Pontillo&#x27;s Pizza

Despite the demand and lines the service is exceptionally fast and friendly...extremely…read moreorganized...it's a well oiled machine! Of course the line is because the subs are SUPERIOR and downstate AUTHENTIC (without the attitude) ...fresh roll or Italian bread, tons of meat and all the fixings! Don't forget one of the old style deli pickles In the case....!!! Can't say enough about Casa...it reminds me of my old neighborhood grocery store...you'll feel like family too!

Tried their whit pizza for the first time and it is absolutely delicious. Top sub and pizza shop in…read morethe area.

Wow a lot of Italian Imports

Small Sub YUM THE REAL DEAL

See all

Dine Inn

Pizanos Italian Kitchen

4.0(7 reviews)

0.9 mi

Stopped in for a slice after the Canandaigua parade of lights. The slices were good, but they only…read morehad pepperoni. I'd like to come back and get a full pizza with more toppings. There was only one area to sit and it was right at the cabinet. This isn't a place with servers.

This was the second pizza place that we decided to try in the area, on the recommendation of a…read morefriend. So glad we did! The menu prices were about hat you would expect. The large pepperoni pizza we received was 100% Instagram worthy. It was BEAUTIFUL. I know it sounds weird guys, but look at the photos! It was so perfectly uniform, the pepperoni was evenly placed, and it made my OCD so ridiculously happy. It also looked like they had sprinkled something extra on the pizza, like a Parmesan spice seasoning? Whatever it was, it tasted delicious! We snagged an order of fried pickles too, with honey mustard and ranch dipping sauce. Just thinking about those pickles still makes my mouth water! All in all, I would definitely recommend, and we plan to go back in the near future to try more of the menu.

Pizano's from the outside!

See all

Our Instagram worthy pepperoni pizza.

Fat Ralph's Pizza

3.7(3 reviews)

2.9 mi

Everything was great. We had the chipotle chicken thin crust pizza. Double fried wings are sooo…read morecrunchy. Sauce on the side. Big wings too. Garlic knots came with garlic butter on the side too. All the sauce on the side is good when it's all to go. Order came out right on time. I'm thinking this is another hidden gem in our awesome Finger Lakes!! Only took me 8 minutes to get there - I did use the GPS for the quickest route. I wonder if it's possible to eat "in" because it is in Ferona's? Next time I order will ask.

I ordered a pizza on a Friday night and came in to pick it up and received someone elses order…read moreentirely. When I returned it and said I ordered a pizza I was told they weren't open for the evening. That my order should have not went through but it sure did as the charge was on my bank account. I used to love ordering pizza from Fat Ralph's as it has the best pizza and wings in town. Please make sure your website states which Friday's Fat Ralph's is closed and make sure ordering is turned off on your website in the future so others don't go through the same disappointment.

See all

Perri's Pizzeria

3.0(66 reviews)

3.0 mi

Ordered a large pizza and 24 wings for pickup. Our order took about 40 minutes on a Saturday…read moreafternoon. The shop has a large open dining area with several booths to choose from. Our pizza was delicious. A little bit on the doughy side for my liking but still enjoyable. We ordered the buffalo hot wings and they had a nice peppery spice to them. The only disappointing aspect of our order was being shorted on our wings. We received 19 wings when we should have 24. I did communicate this to the shop and they were very professional and offered to make it right. I was pleased with how this was handled and will continue to order from Perri's Canandaigua.

This one is a tough review to write. Perri's was our preferred pizza place in Canandaigua. Their…read morepizza is good and close to where we live. Unfortunately service really is lacking. We ordered last week and although the online ordering said over an hour for delivery, we were ok with that. After an hour and a half, I called the pizza shop who apparently has caller id. When the gentleman picked up there was no 'hello' but a 'yeah, it's on the way. We've been slammed and my driver is overwhelmed.' No problem, I understand staffing is tough. My disappointment stems from the delivery. The pizza was crushed and the wing sauce was all over the place. Spending $100 on pizza and wings (gluten free tends to be a bit pricy but due to my son's celiac, but I'm fine with paying the additional cost for GF), I expected a different experience. Not a crushed pizza.

See all

Pepperoni and pineapple

Green Front Restaurant

4.6(229 reviews)

1.1 mi

Always good and reliable. Nikki is great as hostess and Mike at the bar couldn't be better. Good…read morepub grub with excellent pizzas

I recently tried Green Front Restaurant for the first time, and it was an absolute rollercoaster of…read morean experience. The kitchen clearly knows what it's doing, but the front-of-house needs some serious help. We began with the fried pickle chips, which were amazing--served piping hot, fresh, and perfectly seasoned. The kitchen is remarkably quick, too; almost immediately after our appetizers arrived, the staff was already at our table taking main course orders. For my entree, I ordered the chicken tenders and fries basket. The tenders were perfectly golden and incredibly crispy, served with a generous mountain of fresh crinkle-cut fries. I'd rate the tenders a solid 3.5/5--my only minor critique is that they could be a bit more generous with the dipping sauce for a portion that size. My dad also ordered a beer, which was poured beautifully with a nice head. Unfortunately, the front-of-house experience completely dragged the meal down with some glaring cleanliness and professionalism issues. I found a long hair wrapped right around the lemon wedge in my iced tea. To make matters worse, I watched the staff member pouring drinks rub her mouth right at the drink station before handling other beverages. Meanwhile, the lady behind the counter was completely disengaged, literally just scrolling on her phone instead of focusing on the dining room. The overall neglect was obvious if you looked around. Hanging directly above our dining table was a vintage wall thermometer covered in a heavy, flaking buildup of rust and grime--definitely not what you want hanging over your food. Even the bathroom was neglected, with trash and used paper towels left on the floor. If you are strictly judging by the kitchen's output, the food tastes fantastic and comes out incredibly fast. However, management desperately needs to invest in a deep clean and have a serious huddle with the staff regarding basic front-of-house hygiene.

See all

COHO Pizza & Wine Bar on Canandaigua Lake

3.9(71 reviews)

0.5 mi

Food was great, staff was excellent…read more I really hope the management is taking care of the staff. 95 degrees today, no ac, and the staff were all hustling. As a local business owner my concern went to them. On a side note I read some really entitled reviews, y'all need to do better and tip your waitress.

We visited Coho Pizza with a group of three adults, one teenager, and one toddler. We had…read morereservations for 1:30 p.m. and were seated promptly. There was confusion from other patrons on if they were open since the front door was still locked. The restaurant itself is beautiful. The dining room is inviting, and the deck provides a relaxing atmosphere that makes you feel like you're on vacation. The pizza was excellent and definitely the highlight of our meal. Unfortunately, the service didn't match the quality of the food. Our server frequently disappeared, and it took more than 25 minutes before anyone even took our drink order. There also wasn't a drink menu available, which made ordering more difficult and took more time. One other thing to keep in mind is the parking. The lot is very limited, and the spaces are quite tight, so arriving early is probably a good idea. Overall, the food and atmosphere were wonderful, but the slow service took away from what could have been an outstanding dining experience.

COHO Pizza & Wine Bar on Canandaigua Lake

See all

Pisano's Deli & Pizza Kitchen

3.5(17 reviews)

0.9 mi

Great food, friendly service- we visited here a year ago and were impressed. Not disappointed this…read moretime

I stopped here today since it was next to my hairdresser. I'm glad I did because I got 2 huge…read moreslices of thin crust pepperoni pizza for $5 and it was delicious! This is a small place that seems to be linked with The Villager restaurant and the bar in between. The man waiting on me was very nice and using PPE. They have a huge variety of pizza, subs, pizza, dinners, just everything! I plan to go there again soon. My only issue is it's just a really small shop so on the winter social distancing could mean waiting outside. Luckily today that wasn't the case!

Latest pizza had great sauce and lots of cheese but lacked pepperoni.

See all

My huge thin slices loaded with sauce, cheese and pepperoni!

Fire on the Lake

4.5(16 reviews)

0.3 mi

My first time trying fire on the lake. I can't believe it has taken me so long to try. It was…read moresooooo good. Their cauliflower crust pizza was huge and my son thoroughly enjoyed it. My husband and I split a salad and a pizza. Both were absolutely delicious. I didn't think I was going to be a fan of the salad dressing and I was pleasantly surprised. So yummy! We will definitely be back.

If you like spice, get the Seneca! It was amazing. We sat outside and had drinks and enjoyed our…read morepizza. Stop here if you're in the area!

A view of crispy drippy pizza and a beautiful lake

See all

Il Posto Bistro

4.4(132 reviews)

1.0 mi

We had an incredible dinner at IL Posto Bistro last night. The food was so good that I actually…read morestopped eating my rigatoni so I could bring the rest home for lunch today! We started with the crab cakes and homemade focaccia bread, both delicious. Everyone at the table loved their meals, and the portions were generous. I also really appreciated that they offered several alcohol-free drinks -- the raspberry mule was excellent. Overall, this is a cozy restaurant with great food, reasonable prices, and a welcoming atmosphere. We'll definitely be back!

Super rude servers, waiting for food for 1,5 hrs, asking for a bread, still couldn't get that after…read moreafter 1,5 hrs waiting for food. Plus the server all of a sudden is saying that you shouldn't be rude after asking for bread and still not even getting 30 mins waiting. Embarrassing!!! Never dealt with anything even close. Bad service. Would never go again! Owners, watch closely for your staff and your business.

See all

Burratta

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mike B.

125

7 years ago

Very disappointing food order on Saturday afternoon. Almost $50 worth of pizza and wings and both pizzas were awful! Dough was like cardboard in texture and flavor. We all agreed that it was just BAD. read more

John J.

8 years ago

This has always been a great pizza place. The quality of the pizza has gone down though recently. I would not say these people are very friendly though. read more

Shannon D.

8 years ago

Disgusting! Greasy nasty food. I could fill a bucket with the grease that comes off the pizza. Rude, nasty management!!

Jennifer M.

140

8 years ago

Great pizza and wings! Only serve slices until like 2 but still totally worth it! Great place to grab a quick lunch!

Keith A.

5 years ago

Poor service. The pizza us not good . They did not care about me as a customer

Pontillo's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Restaurants near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Desserts near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Things to Do near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Breakfast near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Parking near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Coffee near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Dinner near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Burgers near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Shopping near Pontillo's Pizza

BEST of Canandaigua, New York Movie Theatre near Pontillo's Pizza

People found Pontillo's Pizza by searching for…

Best of Canandaigua

Things to do in Canandaigua

Browse Brands

Pontillo's Pizza

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pontillo's Pizza also viewed

Naples Wood Fired Pizza Smokehouse BBQ

3.9

(92 reviews)

My family loved the pizza! No photos of the chicken strips but they were delicious. Homemade ranch!…read moreSo yummy. Definitely coming back.

This was a very cute spot on the main drag in Naples. Good wood-fired pizzas, nice salad, the…read moretenders my son had looked crispy but juicy. I didn't love that you had to figure out how to order (go inside to the counter). We just sat at a table for 10-15 minutes until we asked another table what was the deal. A hostess or staff that offers a welcome would be helpful. The staff inside was nice. Overall a good meal but an awkward start.

Bb's Pizzeria

4.4

(17 reviews)

My chicken wings in garlic sauce were cooked to perfection, the salad could use more lettuce but it…read morewas flavorful. Service was cool but the appearance inside wasn't so pleasant, they really need to renovate to improve the smell and gain new customers.

Always the best pizza in the area! Staff is extremely friendly, prices are completely fair!read more

Domino's Pizza

3.8

(23 reviews)

This is by far my teenage son's favorite pizza. We order it for him when we have a work event or…read morewill be out for the evening. I was late coming home from work and my husband was at a retirement party for a colleague. I decided to order pizza, wings, and cheesy bread. I personally had the Ceasar salad with chicken, except they didn't send any dressing with the salad. I forgot to grab a pic of that. The cost is very reasonable. I couldn't even get good pics as my son grabbed his plate of food so quickly once it arrived. Delivery is fast.

One of our pizzas got mixed up, but we called and Andrew was on it. He had one made and got it to…read moreus himself Thank you Andrew!! Beefy truck lol

Silverbird Woodfired and Gastropub

3.3

(179 reviews)

Went to Silverbird for lunch Tuesday and loved every bite! Large servings-we had leftovers for…read moremeals the next few days! Hubby tried the trash plate and loved it. I had a wrap that was full of flavor and fresh ingredients. Our waitress was very attentive. The woman who owns the place had a lovely conversation with my husband. Overall, a wonderful experience. Will return on our next visit to NYS.

Pizza was horrible. Overcooked with very little sauce. Ate what I could but left over half…read morethere. There was 5 of us and no one willing to take it home. The positive was The waitress who did a great job.

Mac's Philly Steaks

4.2

(80 reviews)

My husband and I wanted a no frills place to eat while in the Canandaigua area. Found this on Yelp…read moreand Philly cheese steaks sounded good! I called to make sure they had a place to sit down and they did! The large cheese steak is 16" long so we decided to share one. I also added a side of mac salad. We added peppers, onions and mushrooms to the sandwich. The roll was amazing and found out they are delivered daily from Philadelphia!! The steak was tender and not greasy. We also enjoyed the mac salad. It was a very pleasant experience and the gentleman who took our order was very friendly.

I have not had Mac's since 2020 so I was looking forward to this return visit…read more We were the only customers there on a Saturday afternoon, very quiet. We had a few questions about the menu and the person working was happy to help. My husband asked for meat sauce on his cheese steak and they added this at no additional charge. I was shocked by how much they loaded on there with no fee. He was very happy with his food. I loved my cheesesteak as well. The fries were piping hot and fresh. We forgot how filling the cheesesteaks could be and were not able to finish all our fries. I love the mural in the dining area and the comfy booths. Pricing wasn't too bad. We ordered one combo and one additional cheesesteak and it was around 26 dollars for everything. We loved our visit and hope to visit again soon. 4 years is too long to go without Mac's.

Amiel's

3.5

(71 reviews)

used to be a big fan of there subs back in the day but recently came back here and the product has…read morego down hill. ordered a chicken parm sub, sub was cold after asking it to be toasted, chicken was crunchy like eating a bone I didnt finish it it was gross. The only saving grace was the bread, it's made in house. just really disappointing used to be a staple in the Victor area. Hope the place improves because I used to love coming here.

Talk about a good sandwich!! Amiel's knows how to perfect their cuts, everything is such high…read morequality, the staff are friendly when you walk up to the counter to make your sub and the shop itself has a really cool vintage 50's vibe inside. The food here is addicting, you just might find yourself coming here every day!!

Cam's New York Pizzeria

3.6

(61 reviews)

Absolutely delicious pizza with lots of unique choices…read more Genuine NY crust! Don't pass it by

I stopped by Cam's in Penn Yan for carry-out pizza (one cheese, one pepperoni) during a family…read morevacation trip in July 2025. This place has both pluses and minuses. First, the pizza is quite good. However, for NY pizza snobs, you may need to lower your expectations as the crust needs more salt. Second, the ambiance of this pizza place is very old-school with a 70s or 80s vibe. This place looks like it has not changed (which may be a plus for some, a minus for others). Third, the service for carry-out was pretty good. On the minus side, street parking can be difficult to find at the main corner of this busy intersection. But one tip is to drive behind Cam's (toward Penn Yan Diner) and then turn left where you'll see a hidden but very convenient municipal lot. It's only a short 3-5 min walk. Overall, I think this is pretty good pizza for the Finger Lakes region. However, the crust needs more salt.

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

3.0

(6 reviews)

Soft fluffy crust, sweet sauce, crisp pepperoni. Classic Western NY pie. Very friendly staff.read more

I have ordered for 4 yrs from this site . I have been happy until last several months . they had…read morethe best pizza and subs. they delivered in a reasonable time. now they charge more for delivery and it's late. they charge for old fashioned pepperoni and now it's just broiled thin pepperoni. they skimp on cheese on pizza and meat in subs. the bread is soggy . they only offer credit at their site and after three different orders trying to reorder and use credit I'm done. too bad it was a good choice but no more. the last delivery was over 2 hrs and I'm 1 mile from store . the driver said I was hard to find. pass on this store . there are several pizza and sub sites that deliver . also they say we deliver everything but babies but always out of orange and grape soda and never have milk so choose wisely .

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3.3

(97 reviews)