I don't know how I haven't reviewed Mario & Salvo's yet, they are absolutely the best pizza in Syracuse and I will not change my mind on that. Here are some recommendations of what to order: -Classic cheese slice - so good, never fails -In a garlic mood? Try the broccoli garlic slice -Looking for something unique? Get the Grandma's slice, it's a special dough and is delicious! I usually see it on Fridays, and just tried a new version of it with Pepperoni and WOW I didn't think it could get any better but it did! -Don't want pizza? Check out the calzones, they're delicious -Pro tip: add a garlic knot, because why knot?! read more

Mario & Salvo's - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

From the moment you walk in until you finish your last slice, you're transported to a pizza joint in Italy. You are immediately greeted with a smile from the staff ready to serve you up your favorite slice. Any kind of slice you want they'll happily make for you. Try the Grandma's pizza for a real unique treat! The restaurant is clean and full of happy customers! If you don't know what to get, ask for David! read more

Mario & Salvo's - The best pizza everrrrrr - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Walking into this pizza place, I was hit with a wave of nostalgia (even though I've never been to this place before). It had a classic pizza parlor feel and I loved it! One of the staff behind the counter saw me looking at the array of pizza slices and immediately started to describe each choice - which I so appreciated! I ended up going with a classic cheese slice ($3), and they warmed it up for me. While the sauce was a bit on the saltier side (for my taste), the dough was crispy on the bottom and the crust was soft with a great chew! read more

Mario & Salvo's - Cheese Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Rounded out Father's Day at Mario & Salvo's. It was quiet when we first got there and ordered, but definitely picked up as we waited for our food. We chose to stay in and eat there and the food didn't take long at all to be done. We ordered a large cheese pizza and 12 medium wings. Pizza came out hot and perfect, we all loved it. The wings weren't bad either but weren't our favorite (we like our wings saucy). I don't know what everyone else thinks but pizza and wings is not the cheap dinner you expect it to be anymore. Large cheese, 12 wings, and one large soda came out to be roughly $40. Overall we enjoyed ourselves and we're able to relax there and enjoy the meal. There's a small area with enough seating for a few families to eat. The employees are very nice and very hardworking. read more

Mario & Salvo's - Medium wings, large cheese pizza, and our 2 waters - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Since moving up to 'Cuse from Long Island, the one food I'd say I've craved the most is a traditional grandma slice of pizza. Different from the thicker and fluffier Sicilian style square slice, a grandma slice is a thinner, crispier style pizza that is layered with cheese and followed by dollops or drizzles of hearty, garlicky tomato sauce. Mario and Salvos has truly mastered a wonderful grandma style pizza- so much so, they were even named the best pizza in Syracuse and we'd have to agree. This was truly a phenomenal pie, and the wings were also crispy and delicious. We will certainly be back for more! read more

Mario & Salvo's - Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

See all

So far this is the most authentic NYC style pizza I've found in CNY. The pizza is thin, crispy, and light. The sauce is seasoned and the oregano is prominent, so if that's not your thing you may not like it. Personally, it's not a preference, but I did not mind it. What's not pictured is the Sicilian slice and buffalo chicken slice that I had. The Sicilian, despite looking dense was far from. It was very light. Shockingly light. It was crispy yet the dough was soft (not undercooked soft). I really enjoyed it. The buffalo chicken slice, while also thing and light did not do it for me. The chicken was on the drier side and lacked a strong buffalo flavor. I'll pass on this the next time. I loved the interior. The sign/menu on the inside was very nostalgic looking. Think old school NYC pizzeria. Loved it. Service was good, the owner checked up on everyone who was eating and asked how the quality of food was. I liked that he cared about it. So far, this is the best pizza I've found in CNY and I absolutely will be back. read more

Mario & Salvo's - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

I have ordered take out several times from Mario and Salvos through the slice app. The quality is always great. Today was the first day that I ordered for curbside pickup and no one answered the phone. At 38 weeks pregnant, with my 3 year old we went inside and our order was not ready at the designated time. We then waited for 30 minutes and our order was never announced. Finally when asked again someone grabbed an order from the already made shelf (presumably for someone else) and gave it to me. The ambiance was very busy this Friday evening around 6pm. There were many employees working and an equal amount of customers standing around the counter. Only one or two groups of people seated at the 4 tables for dinner. We had a broccoli calzone with marinara sauce for dinner this evening and the quality of the food m did not disappoint. read more

Mario & Salvo's is genuine NY style pizza. The owners work in the trenches will their staff, and the pizza is outstanding. The buffalo chicken pizza is my go-to. Love it!! read more

Saw in Syracuse newspaper review of the many pizza places in the surrounding communities. This spot finished #1. As it's just off 481 in DeWitt, while driving through that area made my first stop. This is what you'd imagine a 70's style pizzeria, staffed with a cast of characters. Busy lunch and dinner times(lots of deliveries) my timing was perfect at 4:00. On a scale 0-20, this is a strong 18 NYC style pizza. They have slices, too. read more

Best pizza in the area. Can't go wrong with anything you get here! Service is great and it's by far my first choice for pizza in Syracuse!

Fuck this. The pizza has gone downhill. They must have changed the ingredients. Dough is not the same. And if Mario doesn't make it, forgettttt about it. Johnnys is gone now too. Cuse pizza sucks now. Too bad. Mario's used to be good. Large pizza, 12 wings. Sub. 56.00. Fuck that. read more

These guys make the best NY style pizza I've tasted in Syracuse. The crust has just a bit of char to it which is delicious. They accept delivery orders via the SLICE app. I used to work in the neighborhood and often grabbed a couple of slices for lunch. Try them. You won't be disappointed. read more

We were up for pizza tonight. Our usual go to for ordered pizza was closed. My wife remembered her brother said Mario & Salvo's had the best pizza! I've had lunch there before and everything was very good. We ordered a large pizza with cheese, sausage, green peppers and onions. It was one of the best pizzas we ever had!!! The toppings were larger than most places but not too big. We now have a new go to for ordered or go to. read more

Every time we get pies to go from here, I am reminded why they have the best pizza in Syracuse. Just absolutely delicious from dough to sauce to cheese to toppings. Well worth the drive out to Dewitt. ***** Five Stars read more

Besides having terrific pizza - these guys are a class act. We ordered 2 broccoli pizzas on the Slice App because I wanted to pay instead of my nephew who was picking it up. The image was of a white pizza - I never imagined the app would default to red sauce on a broccoli pizza (warning if you are using the app). Mario and Salvos remade the two pizzas and they were delicious. Thank you Mario and Salvo's read more

Just went to try a slice for lunch. Small pizzeria, but several long tables to sit down and enjoy your food. Hard to choose as they had lots of pies out for slices. They are small/ average size slices and I selected broccoli and cheese. They warmed it up and it just took a few minutes. The cheese was tasty and melty, the broccoli cooked nicely and it was thin and had that perfect cooked bottom from the pizza oven. Next time I'm going for a whole pie to eat fresh cooked directly out of the oven. I saw a few come out and looked amazing. read more

Mario & Salvo's - a slice of broccoli pizza - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Great food consistently! We always order from there . Chicken wings and pizza are always really good and fresh . Never had a bad order from there . read more

Pizza is always on point. Definitely worth a trip if you want good pizza and wings. Reasonable prices also.

Disgusting experience...We've been going to Mario and Salvo for years...this may be the end. Ordered a large cheese pizza. It was a mass of undercooked dough with tomato sauce and cheese..truly disgustingly undercooked. Quality control does not exist here anymore... read more

Hands down Mario & Salvo is in my top two pizza places that serve NY Style (pizza oven not coal) in the Syracuse region (maybe further). Growing up in New Jersey and just across the river from NYC I feel pretty confident in saying that their pizza does remind me of my childhood pizza joints. Great crust, crispy but with had a nice fold and chew to it. Sauce had great flavor and the cheese was not over cooked. I have only ordered pizza but look forward to trying more on their menu and updating! read more

Mario & Salvo's - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

See all

Best pizza in Syracuse! Mario is a generous, kind man that knows how to run a great business. NY style thinner crust pizza with delicious sauce, amazing cheese and a plethora of toppings. The team working there are efficient and sweet. I've tried several different slices of pizza (cheese, Buffalo chicken, Alfredo, chicken and peppers, pepperoni) all to satisfaction for me and my family. Mario even gave me some free knots on the house for my wait. I was amazed how fast they were able to make a fresh pizza when I came in and they had several call in carry out and delivery orders running. Will be back anytime I need a slice read more

I love this place! I make a point to come here every time I'm in town. This place isn't fancy, there are a few places to sit, but their pizza rocks! What makes the pizza so good is the crust! The crust is the perfect amount of crunch with just a hint of salt on the bottom! The toppings are simple and good. This is straight forward NY pizza at its best!!! read more

Mario & Salvo's - Buffalo chicken pizza.... It's the best - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Visiting my husband's hometown of Syracuse, he said this is a must-try. Love the vibe, small, cozy location, and authenticity. Pizza was good, but inside seating was only available. Was there on a Sunday morning so it was not rush hour yet, would certainly like to try the meatball, other yelpers commented. Parking could be frustrating but we parked at the Tops across the street. read more

Mario & Salvo's - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

This used to be the best pizza place in Syracuse and my go-to spot. But the quality has steadily fallen off in the last couple of years. The pie I just got delivered was a soggy, disgusting mess, that took over an hour to come. The ziti is also a liquidy mess. Time to move on! read more

We love this place. We moved to Manlius NY about 3 years ago and one of our new NY friends introduced us to this amazing pizza. We are a true fan, they do a great job. read more

They gave me and my family old, hard, cold pizza. Then the manager David was arguing with us saying the pizza was fresh but the pizza couldn't be fresh they told me that the pizza will be done in 15 minutes. The chicken wings did not have any sauce on the chicken wings read more

Mario & Salvo's - The mild Chicken Wings do not have sauce on them - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Pizza is the best an no one makes chicken wing pizza as good as them. Owner is so nice however I have had a bad experience three times now with a female . I called to order and a young girl answered and was very bothered by me calling . The way she was asking my info her tone made me feel as if I was calling 2 minutes before closing but it was dinner time exactly 6:30pm. She was so rude I said forget it , I will order elsewhere because you clearly do not want my business for the 3rd time . read more

Absolutely delicious pizza! From the crust, to the sauce, to the cheese and toppings, best I've had in the area. The service is excellent and staff is super helpful and welcoming. My family's new go to! read more

One of the only places you should be getting pizza from in Syracuse. If you are looking for classic pizza, ignore most of the places (either for subpar pizza or bombastically topped monstrosities). Sometimes pizza can just be pizza; don't settle for cardboard or a chain's line of fast personal pies. This is a place with little service outside of taking your order, and making your pizza. No frills, just good product. read more

Best ever ! Enough said I loved it , try the Sicilian Pizza slice, you will have another food craving in the back of your head read more

We got their pizza for pickup, and it was pretty good and cheap! Syracuse isn't really known for their pizza anyway, and this is some of the better pizza we've had in the area. The place was cute inside, but a bit cramped. The guy who gave us our pizza was nice! read more

They're showered is nothing to write home about. I have noticed in the last three years they have developed a pompous, arrogant atmosphere.

Literally some of the best thin crust pizza we've had in a very long time. We were traveling and decided to make a pit stop here before heading to the airport and it's definitely now a requirement every time we travel. read more

Mario & Salvo's - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

See all

Got a pepperoni and sausage pizza, was hands down the best pizza my boyfriend and I have ever had. We couldn't stop eating it!! Definitely recommend. The service was very good, got in and out very quickly. read more

Mario & Salvo's - Pepperoni Deluxe Pizza - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Rudest employees ever. I will never purchase from them again and I've been ordering from them for over 20 years. I explained what I wanted twice on the phone and it was still wrong and I had to wait for them to make another pizza. Also it shouldn't cost $30 for a pizza. They may have good pizza but no pizza is worth $30 in Dewitt New York. And their rude employees ruin it for everyone. read more

In town to visit daughter at college. Selected M&S from Yelp reviews...close to our hotel, as well. Pies were ready upon arrival. All liked the pizzas, good sauce, right amount of crust, sufficient toppings...check out the pic! read more

Mario & Salvo's - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

This place is typically pretty busy, so make sure you order in advance during busy times. Just a standard menu, but my go-to pizza on the east side for a cheese or pepperoni. We don't usually have leftovers when we split a large from here. I attribute this to the light, stretchy texture of the dough, but also the fantastic taste. Last time we went, we tried the wings. We ordered 12 hot and asked for extra spicy. They were good sized, crispy enough, and tasted great. They acknowledged the request for extra spicy, but they weren't very spicy. I don't fault them for that; they never claimed to have spicy wings. My only real problem was that they were 11.95 for a dozen. The wings were great, but for that price there are plenty of better selections in Syracuse. read more

Mario & Salvo's - Large Pepperoni - $17.45 - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

See all

I wanted to write this review in reference to the pizza at this place. I've traveled the country and I'm pretty particular with my pizza. Mario and Salvos in Dewitt, New York is right up there with New York City, Brooklyn, New Haven. The crust is thin, the sauce is like my grandmother used to make not sweet and the amount of cheese that's put onthere is to perfection. You can tell that the ingredients are homemade, and the cheese is right up there with the finest of quality. if you're ever in the Syracuse New York area, I will highly recommend taking the time to stop over to get a slice or for that matter of pie. If you like meatball sandwiches, it's a 10. You can tell that it's a generational meatball recipe. Enjoy !!! read more

We grabbed two slices, antipasto, and a garlic bread. The pizza itself was okay, the tomato sauce wasn't super flavorful and the crust was floppy. I personally prefer my pizza with a bit more crunch and bite. However, their antipasto made up for it! It was very delicious and fresh! They add in these pinwheels with deli meat & cheese which were tasty! The garlic bread wasn't something spectacular, but I did enjoy it. The entire meal was under $20, which is a good deal. read more

Mario & Salvo's - Antipasto Salad & Pepperoni pizza, tomato/basil pizza, and garlic bread. Antipasto Salad I highly recommend! - Pizza Near Me - DeWitt, New York

Skip it. Nothing at all memorable about their offerings other than the items we ordered were hot when we picked them up. Toppings on both pizzas were soggy, as were the hot wings (see my pics please). Garlic knots totally forgettable. Total meh. A good descriptor of their pizza would be lots of chewy and nothing crispy, despite the crust being done. New York Style pizza leaving a lot to be desired at this here pizza jurnt. Pizza is wayyyyyy better the 2nd time around after getting a tan in your toaster oven at home. Prices typical for this area so you know. If you're looking for unique or stellar pizza, wings, or knots, keep on a lookin'. If you just need warm food, this place will do you fine. read more

See all