Just played out overrated. Love the atmosphere. Well decorated and the dark wood adds some originality to the hole mama experience. My mother says the sit down is very good but This is for the Pizza list. read more

Mama's has always been the kitchen to the Italian mother I never had. I've grown up on the meals here from back when they were a little pizzeria, and have seen the expansions over the years. The food- it doesn't matter what you order- is always delicious, and more importantly, consistent. I stick with my regular, chicken parm, which is what I hold to my comparisons to anytime I order chicken parm from another restaurant. If that doesn't tell you how I value this place, I don't know what will. Garlic knots are delicious, meatballs are great, and when I've dined in- desert has always finished the meal on the right note. If you're in the area, and craving Italian, this is the place to go. Dine in or carry out, you'll be happy with whatever you order. read more

Went on a Monday , pasta night They offer a specials menu Had rigatoni pasta with broccoli and chicken with garlic and oil It was fantastic read more

Tasty italian food with huge portions. Service is terrible. Seems they are very short handed. We literally waited for over an hour to get water glasses refilled but it never happened. read more

Honestly might be my favorite place to eat when I don't care about my diet. The pizza here is amazing and on Mondays they have very good pasta specials that include garlic knots, salad, coffee and cheese cake for around 11 bucks. The deal cant be beat. The negative is that there is usually a massive line on Mondays and I've waited sometimes over 45 minutes depending on the number of people I'm with. The negative is that their none-pasta dishes are somewhat lacking and also they aren't what you would consider authentic Italian(if you're into that sort of thing). Even typing this review is making my mouth water from remember the last time I went and I really recommend the place for someone whose into pastas. read more

A masochist's dream. If you love eating good pizza while simultaneously being treated like garbage then this is the place to go! You won't be disappointed. I suggest trying the penne vodka slice with a side of arrogance and sense of superiority. If you really wanna get the full experience that Mama's has to offer- ask for a free refill of soda after spending $30 dollars on a couple of specialty slices! Can't beat it with a stick! Update in response to the owner: I never once complained about the prices, only stated them. Nor did I insult the quality of your "fine Italian fare". Instead, my complaint was targeted towards your employees who have no regard for your customers. Based on that alone, we won't be back, as will most of our friends and family. Hopefully you improve in the customer service sector, or at the very least, train your employees to leave their egos at home. read more

This place is so gross. I heard it used to a fun down to earth place. Now it's not only beyond tacky, it's like a 1980's nightmare. The portions are ridiculous which would be fine if the food were good but it's "meh" at best. All that said, The service is good. read more

I have to start by saying that the food is very good here. The customer service sucks. My 1 star review is based on the fact that I feel I was overcharged on an order & they lied about how it happened. During this trying week of social distancing, we decided to support our local restaurants by ordering take out. This was Mamas "Chicken Night". We placed an order for three meals at $19 + tax each. The menu clearly states that the meal is served OVER either penne or spaghetti. When we placed our order they asked what type of pasta. Two penne. One spaghetti. Then they asked if we wanted the sauce that came with the chicken on the pasta. Well, if the dinner comes OVER the pasta why would I want a different sauce? So I naturally said the same sauce. My daughter picked up the order & showed me a receipt stating we were charged an extra $3 per dish for a change of pasta. I called them & said we chose the pasta you told us to. Then they said well you changed the sauce. I said it comes OVER the pasta why would I want different sauce? Then they lied & said I ordered the pasta on the side & that's extra. I stated, respectfully, no, we ordered as shown on the menu. OVER the pastas. She kept insisting that I was wrong & refused to give me a refund. This is no way to treat customers. I will not go back there during this pandemic or most likely ever. read more

This is one of few good pizza places around me. I enjoy their food. There is plenty of seating, and lots of parking outside. Make sure to make reservations long before mothers day if you plan on coming here because it gets all booked quick. read more

Mama's - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

over priced... so so food... will not go back.... catered food was blah.................had better nice inside

Don't miss the free garlic knots! Visited on Chicken special night. Long wait for a table as expected on the special nights. Waitress seemed a little flustered with starting us off with drinks. Sat at a table right by kitchen entrance and member of my party had to keep ducking every time a waiter went past with a tray. Suggest they put a smaller table in this space. Salad was fresh with a good blue cheese dressing. Ordered the Chicken Alla Zingara, which is chicken breast in a lemon/white wine sauce accompanied with artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, and prosciutto. I'm big on taking pics of my food, however this plate did not look too appealing. The red peppers looked like somebody had opened the jar and dumped them on top of the chix, as well as the prosciutto. The artichoke hearts were whole and looked like they were just thrown on top of the pasta and chicken. The food tasted good, but I was a little disappointed with presentation. The rest of my party enjoyed their dishes, which included Chicken Parmesan, Chicken Francaise, and Chicken Marsala. Everyone took home doogy bags, their meals are so big. Dessert included with this meal was a creamy cheesecake. I was so full I couldn't finish. read more

This is my second review of this restaurant and this one is worse than the first. We went there last Thursday for my wife's birthday. I started off by ordering a grey goose dirty martini on the rocks, my wife ordered a Malibu bay breeze. The waitress came back with our drinks and mine was straight up, no ice and not dirty. Not happy, but I drank it anyway as not wreck the mood for my wife's celebration. After ordering the appetizers the waitress asked if we wanted another round of drinks, we both said no, but my wife ordered a Sprite. The waitress came back with another Malibu bay breeze!!! Anyway, we split that drink, waited for 10 min for the soda and ordered dinner. I ordered veal salt um baca. The dish came and looked like someone had just thrown 3 pieces of slop on a plate; it was dripping with cheese and uncooked Italian ham on top. The presentation was just as bad as the taste. . It was not prepared with care or pride. The veal was so tough it was like eating a tire!!!!! Absolutely awful. My son and daughter ordered linguini with white clam sauce. It was plain, bland and flavorless. My wife ordered spaghetti with meatballs and it was ok. For desert I ordered a caramel macchiato and a piece of pistachio cheese cake. The coffee drink was cold, light, and awful. The cheese cake was ok. We got the bill, and WOW their prices have gone up, up up!!!! I WILL NOT BE SHELLING OUT MY HARD EARNED MONEY AT THIS ESTABLISHMENT AGAIN!! FROM THE SERVICE TO THE FOOD I GIVE IT MY LOWEST 1 STAR RATING. read more

Mamas has the best pasta night around - huge portions, delicious food and a great price. They also have awesome pizza in a ton of varieties. You can't go wrong with anything here! read more

We have ordered from this place sever times. We recently ordered on 6/29 for our anniversary. We each got a pasta dish and a rice ball appetizer. Upon biting into my rice ball there was something hard in there. I took it out of my mouth and observed a very large end of a fingernail. We immediately called the place and took several requests before we could get a manager on the phone. The manager told us we could drive 20 minutes back to the place and he would re-make us the rice balls. We informed him we never wanted to eat at his establishment again and requested a refund and offered to send photos. We provided our credit card number over the phone and we told to call back the following day and speak with Kathy. We called the following day and were told Kathy would be in on Saturday and would call us then. We never heard back from Kathy or the restaurant. We had to dispute the charges via our credit card company. read more

Mama's - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

Amazing food and large variety to pick from!! Best pizza around. Great service! Highly recommend eating here, one of the best Italian restaurants I ever ate at. read more

I'm an Italian food lover. More often than not I'm disappointed by the throw together of pastas sauces and meats. However, mama's has not disappointed. Their portions are very large so count on taking something home. They also offer deliciously fresh baked garlic knots at the beginning of your meal. The waiter we had was also great with good energy and knows exactly what to recommend. For a first timer, I ordered the mama combination and my husband ordered the chicken Madeira. The marinara sauce was so good I ate all the garlic knots with it. The lasagna was hearty, breaded veal was tender and went well with the fresh cheese and sauce. I never made it to the eggplant rollatine as you can imagine I filled up on all the garlic knots. My husbands chicken Madeira was nothing short of what you expect. Two giant pieces of tender chicken breast with mash and Madeira wine sauce. Overall this is one of those restaurants that makes trips out to Long Island worth while. read more

Mama's - Mama's combination - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

See all

Food very tasty but chicken not well done make me sick . I will still come back and ask for chicken well done next time . I love chess cake over there. read more

Mama's - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

See all

Amazing food. So flavorful. Very busy but only had a 30 minutes wait on a Saturday night. Portions are huge and I'll definitely have lunch for tomorrow. Huge variety. read more

Ate here and thought the food was really good. Great portions too. The service was meh. My waiter I think his name was Jordan was not so good. He served my dish and really wasn't attentive afterwards. read more

Good food but a little pricey. Owners are rude but staff is OK. Not kid friendly. Surcharge for Debit or credit.

We had an absolutely lovely time dining at Mama's!! The service was outstanding and the ambiance was excellent. The new management is fabulous, we will be returning soon! Mama's is our new go to spot. (100% recommend the tiramisu) read more

I had lunch there today with my husband. While the pizza was fine, the patrons were as rude as they come. A bunch of guys came in without masks, or wearing them down on their chins. There is a sign at the door requiring masks. I think the owners need to take more initiative in keeping with their posted policy. Is it really that hard to wear a mask??? read more

Garlic knots are awesome. Chili calamari is out of this world! the servings are HUGE, if your not careful, you will be full after the appetizers.. Grilled chicken arugula salad is excellent, service for our large party was excellent, ask for Christina. Deserts are made fresh and they taste to so good, they made a custom cake for us with an hour notice. Their service really is customer centered read more

Mama's - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

Food was good. Spent over $50 for 2 people but they wouldn't honor the free dessert email I got because we didn't order an "entree". Bad customer service! read more

Everything I have ever ordered from Mama's was absolutely delicious. I don't know what's in their vodka sauce, but holy crap! It's the best ever. Chicken panzanella is another favorite as well as the calamari arrabiata. read more

My girlfriend and I go on thursdays for chicken night & you cannot beat it. Let me walk you through it. The best FRESH basket of Garlic Knots as soon as you sit down. Then a nice CRISP Salad with your choice of dressing. As you look through the menu of ENDLESS Chicken options over your choice of Penne or Spaghetti. You get a nice portion to leave you stuffed. And if you are still have that tiny bit of room left, they offer NY CheeseCake and Coffee for dessert on the house. All of this for around $18?? You cannot beat it. Thank You MaMas!! read more

If i could give negative stars i would. I went out to dinner with my friends first of all the waiter was horrible he was giving us an attuide the food took about two hours to come..and on top of that he spit in our drink..and after we went and talked to the owner he gave us no response and top of everything the waiter almost hit us and raised his voice at us. Accused of me spitting in my own drink.BAD RESTURANT SERVICE read more

See all

Pizza was so salty called up owner wasn't very nice very crowed even when corona virus was at highest very loud use to be better never went back after the horrible pizza read more

I happened to be in the shopping center and my 2 year old wanted pizza since I was already there I went in for 3 slices stood on line while people came in and out and were served while I was never acknowledged I walked out will never ever walk in there again would rather travel 2 miles if I had to for pizza as far as I am concerned they are racist pigs I don't know how they make because I have heard horror stories of how they treat they employees and their patrons good luck mamas. read more

Extremely disappointed in this place. The decor is so nice that I had high expectations for the food. Ordered the chicken franchese and the chicken was rubbery, watery, and flavorless. Even the freaking sprite was watered down and bland. Ive heard the pizza is good and that's the only reason I would ever come back here. read more

Over crowded long wait Food was good but not great Prices very high for what they served Service was worse than poor The vesl dishes should be defined as medallions and the price would have been fair for portions twice the size. Not tender at all. Waiter got 1/2 wrong nrvetvsae him again other than tovlbrog the check after asking hostess for help read more

This place is always hopping. Specials during the week you can't beat. Thursday night Chicken night is my favorite. Always a wait but not too bad. Food is plentiful and excellent. Always bring home leftovers. The Take out menu - pizza is excellent with lots of other take out items. read more

This place makes my stomach SO happy. I drive forty minutes to eat here because it's worth it. The wait is short and the food is phenomenal. I recommend the overstuffed clams for an appetizer and the the shrimp bistro for the entree. For the shrimp bistro, the portion is out of control. Six giant shrimps stuffed with *actual* lobster meat and scallops in a Marsala sauce, with a side salad AND your choice of pasta. It's easily two meals for the price of one... Perfect for leftovers. The garlic knots that they give you upon being seated are also delicious- just an added bonus. Price is good, service is good, food is good... You can't go wrong. read more

See all

We had an engagement dinner here with about 20 people. The food was out of this world. We had a plethora of seafood, pasta, meat and cheese boards and bottles of wine. The server was very sweet and as attentive as she could be for a party of 20. I'm giving this 4 stars because even though everything else was great, it's pretty expensive. Definitely be prepared to spend some money while here. read more

Their portions are ridiculous, but in a good way if you're like me and can make it last two or three meals! I've never had a dish I didn't like here. I made my husband promise me he will stop me from ordering the Oreo cheesecake ever again because I almost died eating it, it is just too good. TOO GOOD. read more

Very clean place, very hardy portions , very tasty dishes just beware it's a little pricey! It's not an average pizzeria and you pay for it. No problems but guys really do you have to charge for every soda refill from the fountain? 3 people/ over $100 bucks for a Wednesday night dinner and you can't throw in free refills? read more

As always, this place hits! I took my mother here for the first time for her birthday and she absolutely loved it! Everything came out so well done and the bread was fresh too! We were among the very first people to walk in the doors as they just opened and food was just so on point. I had the garden salad and my mom had the short rib over risotto special and it was delicious! I must give a special shout out to our server Greg on our 2/17/21 visit who gave us SUPERB service, uncompromising effort and attention, and really made my mom's birthday something special. Thank you so much! read more

Mama's combines high brow and low brow in a way that perhaps can only be found on Long Island. Salt-of-the-earth service meets elegant decor. Garlic knots and a straightforward salad pave the way for plush entrees with delicate sauces and fine ingredients. Middling coffee accompanies yummy cheesecake. My father used to come here regularly for the weekly chicken special. It's a great deal. Recently I went for the pasta special, and I was impressed. The penne was perfectly al dente, and the sauces are out-of-this-world. I'd give Mama's that fifth star if it improved its salads, wine list, and most urgently, the coffee. To be fair, one can order espresso on the side, and good wines are available. But it's just a mismatch for a place like this, with such amazing entrees, to even bother carrying low-quality coffee. read more

Great Italian food! Love coming here for chicken night, the plates are enormous and usually leave you with leftovers to take home. Great servers as well, have never had an issue with any throughout the multiple times I've visited. read more

Just had dinner there with my friends. Excellent food,and excellent service. Our waiter, Greg, was fantastic. His appetizer and dessert recommendations were sooo good. Our entries were plentiful and so delicious. I had linguini and white clam sauce, that was out of this world. I totally recommend this restaurant. Highly enjoyable experience. read more