This is always our go to pizza stop. While it may be more pricey than some other places, it is worth the cost. My favorite part is getting the lunch special with a drink, personal pizza, and salad bar. It may be called a lunch special but they will serve it all day. The service is always friendly and quick too we never feel as though we are rushed out the door or that it takes too long. The overall decor is very outdated and all it needs is a few arcade games to be in the 90s. Overall we love this place whether it is to go or in house. Always get the creamy Italian to dip in! read more

We are on the road and stopped here after searching Yelp. The place is ran by young women high school-college age. There was a man counting money so I think he owns the place but not sure. Anyway ordered a combo pizza. They have take out and a seated area but all orders are placed in the same location and they brought the pizza to us after I stood at the counter cause the music was a little loud and I thought they called my name...The combo had pineapple on it which wasn't a problem since I like it but the first combo I have ever had with pineapple. The price for a large was $21.00 which I felt was a good deal. The pizza was good. It came out hot and was tasty. The reason I rated lower was due to a few cleanliness issues. The woman cutting pizzas has a habit of cutting the pizza then rubbing her hands together over the pizza she just cut-I am guessing to get anything off her hands. She also picked or itched her ear prior to this on one of these hand rubbing episodes. Also hair on most of the girls was falling down. I thought about saying something to the girl that kept rubbing her hands over each pizza she cut but decided it was pointless since girls were around her and a male I think was the boss seated near by. Also the front door metal needs a good wiping. They seem to do a bang up business so doesn't bother others and I wished I hadn't seen her wiping her hands over pizzas but as I stood waiting for my pizza she did it 5 times. read more

Fat Jacks Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Payson, Utah

My go to pizza in Utah county. I'm a fan. Fat Jack's is consistently great. The pizza has excellent dough and a bold, flavorful sauce, and the breadsticks are just as good. Reliable, tasty, and always worth it. I'm lucky I live close. read more

Get the western sticks, and all of their pizza is very good. Quality is always on point and I really enjoy going to this place in Payson. The wings are OK nothing special but overall this is about as good as pizza as you get in Payson Utah. read more

The pizzas here are extremely greasy and dripping with grease often times. I prefer pizza that isn't so greasy and is more flavorful. I wouldn't classify this as a nutritional or healthy option at all. The triple bypass is really bad. Some of the others are ok. The Hawaiian is ok. We've only ordered to go. The service is ok, nothing outstanding read more

Amazing all the way around. The ranch dressing here is so good! I recommend the western sticks

Some of my favorite pizza in the world!! Been here, many times, and always look forward to going back. The service and ambience are good, too. If it's still there, don't miss the student's class research and report on cheese stretchiness. read more

The pizza always delious and the saladsnand the garlic bread .is.so delious ,the help.is always there to help you,

We had the mambo combo, minus pineapple. I haven't had pizza taste this good in 30 years. I love when you can identify all the toppings. Nothing worse than having the toppings chopped so fine you can't tell what's what. The flavors were excellent! Since we live out of the state, we're on a quest to find great pizza like that. And, do not pass on the cheese garlic sticks! read more

Ate here on a whim killing time and because I have a hard time turning down pizza. Now the biggest frustration I have with Pizza in Utah, is you cannot order just a slice, it has to be a whole pie. This means you must wait 15-20 minutes at least for a snack. Since I make my own dough and sauce New York and Detroit style, it's tough when you only want a slice to hold you over at home or on the run. Now this joint has apparently been around for a long time in Payson which saying something, do I need to spell it out? This place is quite large inside and could knock it out of the park on weekends especially with live Music and maybe a liquor license. Now TripAdvisor has this place as a 1 in the top 5 with Domino's and Little Caesar as 2 & 3 which tells you not to listen to anything they have to say. As you see there's plenty of toppings which drowns out the flavor of the sauce, but since my girlfriend ordered as I sat in the car, what could I say? I like to order plain on the first visit to taste the sauce so not much I can say about it. I don't like big giant crusts like shown in the picture as I feel that J am being robbed of the cheese and sauce where most would agree make up 75 percent of the rating. I am also not a fan of sausage that is shaped like a marble or the local wild life compared to sausage slices which leads me to believe leave it's purchased this way. I will need to go back and try a plain pie to rate the sauce so for now I give them a 3. read more

Fat Jacks Pizza - Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Payson, Utah

THE BEST PIZZA!!! I cannot eat any other pizza since trying this! Their wings and cheese sticks are also to die for! The bathroom was also very clean and nice! I recommend fat jacks to all my friends! read more

Great Pizza, quality toppings! Never get that cheap woody pineapple. They are generous with their toppings and the prices are incredibly fair. We often get home delivery and the drivers are very friendly and the delivery time is FAST!! Highly recommend this Business . read more

We were in town visiting for part of a day. Went to this restaurant to feed five adults and two children. So much delicious food, we ended up taking several boxes to go. The pizzas are delicious and the cinnamon dessert pizza was the best way to finish the meal. Give it a try! read more

Fat Jack's Pizza is my favorite pizza joint ever. I have been eating here for over three decades. They have never changed at all for the better. Great cheesy pizza, fresh salad. Great prices and fun atmosphere. Do not make the mistake of not eating here! read more

See all

Great food, great pizza great cheese sticks. Not more you can ask for a pizza place. This pizza is so cheesy, we love it!

YUM, YUM, YUM - we love Fat Jacks pizza! The toppings are fresh, sauce tasty, and the crust cooked to perfection. We typically order take out but have also dined in. Restaurant is dated, kind of a throw back 70's vibe but it works for pizza place. This is a popular place and for good reason. It beats the typical chain brand places hands down. read more

this shit so goodi dream about the cheese sticks and the croutons at the salad bar make me go WILDDDDDDD

I stopped by here with some family after a niece's dance recital. We picked up a 16" pizza, some of the cheese sticks, and some wings. The cheese sticks came out first and were pretty good with the ranch. The wings were pretty weak. 6 for $3.99, without any options on a flavor outside of "hot". They were tiny, didn't have much meat on them, and were just bland. I'd take my homemade wings covered in some of my hot sauce collection any day over these. I won't get wings here in the future. Our pizza came out last and was pretty good. The 16 inches of pizza was enough for around 6 of us. We were there with a group of 9 adults and a kid that were eating, and between a 16" pizza, 12" pizza, the cheese sticks and some wings, we were full and had plenty of left overs. While I'm only giving it a 3 star, it is mostly due to just how bad the wings were. The pizza and cheese sticks are great and definitely beat the big boy chains in the area. read more

this place has been in business long enough they have to be making money. And the flooring in there is so so disgusting. I have to hold my breath every time I go in. It's so gross for an eating establishment.... And they always seem to have about 3 to many people working side since have of them just standing around. read more

Pizza and bread sticks we're excellent. However no one would believe me when I told them I was over charged. According to the receipt I was charged twice for the extra topping. Special was $14.99 + $1 (extra topping) + 93 cents (extra ranch) = $16.92 + tax (8.25%) = $18.32 I was charged $19.40 See attached itemized receipt Not a big deal, they can keep the extra as tip, but I would have probably tipped more if they would have heard me out and figured it out correctly. read more

Fat Jacks Pizza - Itemized receipt - Pizza Near Me - Payson, Utah

I don't really know why this place has such good reviews. It took over 30 minutes for a tiny 8" pizza and 12 wings. The pizza was mediocre (someone said the crust was the best part - it's the only good part), and the wings were so bad. They were dry and extremely small, and were so rubbery they were inedible. They made us feel sick. They were supposed to be hot wings and they had no spice whatsoever! Literally the only good part about our meal the crust of the pizza. I wasted almost $20 on a meal that I actually regret. Do not recommend. Pepper shaker for size reference. read more

Fat Jacks Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Payson, Utah

I love their breadsticks. Also their bbq chicken cheese sticks are even better if you put jalapeños on them.

Update, Fat Jacks does not seem to care about their customers at all. Their back door (the main entrance from the parking lot) has a broken gutter directly above it. There is no awning. The result is that water streams onto customers as they walk in and out. It is impossible to avoid, as there are so many streams so close together. This problem exists almost daily because most of the water is a result of snow melting from the roof, which in Utah during the winter happens basically all day every day for 8 months. It does not have to rain for this issue to exist here. As a side note, their ceiling inside of the building is also being affected by water and seems to be slowly falling in. The pictures that I've attached do not do the situation justice unfortunately. read more

See all

Stella is awesome, great service and great pizza and great business ethics, we hope the best for you and you become an owner since you been there for 5 yrs read more

My wife grew up in Payson so she's been going here forever. She introduced me too the cheese sticks and especially the western style sticks. I recommend those whole heartedly! The rest of the food is just ok though. read more

By far the best pizza in Utah County. Super fresh ingredients and great service. Highly recommend the Mambo Combo.

This place always brings back a flood of childhood memories. The tastes, the smells, the location. Everything stays the same and that's a very good thing. Some of the best pizza and cheese sticks around. read more

So I'm working in the Payson area and I get a hankering for some pizza. I'm a fan of Two Jacks so I figured Fat Jacks might be similar. Ordered a small sausage and green olive. Pizza came out in 10 min or less. How was it? Well the sauce and crust are almost identical to Two Jacks. The big let down was the sausage. It was nothing special unlike the amazing sausage they use at that other Jacks place. This was your typical chain sausage, just ok. Parking is available in the rear and there is tons of seating. Service was prompt and friendly. read more

Another Payson treasure! I've only ordered delivery, but found that every interaction with Fat Jacks has been friendly but professional. They offer a great variety of pizzas, customization options, and fresh ingredients! I love Fat Jacks thin crust pizza, and so does my entire household--their pizza disappears quickly! read more

We LOVE this place and continue to recommend it to others. It's a very small and hole-in-the-wall local restaurant. We have come back every time we drive through the area and have been pleased with the quality of food every time. The pizza and cheese sticks are very tasty and have a crispy but fluffy dough. The sauce tastes great and the prices aren't too shabby for portion sizes (especially when you go for the specials). We've had friendly staff each time we've gone. They aren't over the top, but they aren't rude either. We continue to enjoy this place each time we visit and walk away full and satisfied with the taste. Note: It is a VERY small place to eat. So during busy times expect waiting for a table to open up or order it "to go". The parking is found in the back and you walk in through the back door. read more

See all

These guys are a little pricy, but we'll worth the money! Love their pizza especially with Alfredo sauce. Their ranch is to die for too! My favorite pizza place and they deliver to west mountain. Pizza Hut used to won't anymore now they have more people living in Payson. These fits are consistently awesome! And nice!! read more

We ordered delivery from Fat Jacks Pizza on a Saturday evening around 6:00. The lady who answered the phone was extremely rude. I figured she was having a bad day and didn't think too much of it but our conversation got worse and worse. I told her I wanted 2 large pizzas delivered and then she said "do you want these delivered or not?!" I said yes, I already said this was for delivery... I then asked if I could also order a side salad. I could not find the salads online so I asked what salads they have. She read the names of the salads but not the ingredients/toppings. She was fairly annoyed I even asked about salads and to be honest she seemed irritated the entire conversation. At the end of the conversation I said 'thank you' and she just hung up the phone. The delivery driver was also fairly rude. The pizza itself was ok. It was slightly better than Pizza Hut but because of the customer service I will not be ordering from this place again. read more

Fat Jacks Pizza - Cheese pizza with pineapple (large) - Pizza Near Me - Payson, Utah

See all

If you live in Payson, Salem or Elkridge this is definitely the best pizza in the area but, it still nothing amazing. I think they're cheese sticks are better than their pizza. read more

The pizza is simply superb; the atmosphere is classic. Clean place to eat at? Check. Delicious grub? Check. Quality service? Check. Yeah, that about sums it up. Check-checkity-check. Come here if you want to experience one of the only solid places to eat in Payson! (Unfortunately). read more

They have the BEST pizza! I got the Mambo combo (minus the mushrooms and onions) and it was amazing! The medium was the perfect size for two people to share + have leftovers for lunch the next day. It had a lot of toppings, great flavor, and perfect crust. The staff were very friendly and fun. The do not offer a dine in option, just pick-up or delivery. read more

Came here because I saw an interview of my favorite artist Brandon Flowers of The Killers and he states they had the best ranch in the world. I ordered the combo and it was chicken pinneaple and side of salad with drink for $8 bucks and added the ranch on the side for extra $. The pizza and dough was great! The ranch was really good and I can see why he loves it. Ill stop by again if I'm ever in the area! Great Pizza Joint! read more

See all

This is our favorite place to get pizza in payson! The pizza is well worth the price and super filling. The bread sticks are phenomenal!

These guys have the best pizza! The cheesesticks are insanely good too! I've been around the world and tried a lot of pizza, but Fat Jack's is by far my favorite. read more

When it comes to pizza in Payson, Utah, this place is at least two notches above the rest! I'm giving Fat Jack's 5 stars because they have super speedy delivery and amazingly cheesy pizzas and bread sticks. My only complaint is that they are greasy. But then again, I bet to achieve that awesome level of flavor that they rock, I'm sure it's an important component. The Western Stix ($8) are killer-yummy. One of my all time favorites from any pizza place, ever! They are cheesy bread sticks with crumbled bacon and diced bell pepper, onion, tomato, and optional jalapenos. I order them with the jalapeno for the flavor but then pull them off. :) The pizza is great too, but honestly I usually don't make it as far as needing pizza. I order it for the kids because after 3 or 4 Western Sticks, I am completely satisfied. They don't have online ordering, which I usually only order food online, but they are worth it! read more

Fat Jacks Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Payson, Utah

Super yummy pizza! Very friendly staff and great customer service. Well worth the cost.