I think they go by a different name now.last shot lounge.We spent 162.67 to be delivered to my mom's house.first 1 1/2 hours late.2.horrible experience.food was flat out disgusting. 3 mozzarella sticks tasted like burnt bread.no cheese to be found.4,we paid for a salad,did not receive. 5.2 out of three pizza pies burnt. There is no way this place is going to be in business for long.when it was Mario's it wasn't bad.never had 1 complaint.go to jays across the street.we never had any issues there. read more

We decided to come to Mario's because we wanted some authentic Italian food after a long day of shopping at Woodbury Commons. The prior reviews were spot on! Not only delicious food, but also great service and charming atmosphere complete with Frank Sinatra songs playing in the background . The place looks like a corner bar from the outside so I was surprised to find the food was beyond good. We had hot baked bread and had to try the garlic bread with melted cheese- magical! The chicken parmigiana was perfect as was my penne alla vodka. I had to try their meatballs to see if they were the real deal and they were! Phew! read more

See all

Walked in and had a dinner after a long day, was in the country for a WORK trip. had to use a company card for expenses and not being from USA of course we couldnt just give tips without knowing. Our waitress was Hailey, she was pretty nice & i had to round up my bill, when getting back to the car. 2 GROWN MAN came up and f-ing insulted us for not giving enough tips. so much for a nice service, if you had explained nicely to us we could have known. Called my boyfriend a bitch? Dont ever dine here in the night as the drunkards are just scary. Will not patronise this restaurant again. *PS. Tips are never stated to be complusory & we do give tips within our means. AND IF THE SERVICE WAS NICE JUST FOR MONEY, DONT WORK IN F&B INDUSTRY. Please be genuine about your services. So if we're poor we cant dine in? Im sorry we all work a hard job, this is life. read more

Came here to escape the crowds at Woodbury Commons. Cozy ambiance with a seemingly regular bar crowd. Cheery service and outstanding Italian-American fare. Will be back next time I'm in the area read more

We had a large group. We sat down and the first thing the waitress says is they don't have any steak or seafood. We tried to order antipasto and they did not have cold cuts. Tried to order the featured bottle of root beer and they were out of that as well. The food that they did have was sub par. Had stomach pains all night. Do not go here! read more

Great spot! This cozy Italian Restaurant has great food, drinks and service! The chicken Parmesan was Yummy. Una (our server ) was attentive and very kind. Don't skip the desert menu or the Martinis! The tiramisu was so fresh! Baked by the cake lady in Harriman. My coffee Martini was sexy and delicious! read more

Mario's Restaurant - Coffee Martini - Pizza Near Me - Highland Mills, New York

Great bar, drinks are amazing and service is top notch!!!!! Antonio treats his guests like family!! read more

Mario's Restaurant - Best expresso martini in orange county!! - Pizza Near Me - Highland Mills, New York

My wife hosted an event at this lovely family owned restaurant and we LOVED IT!!. The food was delicious and beautiful presented. The service and hospitality was impeccable. Sofia was our server such a doll! Can't leave out the rest of her team that were full of energy, excellent communication skills and exceptional customer service. Antonio did an awesome job serving all of our 40+ guests. Kudos to him. I will definitely RECOMMEND this restaurant for future gatherings and family events. Thank you MARIOS for a wonderful experience. read more

Our household go to for Sicilian Pizza every weekend! Delicious wings as well! Courtesy service with a smile every time! My only complaint is the wait time.. always add time to whatever amount of time they give you, cause you will be there a while waiting for your order! read more

I highly recommend this restaurant to host a private event and also to dine in. I celebrated my daughters baptism here and I must say everything came out perfect! The food was fresh and delicious. Outstanding customer service and hospitality . Each of my guest left pleased and want to go back to Mario's restaurant. Aside from my event turning out a success, prior to the event taking place they made the planning and preparations stress free. They setup the place perfectly, answered all of my questions and accommodated all of our needs. I can't wait to host another event here. I highly recommend. You will not regret it. read more

See all

Great restaurant and beautiful!! Enjoyed the ambiance, service. Prices and delicious entres!! Had the suppa se Pesce, lobster bisque, chicken parmigiana and shrimp and chicken!! Alesandra was a sweet server and very friendly as well as attentive. What a great find. read more

See all

I ordered from Mario's for the first time since moving to Highland Mills from California. We placed our order on 4-10-2022 at approximately 5:00 pm. I am still adjusting to "New York pleasant" so you can imagine my surprise when I was created by one of the most pleasant human beings I have had the privilege of conversing with. I sincerely apologize that I did not catch her name, however she was polite, professional, and extremely patient. The human aspect of this review actually gets better. Our pizza arrives and is delivered by the most polite young man. At this point we were worried that the food must be awful if everyone is this nice...nope! Best pizza we have had since moving to New York! We really, really appreciate the kindness and professionalism! Well done Mario's, we are now officially fans. read more

A great valamentines day outing, very well accommodated by Victoria Gentilla she deserves a raise! Left a great tip . Will be back again and again read more

See all

Everything about this restaurant is great! The drinks, the staff and the food! The chicken parm and sea bass are delicious...

Went downhill over the years. Was thrilled they were still in business during pandemic but food quality and service have suffered. For the price, I would not return. It's clean and I was safe with plenty of hand sanitizer and cleaned restrooms. Food was ordinary but honestly quite tasteless. read more

Amazing food and service. We weren't searching for Italian but thankfully they're open on a Monday unlike their competition. Portions are huge great for a family dinner. Ordered the panzarella bread that could have been my entree, amazing. The inside is decorated so nicely with amazing chairs to sit in. Nothing like your normal Italian place. The staff all work together to ensure the customer is happy which is usually not something you see. There were a few guys dropping off food dressed oddly for such a nice place however they were sweet and very attentive. Great experience and well worth the trip! read more

Mario's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Highland Mills, New York

See all

I've always loved this place since I lived in Highland Mills during my adolescent years. I have been here recently with my fiancé and then recently with my best friend and his family and the food & service is always amazing. The atmosphere is comfortable and the furniture and decor has been updated to warm up the space. The drinks are good and the wait staff always makes sure that you have everything that you need. I had a gemelli pasta dish with sausage and spinach at it was amazing. The shrimp parmesan was also very good. I can't wait to go back. This place has a great hometown feel. Many things have changed in highland mills since I lived there, I'm soo happy that this place did not. Highly recommended. read more

It's a three star I'm tired kinda review. My wife can understand and appreciate the praise that this place gets. That would be because her food was prepared correctly. I ordered a cheese and pepperoni calzone. Human nature would say that it should be served hot especially since we waited so long. The only thing that was hot was my temper as it was stone cold right in the middle which defeats the point entirely. It may have been a one time only ever deal but not when I'm flipping the bill. It was a turn off and may deter me from going back. read more

Mario's used to be THE place for pizza in Woodbury. Thick, flavorful, spicy...goodness in every bite. Sadly that place is no more. What occupies that site now is pizza that is tasteless, bland, sad and pathetic. It's hard to tell the difference between the pizza and the cardboard box it comes in. It's like they gave up. I ordered a pizza that was supposed to have basil. I'm assuming the burnt green flecks were basil at one time. Now they're just charred plant. Don't waste your time or money there. There's much better pizza in Harriman or Monroe. read more

Welcome Dinner for Wedding Guests I contacted Mario's restaurant in advance to host a welcome dinner on September 4, 2021, for wedding guests staying overnight at a local hotel the evening before the wedding on September 5, at Falkirk Estate and Country Club. There were 32 of us. Everyone complimented me on the restaurant because not only was the food excellently prepared and delicious, the service was outstanding. We were served in an orderly manner, no confusion or excessive wait time for the meals. I highly recommend Mario's not only as a local spot for a great meal, but for anyone planning an event at a nearby venue. for a rehearsal dinner. read more

This place is a must the food and drinks are amazing. Every single item on the menu is delicious and fresh. If your having a private event or just want a nice lunch or dinner this is the place to go. read more

If you looking for a relaxing delicious Italian food /steak or seafood dinner or even pizza ...Marios is it. Marios has great vibe (place where everyone know your name kinda place) with wonderful large portion dinners. Una, our server, along with others are attentive and wonderful. We just love this place! read more

Me and my girlfriend came here last Sunday and we ordered the seafood pasta. It tasted really good but both of us got food poisoning and been having diarrhea for three days already. We are assuming it is the seafood, please check the quality thanks. read more

By far the best food outside of the Bronx NY. This place has a really local vibe and I love the decor inside. Every chair in the dining room is large and comfy what a treat! Baked clams are delicious, as is everything else I have ever tried there read more

We just ate here yesterday. We were here for a repast luncheon. We are not from the area, but this was close to the cemetery. The food was delicious!! Everyone at the luncheon was raving about the stuffed flounder, chicken parm, salad, sausage and meatballs, and pasta. The chicken was so tender you didn't need a knife to cut it. It melted in your mouth. The salad was seasoned nicely and had chunks of fresh mozzarella that was very tasty. The flounder was stuffed with crab and shrimp and was topped with lemon. The fish was fresh and delicious. Being Italian myself, I am picky about my meatballs. These didn't disappoint. They were also flavorful. The wait staff was friendly, accommodating eager to please. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. We were thrilled with everything. Thank you Mario's for making a difficult time enjoyable. read more

What an amazing find! While in the area (Woodbury Commons) we decided to look for a casual spot to grab a bite and a drink. Came to Mario's and we couldn't have been happier. There is a nice big dining area in the front, but we went in the back towards the bar area. The bartender was so polite and they even had these delicious drink specials. You could tell this was definitely a nice local spot because she knew all the regulars by name which was really sweet. Drinks were made perfectly, and we got some bar food which consisted of chicken tenders with real french fries lol, bacon wrapped scallops, pizza, and the most INCREDIBLE mozzarella sticks! When we told the bartender how good they were that's when we found out they were actually made there!!! Everything had a nice crispy crunch to it, and the mozzarella inside was so delicious! Biting into it was like when you see someone bite into cheese in a commercial and it just pulls but it actually happened with these! lol! You can immediately taste that nothing there was frozen like so many other places. Everything was homemade and it made a huge difference. Although as amazing as Mario's was, there was one small problem. I only wish I lived closer! lol! But seriously, definitely an amazing small business to check out. Support small and make a big impact. read more

We came here on a Saturday night, a group of 12 adults, with no reservation and they immediately accomodated us. The service just kept getting better... our waitress was so sweet to ask the kitchen any questions we had. For example, we wanted to see of there was a lobster ravioli and she came back with good news from the kitchen for us. The food was awesome... the seafood so fresh and the ravioli amazing and the pastas perfection. Andddd the portions were huge! I wish I could come up from NYC every weekend to eat! read more

I eat really good Italian and this was definitely as good as the ones I eat in the city and long island. Get the calamari, bruscetta, vodka seafood pasta, and seafood vongole! read more

Mario's Restaurant - Pretty empty but i dont mind the quiet ambiance and micheal buble music. I just pretend the place was bought out for me. Haha. - Pizza Near Me - Highland Mills, New York

That Mario's has been around for as long as I can best remember--and that's a long time--says a lot about about the dearth of alternative dining options in Highland Mills, a small village in the Town of Woodbury. It's a few miles north of Woodbury Premium Outlets. Mario's is really made up of four parts. One is the bar. It's not the most upscale bar and tank tops are still in fashion among the mainly male patrons. It's good for watching sports and drinking beer. Two, it's a pizza shop that delivers in the area. In my opinion, the pizza is good old fashioned pizza that drips oil and cheese. Make sure you lean over so it doesn't get anything on your clothes. It's the kind of pizza we grew up on--it's round, not thin crust and delicious. Three, it's a sit down restaurant that serves traditional Italian dishes like meatballs and spaghetti or veal parmigiana. Stuff like that. The dining room has been redecorated, but still looks a lot like a finished basement in terms of decor. But to be fair, it's appropriate in terms of the cuisine. Four, it's at an intersection where it serves as a marker when you give driving directions. Its neon sign is very conspicuous, so you tend to say, "make a left at Mario's," or, "if you see Mario's, you've gone too far." As a restaurant, it's two star. As a pizzeria and road-mark, it's four star. As a rural dive bar, it's three star. So, it sort of rounds out at three stars. But, if ratings are based purely on local tastes and competing options, you can add on a star or two. read more

Mario's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Highland Mills, New York

Overpriced pizza and food what a joke. Why doesn't highland mills have any quality pizza?

Came here for dinner and it's a good local joint. The pizza was great by my New York standards! The garden salad was nothing particularly special - mostly just iceberg lettuce and some vegetables, but not bad. We also ordered the muscles entree as an appetizer which was delicious. We really enjoyed the sauce, especially with the bread. The wait staff was good for the most part. (There was one instance where she forgot to bring us plates for the salad). My only other complaint is that the dining area is close enough to the bar that we could hear yelling from people watching the game in the dining area on a Friday night. For the area, definitely a find and I would return! read more

Great food! I was a little bit sad that they had run out of the plate that I was looking for, but the chef came to us indicating the similar plate he had and I can't thank him enough for making it so delicious. Also, the waitress was very attentive and nice. It's not the cheapest place around, but it's definitely worth it! read more

What a gem! A step back into history, when you got value for your food. I got the zuppa de pesce, and there was enough for two people. And great flavor. The others in my family got linguine and clams, and were equally satisfied. The bread - a whole loaf - was hot and fresh! Our waitress Toni Ann was also great. Italian comfort food at its best! read more

We did take out and ordered their wings and a mushroom pizza. Delivery was quick and wings were on point! Unfortunately, worst pizza we ever had. Tasteless and crust was like cardboard. read more

Just passing here and Mario's is surprisingly good. Stuffed portobello mushrooms is so delicious yet nutritious. Try it and you will know the difference. read more

I truly enjoyed this restaurant. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. The stuffed mushrooms were excellent as was the chicken parm. The serving sides are huge and well priced. Make sure you check for the Tuesday night specials! read more

Came here on a whim after getting lost. Don't let the exterior fool you. Great atmosphere, Freddie makes you feel like family. Will be returning for sure! read more

Mario's is by far one of my favorite places. Great food! Never had a bad meal there. Plus the service there is fantastic. Always on top of Things and know what to do to make thier customer happy. read more

while the food is tasty enough, the service stinks. we ordered take out dinner on a Sunday at 430 pm. I asked for the total cost, the waitress said she would call me back--she didn't. My husband picked up dinner and when he got home, the shrimp (which i ordered over the phone and was charged for) was not on my penne vodka. I called Marios to tell them of their mistake and he drove back to Marios. When he got there, the waitress charged him and he paid it. (The waitress told him it was 7 bucks and he handed it to her. Then she said, well actually it's 7.58 with tax and made him pay it!) When he got home, we looked at the original reciept and saw we got double charged, My penne vodka with shrimp (it was also supposed to have prosciutto--it didn't) cost a total of 24.00!! Yeah, the food tasted okay (oh yeah, the $7.58 gave me 5 shrimp). But when there are SO many other Italian places, I won't miss this one. I will not go to Mario's and I will be sure to warn others about this place as well. read more

Best place to enjoy great food and drinks...the updated dining room and bar are amazing. Looks like the city has moved to the country. The staff is extremely helpful and friendly and if you are lucky enough to go on a night that Allie is there it will be the best experience...she's awesome! Allie is very attentive and helpful with suggestions on food and drinks. Mario's is a must when you are in the area! read more