Best pizza I've had in Utah, hands down. It's not artisan pizza with honey and rare mushrooms or any of that. Just well made, normal pizza, done really well (i.e. puffy, crispy, chewy crust and better than average quality pepperoni). Excellent service too. Recommended: - Cheese sticks - Pepperoni - Hawaiian BBQ - Buffalo chicken Their salads are good too. read more

The best tasting pizza in Santaquin, simply put. I've eaten Chicago, Detroit and New York pizza. There are pizzas out there that are equal to Main Street, I'm sure. But getting your pie in Santaquin ensures 1) You'll have among the best tasting pizza available and 2) You won't have the time or expense of travel to the Midwest or East Coast read more

This place is not what it used to be. The prices have increased which is understandable BUT the quality has gone down hill. Ordered two large pizzas. Both with 3 toppings. Both pizzas had hardly any toppings on them, very little sauce, and very little cheese. It was like we were eating bread with a sprinkling of stuff on it. read more

Great service, and delicious pizza, got the hawaiian and bbq chicken. Both excellent

We stopped here while going to Bryce Canyon National park and we ordered veggie combo (large) pizza. It was amazing!!! There are not enough food places around and we found this place on google. Service was really nice. We loved it. And totally recommend this place. read more

Like other restaurants, Covid has seen to have affected this place quite a bit. They have upped their prices and they don't have access to the food like they used to have (or so we were told). We don't get consistent results when we eat there. We usually use their coupons, but when we call in the order one time someone will tell us that the coupon can't be used for what we want, and another time, someone will say that we can use the coupon for up to 3 pizzas, so that is quite frustrating. They don't seem to offer their coupons any longer, so it is not a very cost effective place to eat any longer. Thus, we don't eat here much any more. This pizza place is much better than the top brands, so we prefer to eat here, it just is too expensive so we don't. read more

Place is not what it used to be. Service is poor, place is not very clean, and I get the need to increase prices but unfortunately quality of food has significantly decreased. read more

Ordered once for a family get together. Never again. No gloves, no hairnets and just watching them make it makes your appetite run away very kind staff though read more

I ordered the margarita pizza my husband ordered a calzone. He liked the calzone and said it was really good. He wish he would have asked for another side of marinara. The margarita was good. I like the tomatoes on top. I do wish they could have the option of thin crust but otherwise pretty good. read more

Good pizza, but I wish their pizza chefs would wear masks. Two of the four had them around their necks. I wish I had just asked for a refund. read more

We thought the food was really good. I had a calzone and my husband ordered pizza. This is a strip plaza pizza place with two tables with four chairs each. It is designed more for carry out but if you're on the road like we are there is a place to sit. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The reason for 4 stars over 5 is only because the front area where you dine could use some TLC in the way of wiping down the chairs, better cleaning on the floors, etc. you read more

Main Street Pizza - 2nd side of menu - Pizza Near Me - Santaquin, Utah

See all

Food was so good, the wings were perfect and very meaty, the pizza was delicious, the salads were great too and very cold which I feel is important! They leave them in the fridge until you show up. Not to mention the gentleman at the front running the register was extremely nice and hospitable! Every time we drive through here we will stop. read more

Definitely a step above the national pizza chains! The dough is on point and plenty of toppings, the price is great and even better if you find a coupon! The side salad is huge and delicious. Don't forget the cheese bread!!!! read more

One of the best Gluten free pizza that we found. Good price,Great service. I definitely will be returning.

Main Street Pizza is a gem of a restaurant. While only having two tables inside the restaurant, it provides delicious pizza. We devoured a large pepperoni pizza. It looks like a vast majority of customers order the pizza online and then pick it up to go. read more

I dont generally like to leave bad reviews for businesses...unless they just absolutely deserve it. We've eaten at this store several times in the past few weeks. For that reason, I am amending my last review. Recently they've sent out some coupons in the mail and we like to take advantage of them for our six person family. On our last trip the girl at the counter let us order multiple pizzas of the same size and same number of toppings on the same coupon. The savings add up and we appreciate that. If you've read my past reviews you know I'm not a big fan of crust. My dog usually gets the outer crust. But, with Main Street Pizza.....I just can't seem to share. I love their moist, chewy crust......down to the last bite! (Sorry dog!) I think they just need to be consistent with all their employees as to what the procedures are for taking coupons. Or for any sales points they may have. And I have to say....if you haven't tried their salads....you really need to. They are freshly made and are loaded with the meat and toppings (depending on which salad you chose.) You know what's better than ordering pizzas from the Santaquin store....? Driving down to Nephi and having the all you can eat lunch at the Main Street Pizza down there! Its located just east of the I-15 Freeway, next to the Movie Theater, at the second Nephi exit. So, the next time your driving to Mt. Pleasant or Ephriam (Snow College) stop for the AYCE lunch special in Nephi. read more

I used to love this place but had a shocker yesterday. Always could find coupons that made the price very competitive for a great pie. Yesterday, I couldn't find one and when I called in the person told me there are none! I placed my order for a medium 3 topping and a large pepperoni. The wait time was 50 minutes and used to be 15-20. I showed up and was a bit surprised when they cost over $29. Figured well everything is getting pricey so didn't mind. I got them home and wow this is not the quality from most recent order. The pepperoni had hardly any cheese or sauce. The 3 topping was okay but not great. Something has happened here and not an improvement. I will think again before ordering here. I hope it's not too late to get back to previous quality and fair prices. read more

Great Pizza - the crust is what makes it so good. They beat the dough while rolling on a steel table. That part is noisy but worth the little noise to taste a good pizza, They are expanding to other locations because the pizzas are welcomed but everyone who tastes them. read more

The only reason not 5 * is because they are closed on Sundays which during football season is a hot item to get that day. I think they are missing out in a lot of money for it and we have to get inferior pizza read more

This is surprisingly one of my favorite pizza joints in Utah. They have great crust and sauce and use quality ingredients. Not that fake stuff like most places. The only pizza I like better is in downtown SLC. It's amazing for a small town. read more

My favorite and make it a meal deal you'll won't regret it! My fave is all meat pizza, cheese sticks or the pizza bread and chicken ranch salad! The staff here are all great! Keep up the awesome job! read more

This is a good pit stop, for pizza only, no frills, really, none at all, not even a bathroom-- although Dollar store will let you use their clean and serviceable restroom. Few drink (soda) options. We were starving and the personal pizzas held their own. Gave it 4 stars bc really the only option that was not part of a gas station in this area on the road to Moab. read more

We have probably been here 10 times and never had a bad experience. We like the pizza and they are quick. Never used their delivery, but they have always had our order hot and ready when we carry out. The salads are very good and have always been fresh. Not the world's greatest pizza, a little bland for 5 stars, but we will keep coming back. read more

I order pizza here every time I'm in Santaquin visiting family. The pizza always has plenty of toppings and cheese. Defiantly a must stop if you are in the area. read more

We just moved to Santaquin and for 3 dats in a row we ordered delivery from them! We have a gluten allergy in our home and so ordered gluten free. Pizza and wings were great! read more

Great pizza! Although it may be a little pricey for pizza, it is definitely worth it. It is like getting sit-down restaurant pizza in a to-go style. The only thing I've ever had a problem with is that they sometimes forget a topping or some other small detail which is understandable. The service is otherwise very good and respectful. Always hot and fresh and i will continue to go. read more

Just moved out to Santaquin temporarily and this was the closest pizza place! Great customer service Connor was really nice over the phone and patient! Pizza arrived on time and both the salad and pizza were fresh! The cheese bread is a MUST HAVE! definitely will order from there again! :) read more

Great pizza, but they tend to have a hard time getting the address correct, or finding it. It's happened numerous times.

Yummy pizza! Love the chewy crust, they don't skimp on toppings, fast friendly service, & at a fair price.

These kids cannot count back, or give correct change. I was ripped off big time and as such will only now pay them with exact change or credit card. Seriously it is not that hard. This too bad because this has become a Friday or Saturday night regular for my boys and I. I get it, teenagers need jobs. These teens should get one that does not require math. I may even now drive a town or two over to get my pizza and give up doing business with them all together. read more

This is great pizza ! We bought the extra large combination the toppings we fresh and good.We are definitely going to go back soon.

Best pizza around to much sauce is my only complaint the cheese sticks are a must have along with cinnamon sticks!!