3.5 stars.
Service--Outstanding. We were 15 minutes early for our reservation on a crowded Saturday, but were seated immediately. Our server was attentive without being overbearing, and the meal was very well paced. Our server was informative and patient (when we couldn't make up our minds). Can't say enough about the quality of service. The Liberty Tavern clan seems to consistently deliver on the best service in the Clarendon area.
Atmosphere--Lyon Hall was packed on a Saturday night. It was on the loud side, but not to the point of being obnoxious. It was a laid back but sophisticated crowd, mostly 30-somethings. I love the giant plate glass windows looking out onto an increasingly hip Washington Blvd.
Food--This is where Lyon Hall loses its points. It is on the pricier side for the neighborhood--we ate well and spent around $300 for 4 people, including a couple moderately priced bottles of wine and tip. The $30-$40 pp price tag would be great if the food lived up to its chi-chi ambitions, but the flavor profiles just weren't there, and there was some sloppiness in execution. Admittedly, I think part of the challenge here is that German/Austrian fare is naturally humble--you can only dress up sausage, spaetzle and snitchzel so much, IMO. I guess for me, those sorts of things will never be 5-star cuisine. Portions on all dishes were good, and in some cases generous.
Our party of four sampled quite a few of the dishes, and we were not wowed by any. Most were acceptable, none were exceptional. The mussels were well prepared, but we were disappointed that they came out luke warm (the pan in which they were served was stone cold, which didn't help). It was silly to serve the duck-fat fries (meh) on top of the mussels, because half of them end up falling into the broth and getting soggy. The potato/prune dumplings were good, a couple of my friends thought they were too sweet. The herb spaetzle was uninspiring--the spaetzle itself was nicely prepared, but the herb/cream topping was bland. My husband was not wowed by the hot dog.
My friend and I shared the lamb chop entree. To our surprise, one side of the lamb was seared to perfection, while the other side was just north of raw, so the fat near the bone wasn't rendered. I'm a big fan of rare meat, so I could look past this, but it was a deal breaker for my friend. I'm sure we could have sent it back without issue, but there were many other things to try. Points for the white bean and mushroom ragu served on the side--that really was delicious. My husband's pork schnitzel was perfectly prepared--thin, fried to a beautiful golden brown, tender, flavorful. But the accompanying lemon-mustard potato salad was not delicious at all. Our friend's kielbasa was as good as kielbasa is going to get.
Desserts--Oh man, the chocolate profiteroles were inexcusable. Rubbery, tasteless and drowned in Hershey's-like syrup. My husband will eat anything chocolate so he was satisfied, but I couldn't bear them. Our friends had better luck with the beer-float flight, practically licking their glasses.
My group walked in really, really wanting to love this place, but we walked away thinking, "meh, that's it?" We just wanted better food. I'll likely be back for a happy hour, but for my money, Liberty Tavern has a better (and better executed) menu. read more