First time in Sidney NE. Nice small town, nothing to do (to be honest) and everything closes super early!!! Came here for a work trip and found myself trying to find a place to eat that wasn't closed after 8pm. Came to a gas station and the sign Margaritas caught my eye. At first at was reluctant, because how good can a gas station restaurant be!? My bad! Never judge a book by its cover. When you first walk in you'll be taken aback by its beautiful decor and incredible art work on their chairs. Talk about clean!? That place is SPOTLESS!!! Great vibe and friendly and helpful staff. I had a burrito, which to my surprise was huge! But also very tasty! Came back the following day to eat a carne asada plate. Absolutely delicious!!! I don't know if I'll ever be back in Sidney NE but if I do, I'll be eating here every day. read more

It was good had fun good service, but there was yummy piece of hair, I hope it was a pub hair so I can't wait to eat agian. 5 star read more

Margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

We were just passing thru town and stopped at this wonderful restaurant! It was bright, cheery, clean and so good! Their menu is very extensive and definitely authentic Mexican cuisine. Huge portions and so good! Highly recommend! read more

My my. The Margarita was a 10. The rice and beans .. a 3. The Chili Relenos.. 1. Service was 8. That average is 5.5. My actual review is 4. Sorry. I may go back, someday. read more

Food was great, service top notch. Didn't have one but I was told the margaritas are terrific!

This restaurant delivers a lot of food lb-for-lb for your dollar. We ordered a burrito, shrimp quesadillas, and the stir fry. We ordered takout and you get a huge bag of tortilla chips with your order. The chips could use more salt but were nice restaurant style (thin) chips. The salsa was a bit watery for my liking but did have a nice heat. The food is terrific and really nice quality. The stir fry had typical Mexican veggies (onions, peppers) but also broccoli, avocado, and mushrooms. The chicken quality was all white breast meat. The shrimp quesadilla was rich so maybe a pass if you don't like melted cheese. I found it to be very good and they provide a healthy portion of guacamole and sour cream with the order. The burrito was ok, not bad but nothing spectacular. read more

Decent Mexican food in the middle of nowhere server was very nice and place was packed very large menu read more

Margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

Nicely decorated, plenty of seating. Complimentary hot chips with salsa was good. My waiter was pleasant, there was a little language barrier but that's ok. I ordered a combination steak, chicken and shrimp fajita because I'm greedy lol! Was a bit disappointed when my food came out on the skillet and it wasn't sizzling! I think they just put the food in the skillet for looks! Food was just ok. Tastes authentic but it wasn't very hot. I would definitely give them another chance when in the area. read more

See all

Fantastic food and good service. I had the Chicken Fundido, as well as chips and a water. The flavor and temperature of the food wonderful

I can see why it's so highly rated. The food was pretty good. Authentic? No. Definitely not authentic. It was tasty though. The beans were full of flavor, the rice was bland, but the meat was amazing. Their chili relleno is strange but still tasty. I'm not sure what it was exactly but it wasn't a traditional chili relleno. The decor was fun and bright and the service was great. Everyone was very helpful and sweet, even when there was a misunderstanding with the order. They fixed it and offered dessert. The plates were so big there wasn't room for dessert. Overall it's a good place to eat at. It was filling. read more

Margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

See all

A shining star in the vast expanse of Nebraska's high plains. A fantastic place to stop and reinvigorate before continuing the a road trip. I was greeted by a explosion of celebratory colors and friendly staff eager to seat us. Around 1pm the restaurant had a few patrons that filled seats sporadically throughout the establishment. The clean interior and the wonderful fragrance of food filled the room Our server took our order promptly and served the drinks swiftly. The horchata was sweet and delicious with great consistency. My steak, bean and rice burrito that was smothered in a red sauce, topped with delicious guacamole, tomatoes and cheese was expertly crafted and tasted like my abuela's home cooking. Although the restaurant boarders a gas station, don't be deterred. I had a wonderful time, satisfied by delicious food and treated to great service. read more

Margaritas - Chips and salsa - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

See all

Excellent customer service and excellent food. Exactly what a Mexican restaurant should strive to be! Bravo!

I went on a busy night, but the customer service was top quality. Very family orientated all of the waiters and waitresses were handling everything in a timely manner. Not Tex-Mex not Baja California Mexican but a very good middle ground. You had the option to dine in at a table a booth or at the bar. Very relaxed setting. A good place to get with your friends. Have a margarita and have a good conversation. I do like my food on more of a spicy level so it would have been nice if they offered a salsa with a little more bite or if they threw some hot peppers in the food but I understand with their location they do not want to have it be too much. I would definitely recommend, and I will definitely be eating there again. read more

Margaritas - Molcajete with a side of rice, beans, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo cheese, and lettuce - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

See all

Very good food for the middle of nowhere. I really enjoyed the shrimp cocktail. The original margarita was great! They definitely have a lot of recipes for margaritas. My husband had the crispy Chili Relleno, it came with two. It didn't have a lot of the chili pepper in it, but we are thinking it is probably because he got the crispy version. Maybe the other option is the original style. The waiter came by quite a few times to check on us. Will definitely be back next time we come through. read more

Margaritas - Shrimp cocktail - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

See all

Pretty nice Mexican place for Nebraska. The margarita machine was not working so I had to go beer and a shot. Otherwise everything was great. I had com o beef,chicken, and shrimp. The fajitas come with some sauce and a lot of it. The shrimp were a nice size. Their salsa is very good and just a bit spicy. Fajitas came with all the trimmings including guacamole, sour cream ect at no extra charge. The menu is pretty extensive and I'd love to try more items. read more

See all

I stopped in while on a road trip. The place wasn't busy at all. The food was really good and was seasoned nicely. Large serving sizes, served hot and fresh. The margarita was refreshing and nicely balanced. I really enjoyed my meal. read more

Best advice is never be afraid of a gas station restaurant! Food was incredible, amazing, delicious. I had a the Chilaquiles con Huevos. Best I have ever eaten! We also ordered Huevos con Jamón, served with beans and rice, and it was a clean plate by the end. The chips were fresh and crisp. Ask for their hotter salsa, I guarantee your eyes will water as you eat more and more! The regular salsa was lively and tasty. Please give yourself a gift of great food and eat here. Sidney, Nebraska . . . What a surprise! read more

Margaritas - Parking lot view - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

I visited here back in August 2021 while on a road trip from California to Michigan & OMG the food was AMAZING !! I ordered a wet steak burrito & the steak inside the burrito was the BEST steak I have ever had!! I have tried multiple Mexican restaurants in the Bay Area & nothing tops this! Whenever I go on a road trip again I'll definitely stop by here! read more

Margaritas - Wet steak burrito - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

I would have to say that this is one of the best Mexican places or food restaurants with best employees. Their food is delicious, and it's worth visiting. Their menu looks super self explanatory, so I didn't have to ask bunch of questions about their food. But let me tell you this. Their doors is awesome and super delicious. I was full and I have ordered only one dish. The outside of the restaurant has lots of parking spaces for cars and for semi trucks. It's really easy to spot a restaurant from the interstate. The interior design looks so mexican. If you have ever been in Mexico you will know what I am talking about. After I have order my food, it came to me fast. It was super delicious and the plate was HUGE. I would have to say that this place is worth visiting. It's just because food is great and employees are amazing. Thank you for great experience. read more

Margaritas - I forgot the name but if you will show them a picture they will tell you what it is - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

See all

food was delicious, very hot and fresh. Interior was nice inside, no music but the atmosphere was still great. service was good, staff was helpful and helped me with the menu and with the choices of meats they offered. overall the spot was great and the food was very good. read more

See all

Quite good for what it is--cheapish Americanized Mexican food. The dining area itself was lively and cute, a very bright room covered in colors and pictures. The server was incredibly efficient, and food was out fast! The mushroom burrito was solid. Good, but not incredibly so. The camarones did amigos were the favorite of the table, well spiced and large--sufficiently large it's a big compliment to say we finished the plate! read more

Impressive for a middle-of-nowhere Mexican restaurant. We were just passing through on our way to Missouri and wanted something other than Arby's. I ordered the Enchiladas Divorciadas with one cheese, one beef and one chicken enchiladas. The cheese came with the red sauce, the beef came with a white sauce, and the chicken came with a green sauce. The best of the three was the cheese and that red sauce--yum! The white was my second fav. We got a side of hot sauce and beware, it is spicy. Use a little for a little heat or dump it all if you're a fire monster. Definitely the best traveling food we've had so far amongst the flat Midwest states. read more

See all

The past reviews were right on. This is a great place. The margaritas come in the shaker and a martini glass. How cool is that? Pina colada was huge with whipped cream. Super tasty. We had a tamale and taco and nachos. Portion size is huge. We couldn't finish the nachos. The service is impeccable. Very attentive and friendly. read more

Margaritas - Pina colada. - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

See all

This was one of the best restaurants we have ever been to! The arroz con pollo was exceptional and all of us wished we had ordered it! The staff were so kind and the service was great. Overall, amazing place! read more

The service was good and the restaurant was clean. The salad presentation was excellent but the flavors just weren't there unfortunately. read more

Margaritas - Chicken salad - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

We've eaten here every time we pass through on our way to Colorado from SD. It's as good as ever! So clean and reasonably priced, especially their lunch menu! Food is always fresh and plenty to eat. The queso with jalapeños is great. We highly recommend! We'll definitely be back! read more

Stopped in Sidney over night on my way West. I don't think I would have chosen gas station Mexican except for the good reviews and proximity to my hotel. I had guacamole, a tamale, and the appetizer shrimp. Everything was tasty. The staff was very nice and the bartender made a good margarita. read more

Margaritas - Appetizer shrimp and guacamole - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

Driving down I-80? Looking for dinner? Look no further! For a quick stop after driving along I-80, Margaritas was a great stop! I was extremely impressed with our service from Alfonso and our food was AWESOME. The chips were hot (the best thing to start a meal) and the salsa had great flavor (a little less chunky than I like, but still good!). We had the seafood enchiladas (fresh crab meat, yum), tacos carbon (loved the tortillas!!!), and tacos al pastor (tender meat). Every meal came with refried beans and rice also which was nice! I want to emphasize how great our server was also - very kind and quality service! Large place with plenty of seating as well. It was still super busy when we went late at night and I know why! Honestly the only downside was the booth we had was really small making it hard to have two adults sitting next to each other, otherwise great! (Sad I didn't take photos). read more

Everytime we go here we have terrible Service that gets worse, we order the same things but get different outcomes each time. This time we ordered 3 Combo with 2 Chimichangas they usually come with sauce, not this time and when we told waitress she said Chimichangas don't come smothered! She decided to argue instead of make it right. Stay away from this SCAM RESTAURANT AND HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE! There really isn't good Mexican food in town but I'd suggest TACO JOHNS OVER THIS DUMP! Not to mention they keep raising prices too! read more

Margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

Clean festive restaurant with friendly efficient staff! Delicious authentic Mexican food, homemade salsa, yummy chips and full bar with top shelve margaritas! Highly recommend! read more

Food was pretty good, great service & medium spicy salsa. Restaurant was nicely decorated. Not many choices in this area to eat.

Great food, salad was amazing. A little unexpected for a place connected to a gas station but wow.

Servings were large. Not traditional Mexican or TexMex. We enjoyed our food - served hot. Restaurant appeared clean

I had chicken mole the chicken was crunchy and dry not impressed. Had sesame seeds on top of Mexican food.

Four stars because of the service but the food was delicious! Didn't like the plates being dropped on the table in front of us or the servers attitude! read more

Margaritas - Very nice decor, salsa is also great. - Mexican Near Me - Sidney, Nebraska

See all

Margaritas better then they food I aboultlyn did not eat half of it and margarita can go less on accoul

I often stay in Sidney for travel. There are really few options for dining there. I have now tried Margaritas twice. It's OK. Nothing to write home about. They serve chips and salsa before the meal. The chips are fine. The salsa needs work. It's almost like tomato water. The food, it's OK. Somewhat bland for Mexican food. The beans they serve with a combo are almost like bean soup. I find that off-putting. Margaritas are served warm with some ice cubes in it. They are just OK, too. You need to let the Margarita sit for a while to get cold. Every cushioned bench in the place has holes in it. Not a comfy place to eat dinner. I get it. Sidney is a little stop that most people drive by. There are few dining options that are noteworthy. Honestly, if you are in Sidney, just go to McDonald's and get a double cheeseburger. You won't be as disappointed. read more

Excellent Mexican food. My wife had their chicken mole, and I had their two enchilada dinner that came with refried beans and rice. Great service and friendly personnel. Their house margarita was fantastic. read more

I can't believe I'm just driving across the country, and just happened to find this place next to the freeway in Nebraska, next to a gas station! Great Mexican food, great margaritas, excellent, warm, friendly service, cool place and vibe. The service is very welcoming, the food was great! My margaritas were spectacular! My cheese enchiladas... excellent! But, the margaritas were really, really great! Served in a shaker on ice, so I could pour them up, no ice in a cocktail glass. The way it is supposed to be served! Colleen had a whole red snapper and the usual rice and beans, veggies! Everything was way better than we ever expected, don't miss Margaritas! This is a find mannnn! read more

See all

We stopped by because of the positive reviews on Yelp. We are Hispanic California residents and believe we know our Mexican food. Margaritas was a nice surprise. Food was tasty and the portions are huge. We could have split our meal. The prices are also reasonable! If I was ever passing through again .... Would definitely patron them again. read more