Hit or miss. Went last night I was not overly crowded we were seated right away. Our waiter seemed overwhelmed and flustered. Boxty Cakes were great. Sangria was tasty. Smothered steak sandwich. While the meat was tender it was virtually flavorless. The onions were barely sautéed , the mushrooms were canned and the garlic bread base was a frozen garlic bread with zero aus jus (the whole point of the bread). I was disappointed with the lack of fresh products. Will try again and hope to improve review. read more

Very happy with selecting this pub for lunch. Took my dad and his girlfriend out for his birthday. Food was great, as was the beer. TV's everywhere. Only downer was Ohio State beating up on Michigan.... read more

This place smelt disgusting & the service was just mediocre. I had the burger and it was OK. I wouldn't go back there for dinner. I feel it's more of just a place to go to drink only. read more

Great food and a nice, clean restaurant area! Fish and chips were awesome and a good pour on the Guinness. The Thin Blue Line flag out front was an extra nice touch. Will definitely return! read more

My boyfriend and I enjoyed the fish and chips, The waitress was very pleasant; we will definitely Return to McIntyre"a in Toms River. read more

The food is delicious, they have a great draft beer selection, and Wednesday trivia night was a blast! Can't wait to come back next Wednesday! read more

Food is great, atmosphere is great, service is non existent. Staff was plentiful but not attentive

Holy hell what a shit show this was ordeder 9 dollar boneless wings was the most shitty repaired thing i have ever eaten bartender walks right passed you when you clearly are asking for service or a drink asked 3 times to close out still sitting with here an empty beer never will be back again another bar in town that just went down hill so sad read more

Used to be on 37 next to the big K, now moved a bit away. Now it's a little hidden but look for the 7-11 and go into the next plaza. read more

Food is very good. Joyce, Nick & Lil are very professional, always with a pleasant greeting.

Stopped in here with me Mum one fine Tuezday aftahnuun..... Mates, I must say that this wuz perhappz one of the luckiest YELP finds I've evah stumbeled akkross! When ya have a hankerin' for a good 'ol Pub Burgah with awl ye fixins...ya pray that she delivers as ordered! Had ye 'ol Cheddar-Ale Burgurr cooked Rare with a generous amount of fixins on it with a goop of Mayo on the side [I wuz thinkin they ain't gonna fix it rare} They DID!!!! Me Mum ordered herz Medium...not-to-sloppy - - came out PERFECT!! Served with fresh Kole-Slaw, Krisp Pikkel and Ruffled Chips....an All-around excellent lunch with friendly service catering to my nit-picky burgah needs! Awesome job McIntyre's! We'll be back! read more

Local Irish Pub with Irish fare. Everything I tasted was made on-site and gave it a comfortable, homey feel. Happy Hour Monday-Friday 3:00-7:00. Lots of TV'S for the sports fans and a large tap beer selection. Great staff and the place is clean. I would definitely stop here again. read more

I came in and got beef tacos and lemonade. The service was respectful and the meal was great! I recommend this pub because I love the look and feel of it, and they have great service and good tacos! read more

Great place. Food and service was great. A lot of TVs for football games. Awesome place to hang out

Good place! Good drinks and food is Good. I defiantly recommended this place . I had the Corned Beef it was so good. Some drinks are a bit on the high side but they do do deals. Best time to go is on Friday or Saturday nights its a lot of fun. read more

Suppose to be a Irish spot but the bartender couldn't even make a half & half correct. The whole beer was dark and tasted horrible because it wasn't made right. I had the Celtic Cuban and the sandwich had no flavor. I never had corned beef that had no salt flavor. This place needs some upgrades in quality. read more

Great deals, great vibes, great food. The Shepards Pie was awesome, definitely hit the spot.

I was there today for Dt Patrick's Day. They were very busy I settled with the first bartender when she was leaving. I then went to settle at the end the end of night and was overcharged. I questioned the bill and when the bartender came back with a different price he mutters don't come back. I then saw the owner Jerry at the front door and questioned my complaint and he basically blamed me for asking about the bill. I will never go back to this establishment. read more

Macintyre's is very clean with alot of great food. Well priced. Easy to find and plenty of parking. Wait staff was very attentive but not overbearing. Warm friendly environment. Can't wait to come back and enjoy again read more

It is a casual pub with the feel of an Irish Pub. Food is just OK. Beer choices over idea the food.

Great Pub with Great food and drink. The prime rib sandwich is awesome and so are their fries.

This place moved from a larger location in Tom's River that was primarily a sports bar with a backroom for live music. This new place is nicer aesthetically, but smaller. Still somewhat of a sports bar feel and majority of the seating is around the HUGE bar that extends end to end. They generally have live music on Thursday's and this is very much a local crowd. This is not fine dining by any means, although they do have decent dinner specials (e.g. prime rib). not conducive for a date night, but rather a good watering hole to meet friends and get some decent food. hot wings, while meaty, tend to come out dry and often with a burnt taste. Bar staff is friendly and attentive. read more

Place has grown on us. It's a solid place and never a bad experience. Good pub fair style Food and they have nice selection of beer. We been here 3-4 times now and its definitely consistent. What we like the most, is the local feel of the place and it's not a box restaurant which is nice, we have too many of those in town. Downside is seating can be a challenge on a busy night. read more

This place was horrible. I ordered boneless buffalo wings but really what came out was a piece of grilled chicken chopped into bits with buffalo sauce on it. They should take it off the menu. I guess if you only wanted to come get a beer you're in the right place but I would not recommend the food and not even the soda either as my Diet Coke was completely flat. read more

Mac's Pub - This is what they call "boneless buffalo wings". These are not buffalo wings - Pubs Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I've been here a few times and enjoyed it every time. I've had burgers and pizza and everything was really good and everyone was happy with what they ordered. The servers are always quick and attentive. The bar is good sized with a lot on tap. Seems to be a mix of 2 separate groups: 20-30 somethings and then 40-50s. I'm always puzzled by the presence of a bouncer between 6-8 for dinner on a week day...but maybe it gets roudy later? I've never been in there late so I don't know, but I've never seen the need for a bouncer. read more

3 stars because the place is fine, the beer selection is nice and the prices are fair. The staff is very friendly and the bartenders are very sociable. I'm not a fan of the clientele that frequented the place, at least on the night I was there. I mean it's toms river, do you really expect the patrons ages 21-40 to be classy and on their best behavior. I will be back to give it another shot though. read more

We have been weekly customers since this pub opened, and have enjoyed the outdoor atmosphere even during COVID. However, tonight was an exception! The hostess did not mask, and when I mentioned it to our waitress, she donned a mask below her nose. In addition, the paper menus supplied had obviously been used many times. So disappointed. As we were leaving, I mentioned the mask issue, and she said we were at a large table with many people who were not masked. We were at a table with my husband, myself and 6 year old grandchild. Sorry, like this place so much, but will not return. This hostess, who was there in the evening of 8 03 20 should be fired immediately. Her attitude was despicable and she is a danger to your customers. The servers were wonderful by the way. No problem. But the hostess needs to be educated or fired. There was no hand sanitizer at her station, and the utensils were in a bag on the floor. She should sanitize her hands after each seating which she did not. Food was good as usual, it I did not feel safe in this environment. We were there last week with no problem. read more

I have been there a few times since they moved to this location. I loved the older location, but I really like the atmosphere of this location. The food got way better and the service is better. This is a great place to go for a low key night out, it is no longer the bar with darts and pool but they have made up for atmosphere with better quality food! read more

I used to frequent Mac's a lot in their old location, been the the new one as well but in my opinion they made a HUGE mistake by moving. I dont go out of my way to go there, its too small and lacks atmosphere now read more

Great neighborhood bar! Friendly staff and patrons! they have a bar menu even late night lots of beers on tap! Seems that they have various theme nights! Been there several times and it is always an enjoyable experience. read more

Been here a couple of times once a few months ago and again last night. Once for food and drinks and last night just for drinks. Both times were great. The food is pretty decent and servers and bartenders were really nice both times. Last night was way more crowded than the last time I went which was nice to see they're doing well! So overall, good food, good drinks, and good prices with a nice staff. read more

Good value, above average bar food and decent dinners. Very large bar but it can fill up quick. The bar is a strange setup but very friendly wait staff. Prices are better the most in the area. read more

Great pub, off the map so to speak. Sits in a strip mall behind a 7/11 which keeps the crowds reasonable. Awesome tap beer selection, delicious modern twists to traditional Irish food. read more

Fun and relaxing place to hang and enjoy the company of friends. The Irish spring rolls are amazing!!! I enjoyed game night on a Wednesday and enjoyed a singer songwriter type of background music one Friday night! We will be back! read more

Not an Irish vibe, more sports bar. Big, clean, staff friendly. Lots of menu choices, happy hour, late night. Looking forward to trying more on menu. read more

Great local pub. Delicious food modestly priced. Friendly fast service and tons of food and drink specials. Try Irish egg rolls for app and Apple pie egg rolls for dessert! This is the NEW location of a an old and trusted local pub from the other side of town. read more

Mac's Pub - Prime Rib-delicious! - Pubs Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Excellent burgers and fairly priced, I stumbled on this place while doing a job near by. I will be returning !

Food is good but I ordered a Knob Creek before our meal and it cost me $10.00 plus $1.50 for the ice - must be made from special water. There is no ambiance like Rooney's or Tim McCloone's where you have an ocean view and great location that would make you feel better about the price. This is a neighborhood bar and there are other similar places where you are not ripped off for a premium spirit. We also ordered a house wine for $8 (should be $6) but the thing is it is not free pour. They have the airline bottles. Go there for average to good food, beer but you can do better at The Brickhouse and the 1850 Pub, even Sweeny's if you can stand the noise. read more

Visit McIntyre's once a week or so. Food and service are consistantly excellent and prices are reasonable. Chili is the best ever, served with a plentiful helping of chips. Tuscan salad was a fresh and tasty concoction of greens, roasted peppers, tomato, and mozzarella served on a nicely chilled plate. Great craft beer selection. Currently offering St. Patty's Day specials on Sundays and Mondays. Authentic Irish Corned Beef and Cabbage dinner was quite good! Love this place! read more

I went to this pub for lunch yesterday and needed a quick meal so that I could return to work in time for a meeting. The bartender/server was very nice, and the service was prompt--I even returned to work a few minutes early. My complaint is with the quality of the food. I ordered the shepherd's pie, and while the mashed potatoes and gravy were tasty, and the portion was large, the ground meat was of a poor quality and a bit chewy, which nearly ruined the meal. This restaurant needs to purchase better-quality meat to ensure that their dishes are more enjoyable. If I try this restaurant again, I would not re-order this meal. read more