My boyfriend and I both are not sure why this place got such great reviews. My boyfriend and I were staying at a hotel across the street & after driving all day, we were tired & wanted something to eat without driving a distance. We stopped in for dinner & it is fast food style type of ordering your food/drinks. You walk up to the counter, order food and then they bring it to your table. If you want more soft drinks, you walk up and get them. They had a few bottles of beer in a cooler but there were not prices posted anywhere, that we could see. We ordered one beer each. No waitressing, so if we had wanted another, we would have had to walk up and purchase another from the cashier. Which, was not very friendly, by the way. We ordered a small house salad ($2.95) each and a medium Kujo pizza ($18.95). The salads were small, which for the price is fine, but it was just iceberg lettuce with 2 thin slices of a tomato and some mozzarella cheese. That's fine. The medium pizza was just barely meh. The toppings were good but the "thick" crust was actually medium thickness, but it was soft and almost doughy. Taste-wise & consistency wise. I ate one slice and that was enough. For the price of the pizza, I was expecting a high quality, flavorful pizza. My expectations were not met. We were there on a Monday night at 6:30 pm and there were several locals in there, which was surprising. I would not return. read more

We had a great time! Just passing thru and in the mood for pizza. We got a Cesar salad, garlic sticks with cheese and a BBQ pizza. The salad was really good. The garlic sticks come in a personal pizza pan. They were absolutely delicious. The pizza was incredible too. Wish we were staying in town. I'd go back tonight!!! read more

Visiting from out of town. Spaghetti dish with garlic bread was great. The Popeye thin pizza was amazing! Friendly and quick service. We will be back. Disappointed it's only in MS! read more

Every time we eat here it has been great. Nice clean environment. Very great staff. The cheeseburger pizza and taco pizza are to die for. They have special names for them but they know what I mean when I say it. Go with the thin crust it's so delicious. read more

Lost Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tupelo, Mississippi

After a semester-long love affair with Lost Pizza, it comes to an abrupt conclusion. My boyfriend and I went to dinner in Tupelo to celebrate the fall semester coming to a close. It was more an hour before they closed, literally had the food in front of us at 8:18. My boyfriend is a very picky eater and requested no veggies on his favorite sandwich. It came out just the opposite, he told the waiter and had it sent back, only to have the same sandwich that someone had just picked off the veggies for him return with some veggies still on there! There were crumbs, trash, and hair at the drink machine. The waitresses seemed more focused on getting out of the store at straight up 9pm than the people still in the building. This ruined our date and we do not plan to come back to Lost Pizza in Tupelo. read more

Atmosphere was common with the retro style but very well maintained and clean. You order at the front with very friendly and knowledgable staff. Then head to your table with a number. Lunch special with a small pizza, drink, and small garden salad was very reasonable for the quality of food. Pizza was just the right size if not a little much. Quality ingredients even though it was kind of bland tasting for my liking. Overall a great local pizza joint. read more

We were traveling through Tupelo. Looked at our Yelp app to find a local restaurant to try. Your restaurant came up with good reviews so we tried it and loved it. Will absolutely eat here again next time we come through. The pizza was amazing and the staff was all very helpful. read more

The food was okay, but the manger was just sitting at a table the whole time they were busy and the girls in the front were standing there looking lost with no guidance and I talked to the assistant manager who seems to have a much better understand of how to run and actually manage the employees read more

Ordered 6 wings and requested all "flats". Was told "we can't do that." I responded, "Surely, you can." Was told, "we can but we don't do that." He then checked w manager and said, "we don't do that." I mean charge a customer more, if you feel a need to but Lost Pizza, "I don't do that" place anymore. read more

Great local pizza place. Atmosphere is casual and great for lunch, but also nice enough for a date night dinner. Service is prompt and excellent. Many choices on menu and food is great. read more

The best pizza around! I definitely recommend the fried ravioli, too. A must every time I'm in Tupelo. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and its conveniently located to everything. read more

Worst service I have had in a long time. Waste of money on all metrics. Don't waist your time and money in this train wreak.

The food here is never disappointing! The atmosphere is fantastic, whether the place is crowded or I am the only customer. Bathrooms are clean, music is nice, and the waiters are almost always smiling. read more

Lost Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tupelo, Mississippi

I can't believe this place has such a high rating. I feel like the high ratings are false. I wish it would have stayed lost to us. In it's defense, no one probably considers Tupelo the Mecca for pizza. But having said that, I really don't like paying $10 for 4 pieces of CiCi's pizza, or the medium 8 pieces for $20. No exaggeration, a small personal and drink is over $10. A med and drink is $20. And the taste and boringness of the pizza is what you would find at a CiCi's or the frozen section of your local grocery store. Again not exaggerating, I am almost certain the crust are those pre-made kind you find frozen or on the chef-boy-ardee isle in the grocery. The only reason I can think that anyone would pay such exorbitant prices is that the area of Tupelo is extremely wealthy and the vibe of this place as a hangout is what everyone pays for and not the pizza. I will say all the decorations on the walls are cool, but not worth the high prices. The place is also clean. I am not from the area, just passing through with the family but if I am ever in the area again I would never return to this place. To the owner, if you read this, this is not an attack on you or your establishment. Instead this should be viewed as on opportunity to look inward and decide if selling pre-processed style, small pizzas at a really high price is what you want to do. Or maybe look at making your own dough and some better ingredients in order to justify the high price or continue with the same ingredients and lower your prices to be more in line with other mall type pizza in the area. read more

Stopped here while traveling and the pizza and cheese sticks were excellent! Cold beer too

Everytime I've been here it's been great. I think the original in Indianola is the best. It's something in the delta water that the MS hills can't match. My favs: El Diablo and Pit Boss. The wife like the Hawaiian and Lucille. All specialties are great though. read more

If you are an Elvis fan and you have to visit tupelo, then you must visit lost pizza too. The garlic bread sticks and Chicken Alfredo are to die for cuisines. Pizza offered are also equally good. I was not expecting much from tupelo in food department, but this restaurant has uplifted my soul like Elvis's music does. read more

Ordered a ranch pizza and could not taste the ranch dressing at all. Also very few tomatoes and also couldn't taste the onion. Bacon and cheese were the only flavors. read more

Literally the best pizza I've had in a while. I wish Lost Pizza was in Georgia!!! We had the fried ravioli and the Popeye pizza. I will eat here every time we travel through Tupelo!!!! Prices were a little high and they don't deliver, so if you need it delivered you have to use Tupelo2Go which makes the prices even a little higher than that. But honestly, I'd pay $100 for one of their pies!! read more

Hi I'm going to be positive about this review. This is the best pizza I've ever had since I've lived in Tupelo (34 years)

A different type of restaurant, as they have no wait staff, you order, get your drinks, sit down, and eat. However, this place is probably the best pizza place I've ever been to, so I highly recommend! Their menu is extensive, with every type of pizza on there you can think of, including a make your own option. We had a pulled pork pizza. Amazing! We got a medium and split it between three people, with plenty for all. They also have good craft beer - another plus in my book! Don't waste your time with anywhere else in Tupelo and try this place out! read more

Don't really care for it. Customer service is awful and the food is just so so. Consider going somewhere else.

I ordered the meat lovers personal pizza and spinach dip. I was a little worried about the spinach and artichoke dip since it was thicker than I'm use to. It was actually good. The pizza was ok. It was much better when I added the Parmesan cheese. Overall, the service was great and the food was good. read more

Good pizza. Good tamales. Good beer selection. The salads are OK, but nothing special. They MUST get new forks. The forks they use are simply terrible. They remind me of the cheap forks from my elementary school cafeteria. read more

Our favorites include The Happy Hippy and The Popeye. The second location is great and right next to the house so we now order once a week!!! read more

I really liked this place. I went there twice on a trip for work. The service was great, and the employees were very nice. I got an individual pizza and it was a great size for me. I definitely would return. read more

I'm surprised this place gets such a high rating. I had a personal size thin crust pepperoni pizza. The crust wasn't nice and crisp. It had the doughy consistently of a frozen pizza. While the toppings had plenty of cheese, there was very little pepperoni. The entire dish tasted almost identical to a lackluster frozen pizza. Ambiance is just a big loud room with some interesting memorabilia on the walls. I'd eat here again, but the quality of the food is meh at best. read more

Great pizza without the same old run of the mill taste. Try the Odis or kujo, both hardy meat living pizza. I really like the thin crust better over the thick crust. By all means...save room for the chocolate cheese cake dessert pizza. A tip of my hat and I look forward to my next trip to Tupelo. read more

Great, great pizza - nice service & atmosphere! Try the Lucille!!

My daughter and I stopped here on the way to a softball game at lunch. We ordered a pizza half pepperoni, half pepperoni, mushroom , black olives. We got our food in less than 15 min and it was excellent. Service was great and food was fresh. We will be back! read more

A casual order at the counter type place where they bring you your food. I first went when it opened and made the mistake of getting the thin crust pizza, which tasted pre-made and I wasn't impressed. On this visit, we got the pan crust "Otis" and a dozen hot wings. I can say without a doubt that this place has the best hot wings in town, period. The pan crust was good and buttery tasting without being greasy and not too thick. The staff was very helpful with our awkward ordering. Would recommend, but stay away from the unimpressive thin crust. read more

The Pitt Boss pizza and a Greek salad made for a great meal at our hotel. And the delivery outfit they use was really good.

First, being originally from Chicago I do consider myself a deep dish pizza snob. That being said, I was passing thru Tupelo on business and staying in a hotel very near The Lost Pizza Co. I wanted something to take back to the room and decided to go with a pizza. I knew it wouldn't be deep dish but I was hungry. I am glad I did. The restaurant is not huge, but adequately sized for most diners. It looked to have an adequate assortment of beverages and was clean. I decided to go with the Popeye Pizza...chicken, spinach, onions, cheese and Alfredo sauce. I am so glad I made this choice for dinner. The pizza was awesome, the service terrific and the prices very reasonable. It's not often that I really like a 'normal' pizza. read more

Family friendly environment. Food was awesome!!!very filling. Kujo pizza was exquisite. Price was reasonable.

The pizza here is outstanding. After inquiring about appetizers I was shocked when they said that Tamales made the menu. Had to try them and darn glad I did! Very good even for a little pizza place. read more

Was looking for a good pizza as a pre race meal. Man we were surprised. We got 2 med pizzas 2 drinks for about 32 bucks. kinda pricey BUT the food was great. I will be back. I made my own pizza, xtra pizza sauce, spinach, very little cheese and grilled chicken. AWESOME! read more

So good! A must stop if your in Tupelo. I love the pizza thick and thin crust. The toppings are great, try one of the specially pizzas they are great. Staff is great the owners are usually there working hard just like everyone else. Always fast service never has a problem. read more

Stopped in while on family vacation. Ordered a pepperoni, a meat lovers, a buffalo chicken and a spaghetti and meatballs. All of the food arrived quickly and as ordered. Buffalo and meat lovers were really good!! Price was not bad for the amount of food we got. Clean too! Glad we stopped here. read more

We stayed at the days inn literally down the road, and was craving pizza, we called this place at 835, put in an order at 845pm and they close at 9pm. I was treated with a lot of courtesy and friendliness being so close to close to closing. The pizza was awesome, a medium pizza could feed three people. I got the Otis (meat lovers) and it was so filling, I ate 3 slices of 8 and that was one too many. I was also given a free sweet tea since it was so close to closing. I would recommend this place over Pizza Hut, dominos, and papa johns, the only negative thing is it's just a little too pricy, the pizza was awesome but just a little to high in price, I would come here again, but maybe just get one medium or one large pizza read more

Very good pie. Fresh toppings with heavy distribution, a nice crust, good service. A little pricey for what it is, but very good nonetheless. I've eaten at the restaurant twice and had takeout 4 or 5 times. read more