th birthday while in Maui and so we needed a cake for her. I had a very hard time finding anyone open after the Kona low storms but I did get a response from Casey thankfully so we took a chance and ended up with a delicious cake that was perfect for the occasion. It was very light and tasty without overpowering flavors and not too much sugar. It was so beautful with fresh plumerias and just the right amount of frosting. Casey was able to get it ready one day early as well for us. All worked out beautifully and we appreciated it. I recommend getting a cake do your special occasion too! read more

Maui Wedding cakes was the PERFECT choice for our daughter's destination wedding! It was not only beautiful but off the charts delicious! I would highly recommend! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Requested a special birthday cake for my Dad's 70th birthday. Delicious cake, vanilla with lilikoi filling. Turned out beautifully. Communication was easy, pick up was easy. Thanks so much for making this special occasion spot on!! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Kinda underwhelmed with the quality for the price. Got a 2-tier wedding cake, for 35 people, $325 USD. We chose the "Maui Dreams" specialty, which is per their website: Top Tier: Vanilla cake filled with Coconut Cream & Crushed Pineapple filling Bottom Tier: Vanilla cake with Vanilla Whip Cream Custard with a layer of Logsdon Lilikoi Sadly, the flavours were so muted as to be nearly undetectable. The vanilla cake was lovely, fresh and spongy, but really there was little other flavour than buttercream and vanilla. The bottom tier was arguably more flavourful with the lilikoi. I was also pretty unimpressed with the communication we had with Casey. I emailed him, and got a response about 10 days later with an apology for the delay. No worries, good thing I was planning way in advance. I told him exactly what we wanted a few times, specifically blue and purple flowers, with no flowers on the top as a topper was to be added. Like with other home bakers in Maui, you just go and pick up your cake at someone's house, in a fridge kept in the driveway. Box has your name on it. No problem. Unfortunately, we received a cake with purple and white flowers, and a bunch of flowers on top. I messaged Casey to ask what up, seeing as I had not been notified of any changes. He responded quickly to explain that they were unable to source any blue flowers. That's cool dude, but I would have appreciated some notice so that maybe I could find my own? Like literally growing on the bushes outside our place? I also noted that the icing was uneven in places with really obvious knife marks. I expected better workmanship for the price. Bottom line: pretty nice cake, not the best, definitely way over-priced, so-so communication with the owner, and don't expect that your specific requests will be met, even if they are put in writing multiple times. read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - This cost $325, toppers are mine - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I was EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED with the wedding cake I ordered for my wedding in Maui two weeks ago. I ordered a very, very simple 2-tier cake since it was just my fiance and I. Originally I asked for a simple buttercream cake with WHITE flowers. Then I sent a picture of another simple cake with sugar flowers. I GOT NEITHER! I was sent an email that my request was confirmed. I never got an email explaining it couldn't be done. If the second cake was impossible, I would have thought I would have gotten at least my first request! Instead I got a cake with RED FLOWERS that I did NOT want. The cake itself was mostly all frosting inside with very little actual cake. We took a few bites and gave the rest away. Did not even keep the top tier to save. For a whopping $215 cake, I am EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED I did not get the cake I requested. I cannot recommend this company. read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - The cake I got with pink flowers instead of white. - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Simply amazing!! We ordered our wedding cake through Maui Wedding Cakes and were absolutely blown away. Not only was the cake itself some of the best cake I have ever eaten, but the service we had was unbeatable. First when ordering the cake I spoke with Casey and talked about the design we wanted and flavors. He was so helpful and understood exactly what we were looking for. Then we had to coordinate between the restaurant we were having our wedding dinner at and Maui Wedding Cakes, and honestly it was 0 effort from my side. The team at Maui Wedding Cakes coordinated with Sea House Restaurant and our cake was there when we arrived for dinner. The process was easy from my side. Now for the cake flavors, do yourself a favor and get the Vanilla Whip Cream Custard with a layer of Logsdon Lilikoi. The best cake I have ever had! So refreshing, so light and so flavorful! We also had Red Velvet for our smaller tier and it too was delicious. The 4" top, 8" bottom two tier cake was perfect for our party of 12 and we even had a little leftover to save and eat later in the week. Everyone in our party talked about how amazing the cake was, so I cannot recommend Maui Wedding Cakes enough! Thank you to the team at Maui Wedding Cakes for making our wedding cake so amazing! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I hate to write this review, because I really wanted to write a good one. I loved working with Casey for the entirety of planning my wedding. He was good vibes, the booking/planning were simple, and I was really excited for our wedding cake. We had a cake tasting appointment a few days before our wedding to finalize the flavor/filling we wanted. The tasting was great and we texted Casey the final flavors we wanted, just like he instructed us to do so. We confirmed the details of our wedding with him multiple times including a final confirmation a month before the wedding and again a week before the wedding. Casey let me know in those final confirmations that our wedding cake would be delivered to the venue in the morning so it could sit in their fridge until the evening when it was time to pull out for pictures/cutting. When we arrived for our reception (an hour before the cake was supposed to be pulled out of the fridge for photos) the venue let me know that our cake had not been delivered yet. My sister had to frantically call Casey over and over during our reception. Casey picked up and immediately started cursing repeatedly because he forgot to make our wedding cake. Not only did he forget and not make the cake, he didn't even know what flavors we wanted or what the design was supposed to be. It was extremely unprofessional and my sister had to give him all of that information, when we had already confirmed with him multiple times with advanced notice. Casey told my sister on the phone that the cake would be there in an hour. An hour went by, the cake was not delivered. After calling again, he said it would be there in 30 minutes. It still was not delivered. She called again, he said he was on his way. She had to ask if he was really on his way or just giving BS timelines at that point. Finally, hours later, a cake was delivered. But it was way past our timeline of when we wanted to cut the cake (at sunset). We had to cut the cake in the dark while the bugs were out and biting us/getting on the cake. The interactions with my sister were extremely unprofessional with him swearing at her and not delivering the cake when he promised it would be there (multiple times). Although I am grateful he was able to still deliver a cake within such short notice, I am disappointed with the unprofessionalism. There was no apology ever given to me and when I emailed Casey after the wedding asking for a partial refund, Casey did not respond. Further demonstrating a lack of professionalism. I am very understanding that mistakes happen. I wish I could write a good review saying despite the mistake, Casey was able to pull through in a professional way. However, he swore repeatedly at my sister, did not apologize or say a word after to me or my husband for the mishap, and did not respond to my email after the event. He should have offered us a partial refund. We are very disappointed. read more

Casey made two cakes for me. They came out exactly as I had requested! My guests loved them. Collection was easy too. Would recommend!

I worked with Maui wedding cakes to help create a surprise birthday cake for my wife when we were on vacation. Casey was able to create the cake I imagined. My wife was very surprised and impressed with the cake. It made the night truly special and I would gladly recommend them. The cake was light and not too sweet, it was perfect. read more

I contacted Maui Wedding cakes the week before for my best friend's birthday cake, I sent them online photos of what I think I would like and they were so easy to communicate with and the cake they produced for us was exactly what I wanted! The online ordering form was easy to use and the pick up instructions was straight forward. Lastly the flavors and taste of the cake was delicious! Highly recommend! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Let me tell you I've waited a little over 5 weeks before writing this review because I've been waiting for my wedding photos to be available to document and confirm my eyes were not messing with me. Before this review I emailed Casey to get his side of the story and to hear my feedback, unfortunately there was no follow through and it has been 5 days. Honestly would not recommend this company seeing how they don't seem to care about customer satisfaction. 1.5 stars for a decent tasting cake. Definitely could have gotten a custom cake from Costco for a lot less and good tasting. I ended up with Maui Wedding Cakes because Costco doesn't do two tier cakes. I reached out online through Casey's website after hearing about him through my wedding coordinator at Hotel Wailea. The website is not the best in terms of using it to provide Casey with inspirational photos. It only let you upload one. Casey responded back via email and quoted me for my 2 tier wedding cake. I wanted 6" and 8" with blue ombré from the bottom tier towards the upper tier. I provided the inspirational photos of what I was expecting and got a horribly designed cake. After doing my grand entrance and dances we walked over to the cake table for our cake cutting. When I saw it, I thought omg this cake is colored so horribly. I was freaking out inside, video and photography going, our guests and family have their eyes on us. I had to keep my composure the best I can, but after seeing my photos, I am pretty sure video will be 3x worse. I now have disappointed reaction on photos and video. Instead of what should have been an exciting and happy bride about to cut her wedding cake that she apparently got all hyped up to think that her wedding cake was going to be so beautiful and great tasting. I trusted Casey and I am now so regretful. I'll give Casey credit for telling me ahead of time that he thought going to dark of a blue on the butter cream would mess with the flavor and I told him I was fine with not going as dark blue as the photos to maintain the flavor, but instead he messed up on the ombré technique.. he didn't disclose the fact that he didn't have any clue/experience on how to pull off an ombré look and failure to distinguish color of newborn poop to gold! The wedding cake I received was nothing I had imagined or provided inspirational photos of. This cake looks like pure carelessness and laziness. For a cake costing almost $300 I expected someone to spend a bit more time on it especially when it's a wedding cake! Could have opted to use gold foil, gold sprinkles, SOMETHING... ANYTHING if you couldn't mix or have gold food safe paint. Literally gold luster dust cost about $6 for a jar. I would have gladly supplied it, although I would have been confused why he was charging so much for a wedding cake if he can't even decorate it to the customers liking. I've seen some photos on Yelp where ombré like design was used and nice gold colors. I am so confused as to how I received a cake so far from my inspirational photos. I am sure he's been in the business long enough (21years) to know better and be able to provide better options than what I got. Casey this cake did not turn out beautifully like you said in your final email to me prior to me dishing out almost $300. Disclaimer Yelpers, don't be fool by the top tier of the cake, toppers were supplied by me, flowers were ordered from Fernhouse and everything was placed on by Hotel Wailea's pastry chef. Kudos to him/her because if left for Casey to do, I think the outcome would have been a lot worse. read more

See all

First off, the cake was excellent. My mom loved the chocolate on chocolate with pink butter cream frosting. Communication was excellent, and we were able to easily pick up the cake outside in the fridge after our long day. Which made things super easy on us since we didn't have to rush. I highly recommend if you are in need of any type of cake. We got exactly what we wanted for my mom's birthday cake! And it was so tasty! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I've never actually physically been to this bakery, but I was able to try their mango and blueberry scones from the local farms market. Honestly speaking, the scones were the BEST scones I have EVER had. Scones are my absolute favorite dessert/ pastry and it's so difficult to find them eggless and delicious. I bought the blueberry and mango scones from Maui Farmers Market, but I wish I had bought more of them and bought them home! Casey is a very talented baker. I spontaneously called the farmers market to tell them that I loved their scones and they told me that they get it from this bakery. So I ended up calling the bakery and Casey picked up. I told him how much I loved his scones and asked if they shipped to the mainland (hopefully they do soon!). The scones were balanced, crumbly but moist and evenly sweet and buttery (pure perfection)! Thank you, Casey, for being so kind and generous on the phone and via email - really made my day! Mahalo =) read more

Contacted Casey a while back to order a cake, celebrating my husband and 4 of his high school friends 50th birthday. All 4 boys and their families visiting from the mainland. Everyone was so impressed how detailed the dragon scale was done on the cake. The blue color I requested matched the photo I sent him and each scale was evenly done. Casey was very easy to talk to and knows exactly how I want the cake done. I ordered the Vanilla Cake and Vanilla Whip custard with Logsdon Lilikoi and Italian Vanilla Butter Cream icing. The combo flavors was exquisite and delicious. Dungeons and Dragons was the game my husband and his high school friends used to play growing up. Yeah they were bunch of nerds then and still is... lol! The dragon itself was purchased in Etsy and dices was from Amazon but without the excellent work of Casey this cake would not have been perfect. Thank you Casey! You did it again! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Dungeons and Dragon birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

We are so happy we chose Maui Wedding Cakes to provide the cake for our wedding. Due to Covid 19, we had to change our date 3 times, and Casey was always so patient, kind and willing to work with us. As for the cake, well it was absolutely delicious and couldn't have been more perfect for our special day! We highly recommend them! Mr & Mrs Daly read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I was putting together a small sunset beach wedding with no guests. I wasn't going to do a cake. But the day of the ceremony I got sentimental and wanted to be able to have a piece of cake with my husband. I called Casey that morning thinking it was a Hail Mary pass. But he said he could do a small 6" cake and had it ready in about 4 hours. It was simple and beautiful. And tasted great! I am so appreciative of Casey making that happen for me! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Last minute wedding cake for 2 - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

I only know this company because they were my wedding planner's cake vendor. I found it extremely easy to get ahold of Casey (baker and owner)- I was able to speak with him over the phone 2x and provide 1 email with images to get my dream wedding cake in Maui. My wedding planner told me the wedding cake I wanted was too difficult and Casey assured me that it was not. He did a great job. The one improvement they can make that would have made this a 5 star review is adding more filling in their cupcakes. The cake was delicious and full of filling, but I got a dime size taste in my cupcakes. The prices are reasonable and their online inquiring and ordering process is very user friendly. Every guest wanted 2 cupcakes! Cake Pros: Light buttercream frosting that doesn't melt easily but tastes like whipped cream frosting. -Recommend Lilikoi (passion fruit) flavor. The pina colada cupcake is rich but yummy. These are perfect for a beach wedding so sand did it get all over them. It was tiered and silverware was provided. I would definitely recommend working with Casey and his company to get your special cake order on Maui. He's easy to work with and everything turned out as expected! read more

See all

Casey from Maui Wedding Cakes made this a fun and easy experience! He helped us with logistics and made the best cake! We opted for the Lilikoi filling with white chocolate mouse and fondant stripes - it turned out gorgeous and delicious- oh, and gluten free to boot! Now, if only I had more it! We will be back once covid pandemic fades. I might need a tiny version of our wedding cake... you know, for breakfast on the the Lanai! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Maui Wedding Cakes! - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

WOW to find a great baker in my own neighborhood in Kihei! Who knew! Now I do...had to find a delicious cake for my daughter's 40th birthday celebration. Casey was great- easy to find the place (on a residential street) but no parking. I called and he came out to greet me with a perfectly boxed and wrapped cake. i was taking it to Lahaina as the dessert after our lovely lunch. The cake was vanilla- just a tad dry and the filling was the bomb- custard with guava jam filling and strawberries sliced throughout and the icing was whipping cream colored a pretty blue- not too sweet We all loved t. . Excellent combo and it was so pretty! I highly recommend getting your specialty cakes here as the way to pay was easy and filling out the form online assured the date and what you want. read more

Beautiful cake for destination wedding My friend tasked me with getting her a small personal wedding cake for her and hubby to be to enjoy after the reception. And here is the review of my experience with Maui Wedding Cakes - Order process: 5 stars - easy. Most information was on website and I only reached out because I wanted to know details to cake size and delivery as I am ordering from CA for a Maui destination wedding. My friend only wanted a small cake and asked for delivery to her hotel in Kaanapali. Even though the cake order was small and I asked lots of questions, Casey was very patient and speedy in responding. He made sure I felt comfortable with the order. Delivery: 5 stars - within delivery window as promised. I did get nervous as time was approaching since I had other errands to run, so I called a couple of times. I was reassured that it would be delivered on time and it did. I had a text when the driver was within 15 min away so I could meet her at the lobby. Presentation and packaging: 5 stars- beautiful, simple, and elegant. I let Casey know that since the cake would be stored in hotel room mini fridge that I was afraid it wouldn't fit. Casey used a smaller box and base and it had no issue fitting! He had a box half propped open wrapped with saran wrap so it showed the design (very pretty) without needing to open the box. Taste: 5 stars - according to the bride and groom, they LOVED it and said it was super tasty! Overall, FANTASTIC EXPERIENCE! Would definitely recommend!! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I needed a birthday cake in 3 days, and they were the only bakery out of the 4 I called that could do it on such short notice. The cake exceeded my expectations. So beautiful and DELICIOUS!!!! Thank you so much!!!! You're the best!!!! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Maui Wedding Cakes created the wedding cake for our intimate reception with just family at The Plantation House. It was so delicious and so beautiful! read more

See all

Maui Wedding Cakes made a DELICIOUS cake for our wedding. We chose them again after they made my birthday cake. Absolutely perfect- exactly as ordered. Our cake was already set beautifully at the golf course when we came to dine after the wedding ceremony. My husband & I could not ask for a more wonderful cake to go with such a momentous day. Thanks! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - a three tiered white wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

I found Maui Wedding Cakes on Yelp!! And we are so over the moon with the cakes they prepared for us. They prepared an upside down pineapple cake for the grooms cake. I really wasn't sure how it would come out considering I requested a walking dead theme. It was awesome from the design to the amazing flavors. I wish there was a scratch and taste on YELP! They also prepared our wedding cake and it was also amazing. I requested a three tier guava, coconut, passion fruit with butter cream frosting. It was awesome I loved loved loved it!!! Correction everyone loved it. It was the most delicious cake I have ever tasted. The best part is no one can stop talking about our cake. Thank you again KC & Cheryl. Xoxoxo Aloha and Mahalo! read more

See all

We hired Casey to make our wedding cake and it was absolutely delicious and decorated perfectly. We had tiers of guava chiffon and lilikoi. My favorite piece was the guava chiffon! Our guests loved the cake as well! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - 3 tier wedding cake made by Maui Wedding Cakes. Photo by Cheynice Photography. - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Maui Wedding Cakes made my wife's 40th birthday celebration cake and it was phenomenal. CAN'T GIVE THEM ENOUGH STARS!!!! If you're on Maui for a significant event or event a smaller event, Maui Weeding Cakes will take your party to the next level. read more

Used Maui wedding cake for our wedding and would definitely recommend! Great service and the cake tasted amazing! It was exactly what I wanted. read more

I let my mother choose the cakes for our wedding and I'm so happy she found Maui Wedding Cakes!! She ordered a two tiered cake with red velvet on one tier and their Lilikoi cake on the second tier. The Lilikoi cake was the best cake I've had in my entire life!! I'm obsessed with it and so sad I'm not eating it every day!! I would defiantly recommend them to anyone looking for a cake in Maui! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Btm layer: red velvet w/ cream cheese filling. Top layer: white cake w/ lilikoi filling! The cake turned our beautiful and SO DECLICIOUS!! - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

The cake I ordered was beautiful and delicious. I really appreciated the fantastic communication from this company. All my questions were answered in a timely fashion. I will definitely order from Maui Wedding Cakes in the future. read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Wedding Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

We needed a cake for a 50 year anniversary party we were having Maui. The cake they made was perfect! It was SO delicious and beautiful! We had a two tier cake with pineapple and coconut cream filling on top and the bottom cake had whipped cream and strawberries layers along with lilikoi layers. So perfect for an island celebration! Everyone loved the cake! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

What can I say but WOW! Casey is an amazing baker! So happy to have went to him for our wedding cake. He made it a breeze to deal with the process and was super responsive and easy to work with! I'd highly recommend Casey to any of my family and friends which means a lot! Thank you again Casey! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Cake with Cupcake tower - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I trusted Casey to do my wedding cake for my destination wedding and I am so glad I did! It came out better than I thought and tasted so good and all my guests loved it as well. I had a last minute hick up and had to switch where I was having my reception dinner day of and Casey made it a breeze and worked with me to get it done! Would highly recommend the below flavors Top Tier: Vanilla cake filled with Coconut Cream & Crushed Pineapple filling Bottom Tier: Vanilla cake with Vanilla Whip Cream Custard with a layer of Logsdon Lilikoi (our specialty passionfruit filling read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Our wedding cake was stunning, and some guests reported that it was the best wedding cake they had ever eaten!

Beautiful, unique, and delicious ... Maui Wedding Cakes created the most sensational desserts for me! When our 9/15/18 wedding planner couldn't seem to find a single local baker capable of making our Grateful Dead dancing bear-themed groom's cake, this crew jumped at the chance and the results were phenomenal! Both cakes had just the right amount of fluffiness and icing, while one was perfectly filled with scrumptious lilikoi and the other with the creamiest chocolate. We only wish we had ordered larger versions... there wasn't a single slice left ending the eve! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Incredibly delicious beautifully simple white wedding cake, with lilikoi filling. - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Planning a destination wedding can be a bit nerve racking if you are choosing things online without a tasting, but Casey made the cake process very pleasant. I had contacted Maui Wedding Cakes for a quote for a 2 tier Bride & Groom cake, and Casey quickly responded to me. The transaction went very smoothly and the cake got delivered to the reception coordinator without me having to be involved. When I first walked up, I was amazed at how identical the cake looked to my inspirational photos provided, as well as how beautiful it was! The cake was delicious! I very much enjoyed the marble cake with banana cream filling and vanilla frosting tier, as my husband enjoyed the Tahitian chocolate and chocolate cake tier. Thanks again!! read more

We were renewing our vows in Maui. I selected this baker by looking at Google. I looked at ONE baker and that's it. I loved the gallery of cakes and ordered. We had a hectic day trying to get to our site and we're late picking up the cake. They made it all so easy! I ordered online and they got it right. It was perfect. Designed just as I asked, tasted great, prices right with convenient pickup. Stress free. Beautiful. Thank you so much! read more

See all

Maui Wedding Cakes made an awesome cake for my husbands promotion ceremony. I got really good complements about the cake. I loved that it had macadamia nuts in it and it was very delicious. Casey was awesome to work with and I would definitely use him again if I ever need another cake. read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Service and Delivery on point . It turned out so nice, better than i expected and it was so yummy everyone enjoyed it! I look forward to ordering with Maui Wedding Cakes in the future. Mahalo! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

I have to say I was a little nervous picking out a cake I had never even tried for my destination wedding in Maui. We never took a trip prior to the wedding to do all the normal things that you do in a traditional wedding, so I guess we were setting ourselves up for the worst just in case... Boy, we could not be more wrong! The cake was exactly like the example pictures I had sent and even better, the cake itself was probably one of the yummiest, smoothest, fluffiest cake we've ever had. We got a white cake with the Vanilla Whip Cream Custard with a layer of Lilikoi with a whipped buttercream. It's not crazy sweet, or really heavy. It was perfect... It was heavenly! I am so glad we ordered larger sizes, everyone was ecstatic to take some back to their hotel room to eat the next day. We devoured our leftovers. The cake was just as good the day after! Very nice staff as well. No hiccups here! read more

See all

I would like to thank Casey for all the help he gave me in planning the cake for my daughters wedding at Pacific O. He was very easy to work with and our cake looked amazing! We also rented some doves through him and the bride and groom released them after the ceremony. It was beautiful. Thank you Casey! read more

Maui Wedding Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii