My husband and I wanted a no frills place to eat while in the Canandaigua area. Found this on Yelp and Philly cheese steaks sounded good! I called to make sure they had a place to sit down and they did! The large cheese steak is 16" long so we decided to share one. I also added a side of mac salad. We added peppers, onions and mushrooms to the sandwich. The roll was amazing and found out they are delivered daily from Philadelphia!! The steak was tender and not greasy. We also enjoyed the mac salad. It was a very pleasant experience and the gentleman who took our order was very friendly. read more

See all

I have not had Mac's since 2020 so I was looking forward to this return visit. We were the only customers there on a Saturday afternoon, very quiet. We had a few questions about the menu and the person working was happy to help. My husband asked for meat sauce on his cheese steak and they added this at no additional charge. I was shocked by how much they loaded on there with no fee. He was very happy with his food. I loved my cheesesteak as well. The fries were piping hot and fresh. We forgot how filling the cheesesteaks could be and were not able to finish all our fries. I love the mural in the dining area and the comfy booths. Pricing wasn't too bad. We ordered one combo and one additional cheesesteak and it was around 26 dollars for everything. We loved our visit and hope to visit again soon. 4 years is too long to go without Mac's. read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

See all

Amazing!!! Definitely check out this restaurant. I had a cheese burger plate with Mac and cheese and sweet potato fries with a side of fried pickles. Tons of options on the sides in the plate. On Sunday's they have breakfast plate options that ends at 4pm. Also the people working there are extremely helpful and nice. read more

This is the first time I have written a negative review, but it is certainly warrented. I placed a delivery order with Macs through GrubHub tonight. First, the order was 35 minutes late. When it arrived, it was missing one item. When it called Macs, an employee answered the phone. After I told her why I was calling, she gave the phone to the frontend manager with no explanation. So I told her the story and it was clear from her attitude that she was too busy to try to help. She offered a replacement order but couldn't guarantee when it would arrive. Her solution was for me to apply for a credit through GrubHub. She accuyme of yelling at her, said she was sorry and hung up. The missing item was bad enough, but the treatment that followed without a "we'll get you a replacement right away" solution was enough me to write this. What a disappointment. read more

Found this place on my drive home from the Windmill, Keuka Outlet Trail and Oakhill Amish store on my way back home to Buffalo/Cheektowaga area. The service was fantastic, as I ordered something literally 15 minutes before they closed. The young lady at the counter, was pleasent, friendly as well as the gentleman in the back that made my juliana salad. Ingridents were fresh, they didnt mind adding extra turkey, instead of ham at no charge. Great portion for a half size, that I easily will have for a few more times. Quaint dining area, and convient location in downtown Canadaigua. read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - the inside of the restaurant - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

See all

This place was in a cute little town in the absolute middle of nowhere but was absolutely delicious and very generous portions. I had a Chicken Philly and the flavor was out of this world. My friend had the Garlic Philly and it was delicious also. The staff were friendly helpful. The place was clean. The bathroom was a little creepy. It was tiny, smelled and the floor was wet, with idk what. But overall I would give this place a try, the food was definitely worth the drive from the highway. read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - Outside - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

The cheesesteak sandwich was massive. We ordered the large Philly cheesesteak meal. It came with perfectly crunchy seasoned fries. I can't say enough about those fries. Crispy, but with a perfect softer texture in the middle. Cheesecake was with mushrooms, onions and green peppers Large drink with meal that one can refill. Great personality behind the counter. read more

Found this place last year when I was traveling on my motorcycle and I loved it. I went back again recently when I was driving between Buffalo and Syracuse to pick up my grandkids for the weekend. They are the pickiest eaters I have ever seen but they loved it. One had a red hot, the other had the chicken fingers. I had a 4 inch Philly cheesesteak. Delicious does not even begin to cover it. And the service from the employees was great. We felt very welcome and they answered all our questions. We will be back for sure. read more

See all

Generous portions and decent flavor combos here. We ordered a Bacon and Bleu and a Chicken Cheese Philly (both 8") and they were very tasty. Staff was super friendly and helpful. The decor has a bit of an outdated feel, but check out the mural of Philly on the wall! My only complaint was that prices seem a little high: two 8" sandwiches = $23, but to be fair we did leave with enough for a little bit of leftovers. We'll be back! read more

This was a case of a bad experience turned into one that tried to make up for the bad experience. I can't say I am completely pleased, but the efforts taken by the young woman at the counter to make things right was appreciated. Much appreciated. It doesn't take away the bad experience as it still happened, but her efforts are genuinely thoughtful and good customer service. I order dinner for my family of 3 with an order time of 6:05pm (online order). It said delivery time of 7:05pm. At 7:20pm, I tried calling the restaurant a few times. No answer. The phone just rings and rings. I decide to go pick up dinner from somewhere else but take a route that will go by Macs. I see the restaurant lit up and the open sign in the window. I park and go inside. Wait...I tried calling while sitting in the spot looking directly into the restaurant. No one answers. Just rings and rings. Maybe their phone isn't working. There was 1 person at the counter ahead of me, but the hostess did come up and greet me after a few minutes. I explained it's now been an hour and 40 minutes, I've tried calling with no answer, etc. She says the driver is new. But....as she asked me my name, she goes to the orders and mine is on the bottom unstarted. The restaurant doesn't appear busy. I took pics. I have no idea...maybe timing is everything and I showed up at a quiet time. I ask the young woman to rebate my delivery charge and she offers me an additional discount, which is appreciated. After I wait for my order to be completed, she apologizes to me for the inconvenience of having to show up, wait time, etc. That was nice of her. When I get the food home....it was delicious!! I can't say 2hr wait time delicious, but sooooo good. read more

I placed an order for delivery with side that goes with it. I get get my order and tip generously. no side sauce that goes with my order, So I call and ask about it if they can bring it if back out my way. My reply was we don't have any of that in the restaurant we ran out , we forgot to tell you. Like I said to him I would not of ordered it if that was the case it goes with the food I ordered!!!!! Just another business taking advantage of the customer for the money! People use to care about customer service this place doesn't !!!!!! Very unapologetic SMDH read more

Today was my last time ever going to this restaurant. My sub is not hot and has half the meat on it as the last few times I've ordered. They also said they didn't have Cajun seasoning which I've gotten in the past (after being told they didn't have it) which makes their bland steak sub much more flavorful. It's really to bad because when they make it correctly I enjoy the sub. Oh well. read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

took about a hour for are food to arive, the guy barely understood what are order was. So many food choices you can barley read the text. and after the hour wait the food was mediocre at best read more

Another great lunch at Mac's! Amazing Buffalo chicken wrap and chicken club Philly!!! Enormous portions and absolutely delicious!! Hope to be back again soon...love this place . A++ read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - Buffalo chicken wrap - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

See all

Philly cheesesteak was great. Meat was not dry at all, service was great, and food was ready quick. The setting felt like any nice deli/pizza shop. read more

While vacationing in the Finger Lakes, we decided to make this restaurant a must stop. The service was great. The Philly cheesesteak subs were phenomenal! Although it may appear small from the outside, there is plenty of seating inside. Highly recommend. read more

hey this is Rich White I've written in many times before about reviews I'm looking to see if I can talk to the owner please give me a call 315-521-3300 it's due to a sandwich I received that was just meat not too pleased I had to throw the sandwich in the garbage and spending $52 on a garbage plate and a plain sandwich that was supposed to be a Cuban read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

You'd think after I repeat my order three times to the zoned out guy at the register, he would get my order correct. If Jayden S takes your order. Have him repeat it back. read more

I ordered a Mac Plate and a "half salad" and each item was two dollars more than listed on the menu. When I asked about it, I was told that since the food prices fluctuate constantly, they would have to change out the menus every single day. What is this? The New York stock exchange? Mac plate was good though. read more

Very good food and a friendly staff. I wish we had these in Buffalo as I'd go all the time. I'm glad I got to try it here.

I have never had a better Philly cheesesteak. Not even in Philly. This is the real deal. Run. Do not walk. Repeat. Run. read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - This is half of a small and LOOK AT THOSE FRIES - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

Food was delicious and service excellent. We plan to come more often! Definitely recommend!

They nailed it on service / timeliness / quality / flavor which makes it a great experience A great sub ! Thank you read more

Food - 4 Service - 3 Atmosphere - 3 (Covid-19 & all) Price - 4 This place has delicious steak subs. I haven't tried their garlic parm sauce but I wish the steak sub had a little sauce to go on it. It was a little dry but good. Some places will add too much sauce, I feel like that could sometimes take away from the steak. Their steak is seriously off the hook. We cant put our finger on it but there is something special about the rolls that they use. They are perfect. Not to soft and not too hard. Our other recommendation is to get honey for the sweet potato fries. To me, it's almost blasphemous not to have honey for the sweet potato fries but that's just me. Seriously though, we love it here and plan to try all the other subs at some point during our next visit. read more

Service was great. They were very nice and helpful. Food, the steak on the salad was cold. The croutons tasted like they used very old oils. My 2.5 years old son would eat anything and even he split it out after one bite. Other food we ordered were okay. read more

Excellent food!! Excellent service !!! Highly recommended!! On time delivery every time. Friendly drivers and staff.

Though it's gotten pricey like every thing else, I still enjoy their food. It's pretty sad that everything has gone up in price.

Best food and service I have ever had. I had the steak plate and it was Mactastic , if u have never tried them u need to!! If u want to my digestion is the one in Canandaigua read more

Pretty disappointed with my experience here. I am normally a frequent customer, however, I won't be rushing back anytime soon. I ordered a wrap with a side of fries and was told it would take 15-20 minutes. Not a single other person was in the restaurant so I wasn't sure why my order would take so long, but I didn't really mind waiting. When I got my food the fries were totally cold. I waited 20 minutes to get fries that weren't even freshly cooked. I was really disappointed in the lack of effort to provide a decent meal. read more

We had a situation tonight where the food was delivered but we were never notified - so it went bad and got buggy on the steps... we were refunded by grub hub ... so giving the benefit of the doubt to Mac's - plus we love the garlic parm steak sandwich... delish read more

I love Macs. It is right next to where I work so I've been a few times. Usually everything is great, my order is on time and accurate. Today it was not any of those things. First I was not notified that my order was ready for pick up until 19 minutes after I actually picked it up. When I did the fries were cold and the salad was covered in items that were not listed and nit things I had added. I had to go through half of my Cesar salad to get rid of olives, onions, and tomatoes. All things not common on a Cesar salad. I am disappointed especially since I ordered at 2 in the afternoon. Not exactly a busy time. read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

See all

Got takeout. I got the full garbage plate my wife got the half! (Half portion would've been plenty and had the same amount of protein) Being from buffalo we had to take advantage of a place that offers garbage plates bc they've all left the area. Five stars! read more

Mac's Philly Steaks - Mac's Plates (full, cheeseburger and dog) - American Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

See all

Second time eating here. Was very pleased with the portions and staff were really great. Will definitely come here again when we get back into town. read more

Boyfriend and I both had combos with the philly hots sandwich. The sammys were very tasty and spicy. 4inch size was plenty because it came with fries. We were full and were going to bring leftover fries home but they were so good we couldn't stop eating them. The place was very clean. Honestly the best part was the girl who took our order was just so genuinely friendly. Hard to come by these days. Would definitely recommend if your in the area. read more

OK this place must of been there 100 years that's what it looks like in this little town named after the local Indians . I had a Philly steak with peppers and onions added with provolone cheese and steak on a home baked roll it was delicious I got the four-inch because the other side was 16 inches that must be the family size LOL my husband got a hot dog with cheese and meat sauce on it it was very messy delicious it was on a Beautiful Little St., Main Street what's the name of it it had a lot of other cute shops and antique stores there was a German looking chalet across the street which was a cute little whimsical store with all kinds of fun stuff in it I will be back one day the food was delicious and the people were super friendly. read more

See all

Best cheese steak I've had outside of Philly... And the fries are fantastic too. I love the little storefront on Main Street in Canandaigua. Great food. Friendly service. A lot of character! read more

This place is okay. I just hate to see philly things here. We get it the cheese steak is a philly thing. Come here for lunch as I'm working near by. I ordered the chicken philly the first time and it was amazing! Food came out at a decent time. I was just strapped for time and had to devour my sandwich. Second time I stoped in I ordered the garbage plate. It tasted pretty good but all afternoon it made my stomach uneasy. I don't know why. Serves me right for trying to order a plate from a cheese steak place I guess. Service was friendly but the prices were a little bit much if you want a quick lunch. Hard to walk out of here spending less than $11 read more

We ordered some takeout here and drove over to Kershaw Park to eat our meal. Beautiful day for it and was really happy with ordering from Mac's. It didn't take long to get our takeout order and we were off to the park. The 16" sandwich for under $12 is a fantastic deal to split with someone. My wife and I split the chicken cordon blue sandwich which came with ham, chicken, swiss, honey mustard, lettuce, and tomatoes. It was a fantastic portion and the taste was pretty phenomenal as well. The subs here sounded and looked really good and the taste ended up matching. Would not hesitate to come here again and I would try something different on the menu. read more

Wasn't sure if I had ever had a Philly Cheesesteak sandwich. I have to admit, I am not a big fan of the sandwich. This does not mean it wasn't a great sandwich. The other people in my group loved their sandwiches so I would assume they are great. I liked the options on the sides. Nice to have choices. The place has a great vibe about it. The decor makes you feel like you are in some downtown hidden secret. Really enjoyed it. read more

See all

I agree with Eric A. The Philly cheese steak here is mighty tasty. I don't care if it is not really authentic "Philly"; if it past my taste test. If you want some extra flavor try the "HOT" cheese steak. That is bursting with flavor. Perhaps it is because I live near Washington DC, but the price was very reasonable for what you get (a bargain really). Since we were having lunch, two of us (females) split an 8" sub and had enough. If we had added fries, we would have had to much. The only downer, was no beer (really). I love my cheese steak with beer. It is not a good idea to have cheese steak to go because the sub bun will get soggy, NATURALLY. Eating there is the best approach even without the beer. When I come back to town, I plan to eat here again. read more